Show ENDS TESTIMONY IN NOTED USE CASE Arguments by Lawyers In Donaldson Don Don- Trial Will Be Made Today TELL ABOUT CHARACTER One Witness Says His General General General Gen eral Reputation Is Good With th tile the completion tion of or t M HI r testimony of or Mark fark P. P Braffett all all' e In the Dr Jim Jini Dona Donaldson ca case w w. w s finished before Arm Armstrong g In the tho l District court Friday afternoon and aud Major M. M A. A Breeden b began gan summing up lip the tho evidence for Cor th tho no nor ney Samuel A A. A I King King- for Cor tho defense will ar argue lIc for Cor the tho acquittal of oC his client for Cor or an m hour anti and fifteen minutes this morning h beginning wit with tim tho opening of court at nt 10 o'clock and District Dis Dis- Attorney Fred will make time the closing for Cor the pros prosecution culion la lasting a little moro more than halt half an nn hour Mark was recalled to the stand on rebuttal to Impeach tho the t testimony tes tes- tes s 's of oC Mrs l Sallie Sallio Yount etor etol of 0 tho Antler rooming rooming- i house ts who ito was on aim the time stand In the tho forenoon or noon lie He declared that Mrs Young hail told 1011 him that a man man maim the description of Donaldson had engaged d the room from Crom her and that she hail described rl such a a. man to him In th the morning the tIme woman denied having hail had an any such with the time Salt Sail J Lake Jake attorney t Called Character witnesses were worb called during dur ing lug th List last hour h 1 by the time defense Most of them testified that Jims Jim's character character character char char- acter was as good among tho the g gambling fraternity though each ch one testified that he ht could hardly talk tall as to the general reputation of tho the doctor Those called were Joseph Casey of or the Turf Exchange who said that he lie had often orten trusted J Jim with all his money Charles Dates Bates of the Log Cabin saloon saloon sa saloon sa- sa loon who knew Jim as a n minor miner In Park City and the manager of oC Johnny Nolan's Nolans No Xo- lans lan's gambling house bouse In Cripple Creek Charles Riley a saloonkeeper Edward sergeant of oC police who sho Is Js ono one of the understudies of oC the Sheets crowd John Gill a youna oun fellow from ron ron-i Glen- Glen wood Springs s who has been on th the theline line hue since he was a kid and who te testified that he lived It on the tho money mOtley he gets from home C C. C. C Anderson proprietor of oC the Imperial hotel of or unsavory unsavory un un- un- un sn or savory reputation and M. M l K B. y councilman and saloon saloonkeeper and the theman theman theman man who couldn't resign from the time coun coun- cil cU All AH testified In iii a H general way to the tue good character of or Jim Donaldson for truth honest and Iud fair Healing Imong his associates Harry Finch h was called ailed but said lie he did not know Don Don- or his pals pils well veIl enough to testify tes Us iffy n hR 08 to Jim Jims among them William Hilton HUton tho the eldest member of ot eh lie force YOM Won aIRo l by bv bythe y the anti niia r I on ing inS was good i H. H Cord l Gnu In opening his hlA nr argument Attorney General Breeden I declared that the count county sheriffs sheriff's office was deserving of or high praise for tho the work it had done In this ca case anti and especially should Joseph Josfph Sharp ho hf commended for his I labors He lie declared that thal the district attorney had handled the case In a n thorough h lucid abl able and convincing manner In telling tolling of the tho trap laid for fOI forthe tho the lc the attorney gener general l declared to the jury that there shoula have hare been boen a sign over the doer dobr All Hope Abandon Ye Who lio Enter Here Mr stumbled when ohen ho he began talking of oC the card carti game and antI finally dropped that subject to let lel District DI Attorney Loofbourow handle It The Time testimony of oC alone seems true and convincing con declared A Attorney General but If It Par- Par rent were here hero alone I would not Insult b asking ou tl to your our Intelligence ence by you believe belle hl his story In unsubstantiated nb d. d But It appears rs to be true trul tho the circumstances sc seem em to b bear ar him out ont In most of oC hl his fundamental t testimony I will It o othe the question with your our lt it It Is IsCOl for COl you yon to decide I want to give e the tIle district attorney opportunity to handle handlo the time argument as he lie can handlo It Il and will not therefore more oC of tim thu time Concludes r. r l Tho Timo testimony or of Dr lr Jim Donaldson Donald Donald- son was las finished during tho tite morning morning- session of oC court Some of or the loose ends of oC testimony were wore gathered to together together to- to gether by Attorney Samuel A. A lIng King Donaldson was put through a n. gruelling In the rc direct examination by 11 Pro Prosecutor Prose Prose- c- c cuter Loofbourow and carno caine out of It rather time the worse for Cor wear the ther Antler The rho game of or cards In rooming hou home e was wis reviewed and lOd Jim testified that one ono of oC the tile Io ors turned the thc la has laa which how d Jim to have ha th the bt best st hand around the board boord the tho witness testified