Show SULLIVANS SULLIVAN'S FATE SOON TO BE KNOWN KNOB Arguments About Finished li In Murder Case Before Judge Armstrong TRAINMEN INJURE ALIBI ALIB Declare Joe Was On Their Train After Ford Was Killed Here D By carl early afternoon tho the fate late of or Jo Joe Joo Sullivan an charged l with tho murder o or of Police Officer Charles S. S l Void Foid old In tin time early morning of December cr 14 last will vill l probably 1 rest st In iii the tho han hands s of ot th the Jury The Thc taking of testimony closed yesterday yesterday yes yes- tel ay and anI arguments were begun County Attorney Willard Hanson Hnnson ma made mad e ethe the tIme opening argument for tho time state an and was followed by J. J H HI Bailey Jr for the defense Mr Ir Bailey Balle talked most of time the afternoon an arid and had Imad no not nol closed when court adjourned He lie will wll continue his argument this Lids morning and amid wilt will 1 bo be e followed 1 by y his law partner partner part part- District Attorney At At- ner ncr Attorney Vickery torney torno Fred C. C Loofbourow will wUl close for the tho state It n is believed c that b by 3 3 o'clock Ju Judge ge George G. G Armstrong before whom whon I tho the murder trial Ima has has- been in ress i during tho the week weel will m begin hl his In Instructions In- In to the tIme jury jur which will wilt consume con con- sume about aboul 15 16 minutes Sullivan Alibi Shattered Sullivans Sullivan's alibi that ho Ito left Salt SnIt Lake Lako before beCore the murder occurred was dir dir- proven when two railroad men conductor conductor conductor con con- ductor nn and brakeman on the time Short Shor Line testified that they had teen seen Sul Sul- Ih ilvan n get set ore oft their train In iu Og- Og Ogden Ogen en In ir bro daylight and that the train di did not miot leave Salt SaIL Lake until after att r 5 o'clock or three hours after atler U the e Ford For murder Harry r W. W Logan Locan West st Fit Firth thi North orth street a conductor on the time Oregon Oregon Oregon Ore Ore- gon Short horl Line testified that he lie left heft Salt Lake Lako on the time morning of oC December 14 11 at 5 He said ho lie knew that Officer Ford had had been boen shot on en that tha morning because police officers searched search search- ed od the train before it left the time yards ar B Band and told him why they the were searching It IL L The conductor stated he saw aw Sullivan Sullivan Sul Sul- livan hyatt get off the train at Ogden about i 30 o'clock on that morning He lit stated that ho lie paid particular attention attention attention atten atten- tion to the tho man and telephoned the time Ogden police that a n stranger had go got oft the time train an and was wa In the time yards at ut Woods Cross TO Logan said ald his train aln made Its first stop stoll at the time initial switch in the tIme north yards In Salt Lake Thu Tho switch is lo located located located lo- lo about a n. mile mUo north o tho passenger pas pas- depot Tho Time next stop was Far- Far which Is 15 Hi miles from Salt Lal Lake Time The train tho the conductor testified lied fied was running at least 25 5 miles an hour lour at Woods CrossI Cross V. w. H. H Harrison on a a. bral brakeman eman on the time train testified to the same facts as did dIll the time conductor In a addition both men mcm identified cd Sullivan as the time man they ha had seen leave heave the time train at Og Ogden en The rime crosse cross examination dl did not sh shako shake the direct testimony Sullivan Dill Did tho time Sawing Sheriff Emery and Deputies Joe Sharp and Axel Ste Stelo lo went on the stand and md explained d again to the jur Jury that Sullivan and not Denting Deming sawed on the bar In the tho county Jail it t was stated told the time sheriff shella about what Sullivan was vms doing and anel stated that If an Sullivan ever found out that he ic had on him Sullivan would bump Jump him George H. H Jepson who Is serving a term in iii tho the city ell jail for an nn assault on his wife and who goes under various names took tool the stand and said saM that Tip rip Belcher claimed to have havo been promised immunity Tip Belcher Beicher was called calle and said he ho had a conversation along that line Une with Jepson but that the officers at the city Jail had promised promIsed prom prom- sed to do what the they could for him provided plo ho could tell them where Garcia was located locate Mike te GI Glenn nn who claimed some time ago that thal he lie was robbed at th the Albany Alban bar jar and Insinuated that thal Buckley Duckley the bai bartender tender knew