Show - I ' ""4t 1 " " - - : - - t' lift' Battitikt gtibunt ' - Saturday korning r --- - — 1 - - August "- - - service inth George F kennan's-tothe United States Department of State and - in the diplomatic corps including many years in Soviet Russia makes him particular ly well qualified to discuss problems of and convincingly in an artidir tiic4thtiii'Atigilit Atlantic entitled "The Illusion of Security" The case MrKennan makes for the "illusion" of security is well worth pender- ing because many 'Americans are guilty of the error of thinking as the author con- tends that there is "such a thing as total : ' security" i it - - 21954 - '7- - — -- - 4-'- - -' ' - ' - ception of the senator at Republican gatherings Knowland was well received by Utahns generally Partly this was due to his flat predie lion that Abe Senate would approve the Upper Colorado River Storage Project next session and his forthright declaration that his own state of California doesn't want any of the Colorado water allocated to the Upper Basin and that California should and would work with the Upper Basin for the advancement of reclamation in the West This comment from such an influential member of the Senate and such a powerful California political leader is very welcome to But equally the cause of a general warm reception for Senator Knowland is the fact he has definitely increased in stature at the session of Congress just closed As majority leader of What at times was actually a he did minority Republican membership of an outstanding job steering legislation through the upper house Even his political foes in the Senate paid tribute at the closing session to his sincerity and it cannot be denied that under his leadership along with that of other influential memben of both houses and both parties a great deal was accomplished It this session Senator Knowland has also demonstrated statesmanship in his refusal to go stIong with some of the more demagogic members of his party in attempting to assail the Democratic Party is a "party of treason" This utterly false charge the sen- ator completely repudiated in an Ogden address where he said: "Democrats and Re publicans alike have the welfare of our country as the foremost thought in their minds There is only one party of treason In the United States today and that is the Communist Party" This needs to be said and we applaud it the Senate so positively argument and opposition in our political demacampaigning without resort to goguery defamation or deliberate deception Senator Knowland made an excellent impression in all his appearances': hereHe is a dynamic speaker confident and persuasive He hes a warm and pleasing personality' Utah wasglad to have him pay In this visit and we will welcome him back at any time ' - t I one-thin- : all" ' 's ' at i I ::L- Adlai Stevenson's letter to Premier Mendes-Francassuring the French leader that the European Defense Community plan was not a partisan political issue in this country and urging its approval evinced the highest type of statesmanship The United States and the peace of the world would be enhanced by mor4-0:telonstrations of such an enlightened STISe of responsibility A bipartisan foreign " high'-policy long minded objective but selfishly partisan politicians have succeeded pretty well in tor- pedoing it Our failure to present a united ' front in our international relations is one of our prime Weaknesses Acting as titular head of the Democratic party Mr Stevenson first checked with Secretary of State John Foster Dulles and was assured his intervention might be helpful In turn President Eisenhower warmly praised Mr Stevenson This is a far cry from the smear techU(111e that marks so much of political campaigning It demonstrates sthe of both titular We hope ' it- beginning of more demonstrations to 'other nations that though the American -—15eopl e may disagree strongly on domestic Issues and may not always be ttogether on '' details of foreign policy we are in harmony in the belief that the free countries must act together to combat—the Communist ' " plague a ('- - - -- - - rower to Veto if the amendment should Utah have from — less than living in rural areas the right to exercise a Analysis of Wortnen chemists have in a more or less humorous manner announced after a chemiCertain of analysis man that ' ' cl" ) fol- - with a princess "Occurrence: Can be found wherever Man exists All "Physical properties colors sizes and shapes Gen- bitter "Chemical 1 - A R Philps t As t - We wish and desire entreat and ask We "wish to heaven" but we pray to God In the story about fused We Scrooge he hoped Tiny Tim said that - campaign Some of they will not even REASONS for the apathy inside- the Republican party vary Some of it in due to a lack of interest on the part of President Eisenhower and particularly of the White House stall in the fortunes of the regular organizations arisen because ‘-i Con of a ba