CLASSED AS the supreme court has said i to lay lav with one hand tile the dower cower of tin tile government on tile the property of tile the el citizen ti and with ith the other to bestow it upon favored individuals to aid private enterprises and build up private fortunes is none the less lees a robbery because it is done clone under tile forms of law and is ca called ailed taxation if it be said raid that a benefit to tho local public of a town by establishing g manufactures tile same may luay be said ol 01 any other business or pursuit u aich em m aloys c capital pital or labor the merchant chant t alit lit met inet hanic the innkeeper alie banker tile ilie builder the steamboat owner are qually promoters of the iho public god and equally deservio the aid ot the at i wens by forced contribute contri contributions but us no ko lines can be drawn draun in favor of tile iho manu fa fut uror which would nut not open tile the cof fert of the llie public treasury to the importunities tuni ties of tio atto thirds of f the business of tile the city or to loan n opinion of iliou S supreme court 20 wallace