Show ChadWick Jury Tji T Tn n i Hits 1 Hit Ilio Deadlock JL I t Stage Belief Throngs in Court Stirred During Closing Arguments When Prosecutor Terms Walter Vatter Chadwick a Home Home- Home breaker breaker Vho Who Killed Under Influence of Hangover and Defense Lawyer Pictures Slayer as Chivalrous Young Man Who Vho Fired Only to Save His Life INDICATIONS ot of a hung jury in the thc case ease of Walter Cha Chad Chad- Chad A 1 wick Slaterville man Inan charged with first degree murder for forthe forthe forthe the sla slaying of Ludovic Ludovie Isoard filtered jury room in inthe inthe inthe the county building shortly before noon after the jury had ld been out since 5 0 o'clock clock Monday ev evening ning or approximately 20 hours At 1230 oclo o'clock k toda today the jurors relue requested th they be to taken ken to lunch Indicating hey no hope for tor ILI 11 IL I quick v rd Judge Judee George Gerge 3 B Barker Baker In whose court the th trial was held he said that the jurors hal had not com corn communicated 1 with lIh him hith himat at noon oon or gIven any l a ai as to how bow they stand JUdge Judee daiker sdI dall he be would permit the tha jurors jural'S to continue their lute late to to- to tonight to night at least be bor taking any action in d theta then wIth witha a possibility they nitty II be hel held 1 noL over Ila Wednesday r I they hoy do not report a before foro r Cc snow SHOW IX At 1230 o'clock odd when the filed tied out oit I t of the on oil their way to tJ lunch their clearly the tue strain strain of 01 nc 1 1 lit closed dam b Their laces uces wore were drawn and u It few tew of o a theta car carried led rather an ot et o ang r as asIt It If they hey hal had been LEn Ar u arguing jg Court b wn wn- wn n HT as assigned assigned signed by J r to Jury slept just c outside lt ide thedoor the thedoor thedoor door of or a large laree 10 In the Heed hoL hold hoil I where th thi Jurors were Ire quartered las lasi ight In or- or ord order or order d der r that they hr ml lit continue their bel deliberations there here Before th case case went ent to the Ife jury the slept in the tho same ram room where 15 IS b J ds were In the of he he jurors uror dis- dis disagreeing dis agreeing a It new trial will probably ly Iy br bl ordered rd aid id he h defendant held In jail without hail lall I The talc fate te of or Walter Chadwi charged wit ds- ds dt gree murder for ho slaying ot L do lc Ie coard was placed in tIe ads ha-ads ot or the tho jury at d a Monday evening t b by JuJu u George Geore GeorgeS GeoreS S Uarl Barker No wai 1 rea cd h- h ed cd at 1015 o o'clock la last L night and the jury ras as lodged lods d in a 11 etel tp to- to IhA iw Crowd I this Titue mo-Titue In the courtr ul to 0 Iho fo-Iho tho ho e verdict In III his to the jury Judge Judee Barker l they hey mu must t j do Jo one Ji Ir several things li h returning a verdIct n They tan Oln an acquit the to of at the coarse charge 0 ot of mur murder er In the first decree deroe or all an any of at th less less- charges of ot end ind ei t him frei frea reo They rhey ran an return a II verdict o guilty ty of ut first fir t degree murder tt thai penalty tarrying dath d They nay find cl Cha Cha i gull guIl of at r in this the degro derr which carries II a a of at not less thai thac 10 30 years yedra In th sute prison sit at tt hard labor which mi mey be extolled ted to life Jle JEl They may find him guilty o volunta v volunta-v volunta r r would m n front from one to 10 ea I In tho the state prison or 01 had fwd hi guilty if f Involuntary I continued on oo Page Inse ae THO o CHADWICK JUR JURY STill IS OUT Continued I from m Pogo Pago One the the the- penalty b being belig not more than one on year In tho the county jail jalL In his hia Instructions Judge Jud e fla ker Da ker Informed the tho jury they mut either rind tid him guilty at t ono of OC thelo charges chance or 01 turn him him free Iree Thero Thera ta Is 1 also aso the possibility ot of ota oa a huns hung hun jury ury which would mea mca that a retrial l of ot tho case CalA would bo be necessary unless th tho thil charge chard against WAS dismissed The Tho J y Ji-y was WM with tO t tat fatO ot of