Show SULLIVAN GUILTY I V IS JURYS JURY'S VERDICT t Agree on First D Degree gre M Murder der With Recommendation for V I Life Imprisonment f TO PASS SENTENCE APRil 11 t tt t Judge Armstrong Will WiIt Th Then n Seal Fate Fat Fate Jurors Held Till last l Ballot V eo e- e V V f V o V V T V r 1 0 OHM 4 4 t t 4 t t t o 0 l 1 4 V Tho Time Jurys Jury's Verdict f V 4 1 V V 1 t State of Utah vs Joseph Sullivan Sul- Sul Sulf f ff f Uvan- Uvan V f 4 Ve We the Jury in inthe f the abo above c case ase V find the def defendant defendant de- de V f guilty as charged and Hk 4 f recommend that he be Imprisoned f for life at hard hard labor In Inthe the state penitentiary f 1 4 HYRUM I VII II EVANS Foreman e V o a nine Forty hours after the jur Jury inthe In Inthe Inthe the Sullivan murder case casc left the courtroom court courtroom courtroom room it returned a verdict finding J Joe c cS S Sullivan guilty of murder in the first degree degre for tor the killing of ot Patrol Patrolman an Charles S S. F Ford rd on the morning of ot f December 14 last Jast and recommended that Sullivan be Imprisoned for life at hard hartl labor Jabor in the the- state penitentiary Har V With a cynical smile smil a n slight droop of the head but without the slightest st st. change of expression except for or or t the tho o hard hartl smile that played about hi his lips s Sullivan received receive the verdict Just as aa though hough he lie had lied lo long g exp expected it and andas andas V V Vas as if It came camo as ns no surprise V The Jury jur returned to Judge Armstron Armstrong's Armstrongs Armstrongs Armstrong's Arm Arm- stron strongs strong's s co rt r loom yesterday st r aft afternoon after after- f r- r noon at It had be bep n in ln deliberation delibera tion since Saturday afternoon at 3 V V The verdict yas wn reached reachel yesterday afternoon af a- at 1 oclo o'clock k arid and notice to to that V V effect was sent t to the c court urt ls T Tand and the sheriffs sheriff's office ce Court Koom Crowded V When Whon the the Jury returned t two 0 hours V later hater the the- court room room- was crowded d. d Men and women wohlen gathered to hear th tho I v verdict t pi pr the JUry jury and all l eyes tur turned cd as Deputy PU Y Clerk l Howard King nead reaU the tew fV Un sot that t i V. V V fixed hiS hta rate fate r Judge Armstrong s set l Wednesday d Y I tn r h g April Apr t as She tIme for or para para- A i Ing V V VV V V V rO f if 1 r 9 Jl w t I r f r 1 o IQ i th t motion S r. r n ans J wiil p a aher Dam r ber her of ot l reasons wh why S Sullivan n should be granted d another trial V Among Among- tho those e reasons it is Js understood understood under under- stood what hat ha happened in hi the Jury loom will stand out prominently J. J H H. Bailey Jr sta stat stated d t to the pr s yeSterday yesterday yesterday yeS yeS- yes yes- T that he lie had been een told bY by Charles Denn Denney y one of C the Jurors jurors that undue Influence had had been used in inthe the the jury room to bring bout about the ve verdict Denies Denies' Stor Story Th The Th- V story told told by n Jag as a recited d to him b by Denney h he cl claims Is tl that at Denney had been d threatened d by other Jurors because he he- was l In the thc minority and held out against agreement nt Bailey Eailey said that Denno Denney told him some of ot the Jurors had threatened to go into court and charge him with perjury It he did not vote with the majority for tor a ve ver verdict dict of or guilty V V Denney Denne denied this story to The Re Re- V Pu publican bI ican V V No undue Influence was use used he ho said hl There are arc not enough men In Salt Lake county to coerce me and andl I Iv Iwas v was as not In any way Intimidated by other jurors There was no such thing thin whatever Do you think that there was anything anything any any- thing which l happened in the Jury room that would woul justify a motion for fora a a. new trial 1 Certainly not was the reply Three Jurors Held Out Jurors D Denney Oldham and Stauffer Stauf- Stauf fer held out against the extreme penalty penalty penalty pen pen- pen pen- alty because of the testimony of ot Buckley the bartender r at the Albany saloon who said that he lie was as hot not certain certain tam tain that Sullivan wa was the nan nian in the Albany saloon on the night of the hold I I Th The vote up to the ninth ballot stood nine mime to three for conviction ot for tor forthe forthe the extreme penalty without a Ten ballots In all were taken and after atter the tenth vim vaS ca cast t the he V recommendation for life liCe nt Instead Instead in instead In- In stead of or death was agreed Upon The jur Jury on on the first b ballot stood d eight for Cor conviction and alid four for ac ac- ac c- c Later It went to nn nine and Denney Denncy Oldham and Stauffer held out because they were not riot sure oure that Sullivan Sulli Sulli- van ran was the man mami wh who was in the he sa saloon saloon saloon sa- sa loon and who later Inter ran out with Garcia and