Show WHO WROTE it fron I 1 j S i ew 1 ork 1 I gottlie giai been dead for more than liall a century and blood aa a oil iu ahe german at last an attack and a bau oue hai made upon ti jp te grIt MT is encored in ahe the ceniu ry an ars pearel upon this tide of the chine who that iho poet is a nian of no parts kierr the founder of tho lew w causing n pro aund in literary lile bernu ly in n man f note 11 writer of elt brUy residing at present in munich chair in alie with the lille of profess bur carriere baya that two lhing led to ha theory of goetges Go ethes literary iiii that lowing wrote a faust ana eliat thu manuscript lot nal devir minted for the natii rul to me was he how did happen waa much talk of goethe for many years but nothing appears from h H pen nil the subject uncil aale death it is adl knawa that leasing disliked awl durine bid lifetime never prejudice against him lie spoke derogatorily bet bolh in letters and in coover falion leasing spent some time in leip lc was a student there but they avoided one another and refused t bo brought together this and far ent from the which ex esteil between goethe and herder at could faust haye come lulu goethia Goe thua hauda could that leavo beau the reason of hatred ricer carriere relates that it wa customary in those daa for the authors to steal from one another and it was popularly called ech leoen goethe did not publish faust until 1807 several eam afier Ls decalli alio second part bot appearing fur several yera follow bior hi own delite de mite goethe is baal to have written n par af lua faust in and yet herder lella that leaver wroten anything while in eliat aad characterizes him indolent as and la blessings Les sings faust it u true waa written in prose but william scharer the well known professor proved years tinco that goetges Go ethes york was not written at first in verse klerr car ricce concludes then that goethel Go ethea work at frankfort far from lein original consisted m les ing rt aiuto verse abany a were allowed to remain iu the original text because aava alie professor they were beyond the foppe of Go elbea intellect lie cit too a of passages from faust and coin pares them with extracts from geesin Le esin showing in sonie their strong in others eyen their exact coincidence aa 0 o the second part of kierr Carric rc broadly as seiad that goethe was not learned enough to compose it that all the questions of philosophy religion and found in the brilliant pages are opu iiona of leasing which the weimer poet never to acquire what the result of the controversy will be it ia difficult to tell many noted goethe scholars have taken up their pena in defense of the nations idol while others spurred on by herr carrieres temerity have come forth with here tolore they had feared to express it is but tho beginning of a controversy which may prove as interminable as that af shakespeare bacon there ia an infinite satisfaction to many people in robbing a creat of his laurels but the majority of germans who deify goethe will resent the attack and many positive proofs must be ad ducca era they will believe that leasing great aa ho waa was the author of faaet lairo it coong you only ay iy cents a day Orl 2 1 laa sin mala |