Show ir iF YOU vou c. CANT CT r uc ne HONEST IIO nJ BIS X Xo ti city can long lone be ruled by its worst people No Xo from froni bad batI men inca and und community Is Js In permanent danger anger there Is no lasting value alue in lies a as an argument Let the people have the truth on every subject Conceal nothing from them Pay thc them 1 the tho honor to tobe be bc hank frank an and honest with them And AntI they will not make mak man many mistakes It is Js perfectly safe ae to trust t tile the 1 PeOPle cople it u Is is perfectly perfectly per per- safe uCo to let them know inow just the facts In the case without coloring without prejudice and antI without bias bins rule and anti they are aro sensible Lethem Let Le They rhe arc alo fair tall a as a them know the truth an and they will take tale care caro of them them- solves selves They lucy need no guardian who ho has to deceive them for their protection Tell them the tho truth an and they will protect themselves These few remarks arc provoked 1 by tho the established policy of the time Tribune and anti the rest of or the papers owned and controlled b by tho the owners of the tho Tribune Wo 0 do o not nce need name them You know how man many and what are their names You know Inow that they the theare are ver very bitter bitterly 1 opposed c lo o 0 The Time Republican an and wo we believe you OU will agree l CO with us that they are aro not en entirely tire I lair fall in their fight ag against this paper We Ve haven't any objection so tar far as that is concerned for with time the right rIg on o our r sl side and C-an C ana we solemn solemnly believe c tho the right is Js on our sl side e ewe ve we cheerfully meet the tho lot of oC them They can not ot cru crush h this paper and antI they can not answer its argument If IL they could they would But nut we want to point Joint out the time advantage they seek to lo take of the public lUbliC For example The rhe men in jn comman command of tho those e papers have sp spent nt a a. great deal eal of oC time an and mone money and InH Int In- In H t lc lual effort effort l In tho the endeavor el to make malo Senator Smoot l U Iii the eyes of the c people of or Utah have o ff pep They not Kim hIni Jihn of or f anything 1101 nor 0 they really accuse accused him But nut after aCter years of insistent i constant o re r reiterated re- re iterated iterate abu abuse e of the man the they assume that thc they have made him bun so black that they can damn any enterprise lJ by c charging him with Its direction Therefore the they have Jave Stated not once but repeatedly l that Senator Smoot Is In hi absolute dictatorial control of oC tho the Republican 1 party of oC Utah Ulal In In Ina a lc recent ent issue of or the Tribune it was stated slated that tho the hold of Senator Smoot on the state of Utah Is stronger now than it ever has been in the tho past The They do e not seem eem to lo realize the significance of that concession after afler after their long tight light to destroy stroy him CHARGES WITHOUT W nnA WARRANT T. T For some somo reason they concluded it would gain a point for them to say that Senator Smoot had bought and bribed O. O J. J Salisbury to tot servo serve the Republican an party of or Utah They rhey seemed to lo think they had hatI made the senator so odious that the odium would be com com- comP to Mr 11 Salisbury They say tho the senator prom promised ed Mr Salisbury to make mako hint him United States Stales senator In 1909 Now Xo that thal does oes not seem to be C true truC Perhaps twenty men ot or perfect credibility In Salt Lake men mei whom an any reader of or either The Th R Republican n or th the Tribune would b lIe c declare no such compact was made malle so far as their knowledge extends and they had C every opportunity of oC knowing what hat was going on I It could not have havo been madd without their knowledge dIC OC Ot course the Tribune brushes aside all nIl such dis dis- diss claimers and anti baldly asserts that Senat Senator r Smoot him him- himo I-SI I made mac the promise to Mr Salisbury But really there thelo are ate are only two II people there lopio there never have havo been mor mort than two people who people le who would know the truth huth about that tha They would be Mr 11 Salisbury and antI Senator Smoot Senator Smoot authorizes The He Republican to den denin tIeny I in lit- the the mo most l positive c terms the statement that he ever eve I. I made made-a a promise of to Mr 11 Salisbury or 01 that he hi and Mr 11 Salisbury or anyone anono to for l' l either of them ever eve r at ut all ull discussed Sed tho the matter maUer Mr Salisbury time am and I rl again In Iii his lifetime has stated precisely r thu the same samo thing thing adding adding that cven even if IC ollice had been offered him bin 1 lit lie could not nol and nd would not accept It IL AVe t a do o J not ot believe there is a n. fair fall man o