Show THE SALT LAKE TRIBUNE FRIDAY MORNING 20 Dr Browne Airs Views 0n S L Milk Dispute Help Planned For Stranded i Dr L A Browne ousted former chief of the Salt Lake City meat and food division of the board of health Thursday termed Mayor E B Erwin a “dictator” who Jiad insisted on issuing a permit to an unqualified milk dealer Speaking before the Salt Lake Lumbermen’s club at the chamber of commerce Dr Browne who presented his story of ths Salt Lake milk controversy re- lated the events that led up to his recent discharge by the mayor then asked the rhetorical question: “Why is our mayor so interested in a little dairy in Ogden to the Dr Hoivells Gives Public Clty-Ogd- — detriment of the health of Statement our own Says Mayor people?" Attempted Reviews Dispute to Avert Controversy Dr Browne explained the con of M E over With Ogflen the permit troversy Petersen president of Hie Para mount Dairy and Ice Cream ProdDr L A Howells city health ucts company of Ogden which was revoked explaining that hid re commissioner issued the followfusal to grant an arbitrary permit ing statement Thursday night in at the mayor’s command led to his explanation of the city health dedismissal partment’s stand in the Salt Lake “When I wag told to give him n milk dispute: to ‘or else’ tried I explain permit to his nibs why I couldn't I was “On January 14 Mayor Erwin Clty-Ogde- Unsuccessful “Mayor Erwin asked me why wouldn't cooperate why I barred Ogden milk why I couldn’t work to help keep relations between Og' den and Salt Lake City amicable I told him it would be breaking faith with industries here which have spent money to maintain milk stand- - - ards - - “ ‘You are too technical!’ the may- or told me 'Anyone would know that partitions dust catchers’” The - former in walls are health just officer re- ferred to a federal rule which for- bids the churning of butter In the same room in which milk is pasteurized with which the Paramount company had not complied he said Eastern Case Dr Browne related the story of the Montreal typhoid epidemic in which 600 persons died because of inadequate pasteurization equipment This old type equipment did not permit the foam to be brought to proper heat and left part of the milk untreated because of “dead ends” he said Foam heaters and valves were devised and Sait- - Lake City dairymen installed the new equipment at a cost of $200000 Dr leak-pro- Browne said “Yet Peterson has never seen fit to install these And he has had two years in which to do it” Dr Browne said further The milk industry of Sait Lake City is paying $14000 for inspection to insure good milk Dr Browne pointed out They did this because the city could not readily provide the money “How different is their attitude civic than that of certain minded officials who through ignorance or malice endeavor to tear down and belittle these efforts!” he declared He said that Ogden has had a federal survey has requested and received repeated inspections by the board of health and that an inspection ordinance has been in effect since 1931 ‘Yet they are still yelling that Balt Lake City is discriminating against them without trying to help so-call- ed appeared before the Salt lake City board of health and gave a detailed account of the controversy over the milk situation between Salt Lake City and Ogden He said it had deepened over the years and recently came to a head when Mr Peterson was ordered to discontinue operating in Salt Lake City without a permit Mayor's Views “It was agreed by the mayor and Ogden city that this constant agitation over the milk situation did definite harm to both cities and that it would be advisable for both cities to adopt the same ordinances and maintain the same standards Then Mayor Erwin instructed Mr Sidney E Gilchrist city bacteriologist with other inspectors to go to Ogden and investigate Mr Peterson’s plant and source of supply and report to the board of health made “After the investigation that same evening Mr Gilchrist reported on January 15 to the board that the plant and source of supply v)ere below the Salt Lake City standard and the board on the strength of this report refused Mr Peterson permission to sell in Sait Lake City Presents Side “Dr Browne appeared on January 15 and presented his side of the controversy After the board of health listened it went on record on these points: “ ‘Dr Browne had failed in proper discharge of his duties be cause he did not present matters to the board of health and the health commissioner (concerning Ogden situation)’ If these matters had been brought to the attention of the board we could have avoided the difficulties and retained Dr Browne He was not asked to resign because he was against the shipment of milk into Salt Lake City” the S Drive Advances themselves” Inspection History Dr Browne traced ths history of