Show SEEMS SI-EIS TO MISTAKE IU COMMON COURTESY At the regular monthly meeting of the Sheets party I Wednesday c ne da nl night ht Jud Judge e C C. C. C Goodwin delivered an ana a address which lacks something o of reflecting cre credit lt either Ith J I on n his ju judgment or 01 his sense serite e of courtesies received Judge Goo Goodwin is an nn ol old man an and is possessed of amore a more than average Intellectual force While utterly lacking In character he hc still has hag given so many evi evl- evidences deuces dences of mental equipment that the thc people of Utah always steadfast in recognizing merit have ha excused whatever cr failings tailings on the moral line he ma may have permitted permitted per per- himself to commit Tho rho judge eVl evidently has mistaken mis taken the kindliness of or for a fear of hl his power an and has sal said things which should have havo been left let for a younger man Or he should have been content content content con con- tent to leave assaults for those WhO whose 6 records s arc are beyond beyond be be- Je- Je yond assailing In the course of or his address before the tho Sheets party part club Judge Goodwin win arraigns the President of ot tho the United States as a traitor as a maker mater of infamous compacts compacts com com- pacts a as a sympathizer with crime and as an enemy enem of ot true American institutions Incidentally ho he told his hearers and the newspaper agencies of tho the Sheets party larty promptly enlarged his audience that such citizens citizens citi citi- zens zenH of Utah as ag he did ld not 11 are almost equally bad That part of his hils remarks can be pa passed ed without much criticism He has received his wage while he was workIng work work- log ins for r thorn and may feel with his peculiar views of obligation at liberty to say of them em the things which 1 his present t employers desire him to say But when he ho accuses accuse the President of the United States State of treason II and infamy the kindly silence which has been beon extended extend extend- I ed ell him In the past mn may with propriety be he broken An And yet It Is not to th lime tho Judge Goodwin of or the present pros pres ent cot da day that wo we would woul address these few fc remarks Itis It ItIs Is to a younger man man man-a a man fort forty years yearns alg younger Ju Judge bO Goodwin was formerly on the thc dl district bench In the new newstate newstate state of or Nevada n e a. a And It Is Instructive e to loo look through the first volume of or the Supreme court reports of that I state In that first volume one finds that Alford and nOlI others against Bradeen and others was appealed from Judge Goodwins Goodwin's court an and the tho court in reversing re reversing reversing re- re him Ea says S 'S The Instructions given ghen at tho ho Instance of or ortho tho the plaintiffs were were excepted to to but are arc not contained con con- tamed In tho the statement on appeal Wo We cannot can cannot not tell what the they were and of course can not say the they were erroneous Ono One of or tho the grounds for a new trial attached to statement on appeal is that the tho verdict Is against law an and evidence e and amI on that ground round the judgment Is reversed Tho The district court will set aside the Judgment in ht the probate court an and or order er a a. new trial inthe In Inthe Inthe the district court unless tho the plaintiffs should elect to dismiss their action Tho very cry case reported is that of Lambert against Moore and the decision of or the Supreme court COUlt o of Nevada may be he found on pago page an and tho the two pages follow follow- ing In this caso case Ju Judge go Goo Goodwin was not reversed because because because be be- cause he ho seems to have ha f forgotten to complete completo his record b by rendering an any judgment at all And the court say fay a d As As s yet ct there bern being no ju judgment In tho the district court there Is not an and can not be any appeal to this court Tho The clerk will strike this cause from the calender But In the very next case It case It seems to havo have boon been tho ho habit to appeal even en then from tho the Judgment of oC Goodwin Goodwin-a a ruling was recorded e In Maples against Geller and with the following rather stinging conclusion b by Justice Beatty The Tune ju Judgment Is reversed nn and the cause is Js rcman remanded ed to the court below The Tho district court will allow allow- the plaintiff to amend his complaint complaint com coin plaint and take such steps as may bo be consistent consistent consistent con con- with tho the rules of or practice an and not in inconsIstent inconsistent inconsistent in- in consistent with this opinion In Crosier against McLaughlin an and Fulton at pa page e of or the tho same volume tho the er very next caso case appealed from Judge Goo Goodwins Goodwin's court tho the Supreme court says say's sa s 's sIn in conclusion The Tune judgment for costs an and dismissal of ot complaint Is set aside Immediately following Is another appeal case that case that of or Jones Joncs an and Colla against James and Compan Company Company Com Com- pany pan and the Supreme court says The uThe judgment of or tho the court below Is set aside o an and a new trial or ordered cre At page pago of or tho same volume volume Judge Goodwin being then thon in his prime an and certainly responsible and capable If ever ever record record is given of or the tho case of or the People on the relation of Flack against the Board Boar of or Commissioners of or Washoe count county and the usual conclusion conclusIon conclusion con con- appears wit to-wit I i The judgment must bo be reversed an and the court below will issue a mandamus In accordance accordance accordance accord accord- ance with the views expressed In this opinion At page pabO of or the same volume o of Nevada Supreme co court court rt reports comes the case of or Champion against Sessions Sessions Ses Ses- and and others and the opinion b by Lewis chief Justice justice Jus jus- tice concludes cs as follows Judgment reversed c and cause remanded The court below will reinstate the case and take such proceedings as the tho equities of or the case mn may require not inconsistent with the thc views lows expressed expressed ex ex- pressed In this opinion Keller against Blasdel Fall lall Pinkerton and others follows on pago page of ot the same volume again volume again the next case reported as appealed from Judge Goodwin And again the tho chief justice mal makes es the usual conclusion conclusion conclusion sion Judgment must bo reversed and cause remanded Clark against Shannon is the title of tho the last Goodwin Goodwin Goodwin Good Good- win case reported in that initial v volume lume of the Supreme court reports of or Nevada e an and tho the opinion by Justice Beatty Is a trifle more salt salty than any preceding It ItIs ItIs ItIs Is as follows at page The ju judgment must bo be reversed an and tho the cause remanded Tho The court below will causo cause the wife of or Shannon to be made defendant inthe In Inthe th the case an and upon her answer coming in will proceed to tr try an and determine this case caso according accordIng accord accord- Ing to the views expressed in this opinion If there thero are aro an any other cases reported repol In volume ono one of oC that court as appealed from Judge Goo Goodwins Goodwin's court we are unable to find them Tho The truth IB is that he was reversed In every single lo ca case caso o appealed And gentle reader the ju judgment of ot Judge Goodwin Goodwin Goodwin Good Good- win has not nol grown any better with ago age |