Show DOWNfALL Of MEDICAL EXPERT S i J r i DELMAS RULES IN IDA W TRIAL k If At i i i Reorganization of Attorneys for br i Defense Follows VI f Victory T of Jerome f- f t 1 i. i 1 t. t NEW COURSE IS ADOPTED IL h 1 fit r 4 Placing of or Wiley lIc on Oil r i t Stun Stand tz Was ns Error Error on t t t j f May laJ Lea Ian c. c S 9 A 1 fl Hy BJ William rIoter Hotter l' l New e YOlI York pcb cb r Ci rA E-rA pA A crisis was wasS I l tonight in S the Thaw case passed cd and with renewed ll vigor the 8 i o vl o bark on Oil I yf what hal It believes cs to w be lIe the straight KL j road to acquittal t c af r lit Iii consequence of i l arose e between 9 k n n counsel for the tho r 1 accused sing 0 for fOl a aS S A Willie th i withdrawal of all nil th the aLi ali al- al i I l fv k i torney except Mr 11 G on Gleas-on a leason-a a In long Jt S TJ Vt was wa as hell held Immediately after atei J the adjournment this afternoon at F which the conflicting elements element 1 1 f fought out theli theil ill Li As a result IC Michael Michael DelS Delilla Del Del- S r mas illa will vIlI tomorrow row a. a assume ump absolute absoluteS S 4 charge of oC the cm case casc with Daniel r O OReilly as his active assistant arid and S Gle a n ge anti and Peabody Pea Pea- j S. S bo body acting in iii an I ad advisory OlY pla j 5 v Deli Delmas un and OReilly will conduct conductS conduct'S S 'S t all th the examinations examination alternately and arid S M the former 1 will rill ha have the tIle final decision de de- I o. o lon In Ill all points that may arise S 1 it Conference a Storm Oll One S. S Tho flie conference Is saul said to have haic h b begun be- be gun gull gun In a storm stormy manner and ancl to tu have o continued with VitI c considerable S until at length harmony wa was vas restored upon the above e basis dictated II mainly h hy by the common Interest which all of ot S the tire attorn attorneys rR hail had In lu securing tile the acquittal of th the lie client In whose whoso InterS Interest Interest Inter Inter- S est cst the they 11 art art- working a u did de defense on It to go O b before foro till the jur Jury It was b believed J as us a result of toda today's proceedings that hat the prevalent S dissension put the Ull ocd accused nan man ingrave in Iii grave gla danger of If conviction through m mismanagement nana e of or hl his ca case me lie conference rEnI wa was as arranged ni before be- be fore adjournment was waN taken and liIl In Inv j v Jv consequence of ot n a definite decision L to reached d lJ by n zi majority o of at- at lorl T Lul r Cha r lIe lIer iL r ro Y II t S lU no iroy whoso whose cars tim I tories stories bad 4 I reached ht wax was IH prepared p in lii the event of or such Uch action being n tulun to move C that n a Juror b withdrawn from tire the box S r thus thUM bringing about a mistrial ry I rha rh conference rok tit ip 1 about u uV i V o'clock lock tonight I u Make Make- Statement Ff i 4 The w result u of the cot conference became be be- 1 came known 11 tonight when Mr HartI hartridge Hart- Hart I ridge K made mad this to your yur Dolphin Michael tI Delmas has assumed as as- sUt absolute lt lIh CI control of if this ease casi S a as senior counsel for fot the he defense Mr dr S Gleason will wiH probably b be In court III In Inthe the morning out JUt ut Mr Delmas and OReilly will conduct the direct tHreet ox ox- S of witnesses for or the defense They will also conduct the Lie cross examInation examination exam exam- of oC witnesses for the 5 lion Ion In rebuttal t S There is II no nn truth In the report S that Delmas will retire leUre There Is no friction between us I engaged Mr 5 5 Delmas I dl did 1 not rot employ air rr Gleat Glea- Glea t II Ho lIo was as engaged l hy y Harry Hany Kendall Ken Ien- dall dali Thaw directly I am nm both counsel ntH and personal friend of or I larry Harry Thaw but hut In my advice ad and desires t have not notS S always been observed cI by m my ray client Pa oJ Commission Jerome lias t q