milk inspection efforts beginning mors than 75 years ago and de clared that money spent on en forcement of milk inspection brings greater returns than any other comHe gave parable safety measure a summary of diseases which result from impure milk Delving into the matter of appointing Salt Lake City inspectors Dr Browne said their examination was based on questions entirely different from the ones he had submitted and recommended that two men were given jobs who did not take the examination and two others were appointed who did not pass the ' testj Contributions to Sait Lake City’s promotional fund flowed into the chamber of commerce Thursday at an accelerated pace Donations were topped by the $3000 sum from Utah’s mining industry and included a number of other sizable contributions according to Harold S Jennings drive manager Hampered by bad weather and influenza the first three days the committee was completing reports Thursday Some 2000 firms were urged to give to the cause of advertising the city and state in order to attract a “bumper” tourist busi$35000 “Today these men' constitute our ness in 1937 Unqualified inspectors" he said W E Ryberg chairman of the Dr F A Clark officer of the campaign declared that the drive United States public health service will continue until every prospect who made a recent survey of Salt has been canvassed - — Lake City and Ogden mllksheds recommended that only qualified Inspectors be employed he said “Dr Clark told me he could not Road-Hoggin- g make a complete Inspection of Ogden milk because he had nothing 1061 Eighth W A on which to base his survey no rec- East street Ashbridge was fined $25 Thursday records no ords of bacteria count Heva Beck Bosone in City Judge by of of Inspection no records any police court when he pleaded guilty kind He advised me not to ad' to charges of failing to yield the to market so right-of-wamilk mit Ogden the y between vehicles Motorist Fined $25 on Count -- I shut it off” Joint Plans He said that the mayor then entered Into a reciprocal inspection agreement with Ogden despite the fact that two surveys showed that ' city’s milk below standard and without any advice froqa his own board - - — of health Dr Browne said that milk inspec-tioi- n had not increased the retail inprice and that the one-ce- nt crease last summer was due to the drouth and the resultant Increase in feed costs — Mayor Erwin and Mayor Harman W Peery of Ogden will be invited to discuss ths milk controversy in a forthcoming meeting of the Lumbermen’s organization it was decided Thursday Frank S Campbell 616 South State street Thursday was fined $25 with the sentence suspended in police court when he pleaded guilty to selling milk without a Salt Lake City board of health permit Campbell admitted not having a written permit but said he bad a verbal agreement with Dr Browne former chief of the dairy meat and food division of the city board of health to sell milk until differences in the Salt Lake City and Ogden inspection ordinances wera settled i Arrested December 27 following at Sixth South and streets East Fourth Ashbridge was originally charged with reckless an accident The driving duced was charge later re- While Interior decorators reno-viz- e the regular city court room sessions will be held in the police gymnasium police announced Repair work will be finished in about two “ weeks f Utah stands second in the sale of liquor per capita because the present law makes a person buy a “drunk” not a “drink" State Senator Ira A Huggins Weber county Thursday told the Women’s Legislative Council of Utah aa he advocated replacement of the present liquor laws with provisions for the sale of hard liquors drink Legislation on fairly and liquor honestly-approache- is not d and deliberations have not been frank Senator Huggins said This problem should be faced squarely and brought out into the open he added ? L Purchase Additional Units Still in 3Iaking After 3Ieet to Marshaling of forces and equipA contract for purchase of addiment of state and federal agencies tional parking meters to "forest’ to rush assistance to 500000 strandbusiness district curbs was still in ed rang sheep threatened with disthe making Thursday night Latest aster through ths recent heavy developments in the metered parksnows and extreme cold was begun ing situation included: here Thursday 1— A proposal of Commissioner John B Matheson that the cityinstal-latio- n Representatives of the state road are® before the new commission the federal forest servito reduce the meter fee from ce the division of grazing the bufive cents to one cent as soon as reau of reclamation the soil conmeters are paid for Destination of servation service the wool growers the "mystery 2—Commissioner William Murdoch's suggestion that the city purand the U S army met in the of- snow