Show HOURS OF DISCUSSION John G Tyler Nominated for postmaster at Ogden FRISOO HAS AN EARTHQUAKE nllht for the Fxii 1o0U gLIIM It Uexlcu l < uw Z1111 I Pulp lorollll SlnllcnVlltu Jmler ii llnni lie slIIer IIIIl llnlor Hl cuIUIr l llullroiul HiIll h VISIIIUTOS Jail 11111 tho Stiinto you terclay Cnlloin ntUicsstd the bcimto In favor I the conference report ou tho Intel Slnlo Commerce bill conllniiiR his marks prm onlly to tho fourth seolion ns to bug and hort hnnlq Iho firnt loquiioinont of tbo hll oil the subject of rales is found in tho Snt section and is that all rates Blmll bo reasonable out jimt his is in effect n duration that under similnr oironni juices and conditions n KroiiUr sum shallot nol hO charged for shortor than for longer Jislineo because under each oiroumslnnoos it t wale not ho roisonablo and just to makeeuoli n charge ripe next requirement 3 I the lull that ufteots the 1 question Is I found erlt f ths first part of tho irU section which I forbids llio Kivitit of an undue or unreasonable unreason-able of advnntnLo to any pnrtl cular locality Ibis H i likowiso n deolnrn thil 11 greater unto shall not bo charged lou UlIsl h rll15 t uirrl hr n shorten than for a longer haul nndor milar cironiuitnuoot nnd conditions because be-cause pack olmrnes vould ho making or iitmu of UII undue or umensminblo pro terence of IPI1STAot Tl OSlo 1VIIIICULAU LocaliTY Or subject Homo other pnrtioulur lo rality to nn undue or iinrcnsonnblo preju dice or disnilvnntnto I lips 1 Senator quoted Ihs four Hi section in full As i understand it thJRCclion I ns it now HtnndsBimnly i pro dll r lf Er tbits i railroad con 11 irntion t from charging i I greater nggroftuto sum not a higher into torn shorter tlmn for a longer distnnoo over tba flimo line in the HIIIIO direction and ado sulHtniitinlly mnillnr ouciimstanccs lId conjitioti when tho shorter Is included ntbm the limner distntito llioro is no other pnliibilion niado in positio I let inn rr i iI7 f of oll lrt 1 Ii TLt fmnrenieiit nf the fourth section then ilbit lidtwitiiHliipniiiiitHof tho Hiiino kind 10 the saute elirtctioiiH over tho I fmmo hue nJ rode I under mibstnntinlly Riniilnr cir nmiancei nnd conditions n 1 printer hum tail iut < ho churned for a shorter than for a IOD liniil whtii the shorter comprises u and the longer haul not Hint the higher rite shall not ho charged per milo but that > creator aggregate Rum Hlinli nut bo cmecl the limitnlioiH placed upon the prohibition that IIIt mailo are very sigoiti cnt and t they must not be ovtrlooked fy hr ns mn ono railroad compinj is Deemed Till SI I MIIUI IT nay CllAHOI kro haul from OIl end of iU load lo the ihur end btoiiincis the iiinxiiiium ninouiitit nnclnrco for arts shorter Imul over that road III the saute dileclion nnd nndoi fliml la circaiustnnccH nnel conditions when a Lloitet distilnoa Is nicliulod within a longer tIthe question that Rooms to tioublo tboBo sho object to this Rootion an it stands is whether the miximuin thus fixed is I the mount which the railway ooinimnv tliarRos tlimfclnpimutH ontiiintiiiu nt and tUmtlnod t tahiti on UN own hint or whothor tile mailmen is what it accepts as its 1 tetiUterasli rate upon Hlnpnicnls pass iIi over to rond which oiiKiuntos it or Ire destine n points on another rond It beau cleYr to 130 that thcio cart bo but ono louver to tll1t 1ueqtioll In tbo trot plnco hIhe menuro of charge that may bo mndo ham a filioilir clHtnnco is i the Hum Hint hoI rullorcal for I II IOIlol dislanco e iv or the qUIIIO ni iinj Ullller siibstuntiullv simllnr oir Jimtinominilconditions llio ratio heed I Jiynrulroiilf unpin botuoon points upon I Fioseul 111 rut me clearly rntes upon ono II line I n m tho twins f tho bill the eaoio lute 11 hhe roilroiel uiiipniiy onn iimUo and con 1 trot rites 11111I its own road nnd the sto I Jowsiv thin m maUitit Hiith rates rue dour IIAUI i niNca LF all oi lie obsorved hue I