Show A GREAT CASE the con troverse tro versy EVIDENCE AND OON will boll maintain a monopoly of 1 he telephone business or not t y hi aad prea to the i aik i NOT ll 11 the hearin the telephone cases was resumed before alio llio ef alic interior today to day V mr guinti for mhd citi com i ead alo plit of and that lie koput in edt lence aa tend ill to show that lull waa not alie original atthe telephone lel ephone aanon tho papers woj a communication from aftin attorney general gooda alio opinion that was the inventor of the telephone and iliac been irregularly justifying in his opinion alio alio suit by the united states to pet aside the patent A number of telephone models originals and productions were next produced and their mode of operating expert A number of affidavits toady by hiven borsand tor sand experts were read at length one by edison wherein he states that liis carbon telephone la now used altogether by the bell company that he had not heard of bells experiments ight n he kahun invented his telephone hone but had read an mccoun invention As supporting the allegations of irregular practices in the patent aulce another affidavit by ex examiner Wllbur was read reciting the circumstances attending the presentation of grays caveat on the same day that bell application was received bilao endorsed by wrapper gravs caveat filed february 24 isar and that beils tion had been suspended became bec aue it had been the practice of the to recognize only a in the date of filling such pai ers the endora nn nt of commissioner ellis speare directing the revocation of the tu pei fory order for alie reason that it appeared that bells application had been filed two hours before grays caveats was alo read extracts from the testimony given in the were presented as bearing on alio alleged unlawful disclosure of the nai na i ture caveat nr young reail an affidavit by pro fesser elillia gray af chicago rn the professor gray benina the statement that ber ochia a num other think fa to delaie the telephones to tho harmonic telegraphic company in consideration of a mock in company patents were alien conveyed to the A speaking telephone corn pany by the harmonic Company fir tie of one ot lie stock of alie american company mr gray beales Anier iran tele phone go tl and stock harm mu aej vestern Ves lern telegraph conk pany y the real defendants ip the bait of the known a the dowd ahe sonae ti me after iff institution suit nays prof grav alx se in pa tents involved iha cm ip 20 per cent nallie roya lilies received ami to share in kelion and the of other ua t nia bays he tiow believes that alio was not in ewd a view li 9 by the court cyp reul leil from llie ex at and after 11 haid lt en waa done for the common bem tit of the and burh a decree as they ile aired rt as entered in the case prof gray had nol control over the case at any time he says and his was by the Q in which lie blued a on february and afterward learned that professor bell on tho bame day filed an lor an improvement on multiple he learned but not until after bells patent had been issued that in it ho claimed to have invented a telephone affiant hen reviews tho circumstances al the dismissal of the interference between hibst lf and hell and the issuance oatlie patent to tho lai 1 tur i continuing he says he is informed I 1 and believes that in a few days after lh issuance of that potent bell mado an which hn t biech ii ech tie learned that first transmitted kiriu ewh limni sli liquid as ijo in ae t and in in bellg ait plu alion for a ann binm he le that alk 11 thal aiila deviny hi counsel eliat bell biad d at the nn one ratie afu clorn pl orn ansin a receiver nearly re ils Cira yB ilia coun fl infra rw hlin atiat li was t itally it ally deft nied and eliat hetvin t an ope instrument would lie did not wr wt th nt in eyo of alie law br H tip yb as w t and ayery hrc famini atom at that hii madeoy n tie wl w dmd beep dealt uh in the matter of Ilece rilly and lont einie tl fral ants were made and referred to falip ramo to iiii knowledge thai fon vim ed libin ilat li WIM aroni in as aad believing hel biad hm he BH oo 00 he liall aann way bif his caveat anil ite and that fth knoHl edlo can which ht fiant rr ue ray had gup poach atiat hl a at i iriti secret in the patent office as it should bave done and known to bell what lie koiv stated on the subject was stated in view of tho in which satisfied him that mr bell obtained his secrets claimed his discovery aa his own nu by this weans gt the crad invention acting however baak under tho bol lefin mr belle fairrus ain alie inetter and unde ritho advice of noun ael as to his rights as before explained pla ined lie made auch and aau aa would mt um to acknowledge bellai invention brini arder aliis arlief br lief continues mr gray lie did not take steps to file liis application or hia caveat but thu matter rested until nd 1 1 in a e that hiowt en arf ull U ll hal in 1877 arof ray ach hr afa idd 1 till f nin r alp cr dit as an actual drs ov crerand inventor under alie baliff as to priority also read a letter telf to the counsel of the bell compa hy calling for the production of the contracts alleged to have between li yell i and E goll antl stock and western union companies the blake Berline radd others aulter sir frnnk ex p that he wished to establish hy these contracts that the alleged telephone were in evolved that the dowd euit was in conclusive and was only brou alit to obtain a judicial judic fal alie patent and aliat beland hiaam entered into an unlawful combination to control all the tele phonic mr Star roty then opened the case for the bell company ilo said this was an eibrt ti reopen the suit discontinued at kempl is re adhere were merely copies of affidavits used in the former suits mr fe tarrow summarized the voluminous evidence that had been taken in the suit pending in haiti more brought by the belt company the company one f made by wil son who was an with sir bell in hh researches described the alie unknown to mankind be ftc thiu liine bell nta at llie centennial Ex wre w re ex nt and the ashtion was anale trial hiie f the who those instruments trial said grav stated cliot it was ali time in his biad ever listened at a telephonic receiver Sr arrow reading frieiro she 0 the baltimore trial up the affidavit of e giffoni conn sel for the wei tem union telegraph company in tin dowd trial u herein he admitted union telegraph company the 1 31 anu ins attorney ev ahloy pollock i as fully mee tint of irre in the issue of the dell pa tent in answering examiner wil hers aB davit put in the petitioners petition ers read from tho record of clift a second mado by wilhur abier the affidavit put in liy the petitioners petition ers and denying that been anny between and iro t hell an affidavit by lieutenant gay of the district police was prevented preen ted tn that eilbur had been akrc led ganv timers last for intoxication abdat least on two between the for the catl ed tho adi davit by ex sione he es that all of tha proceedings edinga tl d bell pai ems rei ular in fonn wag also read at this point the hearing was adjourned until |