Show - - - - 40 10now — ' i ' i - i i - i -- 1 I — 't a - - - - 1 Lindbergh Detiirs'è Plan Contains Faulty Logic - 11 I ' - - 4 By Walter Lippmann - 's - Ibt r eir'power o 1 - - ' Rees e o ' ritv ' - :' - ng '' - - ! te- ' i - ' - 'Hi - - "" " : ' ' ' ' H ''- - - - - - !: I I: t ' t 1 k"!141 'W ri - -- - --- '4 : ' - - ' - - - : 2: - r - G - ' 4 " - 4-- 1 -i- - 9 1 - - : - - li : '' - -- - irI - A ' ' "1 T 4 4 6 -- tri it - - 7 - $ - ' - ' - - - i 1Ii'lc-- 121H I ''t - - : '4" : - one-oce- - ' i' - ''' ' essential'? - f '1 bPiafisi r 'i' i 14444 - t - r441"--T- - ' v441ri 4!) i r í ' -- 1 trvre'y i -- 00 1tp: ' 1 I 1L - f Jr- 44- 1 - - : 1 i - (qtk f 1 1 :-:- 298 at to 750 1 ! Millinery—Second Floor -- 'a4--'''- ' '''' ' i : - - ' e - ' - - - - ' - zi - - -- ' T 'z '' IIIT 95 1 - :: "- '''- I - - - 4 l - - -' - 1 - ' ' - -' 111 I Loi " - cruel T fIN A ' -i ' ' II t I el 1:--1‘ i014 c - 1- s‘ 1 - ":1 i - ! - - - 1 '' 1 P IP - i by 4 -- ' i N 1 I 1 ----- 0 ' 1 '' Li - - 49 !PIIIIIILO 1 - Lk 4 ''' :I - Vi N N 1 e - 01111r -- 7 - - 495 ' ‘ - - ' -- 1 : - 51 i t 14 la' : A - t 1 - 4 - - 3 1 i 1 4111111111--01111111- - 1 - i' -- 1 1 ' at" a - - : ? "good-enough-to-e- 1 it--f:q- 1 1-- -- ' ' 0 'p - - f t" ' - I - 4 ' 1 I - '' 1 4 d '''''' ' '- : - In-185- ' 1 ' 1 e 7rel b - il - - i' '"14: ' t i 1 - S ' l: - llittiliti tVeed9 ' - ' - - d Lip I G i ' - ' ' i 1 I p - ' ' i sizes A :: : The fact of the! matter is that - frlr 60 to ' 4 ' tia013 : :!' a ! the colonel who talks as if he y ‘ : k i had never studied sea power is A ' ' '-' 1 i -under the simple Illusion that !( I i i 1 ' CC70e --oceans are a 'defensive barrier I I ' now not are and never II They they 0 ' 11 have been either in the western 7 ' ' 13 hemisphere or anywhere else 11 1The western hemisphere has 'cl i often been threatened with invai -' invaded sion and several times 1 ) Napoleon Bonaparte threatened t:t N'''''''''''' za invasion in 1802 going so far as ll 11 ' to assemble an expeditionary It' '$ ‘' tL4 t: ' :6 t a ''''' 1 force ' he did not carry out the ' threat because the "negotiated" peace of Amiens did not last and 1' An the European war Wit renewed ' ti Vnteiesting i 1812 we were at war with' In 1r: new i ' 7:11S11 '''41frd ' f r E7':'-:In England and were invaded hetringbone t' '''' Featuring neW 1822 a European alliance threats 211 tweed '' ladveHtilln°:111-1111:11:'ije7-bnIE:rYma3g1-1-1Alsiasbpd ' ened to Invade and reconquer ' ' ' 4 ness iyo Pockets high :1(as elosings ' ' 'A P:7 t- and ' Latin America the project was i I ( the ritil' a ' ' ' skirt and abandoned because-Britai- n and l stibtle ' ' '' 4 newstalght- i A I yet in joint-anthe United States-wersoftness Wardrobe to ' " a new ' I parallel opposition pais!' you flatter and ' Illak'i '4: nrithopt! when Britain was temporarily ilr 1 I won't wantplease iit s '! 1 not on our side and the Civil War n "tad Imo to r 6 I be was Impending Napoleon III ' ' p l' IV' a French arrnyin Mexico ' 4 ‘ and placed his creature Maxime neer 4 ' on 1898 milian throne the In Says Mr Feree ' t ( - the feeble Spanish fleet crossed 1771zz4 Will Guard V S ' 0 the Atlantic caused a panic JjJ TP t"f"41FfL 1 it ''' 4 The colonel Is reasoning in a t along our coast and entered the " w "1 ' JP f a 'V ?A wcircle To prove that we need Caribbean sea before our navy I : vr -1 1:::) ill 1)"bi ' Ili: r i ' N 1 js):: 1-1In ' these not fear an axis control of the Look ii caught up with it ' C" c a — r t - 'i - P -: f‘ il'sseas against our Inferior navy s (ai : 12 ' - - - s I -i 3 4 OA't charming blouses that make every suit be tells us that air power willl 'Atlantic Declared 1 rri-sirx7 From Far Barrier 4) -make tzp the deficiency But he' skirt or pair of guilts a triumph in good I t Th—e Ocean is wide tut fai from ' : taste! Styled in fine quality fabrics t 7 t ) Its being a barrier to sea power : 1 1 SATURDAY ONLY sea It is the highway of