railroad conip inj i unit control I rat s over the road lo T an ercunijwi hut when two or moro com inure nnito in nuuileeeg joint rati s ever their JlopCctevO teak tiny I come in tho eye of MI t lull OIK Did 1 and this BootioiiHnys that T jMsbotthiiul principle must bo obsoi vpd u hiluthuuuc rut Cccv cr Ilmt mat I tho two or luCre roud JIIpOilll it being within the taming Cut < tlnsHiotioii C the HlIIUO hue ho lit n such JOIIIL riles aro concerned tile Purl rallrOlI1 n i nsslflnough mt tho hill iii the worll line is used onlj III thutc eec tlOD ana tin courts will ho bound to iissiinio I ts t 6 hal ttbo u 0111 I line moans sonic thing differ Jlfrom lie word ruehhrueiuh or it would not kuun h lieu uutuoh m tbia i ono instance 1 whore I luorJ h rUlllo eel 1 would naturnlly hno been II Let tlllsollllIlIn dilVerent huh not boon in uJeJ llio word I lino moans II mil rond or f wmlinmti line f railroads It means n tie l nltmi iiiostionby Mi Mdnoli Mr Cutlet I imuHseo undertook to explain hhdefeuuuh Clue bill Ihoio was ho said distinct nnd independent of mil IOI cUun hll rranoisoo and Now York bUe huotuiec oliO lino bj a contract and tllltnt IwUuon them If tbov charge 1 00 n C1f Ir t > m HI < 1 rrniiolHou to Now York hIt wns thu minimum into which they I J Chucw lrolll h Ogiheni or Omaha In New toAllriii HIUI tlioy oenild olmrLo i 1 > lrlf < JIn 0kdenoi Oinnlia or Iluirnlo lb lIuft Thoro is no unison In bo m Mm Him bill why tbuy iluy not olinruo C trolU lnv liilormoeUato point up I to tho C ffiaif 1 I Chic thireenughi olmiuo tuoopl therlutire r fo if linftjt niiiHt be ronuonnblo le SlImtor ptiifoid aiuued iiKiihiHt tho bill trh hul it i tended not only to I iiimonl ahetuuoui I liy rllfonds but It exhibited a je m nW C l letter scitor WIJH Ituo tIle proju N woi uio iinlioad inloiesls If tho ob I tet I were III ulianoo Ihiiwatci I lines at the tfi or flee nuulh l rou ds hl didnt 1 1 know 1 Wtlll bull n mid ho fiamcd to C Hocuio such 1 ° jut bettor tlmn Ibis bill ChIc mil h i IS1011 wn legitimate llioro could be II rtuuutCtit euiui f1f iilrivlIJ tho 111111I11 of tl lit not5 ulllltmi of tholr llOlurty rho I I sOCineli 10 hllll olollrly III s ollltiull uf l tI hlK of llolerty llIul lIf thee rllhlA uf Ill III tl 7r to IIVl OIlllIISlltioli for SOl VhWH thrunII It WIIS IIlso 1I111sUllrnft0JIlellt al t elui IIf 1IIStlllOllt 111 rt1II111 to huu I huit ulIII i nhlll hnlll etch lone ho IIlglll1 Olutuu Iul eu 1111I1 H11IIot 11011 HOIIIO ECII Il r uutij1 l It t ehicohuehehy IIUcsslIry tn I LPrc uuurc fII IIIhrnw1IIIttl hIlSIIIISII 1111I11 1 tiruectu hUKIIWIIS ill Clue oVOlllIlul rill t ro 1 ull riulu ecu t Ctuuuh I Ihol1IlItH very Iuruoly 111111 I < eec I hy tho WlitOH hey r I Itr of Ih hotleeeiuo of Iuenculnluui each IIf ICC h t uug tllllt HHulotltloll 11111 rll uu I I I t HMll ie I I IIOI II iti I I II III UII I bo bad lucy had to at Ih Itll t between tbo I twei i x tuuuu I Ih t inuuue heuerueotl cur of freight rI Llh rciu5 t I I i eueeeheeh f rule i tho east Oetl I IJ Irlllll IlIU n wost to thee IIHI tn i R1 Fl 1 S Iit IOu Olhulp u hit ic Ihlloj hl1IIIIIIIO nf 11111I I 10 l eu ug frolll Ntv Ynrl III Ill Cab llY best ovor I hl VIllIIIIIII Ib 0111 ruiu I eecuchcleig 11111111I 111111 11110 fur I iit I hII C 11111111 iiitee IIIIY fmlll ui 1 S I Jllilflll f Oii I JllIlTlllo In I Jill t S tiuuu t all T u u tn Ulllllhll fWIII Olllllhll 4 I h uuiu I us curl tn IIIU lost 1111111011 lii i lIelll I I No lmllt IR Hn IIIJIIII 1 0 L11 r Tho IIIIHhwss Is 111II1U lit lln I 111 u tilOlllllot to C cIa I It lit 1111 Is t ruili rN cecil In suit leech SIIIIII1 stiutlu It I JII IIIIIIIII IIilllisuty Ihllt tleeuy Hhlll1 1 ll tcu1 wlwlI II 111I11r 11I1I1IOt lee IIlIv l11tlllllll Cu t dinly III ill Clfl j dlvldulIl shliJors amid commullities tile bell olit of tholr moro fllvorllhlo location whether made sue bocatiso of thu googruphi lunch tOlmgruhehiy of the gtOurgto rNl CIIlIIllCIIUS |