Show the chicago nov 6 judge grosscup rendered a decision against alie packer today to day in the case of the big four packers swift armour monis and hammond against tho railroads to recover money alleged to havn been taken from them in excessive rates on meats shipped fast from chicago the defendants aro the philadelphia reading nicklo plate delaware lack awana western grand trunk and eight other trunk lines in the baet the amounts which the packers beek to recover a about judge grosscup practically held that in the absence ol 01 a national common law and legislation applicable to the case the packers could not recover on tho groenda that the rate was unreasonable |