Show GIRLS GIRL'S TRIAL I liKENED TO HORROR PiTI Mi D Dorothy or 0 th y Insane and ani Abnormal Tortured Lawyer Says I l CONFERENCE HELl HEL HE L D w Will ill i 1 1 Plead Guilty to t Manslaughter But Not Murder SA SAN FRANCISCO CISCO March 28 21 The trial of or Dorothy 16 1 I cars ars old matricide will wl be b rc- rc ro resumed Mondo Monday before Judge tn r irold 11 old Louderback Loud it was net a too tola after refusal of ot the district attorney to accede to the defens proposal to enter a plea o of guilt to a manslaughter charge charre on be- be behalf be behalf half haIr of or the oung woman oman ilta lIet defenso nse proposal her coun coon counsel tel sel slid arid was inspired In by humanitarian humanitarian Instinct aroused by the dally dail spectacle of or the girl cirl lly collapsing ln Under tinder the tho strain of ot the th tb public mid trial lIlle Mis Mi's suC- suC suf suffered eight tInting pell spells during the First five fite d do o ot of the tho trial The district r firm In his Ills stand that any hinl less ls than a II murder charge be inconsistent and Uble the end ends of ot Justice The de- de tIe tense I Is equally qually firm In contend contend- contendIng contending Ing that the elements of ot premeditation premeditation tation and malico malio to sustain a 1 murder charge are totally lacking In thO thi case a o on t lilal 1 G 1 It was tras pointed out by the tite til de dc dc- dc defense that th tha Iho gh girl rills I s father alit brother are unwIlling to accept th slate s a 1 hat T i plea pica of ot Rec- Rec see sec second ond degree murder bp hi b ente ed In Ir lien behalf leat lea log ot of th Ih gIrl cirt s a fate in In I lila th he h hands nd oC o 0 the Iho cour cou t and on alienists represent representing represent represent-Int nt- nt ing the prosecution pros and end defense The The- The girl n ta alleged to h bate o shot allot jot and Im killed d her molher on the lie morning of oC January 13 Shortly before th tho ho shooting Mrs rs had admonished til tho gIr to discontinue lien her visits titus to 10 lh Ih dance halls haUs and to drop her In- In in In In the Bohemian life lit of ot the thc city Alexander Aleander of or counsel coun el gave gate out the statement C n I HOI nL MILS MIL'S The Tire purpose of ot counsel for Cor tho thod d defense tenso In conferring with sith JUdge this thia morning na was I Ito to te ale 11 clear our position Yester Tester Yesterday Yesterday day we received Intimation that hal tho Ire district attorney might ad- ad ad address the tho court and anti suggest a con con- con conference ference between counsel on both with the court in it to 10 determine whether hether society h lies riot not a n better method than this thia cool com comb com b bit t of the th Roman Homan IIren arenz arent to soh e etho tho lie problem presented t to It by an and Insane It 16 year old year girl irl No to o such ouch suggestion teas ao made to the COUI t d we Later learned thit th the th district at- at at at tOl orney ney ed previously Ith is he he judge without advising u s us or u us to the conference e e chave hate ha at all nil time times Indicated our to me meet t consult anti deliberate upon this problem anti and wo va are ar wIlling to do so 0 now PIT FIT OF OP Counsel for tor the tho defendant tithes to make malle mak it clear that IbL they are tre not responsible tor for casting this and abnormal girl Into the tho pit ut of ot horror In which she has been tortured for tor the tho past week sweet Jony LOll 1 beCore this trial began we tee e made madelie madeth the lie otter offer to the Ih district attorney to 0 pl pled plead d this tirl irl guilt guilty to a 1 abarge charge barge ot of o manslaughter leaving leasing lea Ing It to 0 the tho judge judg upon the th testimony or if alienists for tor the th state te and tie tie- de defense to lOt determine whether she hould bo be b sent to 10 state S prison or orp oran p an Institution That lisa has been beena I standing otter offer and has not been We Wo can not plead her her guilt or If murd murder r because ii 11 II Is iii not mur Tour murder murder der er under th the law I-eu With our ab- ab ab to ol kno knowledge Ot Of the anti ot if the tirO mental condition of ot this girl to e 11 know knots 0 that hat premeditation and ond malice aforethought can not be besho behon sho shon hon n and end without premeditation and nd malice aforethought It cannot In n any e event ent be bp n II higher blither degre or t crimp crime than manslaughter SI G bin Cr CLE The Th The father anti and brother of or Ihl this girl ml will still III not consent conent to a Ii pica or of mu der because they know knots her mental tenial condition and know hot there here wo-s wo no premeditation nor malice one None sono Will III regret more mor than we wet wele wethe t le distressing spectacle that Is h pI resented anti and the tho lie agony of ot this girl ml but bul bulC bu C we lw have dealt fairly and rankly with the district etto and nd with Ith the public and we cannot lead her guilty of or a II crime which we to are arc convinced cannot be sho shown shon n Our offer or of o a plea pica o ot or man mn manslaughter slaughter laughter stands open opeil op n at all alt times and nO v t e are willing tilling IllIng to confer and I illera cle t upon I It at any ny time I lilt the th C CUI cut UI t and the tho th district II at-II at- at atno at attorney torne torney 00 no- no |