ChadwIcK at 5 o'clock after arter lengthy and eloquent arguments ments menta bJ bj Attorney Arthur WO iI JO counsel for or the defense lJoseph ai-lJoseph JosOph Joeph Z 2 Evans t attorney They deliberated for an hour In Inthe Inthe the tho jury ury room without ai a erdl t and at 6 G o'clock vers t taken tn to dinner by the the- C Returning short shul after arter 7 1 oclo c they again until o'clock wh win 1 hey they quested n r rr J that they be taken to the hol hotel hotl l for tOI the night GO TO At ls L hour JudKO Darker Barker opened court ourt called th the jury uy jn In J the bo bot boc and cautioned th-n th against communicating with lIh any anyone one In I to the case II Its th n In Instructed the o drifts ts IO t Sort hem to their hll hotel l I rooms The rhe was crowded It ci thIs hour by y spectators man many mans t whom Had nad ad remained In since 5 o'clock When the jury jul ns ordered away for tor or the he t the r left Chadwick broke down and we wet I upOn his anns ann's arms during h he arll usa II tn i the attern Jon on when hen Arthur took th Un the jury ury or orha ov O he ha facts ats brought out n 1 1 the evl dance and In referring to 0 o Ills his HI vs lOC ot with Mrs Isoard bet bet rn h hi killing charac him a IO oy i no had been clean wl i L omen In tn th tin also robb t as M Mi Woolly again referred to tl ChI Chad ChaJ WIK ts s i a n i home ln boy lay wh va vat lor tol aI d 4 to protect rOte his rom rn 01 nii r a wo who tho the be to had th h ned him ani an who on In onh th dh th d c Ci tho idio murder waited to 1 il Au AI All Evins Evns In Ills his do di Chadwick lek In dl- dl frent ren firms tl ms He Ifa drew dref t a wo- wo ture ph-ture ol vi LudOvic Isoard 1 rane ii 10 years ago to o seek geek eek hs hi ortons In Coming to ton ton n 11 WI w r t r a o lis is won him Health ant es Mr Evant Evana said and hI he married a mere sup nip Ip ot of a 1 girl n and built her a II beautiful heme Tw tui children cam cami Into tM nome and then owing to Isoard lost maeh ot of o 1 is treasures treasure Mrs Sirs hoard Iward he be said salol wa was wu basking In the love lo ot o a good husband when hen they finally moved to o Slaterville two 1110 Into the picture now cores co cone Re ne defendant Mr Sir Evans E cr and only one halt ot Or what shat hoo happened has hs been told oa on the wit nu stand We find tind ChadwI 1 nd ind Mrs frs Isoard board together l durl-l he last year ear In an escapade to Lit LAke a back at 4 o'clock in hI the tho morn U Mi Mard had returned une une- une pe c nes from rom his cheep camp and Amt n IV wm to 10 the lies lIus hone ue In Ot O OT-dm OT In knowing that his Ills w te was OUt ow with Mrs Hess lIess H Its It's and loll Mr Hoss cut the wires on the tile Chad Chad wick wuk alJ automobile which had bad been le left ne ir II r the Hen iresa home and they li h salt alt alt alt- for Chad Chadrick tn on anGlin I 01 Stone Stoe who were ou out with hoir wires ME MEc IE r GI nE 1 O car drives up with Glea Stone Walter Chadwick and th the two women and siere here nere we get the tle Irs hat glimpse 0 ot Of the he character ot of Mr Mr H ss bats b at Store lly and then he na runs run and end and strikes him ova th the head with hi his yuo un UI Thank Goo fo o- o omen men Ilk Sir Mr Hess I Ilk liki ot of his hig blood bood lIe He beat beA beAIr Ir Ur Sons for tor taking his j wife out ont and he ho u eded It Then Irs tra J Iao Isoard o rd rd with 01 eods ds convinced Mr III L Ioard th thit It nr lair ir to Salt JAke J ake was I an In- In In de de and WO Ve find ind won on or 0 by liy her and trally h ho tows lows th Chadwick car to 10 a h whir r l 11 t might bo Lo pared so h could could go homo home Isoa B a is 18 a n not lt fighting man IRan lie He nev neyr nev laid IId i on lh this lIt lr o a ans ana Cha- Cha leli I asi as a home breaker a au 1 aIled to 10 th s t b- b fc tore fOle th h mooting when ben Cht was out with sith hoard Isoard Tit Tr n n I c it tt ho he declared vu Ve veind md him with witha a a over hang and Ludovic Ludo Iso In thit oa ot at the neck nOck Mr III Evans Brans went over the stocy 01 the he and l declared red the showed It It-it it Iso Itoi 2 never raised d his