or woman Li LiIn In Salt alt Luke or 01 In Iii tho thu whole state of or Utah Ulah who would woul ii not Jot rea readily ll accept the wor word of or either cither Reed HeetI Smoot or vI vIO 0 F O. O J. J Salisbury on an any subject It Is doubtful If Ir there art aro two men Hum In the state stale wIth whom more mor people a of oC r the Iho t state tato have havo hat baa business dealings And we don don don't Pt t I believe e there thero is It one ono of or them who will say sav that cither t. t I I IR R Reed Heed ed Smoot or 0 O. O J. J Salisbury has ever lied to him bin It has hus been thc the same In politics Both Doth have had s some sm mc C i experience In that field Held of activity But Dut wu wo the they have o pla played cd fair fair Wo We dont don't believe bellevo thc they ha have cv ever cr r deceived anyone Wo We o think it will be nd J mil td tl-ey tl y always kept their word No 0 hero is a statement that Mr 11 Smoot promised 11 1 mcc to Mr 11 Salisbury In Iii consideration of time the t taking Jh o comman Jf the the Republican state campaign l If lit t l year car Doth Both men involved e in the tho statement havo denied It absolutely Ono One is dead and yet et ho he left lel his denial of or that allegation atlon on record while In life liCe and ii 11 he the h full pO possession H of or ull all his faculties and the he other is Js still living living amid and greatly grieved Cd that to so untrue u statement state ste- ment mont should have b been en tua made a against ns tho the late lato chairman chairman chairman chair chair- man of or the party In the iho state stute We e c think It certain they are aro telling the tho truth Wo Vo think readers of ot The Republican will In Indorse orse our statement taW state ment that the tho wor word of ot those two men ought to be bec I accepted c against any ammy authority Jet less boot goom good than their thell own LET THE TIIE PROOF BE DE SHOWN Of f CoUt course e i it If any man alive o has proof that the fhe promise wo was ma made e I he ought to show h w It ft It If Senator 3 I Smoot made nt that promise to Mr h Salisbury he hi avery aCI a u CI very wrong thing He lie ha had no right wl whatever to mal make It it He lie ha had no authority to make it Neither ho imo not nor anyone back of him him has a right to promise to toan an any man An And If Je it can be he proved that ho did l l make malee such a pledge o of or the tho United States op ot the theon on ollice ce of or governor to 10 Mr tIr h Salisbury then tho the man with Hh proof of or it should rise Ilse up and sI show oIt o If It he lie have not proof better than titan the tue solemn sla ments of or these two men who know all about It H then ho should not make malc that Surel Surely the dozen men in the confidence of or the ICa leaders of tho Republican party Jart arc are in better position than an any writer niter on the Tribune to know now what was done These men members of or the executive committee of or the thc party lartY men of oC standing stand ing In the state tate declare there thero was no pledge to their knowledge an and it could hardly havo have happened without their knowing A AND D THE TWO ME MEN IE WHO HO ALO ALONE 8 WOULD J KNOW NOW EVERY EVEny FACT IN IX THAT CONNECTION CONNECTION TIO TION ABSOLUTELY DENY THAT ANY SUCH TRADE DE OR ANY OTHER TRADE THADE WAS Y MADE It Tt has never nevel been the I policy C of or The Republican to deceive the people It is not nol now no We Yc say SOY plainly Ifan if an any man can prove provo that Senator Smoot ever el ma made e a promise to Mr 11 Salisbury either of or a n. or of oC the governorship we shall con condemn the senior senator from Utah in such plain terms as arc are at our comman command For ho he would woul be far ar exceeding his ri rights to do so Unless such lUch proof can be furnished however ho we wo aro arc going on the assumption that Mr h Salisbury tol told the truth and that Senator Smoot IS tolling telling the truth We e stated state earlier In this thi article that the Tribune and amI the tho Jrie men l who make maJo It H it proceeded ed on the tho theory that JC If thc they could mt o niao ke the Republican party o odious lous the they hall had a chanco chance to defeat lefeat it H. It has seemed clear to them that that they c can n gain most advantage lJ by pretending that the Republican party of Utah is a n. Mormon sideshow that It is wholly an and abjectly under the domination of or ortho the tho Mormon church that Senator Smoot Is a mighty 1 dictator against whoso whose wor word and whose will om there is 18 no free freedom om of oC action Whether or 01 not it will do 10 any Soo good we want to 10 toay s sa say ay this Is a falso false view Jew Senator Smoot does hoes 1 by no m means eans control the Republican party of at Utah Jle Ho Ie I Ian isn Is Isan a an n honored honore member of that party part and his coun counsel cl I Is I Ilp r lp