in luscious new colors power I new cohirs New styles new noterials 'ttok 3" ' and It Thus the western hemisphere7 a ' I ' ' Arai' vsE new details it! make your first spring shoes since our own independence has SIZES 12 to 20 exciting kl:Inve 1 ' ' t ‘N ' I been invaded when as In 1812" 1 ' ' ' ' a joyous adventure! Styles to complement every f ' 1 i British sea power was against Oe A THREE STYLES SKETCHED: a w "'do' ' us and when as in 1859 the costume a and plc4e every eye (as well aS the I' Pao k our were on side not and British 44 !Three of many sketched': (It top) ' 'feet!) we were preoccupied elsewhere i1I ''''' Keotey Classic" r t I i F On when Britain other hand ' the ' 4 i' Puredye pure Silk crepe White pink ' and America have stood together II ii ' i q 1 beige --z —SA against Napoleon I as ---' 1 i - l'1' ' ': I s ' against the Holy Alliance as in "Do-Peep- " N' (center) : ' 1 :'EXPEIISIVE1 in 1898 when the kaiser ' i TOO! effect 4 1 itched to helpeSpain and was Allover embroidered eyelet batiste 1m a it ' S Have 'Old ' Shoes Made News ' ' ' ' I) ' strained ' by the British—the erd k : l '‘ I II ' ported Val lace trim White only ! threats against this hemisphere "' t 1 44 a do Well quiek thorough ‘ t 4 have been vain ' I ')Pint i t' i''' (at 'bottom) N ‘11alli Doll" I' t ' e4 inexpensive job on rebuilding ' What this victory prove: Is7 :' ' i ' ' 1 shoes It's worth your ! 1 your that the defense of the western !I 3 i Sheer rayon Bemberg georgette or Swiss I ii t 1 ' 1 I 'Sprint" -while to save Bring them in! hemisphere depends not upon ir'1 batiste Val lace trim and entre-deu-x t calf Tan sport pump bow at the width of 'the seas nor upon ' ' oi 116 White k only 11 ' : vamp Square toe the sea plus airplanes but upon pyramid is ''' V t' ' — heel sea power which commands the 14 oltrtit '' ' - 4 seas And fl43 one will ever Un:blV1111104 i KSeette Ithy'ese barodus°8thercretaelntioPnstingi:Jc:nr i 66Glow" derstand how the United States 1 Gabardine or black Moon '' has been defended in the past or 11111111611511 4 r SportosweaRr :Le0CtUSE—S"191 ' pumpblue ' A how it is to be defended in the open toe and cgtoAts at vamp CIS TO ' -- - I future if he does not grasp fully Medium heel the fundamental importance of AU7 9t ' ' ' sea power TIM PARIS CO ZS East Broadway Salt Lake City i driper Site me q'the following "Joan Ranier BLOUSES at 4 OSUSrl 2i9esaseeatseh:nd i -new Black with i low411 gabardine pump Copyright 1941 New York COLOR 17:77""1-CalSIZE I 'STYLI i1 Tribune Inc l I - - - ii J 11 - : - - ‘'v t-4- - ) - OTHER FLOWER HATS '' ' - 'I -- - - ' to: 4 A others 1 I ' 1m1-!- --- --- 4!h t -' '-'- - - ) - - 1i - -- - iln! 1 1 - -- 4 (i vs' - 1 an 'Il ) : at or navy -- ' ! i 4-- arVeils Intriguingly ranged 0 Adjustable head sizes ' '' 4'‘1 L ) -- 16 flower !- -' i 7-- -2 ir-3- L-- s: lilie roses clover valley violets ala and many '' ''''' 'i It I pastels Vihs fl5e49n ' 1 1 e 1 2' ' ' ' 4-1- -- Ilata In black l' 1 - ' t ok -- f- - - kyx4!1!t141 i 5 ng eye-catchi- : A i - N j i r! t'l ' A just 'flowers on your head—in the heart-liftmost fashions all of "PrettyAng prospects" fer springlthere's a flowerh at fqr everyorne!' N - tatifo i IP ' i t ' ' 9 "posie" lats that are fGay new' veiled excuSes to put n: 11' 1' '' c"-- 411- 1: '" — - sow' t 6 -- 4tilli- ' IT S' A - s 6kk- - - ::-- - ' k4 t ' "Flotver Shol' 0 1: 6' - - 1 6- tiN - - ' - t - ' i! 4- - Call 0 : - - - r! - - ' ' - - l r4 6 1 -- tey a i - ' - - IIIP- - '' ' - - 1 - - ' n s -- ' ' ' - ? ' ' - 11 $ : t ' ' I l' - :$ 1 - : 1 : - ' - - 1 1 I - Lie-- '' - SpRil--- Cl ' - I - ' - - - ' i4 - i - cal- :2 ' ' - ' - '' 'i - - - t I 1- 7 t - - - L"-L'‘' 6 On this error t ' breaks downfor if command of i i:i4t 0 J i the seas is necessary to hold the ' 1 't ') 1 bases for air pOwer then the col-- ''' 1 41'0 '1 ' lapse of British sea power ' ' not be a matter of indifference l ti - ' rt ' r it r to the United States When I z 4t 4 N Colonel Lindbergh has explained how he expects to hold his es' ' ' sential air bases overseas in ' '' en— will be South America he ' r ' care tiled to say that be does not i ' 4k '' : what happens tö t h British - c‘C ' Q0' f 11 I " fleet A I ' 41- It Is quite evident from Colo-'n- et 01111)7 1 ''' - ‘ i Lindbergh's testrrnony that he ' i ' i 1 ' 7- 0'-does not realize the role of sea: I 11101195- - ' ' 9 westpower in the history of the ' I ( t ent hemisphere or even in the t vt actual conduct of the present !A 't ' war (Thus he is able to see that ' ' 9' p " ' 9 even the German air force could "- -v t1'14'' I yll 'A'44 not strike at England until the friet German army had occupied nears ' 1 0'4 iv' - ' - 0 1 -- oi N by bases on the European coast "" ' Thie fact reassures him But he I - - tto 42— II ilf is too quickly reaxsured For if 11 el 79490k' ' t fc04 T i diz he looked at another theater of : SIEP- n—retTztr 41 '' '' war he would see that British ' - -r a ik ' 0- 1' - ‘ "1 sea power has carried the royal ASII10N )' 7S) ' ' air force to bases from which it ' 4 iv 14 c1 dominateis nothern Africa and the : 1)4 Ifin ' eastern Mediterranean Despite ' InnICS litz: 1 the German and Italian- navies I ''''''' " and air forces the British navy t ' has planted British air power issl)rritegilgAterrI6tiett - w'itio In a region which 2 X:---- ' A by ' ' I!' air and much furthee by sea 4 li e7vry f 61:Rolin'Sd ill from the 'British Isles than Is C i South America from Europe Ø: 1 i I 41 :II h' 4 ' ' :10 al I h3 - t Britain Offers ' itl it: ri :II '' ' : ( ! :! tI I Example of War rt ' 14) I toats i allw '' a c If Britahe fighting for her life and il ' yA v" Plaid H 'r ' e sin t: i 4 : and fighting alone can do what i:i sAtoli it' : she has done la the eastern r 4111 17 WeIVO eSi Si:itA17' : : iea1:17::suni:: ribto)cyt Mediterranean what could the itit I 41 ' ' ?' '''' German air force do If Hitler ttatreedioos ''' (4 4 4 lip were the undisputed master of ' t' 1 t''4A1' r 't l !1ev '''e Europe and on the sea supreme nla:-this t ‘t t ti t Iddeflaillisc"Isots° with his Japanese ally with his i I ' Italian ally with all the ships t4 ' ‘ ' trItribeinfeol: ' ' ' - 'AyP'4 ' and shipyards of Britain France ': i ' ' 1111 " cons Britain can and Europe? If I rt ' ' ' ' tie: trot the seas and dominate theair I: 7-ift06 le" i '' ' thousands of miles from London ly1 littele It 1 V juet how would the : i 1 IP at:igs 1t 1114e1):ItetielltIS:i1P navy of the United States 'hold 0 ' ' I 4 those South American air bases 'it 4f)115:4:1!ite!I77):me f '' ' which the colonel tells us are N 1 i r' I ' - r 14E4s - t ' ' - ' 1- :7" : - ' ':- 1 s - ' !'' ” : -- ! CO ' 4 t 1 'i ' ' ' - ' at zourCredit Desk) 7:: - - — s 1 -') ' - Zudget purchases - - -- ( 5 - tgake arrangements ' ' ---- -- ' 4 - I - -- at-Ja- ck - f — ' ' e sti70-' t le So—your head is get on a whole new Outtt l orettliv:aEyPurug crn outlitthat will prove you're smartly "on let 'your heart-band let The PCLTIS aid' your guide-71t'Thenttbet you! The:Parts Plan Budget ' givis you' five months to' pay for purchases of '$10 or more - an arrangement which means your "fashion future" happili and conviniently!' : '' ' ' '' brought Intl? the shilling rnowl ' ' for -- - - Task Simple The ellge'net Of the Lindbergh doctrine is that a hemisphere can ' be delendedagainat overseas from any combination of- powers by means of an inferior navy '' provided ther e is an air force with essential axes The oolonel insists that— or the de-fensivethe oceans even with an inferior fleet can by means ' of a reasonable al t force be made impregnable verything t else that the colonel had to say depends upon the truth or error : of this his basic argument The argument when it is ex- amined turns out to be an extraordinary example of false reaFor note that be tells soning us the air force (which is to make up for naval inferiority) can defend the hemisphere pro- vided we establish the basesci--' sential for defense" and these essential bases must be Watt "In'' lished observe carefully parts of South America" Now how does one go from the ' United States to these essential South Americanlbases in order to supply them and fortify them and operate them The colonel himseit though in another eon nection explaine how little in the way of supptlea can be transby air ported ' Now there are no overland ' connctions no railroads or motor '' highways from the United States ' to the South American continent on which we' must have be says these "essential" bases These essential bases can be supplied f thtTpfore only by aea—in time ofwar by transports convoyed by the navyY But if we do not have undisputed command of ' the seas how do we hold and' operate the South supply and American t bases which the - colonel relies upon to protect this hemisphere even after we haVe lost command of the seas? ' ''' a 4- -t" tye" gd I -- tap51e 7 ' 1 ty----- : De-leas- tr -- opeo001 P can-conside- - i A : 1 0 1) t P i' Lind-reasoni- - one-wh- ' tells us also that this air power Must have essential bases over-- seu in South America Yet these ' overseas bases cannot be sheld unless we have command of the seas In his attempt to argue that air power can make up for lack of sea power Colonel bergh proves the opposite that without sea powerit is Impossi- bases to have the essential ' I 'Although and conclusions have - opinionshad wide notice very little at-- : tention has been paid to the rea- sorting which sustains his views' ' on American defense 1Yet - his For ' lis: important 'Colonel- Lindbergh is the only serious critic of the policy of aid- - ' ing Britain who faces the issue hat' squarely: The only 'explained why and bovi he be- lieves the lwestern hemisphere eill be defended successfully by the United States alone' His Views on this crucial question are set forth in the pre- - It pared statement which he submitted to the house committee Ile bases his belief he tells us on twri facts: First that an Invading army and its supplies can-- not come by air but "must still be Itransportedlby sea"Jand see end that with 10000 thoroughly modern fighting planes and esbential 'bases from New Foundland and Alaska to South Amer icaraviation would make "it snore difficult than ever for It ' navy to approach a hostile shore"iColonel Lindbergh's task waii to answer the secretary of Tim who had pointed out that thel American fleet would be greatly inferior to the combined navies of the triple axis once the British and French fleets were lost The colonel's answer is that even with an inferior fleet the width of the ocean favors the American defense: add an air force to thordefense and there Is not any danger of an inva-- sion of this continent" Colonel-Lindbergh- P 1 s - - 1941 9 i --4 0 - I Felirtiary db e 6 e' ' ' t ' - - '- - THE : - ' e r - - 0- t I ' g t 13ases Need U S Navy Superior 't To' Foe Lippmatin Says- IM' i With Nair' 171tetory' possible ' - c gake rrillurte eSalt 1C '' - - - i Saturday blaming- - - ' 1 - ' ' - k- - r ' - - ' 's ' ' - ' ' ' 11- '- - 1 i ' a r ? - - t 1 1 - - ---- :' " ' 495 ' 4 ' - - ‘ t i ca:or remmt 11w1 talus list asboders dti t h i 1 $ ' Rear Admiral Gielo'rgjeaFIL was aide to former Secretary of the be reNavy Curtis D Wilburi-wi- ll tired on February 1 because of physical disability the navy announced Fridaz 0- ' - r I : N3elalVP)whi:11 East Broadway (Opp Paris Co) Pitat (4 Drs So TCMI) 412 IZI South Mai n (4 Drs So Sears) 43 i Will Retire Admiral 1 LOA FACTORY - - - --- - i 1 I I ! - ' - Irdi - ' ' - ' - 1 1 ' -- I ‘ 1 1 1 1 4 'All Shoes - r ' r Fitted X-Ri- ty I THE - A - STREEi ADDRESSI' R'-- : City CO ( -- 011toosttelo- rsup49041z44044 - 2 - - - A I- - I I P N ' S sits TA& STATE k t - - 1 3 add and I — ' 1 i 4 4 : ' 1 - - |