a whole lot about the time alleged up hold was put on the tIme stand Ho He did not testify however as his lila testimony testimony testimony tes tes- was waa wa objected to by b tho time state ant and antl the tho objection sustained Time The taking of testimony r clo closed d at noon Bailey Prince CS Sensation 1011 Attorney Bailey was as the sensation of the day Ho oven even brought broucht his son C G years ol old Into the time court room and stated that the thc mother of ot Sullivan no doubt do at tho timo time Sullivan was 6 years rears oI old had great reat ambitions for him At least three times Bailey Balle started stalled to argue points that hc had not been brought out In the testimony and anel objections b by the state slate were sustained During his argument Bailey Dallo asked for a mInute five recess In that time he ha had hada a a board brought Into the room On Oil tho board he lie placed a l. l bottle Lottie of beer and also a a. bottle bottlo purporting to contain whiskey He placed place 1 a 0 whiskey ke gln glass at tho time sl side e of the time bottle of beer After 6 he lie had everything neatly neath arranged ar 01 ar- ar ranged the time court on motion of or the time state ordered th time the outfit banished from fromn the tIme court room It was contended that the glasses s and bottles had absolutely nothing to do with ith the time c case Mr Ir Bailey Balle nd addressed Jurors D. D 1 L. L. L Murdoch Murdock and William N N. Davis perI per per- I He lie referred to the time when ho he with 1 Mr MUr was on tho the mission mis ml sion field in England Will Curry Ca-c Ca r. higher You were taken on this Jury jUlY Mr Murdock said maId th the attorney because be lIe cause caul Mr Ir Sullivan said Thero There is la a aman aman man I am sure I can trust I believe ho lie would hold out two years If It he lie thought I was Innocent Th This l man hero liere is Innocent and antl will not hang this 81 side o of ot tho the Supreme me court of ot th the United States if IC I have to mortgage my farm form and spend every dollar I have ha haven In n the tho world Bailey had a u. bra braas brasz chain which was not linked together toe He contended tho the evidence a against Sullivan was so t that t. t at t Jest 11 Inh were wee I II I missing Ho referred to many songs songo I that ho he had sung ming while on the mission missionfield field Turning to Sullivan and nd then theno to o th tho Jury he eal said eald There Is 15 no life In Salt Lake I 1 would rould rather save than his He has got more brains than tho time lawyers b on both tl sides e You Ton know gentlemen oC or ortho tho timo jury rind and I know knor the they have ha not pro produced ucc the testimony that 7 satisfy sat sat- your oUt minds 3 that Sullivan 1 is guilty bUIlt sat sat-I About John On Owen en In referring to Mrs Belcher he declared de dc- I dared clale she was commonly known as a n mistress of Joe Joo Garcias Ho declared I I she told the time truth at the preliminary examination The best beat bc t ho lie could do 10 for John Owen who is the time one who squealed on Sullivan an was waa to call him him tho the slinking cowardly l cringing 0 Owen But look at al Sullivan ho said lid He came canto onto tho time witness stand and amid raising rais rals- fn lug ing his noble head answered all nil questions questions ques ques- lions Justly Do they think they arc are going to hang a 0 man like him Thc They will IhL not as long bug as I have a single dellar dollar del dol lar In tho the world I urn tim thankful ful to toI I God we have married men memi on this Jury who have boys to thIn think about I Hanson knows who fired the tIme shot I that killed hilled Ford Sullivan was not there They are fire bringing him to trial simply because thc they caught him When Whon I was a child l 12 years old I promised prom prom- my mother that when I became a II lawyer lawer I would woul never defend a guilty guilt man Sullivan has told mo me he lie is not guilty I have tried to trap Sullivan in a n lie and asHl I cannot do it It The attorney referred to the time Apostle Paul He said he lie had been charged with crimes which he never committed In Iii the tIme same wn way ho lie referred to th tIme the Apostle Peter Peler nn and amid ended this bit of 01 argument by referring to tho the cruel cruel- lon t. of Jesus Christ In tho the next breath he lie said sold that Sullivan an was a better bet bet- ter looking looking- man than his lawyers He lie referred to Joseph Smith the prophet ar ard said that public opinion re resulted in iii hi his life being sacrificed sac sac- and