OCR Text |
Show BaUNh A 4 1 Soviet Ne. ' Nows Aot Ni Social No. AMut8UNt. Nm (Social No. dSflWPAT. Rdo&soc? Kanggsa NEW CORPORATIONS Ci30t AMD - WCHANICAL V. 2300 . SLC; Kagana Smith! 2001 V. 2300 S. SLC; kill Caoria, 7320 S. 3380 E. SLC; Katharine J. Pickering, 2061 . 2300 S. SIC; 61307 I. . - Lorraine Clrela, Kirby Foy, 3307 S. SLC; SLC; John Lorralna' , Jaaaa Alexander Vanlaaa. 183 E St. SLC; Murphy Vanlaaa, 183 St. SLC; bo logrant and prod. . PARK 61308 Hlch-a- al E holo-graph- ic PLACE MOBILE HOME, INC., 160 V. 230 S. Kayavilla; A. Eduard Cooper, 160 V. 230 S. Kayavilla jJaneal V. Cooper, sona addraaa; Fran-e- la V. Cooper, 1749 S. 50 V. ESTATES, Bntfl; Donna J. Cooper, aaaa addraaa; 61309 - HARDY -- CAMP & ASSOCIATES SLC Rax V. Hardy, 762 Hilltop Rd. SLC; Roma H, Hardy, aaaa add-- re i; Virgil H. Canp, 3992 S. Jupiter Dr. SLC; lnaurance . - ADVANCED ELECTRONICS CORF., 2044 S. 300 E. SLC; Rick L. MoAcrlef, 2044 S. 300 E. SLC; Jorgen Oluf Da Bang, 5908 Executive Blvd. Dayton, Ohio; Lynn G. Foater, 625 North creat Dr. SLC; 61311 - TAX, real aetata 61314 - VALLEY 61321 ESTATE AND FINAN- CIAL CONSULTANTS, CO. INC,, 177 E. 9 S. SLC; Monte C. Nel-- a on , 177 E. 9 S. SIC; Joaeph L. Henrlod, 410 Newhouaa Bldg. SLC; Michael Gottfredaon, 410 newhouaa Bldg, SLC; 61312 - MAJC0, LTD., 435 S. 30C E, SLC; 0, Robert Meredith, 2455 Enereon Ave, SLC; Karen F. Meredith, ease addreee; Von K. Jenaon, 3258 Monte Verde Dr, SLC; Sharyn Jenaon, 3238 Monte MACHINE & MAN- Bldg. SLC; 61315 - RTATION, Fk; Sp. 800 289 S. Irving Blvd. LA Calif; M. V. Foley, 2424 Wlle.'J ahlre Blvd, LA Calif; Frederick M. Hunt, 4455 Victoria Park Dr. LA Calif; aarketlng, aer-vlcenter, part storage INC,, 289 E. 900 N. Sp. 7 61323 DAVIS PRINTING AND BUSINESS FORMS, INC.,' 131 W. Ma- aa; - E, Brlghaa City; Steven 0. Jeneen, 196 N. 3 E. Logan; INC., 83 S, Main, Brlghaa City; Gerald Byuater, 83 S. Main, Brlghaa City; 8, H. Hibbert, 1075 E. Center, Bntfl; Karleen C. Byuater, 83 S. Main. Brlghan - 61325 175 S. Main Ervin INC., Paul R. St. SLC; 740 100 Jr. Suite CREATIVE ADVERTISING INC., 320 S. 3 E. SLC; Kenneth O. Melby, 3755 Evelyn Dr. SLC; Ruth N. Liah, 320 S. 3 CO. E. SLC; John E. Runyan, 320 8. .3 E. SLC; - . 61320 VOLEX, INC., 1268 E. 5500 S, S. Ogden; Kent Shearer, General lnaurance Company - Couneel Quinn etux R to Joseph Jack B D Dial Finance to John Rix etux to Wasatch Bank Harry Altschule etux Zions to Dard First 411 to 8SSf!f8i,p0$Si & K Nationwide Finance Rupert G Thomas etux of Counsel t Moyle Joseph Defendant and Appellant. ft to Frank Draper J. Palmer L. M. Cummings, First Federal Clerk Mumford etux. M 444 Merrill etux to James etux D Shumway H Tyndall The plaintiff sued on the bond for the unpaid balance due from Skyline and recovered judgment. The defendant appeals, contending that the action was not timely begun. 