| OCR Text |
Show HAWLEY SAYS HAYWOOD'S GUILT HAS BEEN PROVEN Declares That the Stale H Telly Corroborated the Story Told by Orchard and Appeals to Jury Isr Cenvlstlen ol the i Ltstr Leader. I Brine Idaho Janie II llawley. leading counsel for the state of Idaho, presenting the first of the ar-! gumeitta in the Jury In the ease against William I) I la) wood (poke for nearl) eight himra dlalrlbuted' over three sessions of cotirl Kven when tne allernoon session Balunlay had extended (ar lieyond the clisto-' mary time limit, every el In the court room wa occupied and re raalned ao until the laat word was spoken None llalencd more attentively to the argument than I la) wood, the defendant, de-fendant, and none allowed leu eiwt Hen from time to time lie look oopt oil note In a email IhkiK and frequent!) fre-quent!) made ailggesllolla to mie or other of his counsel Ihirlng hla addreaa Saturday, Mr llawley used an almost cmiveraallonal tone Step b) step he followed Or chard along the rtmd the great criminal crim-inal had selected after he left the Coeur d'Alene. slopping at the Vln dlcator mine and Hten al the Independence Inde-pendence del lu count sixteen dead In Denter om more wa added to the list and I he anabsla of leatlmon) III coniraillcllon of Orrhsr I stor) con cludeil fmiuentl) with the rienuiicla thill uf wlne after wllne aa will fill perlurettt or gullly of unintentional falseho.nl Mr llawle)'a peroral lou was Im presslve There was Ho attempt at any Might of oralor), hut only a strong note of deep alncerll) and great ear ileal neaa when he pleaded for an honeat Judgment from honest men or Idaho W'e will be t barged." he aald "with making war nn this Western Federation ol Minora, hut I ask for )nur honeat Judgment I do not seek to hang the calm of Innocent men to my lielt I am her to hunt down I he guilty" Mr Hawle) aald he did not charge that a majority or eten that man) of the Western Pederatloti of Minora were crimluals, but that the evil deed of the olllcera and of the scum of the organisation had brought dla credit on the rank and Die The time hail Indeed come, he aald when right thinking men should rise and make war tiMHi the evil influence that were the curse of all labor orgnnlsa tlons t n liilmt bIhiu llin Ufirltl Im ni eluded, that here in Idaho we are n law alibiing ami n Hod fearing iieople, who will deal out oven handed Justice to the criminal nccmed or the highest crime aa to the trump charged with some H)tty breach ol the law Mr Hawle) declared that Hie state-ini state-ini tits made l) Orchard hsd been our tlioraliMlratiilMl"-llme,ttiet-.l of the Western Federation or Miners wire brought to Iho bar of Justice nnd shown (hut there Is ,i higher law In this laud than their own desires. "It I time for us," he continued, ''to show them thai hero In Idaho we nre u law abiding, u Uod rearing people peo-ple who Intend to do our duty low aril the leaders of the Western Federation of Mluer or some lowly tramp with some minor offense We bellete )'iu men of Hie Jur) are Impressed wllh a drill desire to do your dtit) as ton see II All that the proaicutlon naka la your host Judgment, )our honest Judgment 'In the argument on the other side we will hear much or capital waging war on labor unlona Nothing could lie more untrue In this caae All that has been spent In this Inqulr) has come from the corfers of the state of Idaho A lo laUir union no mani has a higher regard than I have for them and no man believes mora strongl) than I do lhat laboring mini should baud themselves together to secure shorter hours and higher I wngea Hut the Western Federation or Miners, under Hie leadership ofj M wr ll.i anoii and P'ttlbnne, can 1LLL1 i. rlaxai wllh uii) of the labor JaLLH uiiiinlratloiia that we know of and 'liaHH whli h will Ih- r. fi rred to h) counsel gaLLH for tin labor organisations that mm laLaLH know an not In criminal hands and sgagfl are mu i rliulmil In Intent and par. t MgagaH lane Ni liher are th rank and AM iHKiafl of the Weatern