Show I I I I OGDEN PHYSICIANS IANS TAKE ISSUE ABOUT 1 CAUSE OF MURDER 1 Believe Girl Roughly Handled Handled- I II and Probably Strangled Doubt Chloroform Theory cl l to The llie June SO O.-l O. aln made an nn O examination of ot the tIme body of or Fran Frances J ces Williams i immediately follow in inthe the thc discovery of or the tilo murdered girl Irl In Inthe inthe i the trunk at the thc Ogden Oden Union enlon depot and before re nn any embalming fluid hadIn hail had linan n In r r ri d Count Ph Physician A. A A. A I I 1 n Robinson b n nol ol and City Ihs Physician c an H Wallet Waiter halen of or O Ogden den take Issue with tho Ito reports of or the time cause caus of oC death as six given en enby i b by the Salt SnIt Lake physicians h following a post mort mortem m examination made b by them yesterday afternoon in Salt Sail Lake t twenty hours after arter the body hotly had b been been- en found Hull and tho ho embalming fluid had been u used ed t The Tue Salt Lake physicians reported that thal no violence Jence or 01 brutality o had bad been beenu u used cd as far as ns they the could Tho Thu probable cause of f death th was giVen hen as resulting from chloroform although the they reported the they could not detect signs I n of or the tile drug because of the embalming em em- which had tal taken n place V Considering the circumstances un under er which the examinations w were rl made mado by bythe the physicians of ot the time two cities and tho thu ho time following the time discovery of or the body and believing belle the they arc are better qualified to describe the appearance an and marks Dr Robinson son and amId Dr Whalen oppose a number of ot the ie ie- findings of the tIme Salt Lake physicians clans and ammil have havo given gl I en out tho lie following follow tollow- i in ing signed statement as to their stand In ill tho tue matter Tho rho examination of time the Salt L bake aue rh Physicians after the l bod body ody had been beem for neui neatly ly twenty four hour would be unreliable as us to o tho time amou amour and amid nature of ur Injuries about the nc nci At tho tito time timo the corpse was moved from rom the time trunk or om ou was made malle the vel vel- upper tipper of or thi till the head were ere cn engorged ored oJ s' s In Ing thor thier- had been ca cl life still IJ Ci tC Th The Ing- Ing and the lie vo ruptured Th Tile hi hA dM and neck l the lie process of c Cj S time th lie Continued on I oJ OGDEN PHYSICIANS TAKE ISSUE ABOUT CAUSE Of MURDER Continued from frum ruin Page 1 fluid in the tho auxiliary artery under tho arm the fluid came oame out through the mouth showing showing- the vessels had been ruptured The marks marls on the tho sides of ot the neck and under the chin strongly resembled tears su Bu such h as might be made by finger er nails nans That the they were duo due to an any rough handling of or tho trunk is ab ab- ab surd This is also true of or the lacerations lacerations lacerations lacera lacera- in the mouth near the loosened teeth As to tho the neck being broken it would have been impossible for tor us to ascertain this fact tact without making an incision As to death being due to chloroform it would have boon been impossible to determine determine deter deter- mine this after actor the embalming fluid had been injected This diagnosis was probably made on tho the finding of or the chloroform bottle It It is our opinion tl at death was due clue to strangulation primarily whether or not any chloroform was used DR A. A A. A ROBINSON SON DR W W. E E. WhALEN HALEN |