Show BV CLOSE VOTING senate agrees to a conference tariff bill returned to conferees no instructions given dubols and blackburn exchange coin july 27 the indica bione tione when the senate met at noan today were that the struggle over alie resolution to abreo to a farther conference on the tariff bill ackel for would be ended before adjourn ment in the morning leour debate occurred over the clause n the conference report on the army appropriation bill transferring the apache indians held as prisoners of war in alabama to phenil flarv reservations in the dubois i against bending ahme indians en charge that tr auit aft delay action on the appropriation bill incensed dubois and manderson Mand ereon who accused of bad receding from the amendments ho ufler ed you had no right to receder said dubois 1 I bad the right replied iglio kentucky senator hotia and theja ene tore attempt to define my is a piece of In pertinence which I 1 resent no more than I 1 resent retorted dubois the conference report was agreed to 38 to 18 then at I 1 05 jones called up the conference report i ho pending ort was the doci sion of the chair on the points i of order raised by gray and milid against laih burns motion to instruct the senate conferees to recede from the boc differential on sugar above 16 dutch standard manderson Mand ereon argued the point of order vigor that it was competent for the senate to instruct ita conferees senator harris in the chair the point of order against motions an appeal wag then taken the vote on the motion to lay the appeal on the table was a tie 32 to 32 and the motion was lost the negative vote consisted ot 28 republicans public ans hill democrat alim kyle and befler populists lists brewart edid idid not vote those voting in tho were all democrats ampol from the decision of the chair u yeas 32 32 the senate liavine failed the chair ill boty on the motion of washburn tr instruct alie conferees to from th one eighth differential atie nays 32 tie motion wai not agreed to the bill was then beat to theaon forence without instructions and without a division divi eion of the senate |