Federal Ion of Miner, aHaKan hnt the organisation haa fallen Into taLB alnlaler hnnda flBLB Holae, Idaho- Tbe Held fur arlW- Hn mem iHith from the pnmonitlon aatl HEkv-V' ilefenae of William II llgywoo.1 hi &&' been limited hy Indge Wood, who la fSn J a derision handed down on rrlday r- I Ki y v moved from conslderatloo of Ih Jnrjr jAi r t all evidence bearing on the alhtfal fJ, ! conspiracy h) mine owners and ollicra LA ' i' against the Western Feilemllrm of Ki. ' Miner Judge Vo-d decided lhat Mm HP ' defense of Haywood bad mad no lf Br'''' gal connection of the Mine Owners VKlr' aaaoclatlon the Clllrena' Alllaiics of JfV ' CnloraOo and the IMnkeHon detaclltrei K! agency as la) Ing a fonndatloii for Hue brPi(i evidence intnaliiced by the defensn JHsfv" f to show that the charge agalnat Hay- JEn$ woo.1 and hla riedefemlanla la the tmt- wEt? , come of a conaplraiy to eatermtnate StwyA the federation 'ALan(KM Immediately following the announos- rafltflBsl men I of this decision nrgument cum iB9B metieed Judge llawley, lending conn- 9MsB ael for the atcle. Hikn tor two iHHtm uIkIH land fifteen minute of the aUernoett aLBflaV seaalon the morning semlon having gaLBH been ndjoutneil to enable the Jttdga to aiiH Iprepaie his derision gaaaM ICvery neat In the courtneim was oo bILbB cupleil Outside lb liicbtsiire rt IBfl rved for altnrneya and newr gaiH men, were many iwrsens pttimlnenl In H publli and prltale life and a sprinkling jH of women in sumioer ctMlumM adiltal H color lo the audltortum stc. (lover- H nor Prank Hooding exOoternor Mnr- H itsoti a number of the officers of lb state ailmlnlstrailou. Captain Jama H Mcl'arlaiid Julian P. Hleuneliherg, a H son of the murdered ex-governor, aad H a large galherlng of member of the H bar or Idaho and adjoining state wr H pteieut Hnywooil nl behind six of H his counsel Ills wife. In her Invalid H chair, waa placed on hla right and his H eldest daughler sat Ixslde her mother. H Haywood' half sister and stepfather H occupied seats close to the deltas) H group H Opening Address by Mr. Hawley. JM Mr llawley, who tins been III for H seternl days as the teaiill of the strain H of the long trial, coiumetiroil hla ad- H dross In a volte aluiMl Inaudible to anyone except the Jur) He apol i H glaeil for I hla, however, explaining thai lie hail feared ha would he uinlib owing lo 111 health, tu dallrnr a pio- H longed addreaa Mr. llawley I tho Nrntor of the llolae liar He Is a mm uf Impivjalve presence and aggreaalto iM-edi Warming to his subject Fliday .gagafl Bflentoon, his tolce after tho opening ( afH tatement, In which he explained Hist ' , H he hsd nono of tho grace of word I that constitute an orator" was at limes' 1'tsLLLfl eloquently Impassioned, but withal a I jH plain analysis of the evidence lln 1 lH characterlseil tho case as the "mo!, . . 'H t,-w..st-nuifWT)tyftuJgllJ i' "K tsBLal the United Hlstes, ndrgeiMliifcJi.ry j 1 VbLLH lo a serious iiisldtrallonf'imj,iJflli,iil " "" ggafl siKinalblllly placed upon them Hla de- VH nunclatlnn of Iho defendant and hit 'LeH co-consplralors as the "worst hsnd of H criminal that eter Infested nn) u-r 1 of this country," was forceful and hi H eulogy of exHovernur Bleunsnbcrg H eloquent In the extreme Mr. llawley 1 descrllied Orchard's tary a truihful 1 not onl) betau of the manmr In H which II wa told, but becaipa' it hn 1 H lieen corroUiraii d In ev'ery linportanO' H detail Then when he found rtou H for the roiifeaalou In the consclem e oi H the criminal vtlrreil by meinorb a of B a happy boyliisNl lu n vlnuoun home, H there waa a waver of emotion in the H pleader a voice and mon than a ma- H plclon of tear among his audleiioa 1 Counael for the defense rwtedly H Inlarriipted Mr Hawley with proUsU H and objection, but the only teemed H to allr him lo gnaler efTort (luce lH or twice he turned to Olarasiea Dar- H mv and faced him with a roar of anger 1 and auiilher lime he said "It due not 1 He In the mouth of coiiumI to tlnd ex- 1 cuse for these aw lul crime" H |