pipartisan " ' 4:1111rre-901-- s ‘e to proachpolicy foreign ' J in "these dam sir gerous times" With a heavy Mr Stokes hand he but- tered up the Democrats for their cooperation and pulled out the stops on One of the Democratic heroes former Secretary of State Cordell Hull with whom Mr Dulles recalled he had worked out a approach 10 years ago for the 1944 RooseveltDeivey presidential campaign in the midst of the second world war How come all this—out of a clear sky? Self-style- Council of Churches President did not say as one man alleged that "prayer is What we need to solve our dilemma" The President said in essence that prayer would help fortify us in our resolve to fight- for peace and for those principles which we hold most dear FOR ONE THING the sky enBy proclaiming and really isn't very clear foreignpocouraging the pcimary licy-wise Situations a II truth our chief of °ter the world from Indostate (symbolizing our count china t4 the threatened distry) has reached ti new high ruption of the European DeIn statesmanship fense Community open the Of course an occasional in- - ' Eisenhower administration to dividual still exists who in all criticism of rcliscern- and The congressional elec merit and ominous perspicae tion campaigns now are on In real earnest Ind In them ity has the misguided boldness also' to proclaim: "There anything goes usually is only one thing seriously Could it be that the seeewrong with prayer—it does tary is holding out an olive 'not work" Proof is demanded branch in the effortto remove Even the appearance Of God from the campaign issues of would not quell khe requirements of "proof" for such in- foreign policy in which The administration is obviously vudividuals Should our Maker lnerable? before them such appear Democrats May be overly "realists" would declare that they had a "bad dream" or a suspicious but that was their reaction The timing seemed "nightmare" The unfortunate reality is significant "''' that an occasional individual NOTED TIM the breek- caught in the web Of hrs own of frustrations proceeds to apply down Just the day before ' the Brussels conference over his narrow interpretation of France's resistance to the justice as necessarily being EDC Treaty to Which Secrethe ultimate because it is his tary Dulles also referred in naturally: his news conference They Fortunately the MasteeLls noted also that it was the pretruly omniscient The resultivious day that House Demo ng void between the eternal ce lie knows and the cratic Floor Leader Sam Rayburn had himself issuer1 a "justice" of an atheist must necessarilf differ as does light statement most critical of 'the from the sun with the brood-administration's !handling of ing stifling blackn'ess of the foreign Policy !giver many Michael Provost manths with particular ref- - i pit World The d os - - unkissed unthunk tuunissed ' undrunk II - - : ' -: - ' - ' - ences to - that Eisenhower letter Now jJust at a time when the energies of the Repub licant might better be spent in campaigning against the Democrats a committee of six senators is to hold extensive hearings which will keep the McCarthy issue in the headlines throughout September '014 perhaps October At the grass roots the emotional reaction to the McCarthy issue is so strong that even if the weakest of the percentage totals shown by the various Gentili polls as to those who are on the McCarthy Weis taken as an accu- rate- measurement-- today of the 'sentiraent it is enough to defeat the Republican party by the simple device of their not voting at the coming elections ALL THIS IS GRIST for the Democratic mill Yet the Republican high command beginning with the President and the White House staff are doing little or nothing to heal the breach in the party and the Democrats are doing everything they can to goad Eisenhower staff to stir uthpe more and more friction Inside the party v -- - -- d Editor Tribune: "realists" proclaim the ineffectiveness- of prayer while misinterpreting the obvious meaning of our 'President's recent statements before the - : y raised their eyebrows knowingly upon reading Secretary of State John Foster Dulles' 'ns formal state- '7'"7-:'' ment urging the continua- ' important instances where prayer failed His opinion is "failure" but the will of God and the want of men are not always the same Our prayers are few and our memtlimioo ories ted as Christmas once a year Successful lie - ' surely even God can hear many voices better than a few Mr Harrison cited a few a ' con The troversy has served to dram atize the dissension inside the Republican party and to aggravate it to a point almost beyond repair That's why the betting on the election of a Democratic Congress is growing every day to the point where any Republicans foolish enough to bet can demand big odds WASHINGTON—Democrats prayer we "remember" and d - Indochina Looms as Issue remember on Christmas Day who made lame beggars walk and blind men