Show TOMBS PHYSICIAN SAYS THAW THAI IS SANE Dr Frank P. P McGuire Has Watched Prisoner Closely I Since Killing KNEW RIGHT FROM WRONG Millionaire Sc Scrutiny hmo G I G to o Bt lie ny hy Jerome New e York Feb 17 Dr Frank Frink P. P McGuire the Tombs p prison l on physician will JO called by hy District Attorney ne Jerome as ono of the chief C ses for tor the state state In t tho o Thaw trial The prosecutor expects Dr Dl McGuire's McGuires Mc- Mc Guire's Guires testimony tt lay 10 thc th foundation f uJ atlon a- a tion for the alienists that that TIm Thaw TIma was a aRnn sane on 01 tho night of or June wh when 11 ho killed Stanford i Dr McGuire has hns repeatedly been called rolle as an expert In homicide trials and he has exhibited orl original m methods In ren reaching conclusions lons as asto to th sanity san ity Hy of or defendants He will n called call call- ed ell ns an expert in this ca case r hut merely mere mere mere- lv ly a as a general Th Tombs physician is of tho that when he killed White know w tho- tho quality of ot the act and knew th the distinction 1 between right mill wrong but hi his value to tho state late as asa n a witness lie in the long observation hs 1 ne has hasha ha had l of oC Thaw ani and tho data he has has' given n th the district attorney which will willbo willbo bo recorded in the tho In his hl t o dence Flint McDonald and Mabin Mahin the tho representing tho dl district attorneys attorney's cf have been Iwen prohibited nom from making n Jm personal examination of Thaw They have ha how however vr been able to see sel tho prisoner through ough the sharp eyes S and ami acuto IH hearing of ir D Dr 1 It is said are In a good position to pass lOSS upon ullon his mental montal mon men tal tate state lIne Sc Seen n Tho Many rau Times D During the tho eight months that thal Thaw lias 1139 been in tho- tho Tombs Tombs- McGuire has hn seen een him more thou than one th thousand u limes always with a view of mak Ing an ob observation tr of hl his mental stale The physician has hns kept a ful record of Thaws Thaw appearance words actions nC and antt m moods ds and is II prepared lo ro overy days day's details since June Dr McGuire has has has' watched Thaw in Ills his dally niJ chats with his mother and wife anil his other relatives and his lawyers arid It K 15 said will t testify to toa a domineering spirit ci oh the tho part of the prisoner as Lis shown hown by his w words and acts an and a d determination to have his own wa way While treating Thaw Tha for tor Various arlous slight ailments the doctor has had long talks talk with him and Is prepared rell to st state t that ho ho spoke intelligently and i 10 logically upon every Cr topic and anO gave ga no suggestion of or a n. confusion of or Ideas or Idea Jelen of or Ow I Importance Dr McGuire's McGuires observations p particularly emphasise c Thaws Thaw's idea ida of of hi hl own importance and his inclination to look down upon ev even n his own at attorneys attorneys at- at at times but Jo tho Tombs physician this thi exhibition was Inthe Ir In the nature of d ego referred to by In Mr Evans He lIe looks upon It as rather a demon demonstration otan ot of an nn overpowering o self conceit which had never ne been hampered b by environ environ- ment During the hours of night while Thaw has been asleep asleep- Dr Dl McGuire has ha watched watch ll him from the cd door The sleep of the prisoner oner was as ns quiet quid as us that o a n w well fed JIe healthy child the llo doctor tor will tc testify He nc never er hail an any n nightmares op or disturbances es of oC sleep such as are noticed In wen well l de defined fined ca cases es of or In insanity According to the T of these observation Th Thaws Thaw's w stomach and other vital organs wore were when he t first enl entered r ir tho To Tombs Dr McGuire f- f t f-c-t t l.- l. cloRo watch nt h on Ute the nils' nils oner Gner for symptoms suggesting n. n habit of any sor sort hut but he dill did not find the change in ICe and fill en environment ot oC productive e an any physical Th Thaw w has hns al always I ways had a. a a good appetite and tl haf gained about fifteen poun pounds s since his Imprisonment ne I S ii o or f T Temper mr The doctor fi has R- R Rr r recorded several il s se severe vere outbursts tg Of e temper from trifling cau causes caus s 's but all prisoners give l lol to lo l their f feelings lIng at times in th the Tombs I when hen brooding over U their position The he lIlar diary of f Dr DI covers er a wide range of topics anil much of or it Itt t t is 15 said al Is IR competent nt t evidence anil amI willbo will iII 1 bo 0 In the tho trial The picture n as outlined in that diary I Is that of a man with witha a a. brain the normal In strength an nn active but unstable reasoning process an ung un- un g temper an Inclination to suspicion a nature t mc mt by y selfish selfishness ness In his actions and desires and u facility not sound s und but not ot sufficiently un ol to be ho unable unable- to distinguish right t from Crom wrong |