1 provides: lf the claimant la a subcontractor of the contractor, no such auit shall be commenced after the expiration of one year from the date on which final payment under the subcontract became due. The sole question involved herein is when did the final payment under the subcontract become due. The prime contract provided that the State, would make a progress payment of 90 oi the value of the work done in any given month not later than the 15th of the following month. The subcontract provided that plaintifi would furnish Skyline monthly estimate a of work done and that Skyline would pay 90 of the value thereof out of the money it received the following month from the State of Utah. Nothing waa said about when the withheld 10 would he paid to plaintiff. ' In the abaence of an agreement to the contrary, the unpaid amount contract would become due and payable upon completion of the. work However, in this case Skyline was not obligated to required to be done. pay plaintiff 90 of the last monthly estimate until it received the money from the State. Whn that final 90 waa paid, then the entire amount of money withheld would alao be due and owing if there were no offaeta to be made for improper workmanship, unpaid billa, etc., which might become of the a charge against Skyline. The final bill of plaintiff was for $2, 900 and waa prepared May 10, not sent to Skyline until June 1, 1971. Since plaintiff was making but 1971, monthly estimates as the work progressed, it would appear that the bill dated May 10 was for work done in April, 1971. The payment for the final estimate was not required to be made until the money was received by Skyline for the month following that in which the work waa done by plaintiff. , The first payment received by Skyline after May 10, 1971, waa on May 21, 1971, and plaintiffa share, if any it had, would not be due until after that date. The next payment to Skyline waa made August 10, 1971, 1. Sec. U.C.A. 1953 (Replacement Vol. 2A). 2. 17A C.J.S. , Contracts, Sec. 502(1). arid any amount due plaintiff out of that payment or the prior one would be well within the year before May 19, 1972, the date when this action waa commenced. 2575 Industries to Moench D Eugene etux Valley Bank and Tr to Thomas D Cram etux Whether or not the judge gave the correct reason for hia ruling ia of 3 no importance, since he should be affirmed if he reached the correct result. He did 'reach the correct reault; for it doea not appear from the record that the action waa commenced more than one year after the final payment became due. The judgment ia affirmed. Costa are awarded to respondent. R C etux Lahoda Col lard Jr.. J. peteraon v. Fowler,- 29 Utah Appeal ft Error, Sec. 1464(1). - 2d 366, 510 P. 2d The Equitable Life Ins to Robert H Baker etux State Bn Credit to Cliffie G Mollison etux to Cable 638 Tracy Collins Bank Dewey Moore etux to First to Clair L to Prud Fed Savings Ronald C Kuehrie etux to to Credit to William Horlacher etux 717 E Don K Whit to S to Dale etux Stevenson to 733 Valley Bmk and Trust Gary C Kirgan etux 779 M Sharp Sanders Lewis Chaekatta etux to Victor Prud Fed Savings Victor La via Chaekatta etux Ziona First Nat Bank to Victor Lewis Chaekatta etux 781 785 Kqy H to Ziona First Nat Bmk Burgon etux Prud Fad Saving! George