train” chartered by the junchase but 500 new meters which fices of the Utah Woolgrowers’ asior chamber of commerce for m with concessions allowed under the sociation to hurry plan for relief Sunday excursion into the mounmanufacturer’s offer accepted Wedaid tain vastness Is shown above Munesday would give the city 900 meAssumes Charge ters and install them alternately resounded through the icy air sic Tracy T Wright field man for curbs with a free parking along Deer train from the of two the Wasatch Livestock Loan comDr II B Mojirmann Valley space between each metered space weeks ago (lower) A band ie also pany assumed charge of the situaClarification Urged tion at the request of the Utah scheduled to make the trip this 3—Rewriting of the proposed Woolgrowers’ association Sunday contract to insure greater liability Attending the meeting were Mr protection for the city and clarify Wright R H Rutledge regional the division on the meter “take” forester and C J Olson assistant so the city may receive 25 per cent regional forester of Ogden K C or less of the revenue and the comWright chief engineer of the state pany 75 per cent or more of the road commission D D McKay surevenue pervisor for the division of grazCommissioner Matheson’s prodistrict engiing G C McClure posal was in the form of a letter neer for the soil conservation servstating in part: ice Captain K K Tatum in charge I am not interested in parking of the C C for C the Fort Douglas Explains meters as a source of revenue to area and James A Hooper secrethe city believing that it would be Illimani tarian Laws tary of the Utah Woolgrowers’ asan unjust discriminatory tax upon C sociation of Decides Junior certain classes of people An incomplete survey of stranded by Order ' in “I am however definitely interstate Place the outfits on sheep throughout ested in the meters as an- - aid to our Sunday made by Mr Wright Thursday retraffic problems and believe that Winter Frolic Declaring that the Fraternal Or- vealed that the most serious condithey will go a long way in solving tions on the Arizona exist the strip der of Eagles has pioneered for the parking situation in the business St George and Kanab section the section” properly administered humanitarian desert region west of Cedar City and Destination of the "mystery snow Mayor E B Erwin argued against laws and will continue to focus its Delta extending into Nevada with train” of the chamber of the Matheson proposal saying that junior indications bad in of conditions efforts along those lines Dr H B reduction of the fee as soon as the commerce was fixed Thursday in a devices are paid for probably would Mehrmann Oakland Cal national parts of Duchesne county the sports comLosses are inevitable Mr Wright meeting of it is winter secret interfere with the meter zone orto the still a president of the order addressed a said Every attempt to get equip- mittee but dinance relied upon to legalize use 600 persons who will be estimated session ment joint and supplies rushed to all aboard the tram Thursday night of Salt of the meters Sunday Lake City Bingham Murray and projects where they are needed The train will leave the Denver Would Hurt Garages Tooele aeries at the local Eagles most is being made by the group he and Rio Grande Western railway Commissioner Murdoch also opadded 8 a m at where station for a place hall posed the suggestion ground Firms Contacted that “to allow cars to stand on the tobogganing and ice skating Dr arrived Mehrmann here Air transportation firms have skiing are available and where enow is street eight hours a day for eight Thursday while on a visiting tour of been cQntacted and reasonable rates plentiful according to H E Sancents would put every garage in 1164 lodges of the western jurisdic- assured by them in case it is neces- ders committee chairman the city out of business” to to to relieve resort air travel were considered for Several sites tion He will leave Friday morning sary By unanimous vote the matter the situation both for men and ani- the second snow train of the season was referred to the committee of for Las Vegas Nev mals but the final decision was reserved the whole “Our crusades for mothers’ penwas learned Equipment was being shipped by until Thursday when Mayor Erwin charged that adopsions workmen’s compensation and rail and truck to Kanab St George that snow conditions are ideal at tion of Commissioner Murdoch’s old age pensions have done an in- Cedar City and Delta and work was the favored location alternate free space installation and calculable amount of good” Dr being pushed Thursday night The train will be equipped with a S L Groups Arrange Man Dies in Hospital plan “would defeat the pifrpose of will be continued Friday in an ef- lunch stand where sandwiches hot Mehrmann said installing parking meters” sufto losses