Show UTAH IN CONGRESS the Nat nation ious s legislators trying it to solve 81 hie the veel mormon problem the tile valiant virtuous ter a of his own senate proceedings edin g s nf 0 r february twenty third congressional regional rem ional concluded the presiding officer the tile chair is not aware that the ques right of a senator ta take e on nil appeal where the record stand stands coull confronted with tho the action which he lie proposes to take t a LP lia hai ever been decided mr logan it ii about time that it should be the presiding officer the chair nill will therefore submit that question to the senate mr donai 1 l ir it A debatable question mr edmunda edmunds no it does doea not arise out ofa of a question that is open to debat debate the presiding officer no debate is in order upon any tion the question now submitted to the senate id is whether the senator from louisiana mr jonas has a right fight to ta appeal from the deci decision of the chair mr edmunds the dee dechon islon made the presiding officer tho the de chion majonas made mr mi Jonas aask I 1 ask for the yeas and nays T the he yens y a and 1 nays were ordered T the h e Pires presiding idill g officer those who are of the opinion that tho the senator of bf louisiana has the ri right of appeal will make it known by nying saying yea those opposed will sa say 1 ballu nay as your names are called the secretary will call the roll mr L fr anthony when lib his name was called I 1 am paired with the tile senator from ohio mr pendleton Pend liton the roll call wil having been concluded tile result avas announced Y hiis 9 nays 16 1 as follows YEAS 9 beck jonfa brow n janes of florida vall maxey mckrell aih krell voorhees bees gorman ways 16 allson t jo joneson Jone nevada barrows boglin blair mcdill of wis luH ilIan illan conger rollins edmunds sawyer Garld garland nd Sher inam harrison anthony an thou lamar laphaun butler mcpherson Cai nilen mahone cameron of pa miller coke miller oan Y mitchell pavis of AV we va A morgan dawes 1 morrill fil I 1 r pendleton r ar I 1 ley C platt ferry ry plumb frye 0 pugh george Itan groome Gro onie cro ver saunders dere hale liale 1 4 1 clater slater harris tabora Tabor 4 I lawley vance II 11 van vanwyck hoar hear vest Iii 10 galla walker jack jackson san williams Willi ains johnston the presiding officer tho the senate decided that the senator from louisiana rJ jonas olias has not the right of appeal from the chair in this cac eme mr maxey at 9 and 50 minutes p DI I 1 move that the senate do now adjourn 31 edmunds no business has interfiled inter filed I 1 the pres p idilio officer the chair ai j of opinion that baciu having 6 submitted the question of order to the senate for its decision business has his intervened the question is on the motion of the senator from texas ley that the senate ad journ urn mr call I 1 ask forthe for the yens and nayl iye alie ri yeas yens and nays were not dered mr cull call I 1 withdraw therall the call mr maxey I 1 male make the demand for the yeas and nays the yeas and nays were ordered and d the principal leg legislative isla tive U clerk erk proceeded the r roll oil 11 in anthony when liis his edme was called I 1 am paired with th alie e senator f from rom ohio mr tou ton arc ameron of wisconsin when his name was COI called cd I 1 am paired with the senator croul mr george mr morgan i called I 1 am paired with the sen alor from new ew york mr lap liam the roll call havil having 1121 been concluded the result was announced veas 10 nays 16 15 aa as follows fullow 10 beck clawy at br brown D tri 1 1 9 c call 11 Sher erman nian german gorman plater litter jonae jonas voorhees ea 1 t allison Allie jenft of florida harrow barrow junes jones of nev blair loam cockro 41 ft conger mitcel HAl edmunde munds rollins garland sawyer ul aldrich johnston Johi uton anthony kellogg tk byard a rd lamar butler lapham comden camden ichill cameron Cai of pa mcpherson cameron of wis mahone coke miller of cal davis Davi of ill miller orn NY Y davie davis of IV va morgan dawes dart ea Alo morrill trill fair pendleton parley farley platt ferry plumb arrye orn geogre booi gooi ne BRuM miry broome sal luders grover sewell halo hale tabor hampton ampton II bauce harris van wack hawley vent ili hill walker hoar williams william ingalls window windom jackson so the senate refused to adjourn ad the presiding Pre eiding iding officer the question recurs on oil agreeing to the r resolution m lution of the senator from vermont mont mr edmund edmunds mr german gorman I 1 ask that the tile resolution may inay be read 9 the presiding officer tho secretary will read the resolution odthe of the senator from vermont the acting secretory secretary read as follows order aliat the sergeant tat t at A arms ams bring into the senate enate forthwith the following named Sen Senai ALors ore now absent from this sitting of the tile senate without ita its leave namely senators aidrich bayard beck butler Il camden davis of virginia D dadee frye groome groyer grover hale hampton II ampton harah hawley awley II hill hill hoar Jaul jackson johnston Jo linston kello delloce Kel loce I 1 sia hone bone amiller of now w york morrill pendleton Pend leion platt plumb ransom Pan som saulsbury Saul abury sewell Sh sherman ermano vance van Wyc tand band williams mr sherman I 1 lero desire to c guy my mr germau au As the senator from Kentucky mr beck ie is ent now I 1 mode move to amend the resolution by striking out hie his name mr edmunde edmunds no amendment aroc ailment is in order I 1 make the point of order against the senator from maryland if senators do not like resolution they can vote it down mr beck does the tile reao resolution lution order the arrest of these who are here mr I 