Rasa Harmon etux 2575797 The Greater to York New Lawrence M atux C.J.S., 881 397 BYU to 398 Cr Union BUY Bn to Thomas Wendell JackBon etux 402 Zions First ANat to Charles Hemb rough etux 418 Industrial Town to to to to Prudential In to etux to to 519 Zions First Rail OPS S L & Thomas A etux Kettle etux 062 to W to Loan 076 J R T to State Retireto J R to 787 E L Majestic Sav A Loan Rasband otux L American Sav Max Baglay otux E Bead Strickland etux j Prud Fed 036 778 Utah ment Fund Loan Farrell etux to 777 Bankers Life to Myrl E Ingram Jr etux Brewer etux 069 AHPAL Service .to Kenneth W Fish Ottpc etux Nat B W Louis Lift to Prud Federal Nudell etux 765 F to to 671 Brill woo Fed Sav to Tracy etux 760, 761, 762 Ziona Bank to R W Cameron etux Cr Union State Sav Metropolitan Wright otux 673 Pnd Fed Sar Bevan otux S Adams 010 McGhie to Midwest Const Co Stapp American Sav William W Shay 670 Snyder etux 2577 ; 518 A 984 Bial Finance Deaeret Federal R Hugh T V Federal Rat Mortgage A Major etux to Orrln 955 to J to Ronald 513 East River Sav to Norman Pye etux 981 Commercial Security Bank to Commercial Sec Bank Sav 932 Bank to DeLoy Corp Exchange Cr Union R F Bennett etux R D to Bringhurst Etux Van Valkenburg 613 A to 980 473 478 Sav Loan to Stanley Fin to Gene Russell Beck etux 436 Sarah F Jones Evan D Johns etux State 915 Federal Ooo H 630 to U to Wolff etux 2576 Jackson etux Thgyer atux to Lake &q Credit John Hancock Mutual Life 621 Johnson-Anders- on to Salt Eldorado Rows 890 1st Sec Bank Ted L Jones etux Bnployees Fed Thomas Wendell to Robert UlELCb Credit Union Chrlatophoreon etux L to etux to Victor Mitchell etux First Surety Finance to Robert Smity etux Amerlcm Sav md Loan C Barrua atux Nicholl atux First Security Bank to Ernest Prud Fed Savings E Catough etux 6ll , C 889 Government Nat Mtge to Harry A Madsen 421 Thorlt Hatch atux to H Wilst ead etux The Harcdd L A 396 Bank 600 Federal Nat Mtge 886 to B T Iyla Prud Fed Sav to to F Yeager Uni vac Nielson etal R C Metropolitan Life otux 563 W Security Titel T Dixon etal J Black Realty Sewnane 561 0 to Gaverawnt Nat Mtge Storch etux Pratt etux B etux 882 Utah State Retire- Bank to 791 Jr Glen ment to Fredrc Melton etux 559 F 874 Seamens Bank for Savings to T H Houston Prud Fed Savings H Jensen etux Don D See Bank 553 Walker, Bwik E Davies otux 796 American Sav A Loan to Wm H LewiB etux Ron 390 Cr to 780 to Rollins etux 389 Utah Farm Prod 698 515 American Nat Ins 775 Bank H Davies etux 0 Hweaontree etux First 511 to G Service Corp to 510 Granite Teachers Credit Union to G D Brown etux etux Johnson Anderson 382 to Drake Richard 513 Ma. C Prud Fed D D Fashion Cabinet Mffe. Inc How Bldrs etal 198 768 Zions Bank to Donald Truman Little . AKSAL H Inc, k 739 Prud Fed Sav to Robert L Bevan etux 761 Trust etux First Security Arden 369 & 197 Vance etux etux to Melvin A Lancaster etux Geo. A Lancaster 193 738 Peseret Fed Sav to Donna J HalvorBen etal Prud Fed Sav ' . to Ernest L McDougal Bwik allay Federal Nat Mtge to Jack M Hardy etux 751 G C Curtis etux to Dennis R Wolf etux