and the fort served “It would cost between $30000 and “The work of the Eagles fraterreduce and cold drinks will be It for Annual After Released Being Parley of herds the to Salt the $40000 a year to police the situawill return sheep Lake City about nity was recognized by President fering among Mr state said 7:30 p m said the mayor result he preRoosevelt and as Wright of 31 a u f a t urers From Drunk Charge tion” Governor Henry H Blood volunCommissioner Murdoch held: sented us with the pen he signed in "On of state teered the the services the other hand motorists who the social security act which embodies the objects of out work” bringing relief to the suffering Final arrangements for the Police Thursday investigated cir- wished to cruise about in search of a Mr herds would have that privfree “Our fraternity will continue to Wright stated cond annual convention of the cumstances surrounding the death ilege" space Snow depths in the distressed give its unselfish services We are C 53 Utah association Manufacturers’ of W Bassett who a to died “The areas in contract as prepared is on are reported be from two vigilantly watching the administrato four feet on the level At Kanab tion of social justice laws” were completed Thursday by the local hospital Thursday at 5:20 a m the basis of 1400 meters plus 200 meters 32 which the company has Dr Mehrmann explained that such the packed snow measures which two days after he was released from entertainment committee a program necessitates a large quaa inches according to reports from agreed to replace” said Attorney in the offices of the organiza- the city met of a dismissal upon jail David Patten Woodruff 82 pio- tion in the Kearns building Ralph T Stewart representative of tity of man power and for this rea- that section with subzero temperahim twp agents of the corporation which son the order has an aim to build tures adding to the damage 500 association members drunkenness charge against neer resident of Utah and cofoundNearly Records showed that he was ar- intends to sell the new meters to membership to 1000000 by June 1 settled in and guests are expected at the con of er communities many the city 1937 opening at 12:15 Saturday rested Sunday at 12:50 p m and the early days of the L D S vention ‘Not Consensus’ William H McMillen president of the annual banquet at 7 p m that he was taken to the emergency and church died at his home in Long in the Hotel Utah Delegates from the Salt Lake City Aerie presided "That definitely was not the confor treatment Tuesday at sensus of the city commission when Beach Cal Thursday at the meeting The program also every section of the state will at- hospital Mr Woodruff a son of the late tend included an exhibition by a drill the luncheon and afternoon 10 a m when the charge against it decided to buy meters from the Wilford Woodruff president of the sessions and the combined banquet him was dismissedJn police court Parkrite corporation” Commissionteam under the direction of Bob L D S church at on® time and entertainment and dance Burton During the intervening time police er Murdoch replied to Mr Stewart— said he was in the city jail Sarah Brown Woodruff was born “We have an offer from the comchairman the of Shurtleff Clyde 74 1240 in Salt Lake City April 4 1854 As entertainment committee At the Salt Lake general hospital pany which agrees to give 40 meters Miss Annie Anderson presided the' esEast Alameda avenue former teach' & young man he assisted in at the Thursday meeting Commit- it°f was reported that the man died free with every 100 meters ws pur- er In the Salt Lake City schools tablishment of such towns as Smith-fiel- d tee members dysentery while a report by City chase” attending were King-- 1 died Thursday afternoon following and Vernal in Utah Cardston slcy E Clawson director of the Detectives W C Smith and J J “I am not making this suggestion Canada Plymouth and Weiser floor show progjarff William R Ferrin showed that he was suffer- with any idea that the company a lingering illness is Born in Salt Lake City July 9 Idaho and Burlington Wyo Pollock association president and ing from a similar ailment when ar dissatisfied with the arrangement” 1862 a laughter of William and Active in the affairs of the L D ex officio committee member Les- rested Sunday added Mr Stewart “I merely call After his release from jail Bas- attention to the fact that Jane Crooks Anderson pioneers of S church he served as bishop’s lie Squires William G McHugh the offer counselor in the Big Horn stake Charles N Fehr D J Stoker and sett was taken to the emergency was made on the basis of an inA brief supporting the contention 1857 Miss Anderson had been that municipal employes engaged teacher in the public schools here high council He was former trea- S J Stephenson association sec- hospital where he