see In to ' - - dates will suffer just the samt because of President Eisenhower's part in tho fight The fact remains that Sen Flanders a Republican start-Jk forme move $71111Pt-- ' Senate without the sanction of the Senate Republican Policy Committee Then Mr Eisenhower wrotet a letter to Flanders praising his speech censure hnd the latter has since made public refer- THOMAS L STOKES the people saw him because he was a cripple and it might be pleasant for them justiies- 'i‘ McCARTHY ISSUE is one of course from any political viewpoint and most candidates on the Republican side are fighting shy of any mention of it thing—prayer" Too often we get prayers and wishes con- - a tOld Coryza ! E -- - - - Mr Editor Tribune: Harrison said "Let us be real-THistie and honest about this Jim Jeffries who is an exsalespert man says that experience has a habit of teaching you a lot of things you'd be happier by I CS' i — Not Always Same com- pany has taken up golf declines to give a reason 1 ' For several months the direct and indirect attacks on Sen McCarthy at the President's press conferences have gone unnoticed among ReMiblicans who feel that the Wisconsin senator has performed a service to his country by arousing public inter-- ' est with respect to Communist techniques and methods Of infiltration in America Assistant Secretary Gunn 3year-ol- 44-4?-' stag- - Reaches New High Geo'rge Young formerly Ex- " ' y: t Some of it has - Paysonttah ' volatile' highly innot Ithowing flammable and dangerous in the hands of an inexperienced Wheat You Have person Possesses great affiniTell me not of ty' for gold silver platinum kisses and precious stones of all Never speak of kinds Capable of absorbing 1 ' astonishing- omitM and pensive 'foods beverages rl'ailk to one of Reacts violently when misses tett alone Turns 'green when - Tell 'me no of more ittracLdrinks placed ive specimen Ages rapidly —Amy nek-t-t- ' little was dispatcher for a taxicab swectccasionaand soketimes properties: Federation NV Bile ceedingly - - - the "citizens for Eisenhower" movement is - being - inter-- preted as a threat to discipline regular Republicans who have conscientiously adopted views differing from some of those of the President Perhaps the most serious I cleavage in the Republican party arises from the min- handling of the McCarthy Issue by the White House the real trouble down to do complete indifference of the bulk of the Utah sportsmen (particularly those of Lltah County) to the fish and game policies being formulated In this state Mt Nebo Wildlife Wayne Owens Panguitch Utah suggests that when Club Meets" is 'The run a of the missus should be substituted for mine erally appcars in disguised condition natural surface rarely free from an extraneous covering of textiles or film ° and pigments fl Melts gadily wheri properly treated Boils at nothing and may 'freeze at any moment lly sour: t 41 itk-- happy" dove hunters there won't be any too many birds for the law abiding nimrods who wait for the regular sea- : ap un- stable Ordinarily ' However Caroline Gunn Have you ever seen a child so exquisitely lovely that just looking at her brought a mist to your eyes in your throat? Well such a sight was Caroline ' molecular :exceedingly ''" Our Readers Tribune: Five Dennisi Park prejudice or "Symbol WO Member of tile puma n fainily Specific variable - boils Seated on top with all the proud assurance of a royal Ham comment: '' 4 :1 son ate could tie up every single bill until a reluctant House of Representatives knuckled under And even the House is not exactly chosen according to population since each county would have at least one seat regardless of size Jerry De Gattis o chemical anal- ysis of the fe- male of the species I submit it without structure a doubt state Sen- 17th Ward put on a parade— and with floats! Our interest naturally was centered in the entry from our apartment It was a house the Carol-Jbeautiful fjoat—a pink flower-like mound made of crepe paper completely covering the toy wagon owned by worth gravity to? thietybod uetsir much Fresh variety has a powerful magnetic attraction" Notes on the Cuff Department Neighborhood news: There was eonsMerable excitement In our block last Wednesday evening The children of the Chemical he's about 90 cents Then a cynical member of the ' From Sandpit By Ham Park -- Bruyere cal By - 10 Women are ever in extremes: they are either better or worse than men for bet- f -- - According to unofficial local reports being circulated the pheasant crop isn't as good this year as last year And if it gets further reduced by a few "trigger of the population of per cent - ------ t ' - sl') l grer1144104'--4- pheasants by unscrupulous dove hunters is tremendous Nevertheless the proclamation came out allowing not only dove hunting in Utah County but in many other pheasant areas of the 'state in spite of the fact that ample dove hunting exists only a short drive from these