Show i STRICT LOCAL OPTION BILL BILLI I PASSED BY STATE SENATE I fINAL VOTE i f 1 UNANIMOUS I J J 4 Measure Measure Presented by Committee Commit Commit- tee on Manufactures and Commerce I If Receives Support f I of Members of Upper House 3 SEVERAL AMENDMENTS TS ARE ADDED TO BILL t l f 1 Salt Lake and Ogden Are Made Separate Units in Vote for Local Loca Option Opton and Proposed Tax on n Breweries Br Cut in Two HARMONY IS WATCHWORD IS I r By By Bya a unanimous vote of I 1 I the seventeen members pres- pres E ent the XI Senate at its session session ses ses- sion yesterday afternoon passed the liquor regulation arid and and local option bill of the committee on manufactures and after having commerce subjected it to several amendments The measure as it finally went through Lt possessed several points of difference from t wt it contained con- con tamed when i it the l lv v A committee I ri C t an was i j jl l iF ifa- ifa gaJ faed ea a br mosT mo oY r rne ne c members as a compromise measure I I I. I I No o ono one member of t the e Senate can claim U tl o c authorship of ot the measure as a a a Q half halt dozen or more having havIng hayIng hav hay ing suc succeeded In prett ng amendments through before tho tIm passage o among these th e chan changes cs being ove which had been rejected by th majority of the thc at Tuesdays Tuesday's session for was sas the provision U 11 ObO among Which Chairman Rudolph Kuchler of for the committee has cn be-cn contending s several eral weeks and which was voted Salt down Tuesday TUe Y providing that and Ogden should vote voto as separate Lake f t f olec- olec proposed local IcaL option In the units r r adopted N Hons nother Another amendment tat trat S S. J. J J 3 providing pro pro- t. t vas Ws the state by viding for or the appointment of r examiners Rn of l three Inspectors a board u Ol ci v. v tho the law I Is h carried out I that 10 to see bee tie amendment adopted was that er I by Senator Benner X X- i providing presented that private dwell should I Ibe I officers unos un- un from search Bearch b by be e exempt search warrants Still SUi os with proper that by b which tho the was nn t-er t or revision 1 Amendment of the committee Increasing Increasing increasIng the license fee for brewers was ing the general of Idea half halo An cut In which prevailed can bo be obtained ob ob- ob- ob harmony that tho the It Is 13 e explained tined when cutting down of the tho the motion for presented by Senator Sen San was vias license B. B Wilson and seconded ator James s T T. who prior E. E by b Senator session had hud been boen standIng stand- stand to yesterdays yesterday's apart on the Issues far as about lug Ing It was possible to get involved hl as ns Hurman In III evidence hl E nce was harmony however only onh In n du Any In tt tro 0 Senate not hut but In several t i. i to to the liquor which measure were acted C upon It t 1 other bills before the stan nun about wh whispered was wa that an a agreement haa han of ot tho the session the local cal option been loen reached upon Ulon measure and trat n nt tho the regulation and re take tako would or t the consideration set session when the thc place at the would afternoon be amended to suit some sure themselves f had placed members who It The TheS opposed d to tv directly direct iE as record been I on of the b II had o but It m yesterday h t S for 10 o'clock preliminaries lUll ha been cn r. r after aCter the usual Senator Carl A. A r ono through h. h n ot of Senate j U al the consideration moved until 15 p. p 1 t Xo O. O 8 1 he be deferred seconded b by SenA Sen- Sen us lU The rhe motion ond was th L' L A bill wen wont wint o over r. r Ju gallery In- In Ill ator tor a fair sized was women at nt tho morning several crowd ot at the tar far larger laner r und and a final the I I. I to witness 11 afternoon on the measure p the Senate ot KoLlon bUt bill aS called up Senator I fJ When hen the offered his first amend amend- at once to addition a r of an tint In n the the sl SI ape bill relating to vot- vot f 3 of b by 4 Section or of local option question the ns as reading I ng 1 on amendment the tho lf 11 the provi- provi folloWs that this act u t I of oC section or or of this more cities e al alt tt tO 0 hull when tC tants cities shall ll have i or of such separate ibi nit as a in to favor toor or or of do upon 1 which they tray counties t unit In this act for Os u provided Page e Seven on HI LOCAL LOGAL OPTION BILL DILL PASSED BY SENATE I Continued NI From Inyo On Ono Inc I I Tho Time Intent and meaning hereof l Is that I such Much cities H Hhall bo Io 10 placed th tim th Hilmo provisions a as ns are arc heroin provided pru for tor countes counties 4 O ii Time The opposition llon which this Un amendment providing that Salt Sal LIo Lake and Ogden could vote oto as ns separate unit I I n at t TUI Tuesdays Tuesday's llla session WaR vms not In evidence yesterday and the tho amendment t tI I at nt once went through It wan WUK followed I by 13 the tho Introduction of oC a n I second In to 0 tim tho Ing Ural first ant and reading ax