was treated for stallation of 1600 meters The pro26)4 hours He was taken to the posal to alternate meters with free in the work of public water' supply for 39 years before she was re' surer of Big Horn county Wyo retary are not subject to federal Income tired several years ago She was Mr Woodruff married Arabella association members were general hospital at 11:30 a m Wed space gets us back to the argument Sixteen Lotax provisions will be filed by the & member of the L D S church Jane Hatch now deceased at named by a nominating committee nesday where he died less than 24 on metering the whole business dishours later Miss Anderson is survived by a gan February 19 1877 He married as nominees trict or eliminating meters altostate of Utah with the United States for the Personal papers found in his pos- gether” Elizabeth Anderson again and his widow Mrs Sarah directorate They are: organization R H Ashsupreme court it was announced sister Mrs Lake City and a R Woodruff survives him Commissioner George D Keyser worth W G Carver C P Castle session indicated he was a telegThursday at the office of Joseph Fitzgerald Salt Anderson Austin brother Sam Surviving also are eight sons and James E Ellison of Layton Charles rapher police said He wassaid to called for a vote on the Murdoch Chez attorney general daughters of the first marriage and N Fehr V O Hewlett Clifford L have been employed in Nampa motion and cast his negative vote The brief will be filed in the case Nev Short funeral services will bq con- the following brothers and sisters: Hodgert Frank Kautzman P A Idaho and also in Browning Mont with the mayor Commissioners P of Brush vs the commissioner of Salt Lake Mattingly A C Moore J J Ne He came to Salt Lake City from H Goggin and Matheson Internal revenue which will be ar- ducted In the chapel of the Larkin Asahel H Woodruff Denver Gerald Irvine assistant city atgued before the supreme court early mortuary on Sunday at 12 noon City Mrs Blanche Daynes vllle Ft H Pyker David H Thomas Logan Saturday police said — —— The body was removed to a mor- torney was assigned to work with Bishop Arthur T Burton of Mrs Julia Parks Riverton Mrs Ronald Wadsworth in February of Ogden and with Mrs Sylvia ThompThe United States constitution the University L D S ward in Arabella Moses DilworVh S Woolley Salt Lake City tuary after general -- hospital at- City Attorney Fisher Harris on all of Newton son Wood and ruff taches will had be Burial in of contacted a the R brother be charge these private state of to that elected for contract are funds may not proposed provides C Bassett of Wellsville police said The matter of Smithfield Ensign Woodruff and Eight the Tooele municipal cemetery be taxed by the federal governterms of three years determining the defJohn Woodruff both of Cottonwood inite number of meters to be purment and so payroll checks of theme “Build Utah” based The and Marion Woodruff Tremonton on the association’s chased was not decided Faces Serious Charge states and municipalities have not Funeral Rites Held proFuneral services wijj b® conducted been subject to taxation However gram for the general upbuilding of Mann act charges were For Former Teacher in Weiser Idaho Given Hearing the internal revenue bureau has held the state through cooperation and against Lacy H Lewis 34 inbrought a comthat the exemption from such taxcoordination of efforts on the part plaint filed Thursday with United w V Done who was discharged Final rites for Mrs Bessie Ball Waives Burglary Hearing of all branches' of endeavor will States Commissioner Edward D December 17 from his duties ation is only for employes who are as in59 in necessary governformer school -- Jus Nance 18 Tooele waived predominate in both convention and Dunn "engaged Worthington Lewis is charged with spector for tha Utah state liquor schools Lake in mental functions” Pollock Salt will Mr teacher City burglary banquet addresses preliminary hearingjon transporting a woman from St control commission was given a Because some cities have Utilities and the wife of Charles V Worth charge and was bound over to di- preside at the noonday luncheon and Louis Mo to Denver Colo for hearing before the commission Tueswhich are privately owned the bu- ington were conducted Thursday at strict court Wednesday immoral purposes August 5 1935 day and given reasons for the comby City meeting reau has held that employes in mu- 2 p m In the Evans and Early mor- Judge B P Leverich comelect will The board of directors The He was arrested at Second South mission’s action according to Hugh do not have tuary chapel nicipal waterworks plaint alleges HancA forcibly entered officers to serve during the ensuing and State streets early Wednesday B Brown chairman Rev their income exempt from the proto be H held shortThe Lyon Baynes pastor the apartment