OCR Text |
Show I I THE DAILY RECORD PAGE FOUR, 606 Joseph L Staley 3576 Acone Street to Zlons First Nat Bank etux Christensen etux, 7879 South Deer E Creek Road, to Prud Fed Savings $25000.00 $24800.00 611 Burton D Allred 4853 West 4535 South Daniel 964 etux to Prud Fed Savings $25700.00 614 Qary John Noes etux 7354 South 1420 East to Prud Fed Savings $30950.00 616 Scott R Warner etux 6283 Grlnada Drive to 621 Richard Wolfley etux 1321 Varden Way to Zlons First Nat Bank $4100.00 Tracy Mortgage, Tracy Collins Bank $26500.00 to United Savings, Abs Title Utah $24300.00 and 970 Norman Adam Bauer etux 4190 Ottawa Drive to Western Mortgage, Utah Title & Prud Fed Savings $45000.00 2574647 United Homes 2574 South Redwood Road 968 Rand E Stewart etux 1325 East Pioneer Street Abs. $22400.00 980 Louis Benassl etux, 975 East 6600 South to Valley Bank and Trust $4129.92 990 Herbert R Harper etux 1136 South 500 East to to United Savings, Utah and Abs $18000.00 $31350.00 Wm etux 6025 Paprika Circle to United Savings, McGhle Land Title, $20500.00 992 10486 Utah Title 686 995 Brian K West etux, 4168 Hopl Drive to United John Michael Hornsby N Larry Cvitkovlch etux, 2767 West 6135 South to United Savings, McGhle Land Title $22000.00 688 Dennis W Wlebe 6015 Paprika Circle, etux to Henry Page etux Carnation Drive, Sandy to Warr Construction and Abs $2500.00 UTah Savings, Abs $23100.00 Title Edwards etu: 690 Darrell John Parry etu 3621 Coats Drive to Valley 564 East Hilo Street, Sandy Bank and Trust $17600.00 to United Savings, McGhle Land Title $21950.00 020 Stephen L MacDonald etux, 3600 Mlllcreek Road tc 711 Terry L Nelson etux Valley Bank and Trust 3551 Acona Street to First $4500.00 B Federal Sav $21000.00 726 Leonard D Benson etux 2777 Wanda Way to Prud Fed Savings $3630Q.00 729 Dieter K Hein etux 1349 East 8225 South, Sandy to Utah C V Federal Cr, First Security 734 Bank $17000. Ross Brent Ashworth etux, 6016 Paprika Circle, to United Savings, McGhle Land Title $16900.00 735, 737, 739, 741, 743 Melby Trayner Dev, P.O. Box 17377 to Prud Fed Savings: $24300; $26850.00 $25500.00; $25500.00 $25000.00 all 762 Richard H Barlow etux 3450 East 3020 South to Tracy Collins Bank $18400.0 Draper to Draper 101 103 Agencj . Title 94800.00 Hounand Harold H Prescott 108 Ernest L Waldroup 4599 Highland' Drive to etu Western Sav and Loan $31050.00 122 Midwest Construction, 2827 Scranton Drive, West Jordan, to Western Mortgage, Security Title Jr. etux, 2113 West 7125 South, West Jordan to First Sec St Bank, Blacks G Jorgenson $25000.00 John Leontrez Romero James 0 etux, 1030 West 500 South to Prud Fed Savings 084 Richard J Thomas etux 3597 Cree-Drivto Zlons First Nat Bank $20950.00 099 Kenneth $4100.00 Kearns, to Commonwealth 090 & etux, 1240 West 7740. So. to Prud Fed Savings Kent Edward Zwahlen etux 4153 West 4990 South, 075 Title Ins Bank Trust $5078.18 Ins-Agenc- dba Amfac, $19600.00 123 Midwest Construct!'.);: 3549 Scranton Drive to East 12300 South, etux $16400.00 Western Mortgage, $16400.00 Securil-Titl, 124 Midwest Construction 6490 South Dixie to Western Mortgage Doan, Security Title $16400.00 125 Midwest 3815 Sumpter Construct Drive, to . 1-- , Western Mortgage Loan, Secufl.rty Title $16400. 0: 126 Midwest Construction , 3833 Sumpter Drive to Western Mortgage Loan, Security Title $16400.00 127 Midwest Construction. 6452 South Dixie Drive to Western Mortgage, Security Title $16400.00 In The Supreme Court Of The State Of Utah THe State of Utah Plaintiff and Respondent, No. 13297 v. FILED December 14, 1973 Richard Dale Young, Defendant and Appellant. L. M. Cummings, Clerk TUCKETT. Justice: Jordan, to Mortgage Ins. United Sav and Loan, McGhle Utah Title and Abs. $17150. Land Title $21600.00 Vern 1533 South 6th East to Commonwealth dba Amfac, Title $18400.00 1971 and 999 Kenneth D Allen etux, 3540 West 8360 South, West 2575003 Trust Deeds Lele Falo etux, '2123 Title 991 Wm Henry Page etux 668 Richard Corso etux 4040 West 5950 South to 1715 East 8060 South, Sandy Western Mortgage, Utah Title to Home Benefit Savings and Abs $18000.00 684 672 WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 2R, 029 Alfred J Cosson etux 9494 Poppy Lane to Murray icay " Lewi 036 Robert D Solomon etu 1220 Redwood Road to Commercial Credit Plan, Sec Title $8686.20 Defendant was tried in the District Court of Salt Lake County on a charge of robbery. The jury returned a verdict of guilty and the defendant was thereafter sentenced by the court to serve not less than five years in the Utah State Prison. From the verdict and judgment of the court defendant appeals. On April 8, 1972, the Center Theater at Salt Lake City, Utah, was During the