Show additional TELEGRAPH A disgraceful SCENE gov tallman and senator butler make themselves obnoxious lively row in railway car over the result of a A and profane end in smoke charleston 6 july 31 After the cam palen meeting at union today governor tulman and senator batler melon the train golenp to and wordy altercation ensued concerning the premature publication of an article on the dispensary question to which reference bad been made by the governor in bis speech so that when senator statler followed an attempt was made by tillmans supporters to bowl him down the tor bought out the governor in the pullman car and upbraided him for bad faith the governor showed no inclination to adjust the matter whereupon senator duller exclaimed 1 I want to eay that you perpetrated a deliberate fraud today I 1 have come to tell on that these matter must be settled personally and ill meet you anywhere you know where to find me 1 I know said governor tallman you know you put those hoodlums up to howling roe down and you know you perpetrated a lie when you did continued senator butlar colonel caughman interjected yes be is a liar him and with this be made a move towards big hip pocket was crowded to one side in the commotion governor tallman at this juncture arose and said now general butler you are old and one legged and you are one eyed retorted senator ii ufler that hurt my physical power you know im not afraid of you said the governor 1 I dont suppose you are but can find roe at any time was the reply general batler made some reference to blackguards howling at him governor tillman promptly replied shakina his finger in duttera Dut lera face yes blackguards have fall sway in the state now and you are one of those who helped to enact the anti dueling law about fifteen years apo and a gentleman cannot obtain satisfaction for an insult I 1 am not afraid that make any difference ill meet you anywhere and in anyway said senator butler the two principals kept up a fire of words for a minute or two when general butler said he did not intend to stand any more insults about paying his debts and when governor tillman bad anything to say he knew where to find him you made reference to my debts said mr batler and awill ive beard that you paid mortgage why you state that on the stand because I 1 did not choose to you know it Is not true it Is a lie said Till tuan 1 I just want to repeat to you not to presume on my age or infirmities and to tell you that I 1 aiu meet you at any place or at any time was butlers reply 1 I am simply defending myself youve I 1 been making insinuations in the papers and I 1 am tired of your attacks replied tillman I 1 1 I want you to understand my position I 1 have not insinuated anything about you why dont you deny what I 1 charged and not go into personalities asked batler when you want to ficht eay so 1 I dont want to fight you said tillman r well refrain from making personal remarks about me said butler you have no right to make any insina eions as to my publeo life was the governors reply 1 I dont make any insinuations replied butler theres no use talking any more when you have anything to say come to me first general batler again referred to the howling which occurred att the meeting when governor tillman replied you know had no more to do with that than you did 1 I want it understood that im going to have my free speech if I 1 have to fight for it but dont put those hoodlums on me said batler by this time conductor hawkins appealed to anem to be biet ae he lose his job if be permitted such things in his car thereupon the altercation ceased |