Show W S CROWDS LISTEN TO the mouthpiece of cleveland discourses on finance at louisville 1 ky june 14 the large I 1 personal tollow ingot secretary Car lialo fn this city and alie interest felt by all classes in lie currency question filled the music hall this evanine such a crowd as new wore congregated on a similar occasion long before the i nour at which the wa to bo given alie liall was to overl lowin tiie well to do mid uan jostling with the libor cr and tor a convenient scat nor WAB alie meeting a gathering of democrats to honor a party leader were out in force promptly at 8 mr Carli alc came forward aal was presented by charles it long his reception should have a defied the most expectant when the tremendous applause subsided in liis clear incisive voice mr cari atle immediately into his subject mr carlisle reported hie argument llie metal would be out 0 tin country by alie adoption of a bimetallic system and at some paid attention to the claim eliat the fall in the price of silver was due to raid it is it is that alie ill in alie arico of silver 14 attributable to the legislation in germany the united states franco and various other countries during and bince the year of and most illogically it ie insisted that notwithstanding alie reduced price of eliat metal is the result of unfriendly action of great many acting in concert and with a settled purpose lie united states can alone restore the value of silver of course it it required alio action of twelve or thirteen different governments to bring alie price of silver to ila present state it would seem quite clear that no one of them alone could it if the depreciation in alie value of silver aa compared to god lias been catu d solely by the adv cirre legislation complained of it follows that if that had never taken place alie value of eilar ns compared to gold would now be tho in 1872 before alio legislation occurred what then would have occurred what then would have been the result sot a single dollar of full legal lender silver would be circulation in alie states at this time or any other time bince 1872 because at aliat time the bullion contained in the silver dollar was worth about 3 per cent more than the bullion contained in alie gold dollar and alio two could not circulate together alie earne law drove silver out of circulation under the acts of 1834 and woud have kept it out and instead of having in circulation among the people about egal tender silver dollars aa we have now we would have had none the 1 in alie price of dilver hiie not due to the legislation legi elation complained of but to an enormous overproduction alie average annual production of balver in alie world during alie five vean next preceding wae about while i it was aver an of cent much greater alian alio ati i or the i population of alie w arll i notwithstanding alie price in silver dilver mining continue to beani profitable industry alie fartura far nura i and oilier producers re anro etrue gling to live comfortably alie biot silver mines leave accumulated enormous fortunee necessary to discuss what I 1 bo the effort of lie permanent i ir temporary of an inter national ratio by agreement of lie commercial of the haord because alie free wainage people lie eliat any nation i be consulted and fall hat is necessary is to alie united plates to proceed independently at once it the flat of a single is sufficient to impart value to a coin or any other commodities these gentlemen arc right but lie whole world lias been wrong for thou Minds of years and all the labor and nil the taxation to alio of hie world leave been subjected in alie pat haa bliwn unnecessary and unjustifiable I 1 eliat ilie fiat of tho docs not make was illustrated by alii history of alie trade dollar that was coined arci of chang and i without to alie owners of bill 1 lion and contained thirty six more gribin limn nas contained in two half i dollars orloue quarters it legal tender tor all alts up to ta just as halt i dollars and were 1 alie trade dollar more valuable intrinsically but without the credit of the government bank to SO cents ft lule alie less valuable coins were maintained at full par what happened to the trade dollar was what would haboon to all other silver dollars if free and unlimited coinage were adopted mr carlisle will leave liere tomorrow over alie A ohio for washington after the tonight alie secretary was tendered a reception at alie club |