Show decision in the atchison Atch lson case CHICAGO nov II 11 the arbitrators in the lie Atchi atchisonn sons appeal from chairman caldwelle Cal dwells decision in tit the famous row TOW over rates to denver during the knights templar conclave handed down their deci decision toda today they find the charges that chairman haldwell Ual dwell and various members of the western Pass enFer association are guilty pigi n g with the tile alton to deprive de e the A c h g of its rights ore are maintained but hold that the tile atchison Atch lson was not fai fairly cly treated either by the chairman or ills fellow members they find the atchison was justified in making a 12 rate that it presented cited to the chairman sufficient justification fi to warrant its meeting mcc tint the action 0 of outside lines and the decision of the chairman Is reversed |