shot Ford Fortl Denney was a Juror In tho time murder case easo against Jo Joe 2 22 years cats ago when Biddlecome lecome was found guilt guilty guil gull t ty of ot murder In the first d degree grce and sentenced to life Ufe Imprisonment later being pardoned Ho He murdered a man mun named Jensen near Stockton V OK OF JOt JOB SULLIVAN UI CH i n I-n t. t In History tor of or Man Maim Found Guilty of of Murder r. r Joe Sullivan was bo born n In n nw New eW w T ork City In 1879 was educated t d d' d In the I schools there thero and i learned the trade ol 01 ofa a amarine amarine V marine machinist In he l left tl New NewYork NewYork NewYork York and worked along lIonS the Pacific coast from Mexican p to toS to'S San Fran Fran- cisco Ho also worked on n steamships V plying S San n Francisco co and for for foreign eign ports Ab About ut five yearS years ago he he lie was v l let l out In th the strike of r shipping Industries and after afier v junto of or the West w went t t tc to For Foran nn an assault with a deadly weapon nn and for tor an aim attempt to break j Jail Uhe 9 Continued on UD Three r r V Y V VV T V V V. V Th V Ul V V dl V S SULLIVAN GUI GUILTY TY TYIS IS JURYS JURY'S VERDICT Continued fr from om P PARC lre Op One t r from m Og Ogden en t to five years car Inthe in Itt inthe the tile states state's prison lie He served th tho timo full five years cars and was wa released December December Decem Decem- ber her 9 9 last The Time The first thing timing Sullivan did dill after aCter leaving the tha p was to buy a pistol Next he lie tried to dispose i of oC some seine stolen silverware On Omi the time night of December 10 he hc was arrested l In iii Commercial street with John Owen amidon and amid andon andon on Dec December 13 he ime Rn and Owen were released l from the tho tile county count Jail on the time distinct und understanding r ian hat they theY were to leave e Salt Lake Ln e at once Sullivan was s classed b by tho ho police pollee as an n undesirable unde inde s citizen Onen OD and ami Accor AccordIng to Sullivans Sullivan's own statements statements state state- ments he be Garcia and amid Owen were to together to- to gether earl early In imi tho time morning of oC December Decem Decem- b ber r H. H Shortly after 3 clock o'clock on that morning the Albany bar was robbed and the robbers shot and killed Officer Charles S. S Ford Within an an hour after atter tho the shooting John Owen Ossen was caught h by the police ant arid and he claimed that Sullivan Sul Sul- livan J had hat held up the Alban Albany bar As s the time police had hall photographs of Sullivan posters poster were Immediately Immediate printed d and Governor Cutler r offered a n reward of ot 00 for tor the tho arrest and convIction con con- conviction con con- of or the mur murderer of the officer The Tha poster was sent ent to every city village and hamlet In the time Inter moun I tam country countr From Front December 14 until January JanuarI 4 I 4 nothing was wag li h heard mard ard of Sullivan In a definite def deC mite wa way On time the ho night of January Januar 4 4 howe however er word came camo from Portland Ore that u a Thomas Howard had laid been arrested there and th that t he was supposed suppose to be Sullivan Tho The police requested a picture of oC Howard and on its ts arrival im here here re It was Identified as being being be lie ing a likeness of oC Sullivan Tried Fried to nr Rk Jail Jull Detectives Chase an and Shannon went to Portland and amid found that it was sas In reality the time Joe Sullivan wanted to answer to the time murder of f Charles S. S Ford With Ith Sullivan In custody th the detectives arrived In Salt Lake on the time night of January 17 17 about the lie hour the he grand rand march started In iii the time benefit dance gh given n for tor the tho widow and ana children of oC the murdered officer Sullivan after acter his arraignment was wn placed In iii the time count count jail Te was thero there Just about thirty six hours when ho imo homade made an attempt to saw his bits way to liberty Richard his ImIs mate cell under the time ruse lube of oC wanting to go so to court was taken from the jail and amid he disclosed the information that led lcd to Sullivans Sullivan's being caught In Iii the act of oC saw sawing i ii g. g The TIme convicted man mami has hus one of or the time most unsavory records of or an any criminal ill hi it the tIme West During his bus Incarceration In n the lie penitentiary he ime was wa a third third- grade most of tho time time Three months out of oC the tIme five years he lie was In Inthe he tIme first grade and was accor accorded ct some liberties During time the last six months of oC lila hla confinement he lie was a second second- I grade prisoner lie was always considered considered con con- dangerous al ami 1 was feared alike e b by Ute the guards and convicts lie He lieas was as the tIme known lea leader el of oC the time most des des- men confined In the time house on the tue hill lull |