Show GARS CARS DO NOT OT OTHAVE HAVE TO STOP I In an opinion by the supreme court handed down Friday Frida It is lS decided that the Ogden Osden Rapid Transit company does docs not have hae to stop Its cars at Lewiss resort In canyon Last summer J D Skeen of o Lewiss resort applied to ho tho district court In county for or a writ of oC mandate directed against the street streetcar streetcar streetcar car company compelling the company compan to stop slop Us lis cars at the Lewis resort for the convenience of or passengers Judge Howell Issued a peremptory p I writ rit from frets which the company appeal appealed ed The Tho supreme court holds that tho thoI I lower court was not Justified in Iu Issuing IssuIng ing lug the order and the decision Is re reo reversed reversed I versed Tho opinion Is written raton by ly byI I Justice prIck with Chlof Justice and amid Justice McCarty concur concurring concurring concurring ring In Iii replying to Sheens claim as to residence the answer says sas is somewhat roving loving i t and Inde indefinite mite and amid with somewhat exacting resden wants In Iii glowing slowing terms lerms tho thin company compan boosts for fOl Ogden canyon With true Irue I and pardonable local pride says sas tho time answer the tho defendant confesses confes es tho Iho alluring and cooling allegations of par paragraph paragraph 5 G that hint said Ogden canyon eanon Is at ato attractive attractive as a t summer rest real and hereby pledges pled es to the tho affiant and joins join with him In its continuing and continued efforts financial and moral written and spoken to lo preserve its name and spread Its Us fame fanic ame as such stich Selah Admits that during June July August and September lie Iho gentle and cooling hi breezes cozes the Iho rugged grandeur and shaded nooks and the tumbling waters with tho tIme piscatorial denizens thereof and sundry resorts with their I refreshing refresh lag beverages beverage terpsichorean J floors and amid entrancing music do attract ninny many people up along and amid Into said canyon and alleges In that behalf beha that this lila defendant encourages such I migration for fOl pleasure and health through its said electric line lino and amid by b on of tho the convenience reliability and satisfaction of Its service Further along alon tho the defendant admits large lar c sums of money mone have hao been heen ex cx expended pendell in building summer residences and hotels but bul defendant further sad sadly sadI ly h I avers that they thoy are aie mostly at oth other er Or points than at this resort and that no hotels with wide piazzas and bland welcoming tIme the arriving guest nor otherwise nor at all grace tho tIme scenic acres that comprise tho the said Lewis resort Tho legal battle grow out of the action of tho Ogden Rapid Transit company In refusing to lo stop its Us cars at the tho Lewis resort in time the canyon enn on where several families camp during the summer mouths months Tho The camp is between Peers Peers resort and the time Her Hermitage at both of or which places the railway has maintained stops slops Il It was claimed by h Scon that this Us was sas dis dla discriminating criminating against those who camp ed cd at time Iho Lewis resort In effect tho supreme court holds that in the absence of state stale statutes that courts of o Utah Ulah cannot compel time the railroad to lo provide stations and anti moko stops SLOpS vor tor in other othor words can cannot cannot not hot direct the affairs of oC the company compan It is held that It would work a hard hardship hardship hardship ship upon the companies If Ir followed out ont for petitions could be demanding that railroads stop trains at many man places s whore it is 15 found In Inadvisable Inadvisable advisable by time the companies The su Sli court holds that the time courts have no power to enforce this order Tho charge charbe of oC discrimination is al nl also also so discouraged hy by b tIme the supreme court The rho court says sas that the tho notices of the tho company com pan stated staled that no stops would be made malic between Peers and the time Her milage between which points the tho Lewis resort Is situated If It sonic some oth other other er stops wore were made malle It Is contended contend ell by h the higher court then there thero would I be grounds for the charge of oC discrimination i I |