Nielson etux Dial Builders to C Webster etux 363 Fin to Western Tecton Inc 692 & Baldwin H Trust Mortgage to John Anthony Chapman etux St Bank Doyle etux Realty Rube 366 Seo Midwest 691 Walker Bank 332 & etux V to C to Alvin Deaeret Fed Savings D GaUowgr etux to Western 760 Barney 682 686 Akre Sav It Loan 725 Bell Fed Sav & Loan to Joseph J Sewar etux W Walker Bank 331 State etux 740 293 to 876 523 (1973); 5 to Robert Savings Ralph 178 to 721 Vera A Rose John P Oreno Nationwide Finance H Baker etux 292 to F to Margaret State 172 HI' B Sheffield etux to smith etux R etux Davis Haile etux 168 to I 720 Surety Life to Sav Yori etux R F ' Cutler 9tux W 163 W Granite Teachers Cr Un .to D W Rideout etux St Bank Sec First Federal 280 to Iver J 875 Johnson Anderson Glenn K Parras j"! First Farmers State Bank Louis F Wolff etux 872 Tracy. Collina Baric John F Piarcey atux R. L. Tuckett, Justice Bank E Orren Greenwood Chae DCoopagni atux etal -- Northwestern Mutual 160 Loan to to Nat Mtge to Robert Life 699 Cutler etux Ada Fisher etux 397 to Skyview Develop R Federal 387 R H etux Life to Snell Business craft atl Biesinger etux 695 Cont Bank to Glen 0 Christensen etux Prudential Ins to Verdell J Jacobson etux 643 Dial Finance to Charles Phelps etux J The First Security B & to FTmik A Mottoya 381 R P Hop 1st State Bank, to Geo L Anderson etux 217 State Savings Loan to Lee Muir etux Lynne Sav to 381 Matropolitwi John L Shaly atux etal Vernon Romney 693 274 Co to Fd Savings k Reliance r 691 2576 etux to to State Retireto Alton. G 644 Valley Bank and Tr to David L Ewell' Mavor Gatehouse 860 Utrii- St Em Credit Gary 0 Nielson atux I Drury etux State 689 etal to 807 Pacific Mutual Life David L. Basrdshall etux Allan Crockett, Juatice Eagar Realtors to W Joe Conaway etux First Security St E Warren Fairclough Brewer Robert F. Henri Henriod, Juatice Eager dba 323 Bank 616 Prud Ins June Husbands 688 Todd S Utah 799 Chief Justice etux to Paul Bank Dial Finance to Stavon 380 Marshall Lloyd. Contlnaital Loan Thrift Capitol E to to 366 First Fed Savings H.L. Holm etux Credit ' Bn Veigh Cummings R J Thompson 678 315 Deseret Fed Savings to Toni A Baddeley etux 613 Vetkin E. R. Callister, 082 275 Prudential SavingB to Ronald E Coulter 362 Bank etux F Woodbury 331 Firat Fad Savings Geo F Hanaenotux 365 AKSAL Service Corp Regency Howe etux to etux 081 Dry Dock Savings Bank to Herbert Milo to Savings Bmk WE CONCUR: R to Henry Truddlnger etux to Ingle Llgnell Prud Fed Savings Walter E Burton etux 676 Nationwide Finance to Fredrick William to F Woodbury Gary L Parker etux Myron Thomas Herrick 14-1-- The trial judge apparently thought that the terms of payment to Skyline as set out in the prime contract alao applied to the subcontract. The partiea did not act aa if it did, for when the work of Skyline waa 50 fqmpleted, no further amounts were withheld by the State for payments made on the subse10 of epch payment due plaintiff quent progreaa reporta. Skyline withheld at all times, and this action is to recover the amounts ao withheld. to Robert etux 