Show THE THAW CASE new york harry thaw lias has been declared sane by th the e 7 lunacy I 1 bacy coin com commission i the tiding of t the ta thaw v i nv lunacy luif tiby can commission 1 finias loll 1011 was wasa couch 4 edin the lang ungo of the hy juste 0 fitzg fitzgerald e riold ord order lilg the inquiry the commis commission commisse sl ion 0 ers ra dee declared it re d it to fco be ba ti iligir leir ainan 1 1 I 1 fabous belief aliat the defendant hayr harry K I 1 thaw I 1 11 aw is capable of lightly hiss 1 0 own V 11 position posidio m 0 of f ampre appreciating cratil 19 6 the ea of the ch charges chrones roges a g ai fit li i in and of raio nationally nally c 0 9 walh hia coursel at I 1 t tile tho ahne orthis cr hiis exiting examination atimion 1 1 vt the entire report of the cot commission missi oll covers three ili reo ty typewritten P paes 4 and k vill ill hotbo in mide ade pub lie li mr mi jerome said if iho aho court rule billed a 9 adlist liis his application for acceus to the minutes or of the thaw commus in lunacy lib he would timo to decide whether lie would apply to the appellate appella to division divi bion for a writ of prohibition to lo prevent the ilie trial arial proceeding 21 Justice Fitzgerald debird jerome 44 acress access t to 0 the in minutes i nu es and alid adjourned until monday d declining e to grant more inore time for jerome 0 to o apply to the appell a ate to divisi division oti for a 1 writ vr it of prohibition hibi tion commission REPORT ali the e cone concluding lud par paragraphs of the lunacy commission commis aion report ip in full fulU lire tire as follows A after 4 f ter careful examination of th el defendant personally and nd all the evidence we can flud find the following g facts in the frequent and abid ill in same some cases durin during g the several months P past t intercourse li had a d by the de fondant with the tombs physicians sic ians ell chaplains a plains I 1 keepers other attendants ind and the probation officers cers these persons failed to discover any anything I 1 li g I 1 irrational in his bis con conduct buot or spee cli 44 the pile defendant lias has taken an active part in the he con conduct bet of the ile t tr ra ail il alit has 1 3 ill made n do numerous suggestions 1 or orally ably in court and by letter as to the selection of jurors ans and tho examination of witnesses many NJ it 11 y of those suggestions gest e ions were doomed valuable ablo and were adopted b by y his counsel and examination of the alie letters re referred forred to show ajl t generally the suggestions col con bained were nvere material Fen sensible sible and apparently the product t of a sane man oveile the mony idony of numerous erous exports call ed by the district attorney aud and tile the defendant la counsel is irreconcilable bildt given by certain experts who personally examined the defendant durn during 9 the trial and since bitic i e J the he appointment of the commission on and W who ho of all the alienists elamin ed had bad gre greatest aest oppa opportunity r eunity of observing disclosed the fact that no indi cadon of fi tit at the present time could be found in the speech conduct condu ct or P physical hy con condition of tile the d defendant e fen dant the direct oral and physical cal examination of the defend ant by tho the commissioners them bliem selves disclosed no insanity in ohe deft defendant at the pre present seiA ti time ine upon all of the facts ts it is our opinion opi tion that at the time lillie A adf 4 77 0 our e tile the said harry K thaw is i sane and n not at i in w a state of idiocy i ioe lunacy or S so at a to be incan ablo of ritel rightly I 1 aly u under I 1 ader ret his condition the lie natu nature ie orill charges ages a against ag g ty o fils t him hill and lid of co cond lid uc till g hisa his de e bense in a rational manner i the of tho the proceed angs J hind had before us and the doc 1 rec ec i iveden V ad evidence evi hence anro tt re sub mitt e d f yngne d DAVID AVID D mcglure mcclure j PETER OLNEY ly r LEOPOLD |