Show DAY OF ALIENISTS AT SANITY UNITY INQUEST Experts Tell Commission of ol Harry Thaws Thaw's Mental S State in Past I DR HAMILTON ON GRILL GRilli I Attorney Hartridge Forces Admissions Admissions Ad Ad- Ad- Ad missions From Family Physician 11 I II fior Nov Ne York April Z H. by an any chance J. J jj tice was lurking about the criminal 1 of oC the court toda today she site must have tinie hid her face and anel wept ni at th tho tiis follies which were committed cO hiher hi in her name Tho The apotheosis of oC export testimony In hideous exhibition w achieved c a of the tho workings 5 of the lie Judicial machine opinions welo vere turned top topsy tUI and facts flew out of uC tho the win win- dows lows The The- witnesses le the pro prosecution who sho swore Imore nt at the trial of oe Thaw that he wa- wa 01 sane still tJI attested their belief in hi hl Isis legal sanity while hila convinced con that he lie was as medically Insane Swearing al alo aio o toda today that thal Thaw Tim was as a I sane Salle within tile the meaning of oC the low law when hen he shot hot and that list his condition has not nol changed change since then lien the he same nJ exert experts told the lie commissioners com corn missioners in Iun lunacy e that thal his mental condition Is sue that he lie Is unable to appreciate lit his present condition or to toI ton n advIse advice I c rationally ral with his coun counsel el a ato as asto asto to his defense c. c There l I N no parallel for this travesty of justice ju In the tho history of our criminal criminal crimi crimi- nal Jurisprudence l I It t So o the lie nacy I commissioners commissioners- lo arc are no iso further advanced nd d so far as 18 expert testimony Its tes sony Is lt concerned titan than thy were iverc when i Ih they hey b began n unless It be In the matter of having hl a a. clear idea of the value aluc of all expert testimony The day lar hc began an with the calling of oL Dr Trank A A. A the lie Tombs prison pus pils- on an physician the thc gist of or whose testimony testimony mon mony that he had never ne heard or oraw Oraw aw saw Thaw sa say or do uny anything thing that was ivas Irrational Mrs ts Emily 1 So S. Walker a pr probation of- of fleer of general l sessions e who Is a a. constant constant con con- stant slant visitor to the lie Tombs prison gave O similar testimony Rev flex John Arm- Arm Armstrong strong tronC Wude chaplain In the Tombs Tomb never cr saw or heard anything In n hl his frequent i visits its to 10 Thaw that suggested Irrationality and Rev ne Luke J. J I. I levers ers who ho conducts th the Roman Homan Catholic In the city prison tes- tes tiled lined to like effect Dr DI Allan lIan inc Mcl-inc Hamilton was the the-n lieu returned to 10 the witness chair and antI af- af cr er a a. brisk argument between Jerome and ind tho ho doctor was permitted permit permit- ted cd to testify This alienist was the to fall fill beneath tho the storm that aged i-aged for oh all alienists today The com coin rs held Jerome Jeromo so 90 to o othe the he line and struck o out edt t so 50 har hard tard on cross that the whole force of or the testimony of ton lon on was broken Aud Auel what whal Jc did to Hamilton was kas this Ho ito forced him to 10 admit that he le consulted with the lie superintendent ent of oe f with r regard sard to Thaw and nd th that hut t retained b by the defense he lie had iud freely frech discussed the tue case cose with the thO dIstrIct attorney trying trying- to Induce the latter to send Thaw to the lie asylum l Ct ToJ Together When the tho afternoon session was he- he gun un the i i al al farce Caree was 14 inaugurated Dr DI r. r Austin PUnt Flint the lie venerable genial faC ll alienist of oC the Jerome fleet kas wal put on tho lie stan stand From orom Its Ils nature Use io testimony of all the lie e experts shed hed light on the ti-se present Plesent condition of Tiia Thaw haw iv Dr ics F r. the Thaw III fatally physician was wa then lieu recalled Dr r. r told old r f tho the insanity In the collateral branches of or the lie Thaw family but tut a added that he lie hall hail cr nc seen an anythIng any any- thIng hing Irrational In the mann mahin mating of the defendant n t. t Dr M. M 1 l. l Hammond swore t that list thatto ho he to believed cd Thaw to be he sane sasie now not Our OUI ild old friend Del Delmas mas tool took tho ho st stand and asid swore that the lie memorandum Thaw Thai had ha I cut ads him containing suggestions for his lila up si was ute so u good that ho he purpose purposes pur- pur poses pose to make use of some of the lie sug- sug c Drs Dra Dr and cud Eans uns followed Del Del- nag Both ha have havo ca Thaw withIn with with- In iii n the fj past few days The They found him lane sane The Tue commission will IU hear a few wit wit- witnesses nesses ulesSeS tomorrow and then will ro So Into executive session Their lc- lc c elisIon will be he read ready reads for Justice Fitz gerald cc Thursday morning |