533 534 668 Nationwide Finance 062 to etux to Larry etux etux Mayne Bank of Salt Lake Continental Thrift 351 to Charles Dennis Clegg etux to Aetna Finance State Curtis B R 328 3U Clegg etux Utah to Smith etux to Charles Dennis 663 Hanson A J Dun atux Credit Bn M W 1 33l 662 St F Nat Prud Fed Savings Investment etal Utah Sv to Bmk of Awrican Pork Frank J Cobua etux 325 Beneficial Life Ins to Ben M Redman etux C & S to etux First Zions etux R CMnninghmi otux Bank to Jack William McCardle etux 658 Prud Fed Savings Bernice N Brady to 628 047 Prud Fed Savings to Leonardo Riccardi etux 234 518 519 & Miller R 634 Amsal Service to Warren R Adair etux & Automation 304 to Lloyd Utah ment Fund Bank First to Merlin F Security Park etux The defendant was surety for Skyline Construction Company, a prime contractor on a construction job for the State of Utah. The plaintiff waa a subcontractor on that job. The bond of the surety provided that defendant would pay all debts of Skyline which Skyline did not pay. etux American SavingB 141 467 ELLETT. Justice; to 608 McGhie Land Tr to Hal K Title, Laraen and Sona Const Tracy etux Sav H both Prud Lw, Co. to 281 307 'Amerlcm Cowm etux Trust & ' to Pioneer Prud insurance 283, etux to Pacific Mutual Life 439 17, 1973 to Prud Fed Savings Aaron S Denning 063 to John Everel Carlson etux No. 13359 FILED 028 G etux Leoiurd Moss Firat Security Bank to Leo A Alftin etux Milo Enterprises & 590 061 L 216 315 Walker Bank Paul Clark 570 030 Valley Bank and Tr to John A Kendrick etux Security Title, Tr 395 to J to Mortgage Hielkema H etux to etux 376, 377 to Hendrik 049 Walker Bank '& Trust to John G Khies 374- Nat Bank Gov Nat Bank etux Deck to Bldg Walker Bank & Trust Marvin R Pack etux 369 046 Prud Fed Savings to Leonardo Riccardi 333 333 etux etux First C Security State Savings to Keith Otto 366 Loan 984 Westcrest Inc to Michael 8olon McGee to 2lli Deaeret Thrift to Donald L Runt 534 Small Business Adm James Lowell Fox etux 990 to 232 Prod Fed Savings Lionel McKnight otux etux Rulon F Cannon to' 21b Peoples Flames J.Q. Rebholi otux Williams D Granite Teachers Cr to Lloyd C Pierce etux etux to American Tierra Louise 553 Thompson to 171 lot Fed Sav Melba D Lewis etux to 983 Alin 134 State Sav A Lon Lindsey B Easier otux Ivie Thompson Bradford to Ronald L Loan Bnpire Investment 351 to Valley Bank to f Mlleter etux 136 Margaret H Parsons William E Buchanan 345 975 032 Powell to Holmstrom etux Cleo 329 XPK to Quinn etux R etux VanKcmen Edward Ralph Konopka 531. Ninth Federal Savings to David Ray Quarnborg etux to Sav Buffalo Savings Bank"" 2576 Amerlcm Equity to Corporation, Partial rel- - 9lB 2576 Deseret Fed Sav 327 429 America, . . . f to Joseph 61326 - TURNKEY DEVELOPMENT INC., 175 8 Main St. SLC; Maurice E. Gregory, 1012 N. Cole Rd. Bolae Ida; Melva F. Gregory, aaae addreaa; E. Thoapaon, 415 N. Cola Rd. Bolae Ida; conetructlon and land December statute Prudential Ins The Bart P 999 Stewart etux Foaa Lewi a It Sona Construction Co. , a Utah Corporation, Plaintiff and Heapondrnt, Firat Federal 522 