its 11 follows And tho time manner of or hol holding said Euid el elections in said Raid cities clUes shall be the time same HS as lles api to time the subdivisions lon me If les aPI tl the i mentioned in tIme the proceeding sections sections- with tho the exception that where count county commissioners are arc mentioned in iii the sections ct city council counci shall hal be substituted In II lieu thereof And when count county clerks clerIcs are aro mentioned city be lie substituted In lieu H t thereof lie roof I I The fhe second amendment of ot Mr Ir i Juch- Juch ler also Isu wont through quickly and then thon I Senator offered an nn amendment practically the time same as DR that voted down lown I Ithe the time previous loul day Ia I provi providing for tor tho time ap ap- ap- ap b by the tile state board boar of or examIners exam exam- I Iners mt-rid of or three inspector In with wih time the powers of ot investigating In Into the timo mattel mat mat- matI I ter tel of the thc enforcement of ot tho the law the time I Inspectors to have hn e tho power to appoint i i clerks it I wn was WS provided that the thc salaries salaries sal sal- aries of ot time the In inspectors should hould not nol 1 he be over u 1500 00 a n year exclusive o of ot their j necessary nry ense el This amendment also encountered no opposition and was Incorporated l in the bill bU anc Encouraged by the time success which tho amendments ha had met met Senator Bennor Donnor Benner Ben Ben- nor ner X Smith offered another which i had been submitted h by Senator Hula- Hula I musk Tuesday and anc rejected providing that the sale sule of or liquor should bo permitted per per- II In tho time dining dining rooms of or hotels clubs anti and restaurants where thoro there are aro areno no booths He lie said this would prevent pre ent I persons from going oln out of a n dining room m to a it 1 saloon to get et liquor which was as i to be furnished l at meals and n a milan would not have to carr carry a bottle botto In his pocket Into tho the dIn dining InS room S n lo Jinn This amon amendment encountered opposition opposition tion lon from tho the members on the other side of ot the time Senate chamber Senator Badger remarking that It would L be unfaIr un un- un fair air to discriminate in favor Cavor of or those persons Ho lie le suggested to the tho ho supporters of or the amendment omon that the time system used In Iowa of laying a coin on tho table which the waiter waler could coul l take to a a place whore where liquor could be bo purchased might bo be employed Senator Smith said sald he ho was g glad od to got Iet a l tip of or this kind from Mr Da Badger ller Time The tp amendment wn was voted Iowa down Senator B. B X Smith th then n took up the question of or tho tim amount which was pro- pro I to take from brewers holding licenses ranging from 1000 to j I annually according to output of or the breweries He lIe le said It was too high and cale called l attention to the time fact tact that brewers brew brew- I ors ers or outside tho the state were not lot taxed nn and this would Impose a a hardship on the brewers o of the state He said this thi was applying tho time principle of 01 tho the income income in come tax tx Senator Wilson Wison then moved that the movel proposed amount of ot tho time proposed tax tx be bo cut in two and this was as seconded by hy Senator and carried carrle Senator Smith then thou moved the tion ton of oC the amendment which haitI had I been heen rejected Tuesday n compensating liquor dealers or J manufacturers for tor property made malc useless In Case caso local option went wont Into effect This was opposed op 01 01 vose posed b by Senator C. C Burton Durton Jr who said Bald lold t hero thero might t bo be le a change back Lock from Crom local option opton and unless the constitution con con- was waR amended amende to provide that this timis could not nol bo be dono a compensation feature should not I ho embodied Tho Tim amendment also was opposed by Ly Senator Senator Senator Sen Sen- ator Kuchler and was defeated Senator B B. X X Smith then thon mo c moved l that that private dwelling be lt exempt from search lorch by officers and amid this timis wa was carried carrle by a aoto vote oto of ot ton wn It to x two members being absent Alt 1 IL In In The Time bill LIJa vis a thou then placed on fine passage o. o no further amendments 1 hoing boIng bo- bo Ing ng suggested and passed et by tho tile unea- unea vote vetO oto of at tho the DC senators torR p mi torn present tl o lo I only bring being Senator A. A L E. E Ii- Ii IlI Il- Il I lur who ho was WI to bo be prose I. I About huH tho limo senators their thol reasons fors fot for tho bin bill IU when announcing their votes Senator C C. Burton lurton Jr nal sni I Im ho he I has favored ta ored n a n wide state prohibition bi bUl 1 nt It tho the start and recognized that this YaM was a ft compromise He Ito referred to Uia tima petition which had been presented In favor avol of or a n state prohibition measure should not bo minimized and said fald these le