run gun tor for no Ih ih t marks wire re found upon hi his arIS arI'S or gloves ELOQUENT T Mr II swayed s aed the with his eloquence In lu plea for o s 's life It end and u it u- u that hat hat If Chadwick had had nt his S with a arun arun run oun th that thi Is Isoard rd would now lOW be on trill trial for tor the shooting hootinG of ot Val Wal k I X listened 1 t to Chadwick lC e M a is ta C 4 i the witness ss sa sand nd ad sir str 1 1 l tory tory I look looh t fi t tI I 0 o th the toyes eye ot of Mrs Isoard as asa a i when hen she was eal nd ad I 1 sullied gained 1 from b both bath th ho hc liv- liv ri IP r r isloa that Chadwick had 1 an with that woman I I 1 o II e a man cat caa ride In 11 tho th I bask bark o k seat scat of ot an woman to Salt Salt lAke or 01 t to I Idaho aho and ond still be cleu ClemI I 1 believe a IL man can take n II Iole tIn lii In front ot or a woman and give five h wo wo or ot three drinks drinke out of ot t Sc c c amu nt b and nd he ca can caa r rn rn sped her virtue Thero There was nothing so hal ha about th the associations of M ld Isoard and Walter Waiter lck Chadwick II as the tho district attorney would maLt us bellee belle e Mrs irs hoard wad was alore She tN failed Chad ck to take her places where here she abe a J v her children coult not go wItt I out his lila help He lie for th thi boards and he answered the tho cJ IJ ot of a woman t I HOT OT Or LIKE IKE DUE Consider Thanksgiving day lie He took Mrs Mra Isoard to her hr fath's fath house with her children She hl hii no means of ot conveyance to go 0 goto coto t to l her folks home for tor log Ing r She Sho called upon Chi Cbs Ch 1 wick and hu ha took her t there tero In ht hi fathers tather's car lie hurried hurrle 1 home and then went to tha and plowed That may m y be th thc conduct ot or a II home home home-bl aker l fl ania a 0 In the tho opinion of ot district attorney Mr Mrs Isoard wano wanted 1 him h he came And he was wac nsf- nsf nat naturally thrown together with thi Un j I Isoard hoard Is 13 that such a SiC I Ister thing thins Consider Mr Woolcy t where l cu have e see seen sect a sing tear teal during this week o trial except when Chadwick came calno down from the tho witness bland and wept like liko a boy I Is the sta se sea of ot a 11 sneak and a hom ioni breaker V to the shooting Mr Woolley declared ir It Walt I Chadwick bad not been quick on the drollY draw Isoard woud now nov be In III this charged 1 with a cold blooded n m mner er Ic- Ic Icard Isi-ard Isi ard hid behind altra a stack s and waited Ilie ile le two men inca met eat CIal ea with a shotgun sholun Thre words In which Chadwick Isoard of ot snooping aroud again because because he had found him In tl- tl Chad wi barn on November 15 LIES IV Js W l swore and ral raised et his hisgun hisgun gun and quick as aJ a flash Ch Chal Chalwick Chadwick wick threw his gun to hi his hi- shoulder shoulder shoulder der and fired tIred Isoard the tte aggressor aggressor sor waited al pd the night let ore for foran foran or oran an C opportunity to slay It Chad wick Chal-wick wick had hail approached hl hia home Chalwick tired fired one shot aM still Isoard tried to work his gut cul gu Isoard was Tas as not y i by the tho first shot o Jn ChadwIcK turned and ran af atta firing 9 first shot wo-ild wo he ho b ba here tolay to lay tay The tea tes- tes testified titled that Jut the first shot ahot would not have Incapacitated Isoard hoard or 01 again a was confronted wl a which meat mean his 11 and nd he lie tired The Qu qu-kness qu kness he has demonstrated In thO court court- courtroom courtroom courtroom room with wish lila his gun Jun sav J his I You Tou Jurymen cannot find him guilty ft r t t murder or 01 of man man- man I for tor having assoCiate with Mrs Urs Isoard for tor motor trips with I her dances or for tor the ot ol any anything tiling Who to tod 1 the real l story upon te t e stand If It had not be been n for tor tl-i tl testimony of at Chadwick and M Mr Isoard Isoard Mrs Hess and Mrs crts CriB defense wh whit t would 1 have hll known It The testimony has liaa cealy inthe brought out one ono thing that in n the eyes of ot God Walle Walter Waller killed in nfl nn |