areas etc workmen's compensation 1 system ' months ago on March 24 1954 we wrote the Utah Fish and Game Commission in Salt Lake City strongly recommending that the mourning dove season not be opened in Utah County for 1954 The reason for this is that Utah County contains a large percentage of Utah's small pheasant area and the opportunity for poaching the young it will amount to Daggett County voters So why a‘'' k-: '' against such legislation Editor xpect lost change—the-Britis- h - Total Indifference times more Weight and influence in the state Senate This amendment will do away with equal representation but as the cities continue to grow the Y will progressive legislation on traffic Jams race relations health juvenile delinquency and education factory safety 1400 vote i:1-1 farmer-controlle- d to do land 10 if representing Salt Lake to one which is not necessarily an easy thing - took Veto the amendment will the seven senators Second passed Ncoming ( L now The dangers of freezing legislative representation as is provided in a proposed Utah cohstitiitional amendment is demonstrated by English history In the late 17th century seats in the Itouse' off Commons were assigned tovarious cities towns: and (MC corporations This was before the industrial revolution Whith was to transform the face of Eng- - k- : County Tile Enrolls!' Example e' - ' 7: eastern states and thus pattern our Legislature after is not well taken What will the amendment do for Utah's heavily populated areas such as Salt Lake City located in Salt Lake County with 285670 of the state's population? reduce eIi -: -- 's Utah's comparatively small: slumless cities are closely associated with the country 'side so to say that Utah is congested similarly to the big First --- '- -- '' - lowed - - - profession e ' ' - ::: ' - Tribune: Having the Public Pulse on reapportionment by Paul Ashworth I want to present my Ideas on this important issue among search' parties individuals to avoid in the future the 12 hours of needless continued searching for Bruce after he had found his way to safety party-head- tk'' Editor ter communications - : is - s '!'0- 0 " ' st November Letters received by this correspondent from many parts of the country tell of influential Republican party workers including some county chieftains who have dcided to be passive in the s''' -- - t sn:4-4" giving The result was that by the beginning of the 19th centurY the whole system of par- liamentaryyepresentation was out of joint Once prosperous towns had dwindled away while other towns practically Unknown before the age of industrialization had become teeming cities But the old borouehs —by then "rotten boroughs"—had the seats in Parliament while the new cities did not The situation finally became so intolerable that in 1832 after a terrific contest:Parliament enacted the first of the reform bills to equalize representation If similar - population shifts were to occur in Utah- what would be the result? Under the proposed amendment representa-- tion mould be frozen into the constitution Could the people Of poorly repreSented ur ban areas—practically disenfranchised un-- der an unfair and lopsided reavportionment system eventually fOce a change? Not without is much or greater effort than It - -- 1 r control of both houses of Congress in the - '---- - read learned be 11 yved ' t-' ' ' N 144 ' 414' - The lost hlitterind 0 The Public Forum ident does eniphasize the need for careful supervision of boys on mountain hiking or camping trips it also is a reminder that most youngsters if properly trained can take care of themselves if they do become : 1f Jit - ' - -- courage If there is any lesson to alori‘ ' Republican 4 t 6SociefaL - of young American boyhood and to the training given by scouting While the inc- from the case it might be the need V s The story Bruce told indicates a self- - emergency ' ' : rugged Granddaddy Lakes wilderness where va 0 '3 - area in the high Uinta& Bruce little the worse for his experience of sleeping out two pighti and following miles of trails in his search for some human habitation finally walked Into a 15 miles N - '' f contributing to the loss of 'Ne 1 - INEAP1491:0!10'T - - Cstirt The Tribune joins with the parents and friends of Bruce Bingham of Provo in welcoming his safe return from nearly two full days of wandering lost in lodge : P Nit states is shot to pieces and this may prove i 0 : publicanparty In several 744-6--- i - 1 - - : 0 - the Wilderness on Rock Creek some he became lost ) - But the Republican sawn- - WASHINGTON— The mo-rale of precinct morkeri and local organizatiOns of the Re-- - on ' - i A IA ' - -- - 4 ' e -- - Is the ' -- d insecurity The astutely points out is for ta to assess the "relative importance of the various dan- gers'emong which we move" This is the concept of "the calculated risk" which is present pulley of the American government It accepts the fact that in this modern