regarded as Immensely valuable But DUl it Is Js a n. bad compliment com corn p to the many men inca of or Utah to cre credit it the S senior lIiOI s senator or any other man alive o with the thc pow power r of or dl dictator And n whether or not it will wili do o any goo good we want h hero here ere to disclaim the time control of oC the Republican part parly b by y tho the authorities of th the tho Mormon I church Let us be bc r re reasonable about this Suppose tho the Mormon ormon cl church I Iha h ha had u ad been In a a. position to command tho tim recent legislature legis legis- Ja la lature ture Dont Don't you OU think the they would have the W wor wording of that law Jaw which prohibits polygamy an and sa says sas ys never ne a word against bigamy Thero is a a. w which makes males ever every bigamist a n. polygamist There Thele Js Is no law against bigamy hero here An And every bigamy ca cao cac e es is s heralded b by the Tribune and its kind of or publication L La as m a case of new polygamy Dont Don't you suppose th the jf Mormon r church hurch would have corrected that If Ie It had he been e eri in control of or the legislature NOT OT A PROBABLE CASE Dont Don't you rou suppose the Mormon ormon church would have havo CO compelled the Iho enactment of oC the police an and fire bill if Jr itI i been In e control of ortho the l and the local L fl an party PC There was was' need neetI for that la In iii Inthe Jh i th the e interest of the tho people and friends of the Republican ca can n party parly wanted wante it passe passed The Tribune tells you ou tho the I M Mormons are demanding the tho head of or George Sheets Sheet I Iare are are In a conspiracy to crush him n. If they had been an anth and d ha had controlled the this legi legislature dont don't you OU suppose they th ey would have forced the enactment of or that law lav I You are arc a against Mormon lormon church domination or or orthe th thic the e domination of an any other church So is The Icon ic iche an But neither tho the Mormon Jormon nor nOlO an any other church I Is he ha has s ever c attempted domination in this office nor nOl has Iia i Sc Se Senator Smoot nor ha has an any any other man or organization T The he n Republican has been heen absolutely free free and and we do de donot o olot I n not lot ot believe another paper In the city can as truthfully ly a y as much I You are against Mormon church domination but buto d tIo o you believe th the Mormon ormo church ma made e a tra trade o with wiLt I P resident Roosevelt cIl Do you l l that ir m nan man an that ever fronted the people abased himself an and I b ought the support of or state stale or states slates by dishonor Now we speak r of cf these things at some length be because because be- be c cause ause we wo want to appeal to the sober sobel reason of or the tin p people eople of Salt Lake an and of Utah The fhe Tribune is lea lead lead- Ing I ng man many of or you rou wrong It is not telling you the truth I It t is asserting man many things which it believes will discredit dis dI- ls- ls c credit the Republican party part In your eyes because of or your y our known hostility to a a. m man n or a a. religious t L tion ion in this en endeavor It ft does docs not decline to Ima invade e the s sanctity of or the death chamber nor the hallowed circle c o of ot f the thu grave TI THEY EY ARE AnE WORKING THE rilE BUGABOO Gentlemen it is unfair to you ou It Is untruthful And 1 HI its whole case is made of or ma o just such materials There Thero is no basis for them There is no truth In them You have reason Use it Get the facts an and be bo content content content con con- tent with nothing nothing- less Jess Be SUl guided etI by them when ob ob- ob- ob tamed And n nou you ou will realize realise that the policy polie of oC the I iu Is founded out on wrong that its charges are known n to lo bo be untrue by the men who write them It has beguiled you OU Into the ghastly mistake of oC a city election It has sought to drag down own the time public I schools of ot Salt Lake to tho time base uses or a partisan cabal It has denounced your our President ent as a n. trader in the spoils of politics a as a a. barterer barter r with traitors as a n dc tle- do- do fender of or perjurers And AntI throughout the whole courso course of or that continued slander er there has been no warrant of truth for tor its Its- utterance Get the truth Be lle gui guided by It Let time Iho infamous article of oC Limo Iho Tribune o last Jast Monday Monda morning defaming the the character of the late O. O J. J Salisbury illustrate to you ou the tho whole course of the Tribune Tl Unfounded un un- foun founded e assertion c calumny lumny brutal a assassination of or tho the characters of men living ln and mia Hen fiendish dIsh assaults on on their good g name when th they are arc gone bone You dont don't want to follow Collow that lea lead C CI I |