by Iv the m members lb Ho said paid he voted for tor n rig 08 n n. Which i I slower er In acton action than direct prohibition pro pro- might lead leod to tho the same samo re ro 10 suits Senator W. W C C. Horsley said ald ho he supported supported sup sup- port ported d tho taken b by Senator Burton Senator C C. E E. E Marks said ho imo had ha hao been eon in favor of ut straight ht prohibition but ho hmo found many things to approve O In the time substitute measure and ns as it I of tho the provided pro for strict regulation liquor truffle traffic and local option ho would support it f. f Other reasons given were as us follows Senator John II 11 I No 0 bill bl has suited me mc up to the time present time and suied this has como come tho the nearest to doing oln this of ot nn any For this rea reason eOn I 1 ote tor the tho measure Senator B B. X Smith If I there had lint hadnot hadnot not been beon so 1 much politics around here we probably could have havo passed a a mill bill which ml might ht have havo suited l the people of or tho state better I believe o helo In local option opton op op- tion and beter self government and as os the tho bill ton has imas many mummy features of or which I ai approve ap ap- bi prove provo I 1 support it i. i Vote Are re l t. t Senator John Y Smith I am nm satis- satis fled with my attitude up to date on onIc Ic legislation 13 ot of this k kind Ild and o tho the bill In is li good for the time present time 1 believe bi It is as drastic as the people o bele J would stand for tor Senator a. a J. J In the midst of ot all this 1 turmoil all probably have o been ni seeking tho the same samo end ond althou although h thoro has been heen a difference in the tho means menns employed We e 0 had bote butter stop the tho liquor traffic in a u ua a way that will nut shock tho business bushless interests of 01 not tho state and anti as aR a 0 move o 10 0 In tho time right direction I vote veto for the measure Senator W. W N N. Williams I have o ha done dono what I 1 could coull to further prohibition antI concessions in iii accepting ac no- have ha e mado made many 00 this bi bill I 1 accept accept it it as ns being being the best I can secure Senator hest J. J B. B Wilson Best Rest I pan san au augot got get I vote voto ayo aye After ter the tile session Senator Bullen Dulen said The TIme bill is in iii 11 harmony harmon with tho time bil in Cache Cacho county count republican platform tho time last lant t election It I Is in harmony with wih lu have m my views as 08 far tar as It goes 1 ha e realized for Cor some Rome time that a 0 strictly prohibition bill bl could coul l not pass lines tIme the Sen Son ate atc It I Is a D question queston with which many of or our states have 11 0 struggled for over overa a half a century an and l which whelm is still in Its experimental C stage A question queston to with many conflicting opinions as ns tho time wIh wisdom and amid expediency of oC tho tIme Involved d In Its Is solution Tho Time enforcement of or laws Ians are aro seriously hampered prohibitory 1 by time the limited con con- troi of at the states over o er trade en toon northern states have huo passed prohibitory pro imro- laws s II since tho Maine law of ur 1851 1 and amid out o of timI this nun number fourteen have havo confessed ct to a failure by repealing repeal repeal- In ing their thol laws Jaws leaving laving but three three- Kansas Maine and amid North Dakota Dakota- ota ota- with strict strictly prohibitive laws s an and these three states have ha hatho the tho law un under er con constitutional amendments On Or 0 account of these facts It will I be bo readily seen that there thero aro arc two tides s to the question an and l the more one slI gets into it tho time more Intricate ate It J becomes With Wih full tul faith and implicit onn dence In fn the time judgment of ot the Senate In imm 11 going on record against radicalism which too often resul results In disastrous reaction I did ld hope that the they would accept tIme the report of oC the majority of or the committee on omi manufactures and commerce and accept section 89 69 which provides for Cor a n submission Tho Time majority of the Senate Sonata thought otherwise Legislation Is more macro or less lessa a n mate matter of ot compromise and it cannot cannot be expected that each ench In individual l senator sena senn- tor have his Ideas alone alono govern In great questions It H Is a n good measure meas ure time tho tl regulation features are dras aro-dras tic tc and if 1 the optional provisions pro donot do donot not aoL ten bend l tho time entire entre state dry lr they are arc In harmony with tho the policy poley or of the tIme Washington ton B D. D C C. CI department of ot th time the saloon league loague of or gaining prohibition b by piece meal In Instead tead of oC striving for tor everything at ant and gaining noth noth- In ing which ace after all ni IH Is lt tho the course most surely calculated to produce results for tor reform It will make Cache I wIl coUnty county county coun coUn- 1 ty dr dry |