always been beell n In lit favor Cavor of or a commit Ion III in luna lunacy C to pass on the mental state of Thaw and If it there ther Is the slightest hint on our the Ule part of or any of the experts of the he defense e that S Thaw Is crazy the appointment of oC aS a commission will be bf moved mo It may maybe S hour houf A delicate be appointed an any 5 suggestion to the trial Justice might q bring It about At all events tnt there thereS S S wre ie hints of combination about the district attorneys attorney's today I s As to tire tin results result of or the day i it was tae tiu t day of th the actual presentation of ot the tho lit case of oC the deCon de- de Con e It 11 was a distinct triumph for fur the prosecution o lh The defence sought to prove through Dr Charles Chase Chal Wiley I Pt bUrg alienist that Thaw was waa In InI Insane In- In sane c and held expert rt opinion that I S th prisoner was wa unsound of or mind at atS atthe S the of tile the commission llon of or the thc crime and gave e Instances of previous S Irrational conduct on the tho l part of S Thaw but bul after r n a live l hours hour cross cross- 1 f l examination l by Jeromo Jerome he ho became for Cot the defense useless as a witness de developed In Dr DI Wll Wiley Iley y the ther r S. S astounding lack hick of knowledge of the ilio ordinary If tests of Insanity com coin j 4 1 polled polle him to acknowledge errors In f S mental antI and physical science drew Sum from frum him hint admissions of luck of In Info Information In- In S. S fo formation at lo n about the J matteis rs to which h un hH was vas te testifying and 11 finally na II compiled com coin there theme was that hut piled him to Il admit of Thaw on the HIP hi- hi lii In n the o hi of the of ot Stanford night It would argue a lun condition While that S of or irrationality ut lit rcy Mi-rcy of Jerome S tu to I Js Dr Wile WIleY fact factS Cf I tire S lion however l by hurled upon th the WJ was that h ire ire- S to chance hull had a a. ln ha stand lf himself or to talk tull lt 5 S e cn a Y In artY L h S I upon upun th me the meus CS' CS us foundation having ben been S without any uny he Ito was as arid and testimony S laid for his hypoS hypo hypo- to lo a v. Answer answer to 10 mal make o S compelled which was 1 S question ever put of tho acts I S S ono rise to an all expert n. n S. S in In n shoot S of or the 1 J to limit a ns as a SUi sup Gardt ll were flint 0 waN wai S 5 O. O upon ru I 5 whether hether OJ nol a asked lkc to par mK ne ot S safe l a m CS S S S t thus his beSt t S lIe Ih did e eS crazy might r l WU y Dr FinallY nes ne's Oil d the Oc orEl o with credit had I S anti cI come off fn tim tho th la l 5 5 ll I him i m Lu o leavo IYo disS db- db on Y Glea Gleason when ll U of oC the JI st t ut ht the e end d him him S S S S 1 S S cross Hut But hal one little Ith to put on un n 11 lI t anti and I that hia opened t the lIe Hood lood sail gates After A e I that Dr lr Ulley Viley sa at t I I and nOlI writhed d f f three hours ami IK lit will probably back to the expert rt opinion that we wt m. m are a most mos t I Inhospitable people down n he here licie n ii in ill w Nc w York 1011 All Cly tolla today there were ln rumors In iii the court room as ns to a n split among coun counsel cl for Of Thaw After Afler the conclusion lor of the proceedings In which the case Wa l subjected to open ridicule ridi cub cule cuJe In lh th the trial chamber an export J for rw the thu defense being turned wInNI Into a strong for 01 tho the prosecution two other witnesses e being stood aside because because be h.