1 make the point of order that not in order mr beek I 1 propose to inqui inquire re whether the tile resolution now offered prop proposes osei to arrest those of us who arc are liere here tho the Pre presiding eiding officer the secretary will read the tile resolution for the information of the senator froni from kentucky tho the resolution waa was again read mr beck that ia is net not truo true upon ita frace liim in the senate mr edmund debate ia is not io in order mr beck beek but the truth ought to be told if the senator from vermont thinks it ia is in order to have the record state what is not true I 1 have tho the right to tell the truth I 1 mr voorhees I 1 rise to it parliamentary lia inquiry I 1 ask whether it is in order for the senate to put udom its record a self evident falsehood senators aro are named in the resolution as absent when as a fact they arc are here present and answering to their names the Pre presiding eiding officer the chair docs does not feel called upon to decide a question of that description no point of order having been raised mr edmunds t will modify the resolution by striking out the names of the senator from ohio mr sherman and the senator from kentucky mr beck beek mr slater the tile berla and naye nay were ordered upon the resolution and it cannot bo modified without unal unanimous limous consent I 1 object mr beck beek I 1 went home having been paired ed and my family being sick and I 1 came heck hock ae as soon as I 1 wa notified so did the sel senator from ohio mn in berneau bern au lau I 1 under understand stend that mhd th reeo revolution lution is not ilot ame amendable Jable mr edmunds edmun ds no butI but I 1 haye linTe modified it mr brown if it ii not amendable what right has the senator from froin vermont to modify it without the consent of the senate I 1 mr edmunde Edmun dg lecause leca uee we are not acting 1 I can not make the argument aument na a debate ie is not in order the presiding officer veer the nie chair holds that this resolution as all other resolutions before tile senate S nate id is nm amendable but that it must be done one without debate mr barrow TZ then i an I 1 move to strike out the names of the senator from ohio mr sherman and the senator from bep kentucky tu mr becaj the presiding officer the question ia is on tl the ie motion of the senator from georgia mr barrow to strike out the names of the tile senator from ohio mr sherman and the senator from kentucky y mr beck mr cal cikk e on that question I 1 ask lisk for the yeas and nay the tile yeas and naya nays we wy vp ordered mr ale mcmillan millan I 1 understood ahr t the resolution was modified before the motion of the senator from georgia mr barrow waa was submitted the pre presiding iding officer it was a question whether the resolution being in the possession of tho tile senate the senator from vermont had the right te to modify it without leave leate mr ur german gorman I 1 submit immediately after the resolution was read I 1 moved to amend it by striking out the name of the senator from kentucky mr beck the presiding officer the chair so understood bafo before rc d the 10 proposition to modify ill daify had been made the secretary will call the roll ou on agreeing agreci ng to the amendment oath of the S senator at r from georgia mr barrow what is the amendment the presiding officer the bucs ion is on the motion of the tb senator from Georgi aMr barrow to strike out the names of the senator fro from M kentucky ken tucky DL mr fr beck and tho the senator from ohio mr sherman mr jonas I 1 ask for a division of the tile question tion tho the ke presiding si ding officer the senator tor is entitled to a division of the qu question tion the chair is not inuos in sion of the precise form of the amendment whether the name of tho senator from kentuck kentucky or odthe of the senator from ohio occurs birst first mr barrow barrows the name of the senator from ohio was stated first the presiding officer the question fuestion W be therefore taken first on striking out the name odthe of the senator from frow ohio mr edmunds that is a mistake of fact the names arc are in alphabetical order mr groome mr mt president I 1 should like to ask what question la is before the senate tho tile presiding Pre tiding officer tho the question before the senate is upon tho the motion gia mr barrows to strike out the names of the senator from ohio mr sherman sherma p h and the senator from froin kentucky mr beck by way of amendment te to the resolution of the senator from froth vermont mr edmunds mr 1 conger I does that mean to strike them from the rolls of the senate the presiding officer it ia is to strike them from tho the order which ia is proposed by tho the senator from vermont mr groome I 1 should like to nek ask what the order is having been out for a short period laughter mr maxey I 1 submit that the senator from maryland is not present ell t the presiding officer the chair will not entertain any question of order until the senate ia is in ord order er mr groome exactly what I 1 am endeavoring to ascertain ia is what the business is before the senate edmunds it being perfectly amr I 1 obvious under the rulings of the chair and the votes totes en on the other side that it is impossible even to s nd for absent senators I 1 move that the senate adjourn mr cockrell I 1 hope the senator will not make that motion until we get those senators from that residence where the host bost refused admission to the messengers odthe of the senate mr E edmunds debate is is not in in order the presiding officer debate is not in order the tile senator from vermont moves that the senate adjourn the motion was agreed to and at 10 p ra rn the senate ad jou journea jour ned |