Show Luke antI Vindicated JutI Judgment ment in favor of ot Ju Justice Charles Durand of ut Murray and James A. A Luke of ot this city In ono one of the called so-called Luke cases was given yesterday yesterday yes- yes erday in Iu the thc civil cl division of oC the city court by J Judge J J. J J J. J Whitaker In iii the case wherein William Hobbs Hobb was plaintiff and In lit which he sued the lie de- for fOl damages In the sum um 0 ol of 10 alleging fraud and collusion This suit was as commenced July 23 3 1906 Jud Judgement ement was yesterday awarded In n the tho district court to Charles Durand Durand Durand Dur Dur- and and Bros in lit the thecae defendants defendants defend defend- made case cae wherein they are ants In a suit stilt brought by hy Paul Engler Ensler Eng Eng- ler cr In one of ot the so-called so Luke Lulee cases in which fraud and unlawful collusion of ot Ju Justice Durand and aull tho the Merchants Merchant association were alleged Ills His suit was for damages Inthe in he the sum of ot and amid asked that a JUdgment rendered a against him In the Murray Y court be set aside and antI l' l ed d void setting forth foith as his reasons this his alleged fraud and amid collusion by means of ot which he charged charge tho the Judgment Judg judg- ment mont had been secured The case cn c was vas yesterday dismissed ed by tho time court and ind costs taxed to the plaintiffs I |