Show GIRL IS TRIED TillED FOR I Alice Roach Tells of Encounter Assyrian h p Peeler lef STORIES ARE AT VARIANCE Victim of 01 the Affair A Gins Ills YlI ion of Shooting for the Fh First Fht t Time i m Bingham Dec 19 rime Tho case pf pC Alice Roach the thc lC- lC old IG old u girl gill who shot an Assyrian named Tony n Anon Ann Annat at the time home of her sister Mrs Charles s near neat Highland Boy on the of of last Octo October ci- ci and amid who wag was vaS chal charged with ai as assault sault to commit mur- mur tier iler came callie up UI for fOI hearing before Ju Judge ge E. E Lee Lec thIs hm at O o'clock and continued until 7 i o'clock this tiLls evening e Assistant Couii- Couii t ly ty Attorney n cond conducting t tho anti and Atto ne ney 11 II J. J Rob fob I IThe n the tile defense efen c The court held hell Miss lIfs Roach In GOO bOnds s to tu await the thc action of the Dlf- Dlf Dir Dir- court The Time peddler lel after aftel a long bug oll s. s recovered sull sufficiently to appear as is the tIme prosecuting at the hear hear- jug ng His Ills testimony that thal he lie went Vent to tn the tue Gibson home houtie on oil the evening e cn even even- In log ing of or Oct 21 with two valises mIll showed his huis goods to lo Mrs Mis Gibson auld Miss lili Roach Hoach that Mrs l Gibson pur purchased put put- chased a table cloth u to pity pay 4 for fOI It Il claiming that lint site she would the thc money that evening and pay fOI for It th the next morning Ho lie went vent batik badi the tue next morning without his valises at about 9 i o'clock and rapped on Out the thedoor thedoor door doot several tinier times without getting a response said al the peddler J the women opened the thc door 1001 a 8 little w way vay n anti and asked what wiant I wanted I told themI thorn them I wanted the thc table cloth or the tue 1 1 They told mid mo the they didn't have any ony table mule cloth I told them I would go to and get an nn o They said i You get out anti and each pointed a revolver at me inc up lIlI both my hands and stalled down lOWn the hill hili When I w wis ws s swithin within twenty H ct of oC the road two shot shots W. W wM-o wM One Otto wont through my ray coat and the lie other sit sti tic tuck tick me ne In iii Inthe the lie hack back anti and I fell I don't dont how khow which w on one fired the tiLe shill rc of or the Girl Alice Hoa Roach h testified that lint on the thc e evening of or the Hh the peddler came caine cameto to th time the house and amid tried to sell her mal and malher her sister some soie skirts and other dry goods that tile the they told him they lucy to buy uy an anything thing Then the filow fellow fellow fel fel- fi- fi low became angry angl and pulled a no Ion long longknife longknife knife which lie he brandished in a threatening threatening threatening threat threat- ening manner manlier I saying raying Me le kill you ou if ir you ou dont don't bu buy Shot Shor ti th after he lie packed his valises vallEe's an and went away awty The rhe next morning about 9 h o'clock he lie re re returned lun turned cd and pushed open the tho rear door without knocking saying You stole tolo In my valises I want them at the s tame sume ine tIne time going toward towal lie bedroom Mrs Gibson was standing there near the wash washtub tub lie He rudely seized her an and I brutally hei her lo Hf tn to ono J MOc tn pg l Mh ilie got t Into tho the bedroom first and ana secured a caliber as-caliber Colts Coils revolver while her sister seized a 82 Colts Colt's from a u washstand to her left Oft Mrs lr Gibson on discharged re hers to frighten fright fright- en the peddler ler then she sho ran to the lie next house for help but bitt finding no noone noone noone one at home honie she sIte immediately re re- re turned Miss lIss teach Roach said al she he then I fired le a shot hot 0 ocr cr his hea head l. l He lie then left the house When part way down the hill he turned turl I OIl 1 thou thought ht he was about to renew the thc attack sal said Mits li s Roach and amid I mC fired We Vc thought ho he was going oln to tokiJI kill kiJI us bister Tell Sonic Story Mrs 1 Charles Gibson told the lie same sallie story claiming that tho the peddler acted a u very ery brutal manner manner- Dr DI F F. E. E testified that hint the ball hall struck the peddler a a. little to the time left of the middle mid mid- die dle Ic of or lie Iho back hack deflected a u. few ew Inches ti lo to the tho left and then ranged downward at an all angle o of about 30 de degrees rees The fhe stories of the peddler and Miss 1 Roach floach nn and her sister are much at variance There were vere no nu other oilier eyewitnesses to the time shooting |