fled A few Cew days hays ago It was Larry Jarry OBrien O'Brien who did the turning turn turn- In ing and antI he ho told Mr Loofbourow that t he might have o boon been mistaken on tho the former fonner occasion hut but that h he was eel cor- ei who turn turned tam lain that It wn was the thC last Int not enid not OBrien to testified that he did note not OBrien O'Brien go to the tho satchel Jack see e small grip or whatever er It wa wax wal and tn take o oa a revolver er from Crom It It In lot C Jim was certain that h he dirl did not tul take c a gun out have seen een It would he suld suid because he lU have ha been some very cry small object object ob oh It must uIl concealed Jim argued a as OBrien O'Brien In the palm of or hit his hand It wa was then it Il OBrien O'Brien returned to Uio thic table t tb the thelast that and Donaldson Donald 1 turned over o card wa wan as last t d declared to have thin tho bc bo bet t hand son was the board It was WOR then that tho the around lo kicked a agu against era hint t the tho deal Joal received and Donaldson continued continued con con- had the they tinned Jim himself said that If Jt the they thought th they y had b been n robbed It would be best to send for Cor a policeman The winning hand entered tho the room When LooT- LooT Attorney what did tild he ho do asked ho bouro tI ro W. W ll hand and said Ho lie pointed to my the winning hand That's change your 11 0 testimony tes Us ou want to you Then of or a few days ago aJo and mats the winning han hand not said That hand wins sins 20 I Is that what aldes said ald said mine he Yes es Im I'm sure sur winning hand wa was the stated ted that his sister mew knew Donaldson time made madu a Il business busi- busi had at one ono that he but that h ho he hod had told gambling ness neBS of oC that with It and that ho he wan vae done don her iter not Ilot turned a a. rd cr for tor or nearly he hull hud In proof of or the tact And Ami three throe years had hall dono something else clue than thOn that he lie hilt hat he during the many years year ear gamble mediC Salt Lako his homo home Donaldson that he hat had told toM the district attorney worked cd for Cor the Rio Orando Grando railroad In a n clerical l capacity for nearly nearl near near- l ly 1 lh five m months at ono one time Other than that he could not tell of oC any work h he hA had ever er done tIon That was as the thA only I to Donaldsons Donaldson's original state slate meat ment that gambling was waR the only thing he over ever er did as ns a 3 bu business I Memory In is loor oorA A As a matter of or fact your memory Is rather poor Isn't It ItT asked the district attorney Yes at times I cannot remember what I say I h have told toM you some things while on time the stand anti and ten minutes after I forK forget t Just what I have said That Is la wh why you ou may catch mo rae once or twice In making sinking different sat statements to 10 yoU Sometimes m my brain becomes troubled and anil I cannot ber her at nil all nut Hut I am positive of or what happened 11 on the time night of or the time card cartI game and amid other things just before that tI time rn e. e Is your our poor memory caused by any ny recent habit that has clouded your our brain Iraln r asked tho the prosecutor No o. o Mr Ir I then turned the star star witness over to his own attorney Mr fl Donal Donaldson on Ill I'll ask you OU that if while In Denver dm during Ing those fI five or six sIc days you wen went t under your own name asked Attorney y KinK Kins Yes sir I registered as J J. J M. M f. f Donaldson Don Don- at the iho Denver Athletic a association association asso asso- so and at th the Eagles Eagles' club answered answered an an- I an-I the defendant When In lii Hot Springs Ark lid you go under own name and deposit money under your own name Yes sir ln Officer r COlli Ill ask asle you OU If JC you arc acquainted t l with Mr Ir Sharp and If you ou met him In Hot Springs Yes Ys I know him When I returned I from m my bath one da day the clerk told toM me I that an on officer from Salt Lake Lalee was Inthe Inthe In Inthe the city mill and was looking for foi me I put plIt on my clothes clothe nt at once onee and went to jo 0 look for tor him Jim told that he had found Cound Chief f Deputy Deputy Dep Dep- uty Sheriff Jo Joe Sharp and that on meetIng meetIng meet- meet Ing lag he had said I guess I know what you ou want me for or He lie said he was more than willing willing- willingto to come back to S Salt lt Lake and face race the music ic lIe He got his things to together together to- to gether ether and returned with Sharp within two hours after afler he had met him Both Donaldson and Sh Sharp p went to a bank In Hot Springs where Jim drew diew t-ew t the 1000 which he had hail on deposit Thought ht Ilone Won Vou When you ou won that monc money from the lid did you ou think you OU won It honestly asked Attorney KingI King ICing I 1 certainly did replied the witness I Ineer never neer took money under an any other conditions conditions conditions condi condi- In m my lire life The lawyers wrangled over the attempt of ot counsel for the defense to get set from Donaldson Just Jut wh why he returned the Iho 1000 to lo Jack OBrien O'Brien after afler he had hall won It honestly from I Judge Armstrong Armstrong Armstrong Arm