amI that ho lie was nicknamed Joe Smith Sullivan to Milk lIIk s. Co CO Although he lie did not explain exactly exactly exact exact- I I ly what he meant ho Ito said a 0 house housecleaning housecleaning I cleaning was needed neede in Salt Lake Why Vh this town has hns Chicago and amid New Ness York City sl skinned skimmed a milo mile and arid you ou know It If It you ou t try this timis case not by Iron bars and amid Garcias Garcia's shoes you ou will viii not hang this lIlls man maim This man will go on my ranch much and milk m my cows cn and drive drle my mowing machine I toll tell you now you ou are not going to hang hans him When Whelm Bailey alJe reached reache this part of his imis argument the time hour of adJournment adjournment adjourn adJourn- ment had Imad arrived and amid Jm lie he will resume his Imis argument ar at 10 lii o'clock this morn morn- lug ing As a a. time limit ha has not been arranged ar ar- ar- ar ranged rang he lie may use time lime at his own discretion i TIme The opening opening- argument for Cor the time state which preceded the time speech of or Balle Bailey was mn made e by br Willard Villard Hanson county attorney He began begun at 2 o'clock and finished at 3 After re reviewIng reviewing re- re viewing the time facts leading up to theFord the time Ford For murder ho said I start with the assertion that the prosecution does not know l who v fired the time shot shut and and amid as' as far fal as the time defendant is concerned concern it It mal makes no difference All are equally equall guilty All MI act to to- to gether If It any other rule of ot law were to bo be enforced all would escape under the time mere technicality that the time one who fired time the shot hot could not be located It ItI Itis I Ks is no use for the time defendant to stand standon on the simple defense that he did not firo fire the time shot Not Wanted in Saloon S Mr r. r Hanson Hnnson pointed out that thal the time evidence showed that Owen dl did not have a n. gun at any time after he lie wa was wag released etl from the time city jail and that even oven after the robbery Owen was captured captured cap cap- without a n. gun un being in his pos pos- session Was as as Sullivan in tho the Albany any bar at nt atthe the time time timmie of the time up hold hoL up 1 was a question ques quos I lion tion put to the jury Jur for tor consideration I r want vant you to remember that Garcia asked for fOl Sullivan an on the night beCore before before be be- fore Core the time shooting He did not ask for tor Owen That Is a circumstance worth considering Why should he have given Sullivan a weapon and not Owen BoUt Both men were going to leave town Vh Why would Sullivan an need a agun agun gun gumm any more than Owen Just consider con con- sider aider these things timings I In a u. forc forceful tul manner Mr Ml Hanson I then took tool up th the manner manlier in which Sullivan Sullivan Sul Sul- livan fled tied from S Salt Lake He called attention to the time fact that he hid In boxcars suffered from cold coM and amid was emaciated when he reached re ched Portland Do you ou believe an aim Innocent man would act ct that way ho he asked Denied Ills His Identity Again the minute ho was picked ed up In Portland he lie said his name was Thomas Howard that ho he ha had 1 never been In Utah an and 1 that nobody in the state could J Identify him When h he was ivas shown a picture of or himself ho he still sUIl claimed he lie was as Thomas Howard II lie was willing to admit that a Joe Sullivan ha had been connected with the tilling killing of time the officer but that he was not Joe Joo Sullivan He was wag somebody else che I In closing clo Mr Ir Hanson said That i E shot hot that 1 killed Officer Ford was not riot notI I tired fired at him as a person It was a n shot against organized law and order It II was a shot against me and amid against you yuu Ford For with his helmet and amid badge was merel merely the time target Tho Tue blood of Charles S. S Ford is crying to me and antl to you to do our sworn sworn dut duty The defense will ill ask you ou In verdict for tor justice and amid mercy your I want you ou to have hove justice justice- and antl mercy on an an outraged public In your verdict I r want you OU to have justice and n mercy for tor the wife and children of ot Officer Ot Ford in your our verdict If It you ou do this tho the defendant will pay a the penalty of ot othis his crime j James F. F Anderson u erson tIme the Portland Ore Ole police officer who arrested Sullivan Sullivan Sulli sum van left last night for tor Portland 1 |