Show CAFFALLS CASE Marriage Proven Out Vlsltliie Doubtful Richard Caffall who on Saturday evening entered a plea of not guilty to a charge of unlawful cohabitation in Judge McKays court was up today for examination exam-ination The case was opened by Mr Varian I calling Mary Ann CafTalf who said I was married to the defendant fortyseven I years ago I am his first and legal wife I do not care to testify against him Excused Ex-cused Sophia Cullens said I am not a married mar-ried lady I live at Mr Caffalls house I have lived there for some years I am not related either to defendant or his wife I am advanced in years and live there out of charity there was never any other lady living there have heard of Mrs Murrin she was pointed out to me j dont know whether or not she is defendants defend-ants wife I Ephraim CatTail said I am a son of defendant I know Mrs Murrin have known her ten years she lives on Sixth street she has three children she was divorced about ten years ago she has had no children since i has been reported re-ported in fathers family for three or four years that she was fathers wife I have I never been to see her I am not on visiting I visit-ing terms with her and am not on very I good terms with my father Excused I Sophie Cullens recalled said I live apart from them so far as I know defendant de-fendant lives with this wife exclusively I hear him in and about the house everyday every-day and uearly every night Excused At this point a recess was taken until 2 oclock in hopes of securing further witnesses wit-nesses At that hour the case was again opened Mrs Berthia Caffall was called and said Hive in the Twentyfirst ward my husband is a son of the defendant I know Mrs Murrin she lives two or three blocks from me I suppose she is i Caffalls wife but I dont know it she is reputed to be defendants wHo I think she has three children Mrs Murrin is an elderly lady 48 or 50 years old Excused Ex-cused Charles Caffall said I am a son of defendant de-fendant I know this Mrs Murrin it is reputed in fathers family that she is his wife I have visited her but never saw him there I have never seen her at his house have never heard him speak of her as his wife j I dont know of any children of fathers except my own brothers and sisters Excused Emily Grissold who had been subpoenaed sub-poenaed had not put in an appearance and Deputy Franks went off with an attachment at-tachment for her while the Court fell into a lull to await her arrival |