- cause counsel wa was not nol equipped to argUe nr- nr ar- ar gUe gUl points In dispute PUh the vital testimony tes tes- concerning Jn insanity In ti the thc Thaw family being being- ruled out until counsel could submit rEn reason OIl for It IL being admitted In evidence uno one one member ol of th the 1 defendants defendant's counsel declared de tip- himself lf in tnt open lv revolt It another rr himself in strong language lang as to tho tire maladroit conduct of th the proceedings and amid th the statement Int m nt was vas mull made that tomorrow might aught witness q time the of If nil all of Thaws Thaw's counsel except Mr Mm G Glea Gleason on ii Stands lone Alone Mr Gleason Indeed seemed scented to be Lf bethe time the only member I of ot Thaws Thaw's counsel who was ns satisfied with matters n as the they stood Delmas Oneill O'neill OReilly Hartridge Hart- Hart ridge lidge Peabody and t. declined to discuss the alleged disagreement but two to incidents of If the Itt trial today Illustrate how lion wide apart coun counsel 1 nr are aie areat at this crucial period of the time defense It wa was vaa j the the- understanding when court convened on omi M Monday t that haL l f Mr f Delmas Delma was to assume charge of the the case an and l he lie did so so conducting I the hi cros examination cross of the states state's wit wit- n nesses nessen When the first witness was tas S called for fOl the defense this iris morning however Mr Gleason took him In In hand for examination Harry Thaw having ha been so o well troll pleased f d with Gleasons Gleason's op opening address that ho passed over 1 the time conduct of tilt the case Cas caseto to lo him Half Halt an hour later l arrived d He lie appeared appealed surprised pd to see Mr Gleason conducting conducting- the II iii examina tion and as fiS he took his seat eaL b beside Delmas DelmaR 1 he to him Time TIll Witness Dr nl ot Pittsburg was tas In clue tho throes s of a cross lion tiomi hy hv Jerome that t 1 r ill Pm i h i is l alue value to to time the defense e. e I What doe doe- W was vas heard lo to n ask k D DAli D. iJ Ali t NI 1 jJ L r-j-i r j enn fl part O Oh h i li I r k u t fait a r e Il mi to hk k nimy part In iii the tho proceedings pro pro- bv ty till the Thaw Iman ta table le t today ll y but lIt Mr II GI Gleason a Half of or the thc time line Hartridge Start Hart ridge aunt and OReilly were vere out In time the an- an te I Peabody P sat Fat aunt anil chatted with Thaw gaii 0 about dout the co court courtroom rt room and am an nn expression lon u of extreme ennui et Oh on his rac face sat at with folded arms and ane half closed e eyes gazing gaz tug lug Into All this while Jerome Jerom was scoring a notable triumph and on onDie HI tire Die eve tV of what will be lw Limo tho most Im Important mm- Im- day of or the th trial for fur it IL was wa sal said tonight ht that thai Mrs Mm's Florence Evelyn Thaw will wilt lal lake ala time till stand to tomorrow to- to morrow v anti and tell the story tory on which the defendant bases his imis hope of f f ac nC- elMi 12 Thaw rc I lies Toda She dragged herself through the snow tn today ay to be he on hand if Ie wanted wanted- She Rhe has st steeled h herself for fOI time the o 11 an and has ham announced to her friends that thai she will neglect no d detail tall o of the story tolY wl which as aR Gleason ason told the Uw jury jUr In the thi opening n address dc narrated to Thaw haw bythe by br bythe th the beautiful woman fanned into mitt action action ac ac- tion lion the Insane fury which drove him I to lo take the time life of Stanford White Amid the Site l' l eddy dy and whirl of conflicting con con- rumors 10 today there came caine con I another another an an- other othel which If It ii takes on the form of oC definite fact may bring the trial to a a. speedy end Jerome today tollay went for the record in the Terranova case cae That hints at a commission in lunac lunacy to decide on the sanity of Thaw The pleaS pica Ica of hereditary Insanity has opened a new now avenue to the district attorney If hr Thaw inherited insanity from from his ancestors ancestor's he Is IR Insane now fht There l' l i. i la is Coot Continued I tl on nm o H. H PAST j DELMAS EMAs LEADS DEFENSE Continued from 1101 page 1 n. n direct command In In the law Jaw that r 0 d district attorney cannot try an In man for tor his life Through Dr tX Charles F. F