Show SENA SENATE TE FAilS TO FAVOR ALL DERNS DERN'S NAMES NAME McKay of Huntsville and Disapproved SALT fALT LAKE LAME March The Tho ll Th ao refused yesterday esterday afternoon to confirm Governor Derns Dern's ap- ap app p o of the state fair board D DW Y aa as a member of the board o of control o ot of the state his his- historIcal his society and D D 0 McKay a as asa aa II a r of ot the state stale board of o agriculture This Thia action was taken upon of the th senates senate's special special cial dat committee on appointments antI and following a caucus o ot of the tho sea sen- senate senate ate at which the tho one Democratic member Mas as tas All the rest of o the th governors governor's governors appointments submitted to the tho th sea sen- senall senate ate all were approved by unanimous consent o ot of the upper house The senates senate's refusal to confirm and McKay WM was over the negative vote ote of Senator Patterson the lone Ion Demo Demo- Democrat Democrat crat C rat H L who was nom nom- nomInated mated by Loy the he governor governo to succeed as a member of t time tile th state fall fair board from Salt Halt Lake Lalee count county wa was r the first to draw the tho fire Ure Ire of opposItion Chairman Hamilton Gardner of thi th special committee on appoint appoint- appointment appoint ments ment said when he reached the th name nam of Mr lr that the th committee felt It could not recommend mend confirmation of ot the appoint appoint- appointment appointment appointment ment of Mr lr The chair chairman man inca sal said 1 that the th committee hl hai felt that owing to Mr Ir 1 connection with th state fair boar board 1 and the th racing association and the further fact tact that his con con- conduct con conduct duct as u such uch was now under it could not at this time hei fe justified in con con- confirmation ot or his appointment nt to succeed himself on the fair air board Senator Patterson asked It if it the entire boar board 1 1 were acre ere not under In- In in investigation Senator Gardner said perhaps It was but the committee had l felt that the th situation with to Mr 11 was different than wili other members of the board because o of admitted status of o Mul Mul- liner as a member o of tho the fair board and anti attorney for the racing association at t the some same time objected to Mr ner ncr being singled out from the th board membership when the entire bo rd was l Investigation but buthis buthis his protest was sas as of o no avail A call for tor the question brought a vote vot that registered all the th sea sen- senators sen senators present against confirmation of except Senator Patter Patter- Patterson son lion C CI CASh CASE I 01 or 01 1 In the case of D W larraU who was named by bi the governor a i a-i a 0 member o of the historical board Chairman Gardner o ot of the th committee stated that the tho commit commit- committee committee tee had felt that Mr had ben radically active In itt connection connection connection tion with governmental Co matters In a way that the th committee committe thought rendered him hint unsuited to tobe tobe tob be a member ot of o the board o ot of the th state historical society vote vole vot to refuse to confirm his hb appointment w Wa was unanimouS with exception ot of o Senator Pat Pat- Patterson Patterson Pat Patterson terson IK Y OI IOSE Asto As A to 1 D U D McKay of ot nominated by the governor for member of o the state board of ot culture Chairman Gardner said 1 the tho committee felt that Mr lr Mc- Mc McKay Mc McKay Kay ICay was WIUS wa not temperamentally suited for tor the th position and It also ao felt that he h was not qualified tn in th time line Uno ot of o experience to render the right sort orl o of service on th the board refusal to concur In this a ap appointment p was unanimous with ex- ex ex exception at Patterson While confirmation of the ap appointment of ot David U H Madsen as fish h and game commissioner wa a unanimous on the floor of the sen- sen senate senate ate en-ate ate It Is understood that there was W some oppositIon voiced In the special committee meeting and In Inthe Inthe the caucus preceding the session One senator It is learned opposed Madsen on the tho ground that ho he h conducted his hi department too much for or the Interests ot of o the silk lIk stocking sportsmen and not enough for tor or the Interests of ot the people le In general o of the Ibe state elate It h hIs Is 16 understood that the objecting enor senor made mad strenuous protest prot against confirming Madsen ap appointment Jut but ut the majority over overrode overrode rode his hij objections and when the matter mailer camu caine up on the floor loor of or the senate his confirmation was waa made madu Unanimous ur It was reported that some Continued on l Page Iago gu Two lao SENATE FAILS TO APPROVE i 1 Continued front from One I I Sl l n also atao developed eloped to lion 1101 llon of or W D Sutton Button ai III a member ot of the state board of ot equalization but nothing of ot this developed on thea floor of the senate His Hla nom nom- nomination was made unanimous In the Inthe official ote vote taken The fhe appointment of M H H wel Wel- Wei- Wei Ii ling welling Weiling Democrat to- to to succeed J T Republican as director ot of was IU recommended by the committee and find made un- un un unanimous an moua by the senate sen e The lIam samu wu was true In III the case CAle of ot Henry N as IU member m ber of ot the Industrial |