world there tan no longer be total security for America and that only)! we are prepared to live dangerously ever alert to the perils which surround us can we hope to live at all Out - - ' ' 1 - But the real challenge to us is not to seek absolute security or cravenly accept of I 101 t44‘1- - 11 -- "'se° " '' " ' -s-- 11 ' it a is me any other nation n- - fe ' - Truth is we must be prepared to live In a world of peril The hope of absolute secu- rity is indeed an illusion It may of course satisfaction to us to know that absolute security is equally impossible for be-so- N a :'--- :: --- - - - - -- - GOP Seriottsly Hindered 'By Cleavages - A1 -- TM'1 T 100 " 710THIM fts CONGRESS '19 4 8 ‘ i- 44 IC 14 f- -- i- ) - 9- ' - - — -1 4'7'7 to - ' rkr DAVID LAWILFINcE --- - C e - I - 1: ?9 7v4- ' ' I ' 47 from attack Statesmanship ' Lamlable '' ' ' - -- '''' YEAR - - It is true that American experience would naturally lead us to believe we can be safe from attack behind our ocean ram-Partparts well protected by naval power For more than a hundred years we did have such military security But that day is past and there Iis eel-tainly need for Americans to adjust their thinking to changing times and conditions —to the day when super:sonic planes subtguided missiles and marines have wiped out those ocean rem- parts of ours and brought the possibility of enemy attack literally to every part Lour country We do not have thesecurity of the 19th century and there is littlelikelihood we ever will have it again Nor is there any reality to the hope of absolute security from the standpoint of amassing such overwhelming power that no foe would ever dare attack us No system of allianeesto insure that kind of power would be proof against the vagaries of inter---national politics Nor is it conceivable we could amass such overwhelming power our- selves as to overawe all the rest of the world and compel it in fear of our :strength to sullenly and resentfully stay on our side or even though aligned against us to refrain seeking ' s There s ' M5 WORK of entirely capable of bringing this country a point where it will have no security total - n ' AMA trW0t41 ' '4 - - - Is atom-powere- Visit to Utah this week of Senator William F Knowland of California Republican Senate leader was quite a political feather - In therap ottallrampaigning Republicans here For besides enthusiastic partisan re- - of Perfectionisi& I'M TELLING YOU ly Mr 'The Sinator has Grown - - "— - undermines and destroys its own- basic purpose The French have their wonderful proverb: Le mieux est Pennemi du bie- n-the absolute best is the enemy of the good- I4gthingtrtier Jias ever biertse14-- foreign - self-defeati- : "" ‘ ifitylillitecratitlittifievilliétteetibtartis '” curity can think that Is the - - ! Stymied - extremism—the persistentdemand for and belief in 'absolute solutions "There ie' warns Mr Kennan "some-thing about this quest forabsolute security It la an exercise that is it - ' Which like every form Kennan declares this belief comes from our 19th century experience 'which leads many to believe there could and should be such a thing as total military security for the United States today Partly it is a result of the American tendency to - 4e " I ' : - - -- - - ug ' ' s The Illusloli of Absolute U 'S Security- ! ' k "- -- - t erence to Secretary Dulles' "threats to retaliate against friendly nations" It was perhaps another in the Rayburn i aPtaartaegmreanP that caused most concern aI t the State Depart $ ment In iit he recalled pointedly that Republicans had con-t stantly assailed the Truman-Acheso- n foreign policy in the 1952 campaign This reporter recalls vividly the visit here 10 years ago of Mr Dulles in connection with truce on foreign paoeliacmyP''aHig came as the official emissary of presideptial candidate Thomas E Dewey There came to be however lune exception to the gentleman's agreement to remove foreign policy from the 1944 campaign THAT WAS CHINA and the Far East The late Sen Vandenburg of Michigan foreign policy spokesman in Congress for the Republicans imposed that exception on the groundI that Republicans had not been consulted by Secretary Hull an China iand Par East policy as on policy in Europe and This reporter reelsewhere calls hew Mr Dulles joined the Dewey campaign train to advise the Republican candi- date on speeches the governor made later attackifig Democrats on their China policy It would not be surprising if Democrats made their own exception in this cam paign - That would be Indochina and its loss which would be exempted from any gentleman's agreement That is what Republicans fear Democrats took a beating in Korea two years ago and Indochina seems to them a fair substitute to toss back at the Re- ' publicans ' Soaper Says — When television fitally gets around to bringing back one of those - world's champion all our friends fro vaudeville have been iaccipunted for ' I - - - 01161kan |