Show HARRY ARRY THAW TA IS S DECLARED DELAR I AND AN MUST GO 1110 BACK TO 10 I I I Justice Advises That Privileges Enjoy Enjoyed ed at First Be and That is mothers Visits Be Unlimited I Whit Plains Aug state of New ew won a complete victory over Ocr harry K Thaw rha when 1 Isaac Isiac N that the Uie slayer of Stanford White was sUll sUIi SPIlL him 10 I o the lie for fUI forthe the insane at Not ot olle of the man muJe jud hy by Thaw during the three of his recent ts h lie He HeIs lieis Is somewhat belter off of than lie he the thc present sull because Justice Mills In his decisIon Su lie sug suggestion amounts to Thaw at be restored to the IU privileges ho he en cn jo Joyel 1 during the nl first t three months of his stay slay there and that his mother lie he nil a I I the thc mill receive eel every when whon she calls call to see him Thaw will ilI remain In the jail at least until tomorrow when lien his altor Hey will be given a chance to make an any motions before iI I at his chambers in Ver Vernon Vernon non The prisoner OOl the decision cool cooly y Ills His only statement was a denial J of f the assertion In the courts opinion that he still cherished the same delu delusions that drove him to shoot White Whilo In formal language Justice Mills III II s decision dismissed tIme the writ of habeas corpus under which Thaw applied for hl his lIberty and remanded him to 10 the timo custody of the tho Robert Roberl I D Lamb of I slate hospital In Is now mios Insane the court gives first importance to hIs mill auth history His Ilis do de t I hat time prisoner has lint yet ret Is bused basel principally on Limo tho opinion of Dr Amos AniOs Baker as Superintendent of asylum in All such authoritIes sa says s JustIce Mill ore arc wilh no con conceivable motIves to do their duty ci Ott court sa says s It was as more coil COli IJ hy the testimony of the call called d for time the state than b by that or of time the experts RegardIng Dr D lie he says H lie e experienced groat Iii In iii reconciling his present opinion with his Ii is at t I I ode III I mm con eel Ion wI Lii time the homicide trial and to my mind r did not entirely stuccoed ill iii so 60 doing made a mad iliad on the judge by his actions both bothon on and off the witness stand The opinion calls particular atten lion Ion to Tha Thaws s facial appearance OS es d durIng the lost last afternoon of the thc testimony whon hon for t twenty went I tiles utes ht he In of his extravagant belief as to Whites con comi with a certain woman An unusual paragraph In Iii hums ice Mills opinion Is in 10 Mrs Ills Mary I I I Copley Thaw lImo tho prIsoners mother rhe Ihie court says While this regard to DI time the court il is b by no means sat I with he m treatment which has at aL since his return In last afler his unsuccessful attempt lit In tIme the courts then to obtain his freedom No ono one I could help being g hy I lie tho unfeigned listless of time molher when hen ns as n a witness she nat Hal rated that treatment tellin telling how after his to the in institution ho was refused his fornier formel comfortable rill fit u room roon nightly to till In iii the ward lm In the pre of fifty or om more memo unquestioned to 10 las pasH the between rows of ci cots time tho sick In them to his wit h the hod as its solo sole ar article tide of ore amid remain thoro in iii darkness ten from S p m in mIn lii In considering this less allowance must be made for forthe the of the feelings It 11 mush he be understood that Thaw i is not in the bOj hospital as a to un on Tho Ilio time the sit u authorIty In III the tho matter has b bits by its declared Thaw of an aIm crime in iii the mat tel em of time the I clde and that lint must he 1 re respected at L least b by nil all public lit In tIme the hospital hu ho be regarded is an person afflicted with there Ic not to lo ho bo for any but solely to tobe tobe be cared carell for protected ani guarded d so that hat I lie he may not or 01 himself bitt always with tho ho distinct hello that he mar he be hoever great or sma small that hat hope real really ly Iy ma lila be beIt beit It Is vohl that care came should be bc exercised h 1 the tho authoritIes that he be not favored because or of Continued on Page Four 1 HarY Thaw Declared Insane and Must Go o Back to from Page One tho he wealth and social position of his family I It Is wel however thaL care caro be o exercised that hue 10 lie ho not as aa worse on those It Il mn wel vohl Ill be that tills court in iii the tho exorcise of ls chancery pow iio en has the ii h order to tomake tomake make Rn specific directions cus as to lie treatment of nfl an Inmate In such an however lint may Dm ho he I to lo to the lie auth that lint when Thaw is TO their custody the privIleges ho he waS permitted to enjoy In his imis three months stay be 0 to mo him II if much a be not no found to ho be lellI with due disc plino mind and further lint his venerable and most mother he be at al ni all times Ir I with tie tile CO con consideration 1101 I condition commands the sympathy of norma mind flayIng omit nut of for Iho Ih mot hem con J MIlls her ben ns as a witness lo Ic nl at wil her for fOl her son antI In so holing to gle give certain which I of id II u Jermo I deem It my duty ul to tc tolar I II lar say that criticisms seem to 10 00 me 10 h 0 be and iii ai sincere In the er 01 record mo me I fluid I Ino It no evidence of nn any or 01 undue urn zeal upon pun mm hl part parl I I I lie he made the i h by tl Irs vs ha w I hat he her SOi son Ie he frol I Iam I Iam I am confident It IL was made as the ex cx expression riot not of a hope hut but of a con Iclon that Ire he would not noL recover After the Iho evidence Jima Jus elusion Ils was or of the con Time The insanity which Harr was tin on une 25 nL at tine tho tinie Ire he the chIc was the lie kind known os as chronic or parnola paranoia rests tIre fuels facts