Arm- strong finally let this go Into the case Donaldson said that fearing fearing- that there would be some trouble as a result of or the game and at the suggestion of OBrien O'Brien he had turned the 1000 bank note over oyer overto overto to the elder OBrien O'Brien to give back to the and avoid ord i if possible pop an any trouble as na a result of tho the game same Jack ri ran n the game Jim said and he thought he ho should be bo protected is as as much as possible pos pos- sible Mr King Kine- sought to erase crase the testimony of a n conspiracy b by the witness J If he h. knew Mrs Mis fr Peterson on and had ever N been to Ie C see her hr with either cither of ot the Jim said he had never seen Heen the woman to his hla knowledge and that he did not nol know Mrs Levi at whose whoso homo home he had on one onO occasion been In conference with Jack 10 rJ h In Star Jim Don Donaldson ld n an Jp au an n. n emi emissary nr to to rid rid tho the city of or was the new rob rolo given the gambler by Al Attorney King Donaldson said ho he had hart told Martin Mulvey Mul- Mul VO vey that that there were wre grafters in town and that he could prove it Mulvey ulve him to get more more evidence and nd that that the they would see what wha could be bo d done about tho matter Donaldson told the councilman Particularly l th lh the O'Briens w were running running run run- ning a a. game and arid was told to further In Inc Investigate investigate In- In c the matter Ills His little up clean-up of oC- oC 1000 10 was one of or his steps at In InU Ua U- U gation a In direct re-direct examination Donaldson said he was not really connected with Mulvey Mul ve vey but that he merely knew him He said the two did not have a gambling agreement or nn anything thing like that What do you ou mean by running the grafters out o of town asked District Attorney Attorney Attorney At At- torney Loofbourow Well IVell I had heard that there were grafters In Salt Lake and told lold Mr 11 Mulvey Mul Muil- vey y about It lie He said ho he t i didn't nt believe It and told me to Inel Investigate further and that limit If tc there w wore were re grafters ho ito would run them out of town Donaldson te testified Wednesday that he was under the employ of oC Mr Mulvey but hut stated on i LuO LO o Friday that ho hI did not mean macan that ho was wa under pay from Crom the councilman out alit that ho he merely I c carried car car- r. r rl tiled ried d n news WA to him of or local conditions In the gambling world C Could Not ot net Return urn In answer to a question from the district dis net attorney as to wh why he did not return return return re re- re- re turn to Snit Salt Lake before hero tho the officer ar- ar nested him Donaldson said that he aid not know he ht was d here he here he thought the matter ad blown over He lie said h he was waR tithing treatment at nt Hot Springs 8 and could not ave returned sooner If Ir ho had 80 so lie desIred Donaldsons Donaldson's testimony was then con- con concluded tho the defense called Mrs Irs Sallie E. E Young who conducts the tho Antler Anther rooming house haune Mrs Young Young- lost her temper tem tern per several times during her examination examina- examina llon tion and once or twice refused to answer the questions of or Prosecutor Loofbourow She crime come near being h ld In contempt for her replies und not until Judge Judg Armstrong Arm Arm- strong had hall severely sQ reprimanded her did dirt she answer an civilly 01 What tho the district attorney wanted was to know where the register had hatI gone sone which she kept on the of 01 Septem- Septem bor 19 1905 1908 when the poker game gamo wa was going on In her hr house at which the Mc- Mc fc lost nearly 1 1000 through cards arda I. I and bogus bocus police officers Did you ou over find that register asked d the he prosecutor No I didn't I never looked for It Where 1 I is that book hook I donl dont know lint But I do know that the tho only cob book haole that thal I have Is there Is Book nook I I II you yell O 1 tell mo me the other r day when I was down there that the thc book hind had been lest and that you ou could not find It ll 7 demanded demanded de de- de- de tho prosecutor No sir I 1 did not Ill I'll tell you ou right now that any arty book I 1 have ha ever had Is at the rooming house Can Cnn you ou produce those books I dont don't know lenow that I can answer answered d Mrs Young smartly When Attorney Braffett Chief ef George A A. Sheets SheeL and Raleigh went to tn your place didn't you give them a description de do- of the man who had rented the thc room and didn't Chief Chic Sheets Sheets' ask you ou If you OU knew I I dont don't remember an any such uch con er conversa tion Hon Did you OU say It at nt that time or any other time I 1 said It at no time an any place O or any any- where shere I You mean to sa say that you ou n never ver gave sa I f u tl d description of that man I told you ou that tha t once once I lOwing Owing to the demeanor of oC the tho witness I the court was waa Co forced reed to to warn her that I SilO sno must answer civilly and that she would answer the questions no matter If they were put to her ten times limes There seemed to lo be he a general understanding and Mrs Young answered questions put to her without comment until she was excused Mrs In |