tal tux to Sav etux VanXoman to Arthur Utah 326 H developaent Jerry S Young Oil Workers Cr to Calvin Spencer etux Atlanta Georgia; In The Supreme Court Of The State Of Utah Ov Release of Mortgages' North-cree- k, I, Bart F mtge 308 ' First Federal 913 CO 61329 615 Nevhouse Bldg. IQ Exchange Place, SLC; V. L. Keeler, Jr.M. 2606 E. 6200 S. SLC; Devere Watkins, 1895 S. 775 E. Bntfl; Dale Jay Curtis, 2830 S. 11 E. SLC; ranching operation etux to Cecil Construction 3715 Northalde Parkway, City; real eatate - MOTEL FUNDING, J Jtmiaon atux to jsms H'BodaH to to 906 Western Sav md Loan L- - 911 296 M. PETROLEUM to Bank etux Valley Bank mid Truet Richard F Andaraon atux CORF. KILLEBREW-SDMSNI- ' 93 175 S. Main St. SLC; Frad C. Aah, 1600 Pacific Ava. Dallas Texas ; buy and, a laughter livestock EQUITY K. R. 61324 C0RP., 175 S. Main St. SLC; S. E. Wlddoea, 100 W. 10 St. Wilmington Dela; W, J. Relf, aaae addreaa; J, L, Rivera, aaae addryea; general oil and gaa bualneaa 6 61319 AMERICAN ROAD Robert S. Olaon, The Aaerican Road, Dearborn Mich; J, C, Deai, eana addraaa; C. A. Glaub, lane addreaa; W. H. Guinn, aaaa addreaa; J. A, Janaaa, aaaa addreaa; G. W. Malone, aaaa addreaa; 61317 - CAPRI SALONS, INC.y 564 N. 6 E. Brlghaa City; Glen P. Jenaen, 564 N. 6 E. Brlghaai City; Ruth W. Jenaen, 564 .8. REALTY, - CORF,, lvern Ava. SLC; Robert E. Davla, 2155 Oliver Circia, SLC; Beverly B. .Davla, 2155 Oliver Circle SLC; Mar tale Davfa, aaaa addra- BRIGHAM II LTV WILSON ca - - - 61328 148 Stan Meyrlck, 417 S. Nebo, Fk; Dan V. White, 269 E. N. Sp. Fk; Eduard L. White E. 900 N. Sp. Fk; 61318 - 61322 - SWEC0, INC., 175 S. Mein St, SLC; Horace G. Miller 17 Berkeley Square, LA Calif; George W. Cleaaon, 1700 S. Victoria LA Calif; W. A. Jen-kln- a, SPANISH FORK TRANSPO- ELCO METAL PRODUCT 175 S. Main SC. SLC; Richard Asar, PO Box 1808 Santa Fa, Nee Mexico; Charlea J. Jelllcoe, PO Box 1808 Santa Fa. New Mexico; Albino E. Castillo, PO Box 1808 Santa Fa. Mew Mexico; Denver Colo; INC., 430 Judge Bldg. SLC; Steven F, Ovnby, 8635 S. 7 E. Sandy; Dale John Habb. 90 V. Fayella Ave. Murray Lauren M. Beaaley, 430 Judge - 61327 C0RPal FACIKIC STEREO NUMBER THREE, INC., 2198 S. Highland Dr. SLC; Jerry Hlchola, 7805 Creat. Dr. Lakewood, Colo; Donna Hlchola, aaaa addreaa; Carolyn Bruce, 5621 W. 14 Ave. UFACTURING, 61316 INC., Suita 334 Beneficial Life Bldg. 57 V. S, Taaple, 61310 61313 - CHANGE, INC., 950 24th St. Ogdan; Hllllea L. Allan, 59 Ogdon Canyon, Ogden; Evlyn B. Allan, aaaa addraaa; Nopl 133 V. 2800 S. Bntfl . (XU, , 3387 LUMENS Clrela, ; 1332 Harvard ave. SLC; Richard Carling, 1075 Alton Way, SLC; Stephen Trotter, 1268 E. 5500 S. S. Ogden; narchandlaa J. ra pairing CCU.. 201 MANUFACTURING ' Varda Dr. IIC; alarm syatsaa DEVBLOnUI U.SR to .104 Zions Sav A Loan to E Garth Kaufman otux to 790 to Murray lot' Thrift Murray 1st Thrift R G R Hilton etux 0 Hilton etux 835 Bank Central Savings to Glad Christensen 839 Aipirs Invest Oorp atux to Practical Dwellings 857 Patricia 8 Under- etal to Jay Zabrlakle etux wood 879 P W R Red Bldg A Loan Meyer etux to |