late evening hours theater manager, Paul Widdis, the cashier, Ann Bischoff, assistant manager, David Benzon, and the doorman, Steven Fellows, were in the theater office. The day's receipts were being counted when there was a knock at the door which was answered by Benzon. When Benzon opened the door a man armed with a gun entered and ordered Widdis to get on his hands and knees and to face the safe. A second man entered the office and was identified by Mr. Benzon as being the defendant, Richard Dale Young. At lineup held on April 11, Benzon stated that he was unable to identify the defendant as being present at the. Center Theater on April 8. Durixfg the trial the court permitted the prosecutor to examine Benzon on extrajudicial conversations he had with a police officer, and the prosecutor was' also permitted to ask Benzon leading questions over the objection of the defendant. robbed. 04l Joseph R Thompson Jr 965 South Spruce. St. JP Zlons First Nat Bank $3584.00 etux, 042 Nancy R Castleton Thompson 1881 East 3825 South, to Zlons Bank $1850.00 First Nat 043 Harold I Cowley etux, 3470 South 335 East to Zlons First Nat Bank $5687.40 Wlckel etux Street, Sandy to Zlons First Nat Bank $27823.20 815 Robert P Carlisle etux 2834 Wanda Way to Walker Bank and Trsut $60000.00 044 Barry 9480 David 819 Klaus D Schmitt etux 95000 So. 1400 Sandy & to Walker Bank East, Trust 046 Bruce M Weyland 3415 Eastwood BRive, Zlons First Nat Bank $60000.00 $4912.56 820 John A Hlppan etux, 2797 East 3400 Sout to Walker Bank $60000.00 070 R Emerito B etux to Manglinong etux, 1142 West Dalton to Commonwealth dba Amfac Title Ins Agency $18100.00 SpeatiM olflLe, Jguy." Benzon testified that prior to the robbery he had had conversations where the defendant and others were present during which Benzon stated that it would be easy to rob the theater. Prior to the lineup Benzon had told the police that the defendant was one of those involved in the robbery. Benzon also testified that he had known the defendant for about five years. In view of the prior inconsistent statements and conduct on the part of Benzon it was not error for the court to permit the prosecutor to examine him about prior extrajudicial conversations and to ask the witness lead- ing questions. n The record indicated that a sum in excess of $7,7'00 was taken from the theater in the robbery. Over the objection of the defendant the prosecutor was permitted to show that the defendants few days after the robbery paid a bank loan which was in arrears with ten and twenty dollar bills, and that he paid off the loan to a finance company which was not then due. The prosecutor also adduced evidence to show that the defendant had purchased home appliances amounting to several hundred dollars. While the prosecution did not lay a foundation which would tend to show the defendant's financial status prior to the robbery, nevertheless, where the evidence shows that the perpetration of the crime would as the natural consequence tend to improve the financial condition of the perpetrator, the sudden acquisition of money by a defendant may be shown even though the money cannot be identified. The defendant countered by testifying that the money came from 1. Rules 20 and 63 (1) Utah Rules of Evidence; 71 A. L. R. 2d 449. in inheritance received by his wife. The defendant urgently contends that the identification of the defen-Udr- it was unsatisfactory, and that due to the nature of the testimony on that aspect of the case the court erred in failing to direct a verdict of not guilty. It would appear from the record that a person involved in the robbery was disguised to a certain extent, and there were certain discrepancies in the testimony concerning that person's physical characteristics. Nevertheless, Benzon, who had known the defendant for a period of five years, testified that the defendant was one of the two men involved in the crime. Identification by a single witness who had known the defendant for a considerable period of time is sufficient identification to overcome the defendant's objection. 1 We are of the opinion that the verdict and judgment of the court are amply supported by the record, and we find no grounds on which to base a reversal. The judgment of the court below is affirmed. WE CONCUR : E. R. Callister, Jr., Chief Justice F. Henri Henriod, Justice IT 15 ILLEGAL TO WALK UOWN THE STREETS OF LMRENCEVU1E,PEWNA, AFTER SUNDOWN WITHOUT CARRYING A LIGHTED CANDLE. A. H. Ellett, Justice J. Allan Crockett, Justice a 2. State v. Crowder, 114 Utah 202, 197 P. 2d 917; State v. Anderson, Kan.' 52, 446 P. 2d 844. 3. People v. Ikerd, 26 111. 2d 573, 188 N. E. 2d 12. 202 r t 1 Mr |