of Mrs Ft L Stev- year at a meeting visions of the federal tax law of the Bethel Baptist church was ens 50 East First South street on ly after the annual convention PresThe ruling of the bureau is now in charge Dedication of the grave January 12 ent officers in addition to Mr Pol lock are: J J Neville first vice being tested in the courts and va- and commital services in Mt rious municipalities and states were also conducted by president Albert Becker Ogden second Vice president H A Snow throughout the country are filing the Rev Baynes Mrs Worthing' briefs in support of Brush in his ton died at the family residence 777 corporation secretary and Mr Ellisuit against the commissioner of Fourth avenue Monday following a son treasurer — V internal revenue long illness Protesting the stand of E J Fjeldsted secretary of the Ogden Civil Court Limit chamber of commerce end of the state organization-oCi f civic clubs-o- n the proposed $100000 state promotional appropriation from the Studied Challenge state legislature the Salt Lake Advertising club Thursday sent letters to Governor Henry H Blood Herbert B Maw president of Brown B detailed commissioner Hugh Following a report by Governor and Mrs Henry of the state liquor control comof a contention that juris- the state senate and Joseph W Jensen speaker of the house of Merits Miss Frances Parsons on the H Blood received members mission wHe also addressed the diction of city civil courts is lim- representatives findings of the committee of nine of the state legislature and group upheld the principles of ited to suits Involving $1000 and less The letter cited newspaper arti- bring large returns to the state and at wives their to state on Thursday private Appropriations night the present law and stated the had been taken under advisement cles quoting Mr Fjeldsted as saying to its citizens their a reception special In regard to advertising the state purpose Is to control liquor trafagencies the council voted to upby District Judge P C Evans so home 649 East South Temfic and not to raisa revenue as many other demands are being the letter said: "The efforts in the hold the recommendations in Wednesday night ’“ street ple full many seem to think The case was brought in the form made on the state government for past of the railroads and the Salt The senators and representUnder the present system The committee in Its report of a writ of prohibition peition money that in the Interest of econ- Lake City chamber of commerce are s and wive-their with atives not too filed by Lawrence Barclay attorney liquors can be suggested that state funds be we feel that this is not 'a indeed to be commended and we ladies sailed between 8 and discontinued to several agencies high a price to warrant of Salt Lake City against City omy congratulate those responsible and 11 m Legislative p employes M J Bronson and Salt Lake proper time to urge the establish- we trust these efforts will be conwhich are of benefit only to peoof the bootlegger and not Judge at- and their partners also too low to meet the desires of ment of a state publicity bureau” tinued It seems logical to us tjhat ' City court ple of the immediate surroundtended youth Mr Brown explained He Mr' Barclay challenged jurisdic-tiod- n The advertising club stated 'that the state of Utah should also ings and are not statewide in reA of music and program of eitv court' in connection it felt that a $100000 appropriation proposed revising the beer statute officially that it has attracscope In the past these agenclimaxed the en- fresh of the law so as to bring it under with a suit Jiled against' the attor- for the promoting and advertising tions to advertise and should take cies located in various parts of tertainmem the supervision of various comUtah have been assisted in their ney by Mrs Elizabeth Searle tore-cov- of the state was not an “expense” logical steps to keep people inter' but an "investment” which would ested and if possible enthused” $104567 munities’' work by state appropriations ? com-missi- FOE Head AddresscsSL ' I Mystery Trip Plans Remain Strict Secret Group Work Done for C Past for Sports 500 Expected Police Launch At Industrial Quiz of Death Meet Saturday In Jail Case it a on-th- e n Death Claims thirty-se- LDS Pioneer Teacher Dies US Tax Case BriefPrepared -- I ar a S L Advertising Club Raps OgdenStandonPublicityFund Legislators Entertained Women Hear Debate on Liquor Sale by Drink by the Wit- Smaller Fees Asked on City Park Meters Former S L Promotion L 1937 Several Groups Join in Move to Rush Aid to vT' Deep Snow Sections dairy ' ' - 22 Snoiv Train Ready for Trip to ‘Unknoivil’ Range Sheep Brands Mayor Erwin as ‘Dictator’ in Telling Luncjieon Meeting Story of IBs Being Discharged by City’g Chief Executive JANUARY By Governor ty in at at ‘ rn ecognize er -- ' I I t |