Show TRIAL the Mi murderer man felts bore more malice malica and mischief fo causing jim to be at last removed to the dock where whom ho he rid fidgets gets for rear to be fired at oy W U tele mah to like HERALD washington dec SS 28 guiteau came into the court roam this morning looking paler than usual he lie had not slept well A nan man wag was placed in a cell near his in s who was suffering from the most violent type of faustd by the excessive use of morphine and during the whole night his shrieks rang through the jail Guiteau was annoyed and asked what was the occasion for such riot the keeper replied weve got a crazy man on our hands ds tonight to night well said eaid guiteau why dont y you on choke him and make him keep quiet and not let respectable people be disturbed in this way by a miserable lunatic dr macdonald was cress cross examined by scoville Sc oTille mainly on temporary insanity the witness was asked if in his practice he lie had not met an instance of temporary insanity he lie replied yea yes sir I know of a man who was insane for 24 hours scoville eagerly and then begot we well I no N sir lie died pa laughter at scoville villes expense the witness was fu further asked what he lie meant yesterday by saying think lie th the prisoner haa been play ing in a part in ill court and replied I believe he be lias has been feigning what he believed to ba insanity I believe he lie has been attempting to give an imo im pres Bion in court that he lie is insane and with that idea has been acting a part scoville soon became involved involve I in in discussion with counsel on the pertinence odthe of the question when guiteau shouted you had better let go you ou are making altogether too muc much of him isyou if you have bave not got enough sense to see it I will have to tell yon allusion was made to the aie axe incident when guiteau commented con temp oh oli nonsense that axe story is the merest fiction its allrud all rub bish bi shand and shortly afterwards dg doe doctor just tell something about abraham and we will let you go the witness was asked if he lie was not discharged for granting a false certificate of health to win amm M tweed when theatter the latter was in confinement in the penitentiary he lie replied I never gave tweed a certificate of health and I was never dischar discharged gd from any position in my life dr randolph barksdale bupt supt of the central lunatic asylum near richmond va had visited the pris prisoner at the jail he ile had also closely observed him in court and from his personal examination and observation was of the opinion that he lie was sane the witness also testified that he believed guiteau had bad been feigning felling in court the witness believed taking as true the facts set forth in the two hypothetical questions of the prosecution that the prisoner iva was s sane when lie shot the president dr john 11 cullender Cul lenden of nashville supt bupt of the tennessee asylum for the insane had given special attention to the study of insanity for the past twelve year years and had san seen about 2000 cases during his connection with the tennessee asylum tae witness visited the prisoner in jail and also closely observed the prisoner in court and believed him perfectly sane tito witness L believe brieve tile deity ever inspired any one to kill kil I a fellow c creature an in any one who labored under such and insane delusion would show allow it in act if not by words Ans answering the hj by po questions he lie said the prisoner was undoubtedly sane scoville excepted and guiteau interposed his remarks scoville made a sharp cross examination after recess scoville put the hy ho question which embraced the clause suppose the prisoner believed himself to be partner with jesus Ch chraft rift judge porter protested against the 01 question u estion as blasphemous and it would be a disgrace to a court of justice and christian nation to allow it entertained for a moment scoville replied if no allusion could be made to what was claimed to bo be the actuating motive or influence that led to his act then the whole defense would be wiped away with one single stroke judge porter proceeded to insist upon his views and declared the time had come when in the name of the on behalf of the government in a federal court he lie felt ft tt his duty to demand that the edner be removed to the dock guiteau spitefully oh you do you bis biz mouthed porter the court officials sitting behind the prisoner attempted to quiet him when he lie wheeled around and snarled atone at one of them will you mind your business or ill slap you in the month you f fool 01 you youl it judge porter continued his remarks and guiteau again interrupted him and shouted well you had better mind your own business judge porter that is my business bt here her today to day and your honor I must now insist upon my notion motion of saturday that the prisoner be removed to the tile dock ocl scoville arose to speak when judge cox said let me know first if the counsel chuh tel desire to be heard upon the motion to remove the prisoner to the deck dock judge davidge then proceed proceed to s speak eak on the motion ho believed me the time had come when everyone every one present was perfectly perfect satisfied that the prisoner was perfectly sane in respect to his behavior M and amenable to the same role rules as other prisoners in the case of gen sickles who was tried in this court for murder the ju judge ige refused to deviate from the rule although t laough he lie was a distinguished lawyer and member of congress at the time ho lie sat in ahn prison prisoners ees dock durin during ghis his trial scoville said he would assent to any proposition pro si t it which wl ch might night I be deemed necessary e sa r no one had suffered mo more re than b he had id from th alic e prisoners behavior guiteau interrupting well its because you are a jackass on this case if I had bad a decent counsel I have any occasion for remarks you are doing well enough on your theory but your theory is allo altogether gether too narrow you hatnot got brains enough for this case col reed denied the assum assumption tion that the thi prisoners sanity had teen been established no human knowledge could fathom the workings of an insane mind and humanity would dictate that a reasonable doubt should exist that leniency be extended to 71 ward him he ili ought an admonition from the court would tul aultice tice burkhill Cur Cork khill bill insisted upon the removal of the tile prisoner to the dock and the removal from around him bim of lie tile special policemen who were not regular attendants of tho court that f should bo be kept in dock with no other special protection than is accorded an any oilier other prisoner guiteau trembling bling with nith anger apprehension shouted out yon to shoot roe me do you you corkhill you rant cant convict me meso so you u ant to get ino me shot you might aj well hang me up outside and tell men to shoot me I tell yon raisin his hi voice almost to a shriek god Almi lity would curse you sir if I was pui put in a that dock and shot you miserable retch you scoville with inn feeling protested against the tile imposition of the dis district t brict attorney NN aich the court knew would not be understood by any one as other than an invitation to all who heard it to shoot the prisoner an all L opportunity offered alter after a most impressive argument by judge porter in which he lie repelled the reflection of the counsel for the defense upon the district attorney jud judae jude e cox gave his opinion stating eliat no certain measure to silence the tile prisoner could have been taken that would not have abridged his constitutional tut ional rights whereas it had been deemed and he thought rightly that the prisoners behavior and utterances would prove the best means of determining terin ter ining his bli mental condition he ile ordered the prisoner removed to the dock which was then done |