of ot Pittsburg thin the second witness winess' winess to f for forthe o othe the defense e and the famous physicIan for the Thaws Thaw it was proven that tha from hl his yo youth th Thaw was wa of or a highly high hihi ly 13 I nervous nervous temperament and erratic and that bo lie had on one treat el Il I oung young Thaw Thaw for St. St Vitus dance Object Ion Stops WJ ness Gleason Genson called Benjamin Boman Doman o oC Brool Brooklyn I n to testify to a n conversation converston lit lit- had with wih Thaw haw ThaIn In 1 1904 another another effort efort to show Thaws Thaw's erratic ways ways- a but Jerome objected to tho the evidence c cand I asked aske Gleason Glenson an and Ju Justice tco Fitzgerald for tor his r n reasons ons for offering the t st- st mony The ThC tatter latter waH was compelled to tc admit tiia that thai he lie hod haal not the record o ohis or oJ his authorities with him Im rind and the witness witS wit wl- wl ness nes was wa set aside asie until the tho defense has convinced tho the court ourt of or the thc n ad- ad or of the testimony Somewhat upset by these rebuffs Gleason called Alfred Arel Lee Thaw of ot Richmond Va Ya to the stand stan Mr Ir Thaws Thaw's father rathe was a n cousin to the father of oC Harry larn Thaw and amI a most Important Important Im Im- Im- Im witness for the tho defense c in that lie hi was called caled to prove that his father died in 11 an insane asylum thus thu establishing one of or the links in the chain of hec hereditary lalY Insanity Gleason Glenson got as far with the hc witness as to ask him him to lo state tho the circum circumstances stances of or his fathers father's 11 death nth when hen Jerome Interposed his objections He lie sl said Il that to prove IHO C UH t the the- tw cousin of oft t the I father of the lie lw prisoner was vas wa insane wn too tuo far fetched fetchel To ifo In find on absolutely common stock In ancestry str said sill he lie the tracing trac trae- tracIng ing would have to- to to togo go back hack to great- great glnn grandparents Four distinct stocks have entered since tho tue absolutely common common cornmon com corn mon stoc stock and amI Insanity may have havo entered with wih any of the other oilier stock Tho The court seemed to understand perfectly this tills little talk taIl on genealogy hut but apparently no nu one else tilt did l Comes Conies Ra Bat Ic to l Again n But t further said Jerome getting to Ic level l again the tho fact act that the man mal died Iel In an nit insane asylum is ss no Jogil logical logi Jogi- cal l evl evidence that he lIe was insane S Gleason answered on this point hut at the height or of his Ills argument argument ment uncut he was waR compelled to Admit once onN that ho lie had bc been n talc taken n unawares On account of or the sal said he h I 1 have hae not Jot the memorandum dum I meant to have hae here toda today So tho the court stood the witness aside e also ilso until Mr lr Gleason has ha of offo d t convincing pi proC of or the relevancy rele of the testimony This is oner on ono of ot the most ost important points of oC the case ense With John T. T Deemar of or Pittsburg one ane family physician of or the Thaws haws Mr Mi Gleason made a n little littlemore more nore headway Dr 01 Deemar testified d bat ihal he lie ha had treated Thaw haw for Cor a n nervous nerv- nerv ous us ws complaint What was the condition of or the tho defendant de tie- en ant asked Gleason He was of an unusual tempera tempera- ment n en t. t Continuing Gleason drew from Dr Deemar statements that Henry W. W U Copley Cople a brother of Mrs William haw Thaw and John no Ross floss son of Margaret Copley opley Ross a sister of Mrs William haw were weak minded ee Jerome allowed the statement with regard lo to Henry Copley Cople to go In but hut hute butI buthe h he e objected to testimony as the c n- n of oC John Ross floss Ilos on the thc sam rounds grounds s. s that he lie a asked for fOl the ox- ox ex exclusion x- x lusion |