Show J THAT SUPREME COURT DECISION The only criticism that could bo ho properly offered of of- tred Is 18 that tho the Supreme court accorded to tho thu f party part considering the nature of ot that party's contention an any courtesy at all The Tho rule rulo might I well have been ma made e In four tour words Tho The demurrer de de- t mUrr r i Is sustained iTi In all the history of litigation there has probably tab ably tably y never been a cao which so completely exp expressed ex ex- p pressed insolence Impertinency and a consciousness conscious conscious- n ness 83 of ot improper r contention Thero There has hils never In Inthe Inthe Inthe the history of or litigation been a n case In which ganta fo so presumed on tho the goo good nature of ot the court and tho the patience of ot tho the public There Thero has never been a case In which litigants evinced such utter utterly bad faith or RO so arrogantly d demanded an unjust and prejudiced ruling In the t place there thero 1 is no Taft Liberal parly The five hundred p petitioners are members of ot what nat Is la Ina inaccurately called the American paTty party Thy They ore re the tho tame rame people who indorsed the American Amen Ameri can cLu party ticket et in convention or sent cent to conven- conven tio Uon th the delegates es who ho did Indorse that ticket There Thero I IP Ie no Taft party panty there never has been one there thero never will boo bo The whole hole contention contention conten conten- tIo tion was wa a a. cl demand mand th that t what is called tho the American Amen Ameri can Cal party parly bo be given two or three times as aa many tickets on tho the voting machine as aJ any other party has hae In the second place the contention If It granted would mean moan that an any candidate to could coul l bo rna made to stand n 1 for tor a L party part whoso whose principles ho did not at all indorse or b by resigning that offensive o I party's parts nomination be pr precluded clu ed th the possibility of ot being a J r candidate ot of an any part party oven o if It Its nomination wore oro equivalent to an election In tho third place tho demand was palpably that tho opposition bo be mado to serve tho the tho uses 0 of tho the party part appealing Tafta Tal's name namo on that tlc ticket ot would havo have meant many manS votes for or tho Kearns count county ticket and eVOl every ono one of ot them at the tho ox- ox ponso pono of or tho the Taft party There is not a n reason in logic or good conscience conscience con con- science for tor treating tho plaintiffs In this case caso with the tho common courtesy accorded litigants Tn Thoy might well have havo be been n bundled out of oC court with v single sentence Instead the court has given gl them every form and ceremony of ot usual accustomed trial has taken time to look for some Rome vestige of ot reason In their contention and has pointed out at length what might with Justice havo have been expressed in inton ton sec sec- And for tor reward tho the court Is branded In tho Tribune as against tho the Taft Tatt ticket It doesn't pay to bo ho decent docent to the tho cro crowd dD d D By tho the ruling ruling- of ot the Supreme court in this mattena matter mattera mat mat- ter a ten a hearing that constitutes a generously gra- gra courtesy to tho the Kearns managers the managers tho tho principle principle prin prin- ciple Is established in tn Utah that a n candidate cannot bo be driven off his party ticket b by an any trickery of ot tho the opposition D By it the tho principle Is established hed that bo bogus us and non-existing non parties cannot ma masquerade as genuine B By tho ruling tho the principle Is established that American voters must to a n certain extent exercise tho the reasonable effort contemplated b by tho law law of elections and that they are ore supposed to have havo sufficient suf suf- Intelligence to vote for tor the tho people they want to voto veto for when the tho names of ot their candidates ates al are aro j before booro them on the face taco of or tho the machine And though And though the court need not bo charged with fth this OB ns It was probably not tho the purpose of oC tho the court court the tho principle Is c established that Tom Kearns Kearn and and his made hand party part doesn't get got an any moro than a square deal leal whereas managers of oC tho the organization organ organ- had bad boon of ot the Impression that they might havo whatever t they demanded Thero There will t bo be no Taft TaCt electors on the Amerl American n party part ticket deleot It If you oU want to vote voto for tor Taft electors you OU will vote voto for tor them on the Republican ticket If you want to ote vote the Republican ticket straIght every every upon It you It-you you ma may do cIo so with i i 1 want to vote voto single movement of or tho lever If It you ou for tor Taft electors and American party candidates for local or any other c candidates l ates othor than Ulan those of ot the tile Republican party part you may The machine machine machine ma ma- chine Is constructed so that you havo have tho the ability to do so so-as so as you OU certainly have tho the right Tho The practical result of ot the decision Is fatal tatal to even evell the Ule last hope of oC the earns ClOW crowd Tho Thoy will ill not riot carr carry the tho county count anWa anyway It I Is doubtful If the they elect tho the city candidates of ot their party part The They will not elect ono of their candidates ates for tor tho tim county or tho the legislature We believe when hen the tho votes are aro counted It will be demonstrated that tho the I crowd could not riot have carried the tho county en if they had had the tho help of or this bogus ticket the they tried to rush past tho the Supreme court count But Dut in any event cent they will not get the count county The They will wIlI not get g-ct the legislature Thc They will not get got the state Elate The They will not get any anything thins thins- i They would havo have gained some votes otes for tor their county count ticket l If the tho court had ruled differently And those votes would have boon been at tho expense of ot tho the Republican count county candidates the candidates tho very er people that the wa was trying tring to defeat e eat Considering that the plaintiffs had no o party part no nohe nohead nohead he head d nor foot root no organization no pl jl platform l no principles no candidates candidate and no justice or or right In their cause it will be bo conceded that thc they havo have dono pretty well to get out of oC the tho city and count county buildIng buildIng building build- build Ing Ing- without being arrested 1 for or contempt of or court They rhey certainly aro are In contempt of the people |