which apal to mo me to he be clear I iv I I I There Thoro wa as in lug his stock stocka a lout not ery strong race of Insanity By y not iery ry is 13 that rio no one or of his direct an wa ever eer Insane Oui On the ma maternal sIde tivo lo uncles veme of urn un unsound sound mind fund each at al least lou for a pOl por porion ion tion of his lIfe aut antI on his side able an aunt was vas HI least an air tic Ilc Ind and Insane and atul S 1 0 more remote es were svere doubt edly Insane though ns as to them lie tho Is no not hurt hUl there had Insanity In iii ono one of their ances trl blues not common to the prison prisoners ers own descent As a young hue ho w eak l and exceedIngly and wIlful Older Olden he was to lent spoils amounting al almost almost most to of with without out cause lie He at schools for hf dlf periods from the a age e of six upward hiL limit made ILe little progress in fl at II lii his earl yours lie ha hail had out mit of excitement In which his Imis fadal facini appearance was wid it i Id and anal staring staring ContInuing the thc history of Thaws life MIlls says About 1 DOl 1901 he bolle became of a young ullis Nesbit whom lie he She w was shy b reputation aton wel well leown the or a ml mistress tress of Stanford White She son soon tnt that rein rela ton thou to lo Thaw and O obviously to ac account count to mIni him for hOI her ton then with While told toki him grossly stories of the lie in copLon of that relation Although ho he ws OS far from froni fronia fromn n a I om I lan and wag there engaged or soon thereafter became engage I II Iii practices of a perverted character Lr as revealed hy 1 the testimony 01 of the Merrill 1 woman ornan which the t afforded In other el dence In the case credible ho lr 3 gave absolute credence to lo the laeB S told iii br Miss Nesbit about t White II H obtained information as to n nr wl with h a few fow othe r youn women either Iron there or Miss al all of o I which information of the tho samo weil 1 Ind and Improbable to mind wat sas grossly 10 To al all however lie he ga helo His mind became oh ah wih stories He ll 3 not nol emily believed thorn them II thom eUle I ly bul lie hc from them COl corn as to th of far what stIch belIef In hele II a not lal mild Irom the ho charges separately maee by these few fow admittedly immoral women lie he con hUnt White maintained several In New Nei York City where he nc ac h by force or hy by the he ruin of young American girls as it Il WOe vere hy by whole wholesale Such belef belief to lo extreme was vas a ills us as to lo tine tho practices of were not shaken b by the tal tall urro of the investigations mado by y the lie detectives and amid iris his delusive In his special mis slon led to o his mind mindIn In that con condition at the roof gRden lie ho camo caine lute the lie presence of hlo and shot hot him to 0 heath In a SliCe since and manu maimer 01 lii In so doing lie ho believed itO was VOS acting a as aslie lie agent of arid and perform performIng burg Ing a act like that of Oal David In staying Colah or St In killing Iho ho t dragon Regarding Thaw or of n a against him h 11 his earl tho tic court Gars Such helo belief lint thal Is as to the tho PI oil without anti and u a clear AI A I i this coot 1 ii II is to the tho weight of expert to I Is lO of u it hiatt Thaws cit al tIre the commission of r ihie wa of r I imo kind lown Hi its paranoia and not al al I oj of I im half huf a il l suno sopo hal half a tommIe ii If an such zt n riot reI really The line verdict of Iho ho jury was plain plainly I ly warranted hy by tim evidence riot not merely cia as nn an expressIon of oC doubt l hit limit oven us as an Ing of time the fact of insanity I it Is m I ruo mure that the now this Introduced lii In behalf of the ends to II ury an lie of his life m as boo above ii St mod I h am convinced however t I II Inn such variance It I is ly largely ml millS tal n aunt and hll bitt the tue tc T t hal poInt t given shen at am I Ihie he second tm I trial In h nurse family ph anc teachers Is tho ho moro Conclusion K Ic Thaw hums not noL yet yol from his It IL all and defined This la Is made lp imp on the lie fol following lowing the experts agree thal in ina ina a case o of true paranoia recovery Is 10 vry very doubtful court Is disposed to lo lopar toI par I great respect to 10 the lie opinion of oC tho hospital Di 01 Baiter the hospital havIng mind charge or of Thaw tero Al All tHe silo cure arc with no conc conceivable 1 aule moll to do 10 doI t I hol dud du y sIes of lending traits of paranoia time the 11 lay testimony given hy in so man and eyed I wI conduct on the prisoners hart parL In the Tombs at and In the tho and Westchester jaIs jails Is riot not of force of tIre calell for the at as asto ato I to o his present condition seems to me meon I Ion on Ire tho whole more con convincing than thaur that hat or of caled called for fOI the prisoner roy my own oh of lie conduct of Thaw Thac hit his c actions and his speech II Iii tine tho court courtroom rom room hOlh on HII mitt or off tIne the witness t In c I have hae been Impressed that Inc ho hoi i bu now or of mind He was ex cx very cry oil iris his counsel with lons boris On Iris his it t oven cn h by hb liI own admissions that lie he holds his former a as to tc toI I Ilie I lie he ei evil of just as cx and just as strongly today at as I ever If beliefs ule do OIS In his mind wh when m he commit tod ed tIme the the Ire are uro the saint Hame 3 now lie ho has hns n evidence against White h lie lund had then it Is Isal in al all of to te and anul I or with what Ire he hal ham 1 i o extreme convictions In ii m lIne Part of his examination I when he was as mightily to do de defend loin fend his and amid heles his fa facial cial I Li rue e not lo loho 1 i ho that ol of a sane samie Sixth enlargement t 01 K now be than geromus to tire the and gells safety ali canot he |