OCR Text |
Show VWli wryw Hfl a I I? TNI FOUR RICORR tAILY 198 4800 J. 199 No. fJ186 FILED July v. Utah State Road Commie lion, Defendant and Respondent. 4800 - equip 10, 1973 - 307 - Jays Smith 3299 Meadow City Co Inc; e4Ulp Air Inc; equip Llqd - Michael Plaintiffs commenced this action to recover damages allegedly caused to their property on the northwest corner of the intersection of 100 South and 1100 East streets in St. George, by the construction of an underpass of highwhich lowered the grade, and impaired access to the property from way 100 South Street. The court granted defendants motion to dismiss. Plaintiffs 217 - Michael G. Hood, 7767 Jo Ann Dr Sndy to Dial Fin Co; hhg 1-- 15, 218 - Robert D. White, 345 E. Leslie SLC to dlol Fnan Co; appeal. There is no taking of property involved in this action. The law has long been established in this State that under those circumstances there can be no recovery from the State for damages because the construction of a highway may has impair or adversely affect the convenience of access to property. Sufficientand .. we it that think of con this and unnecessary to the been said as subject pro 1 undesirable to extenuate thereon, but refer to the adjudicated cases. hhg Plaintiffs do not contest the validity of those cases, but contend that the Governmental Immunity Act. Ch. 139, S. L.U. 1965 (codified as Secs. to 34, U.C.A. 1953) should now be construed as permitting the maintenance of U.C.A. 1953: such an action. Reliance is placed specifically on Sec. Trst Co; equip boat 377 - Excel Corp., Inc., 154 E. 7th S. SLC to Fetsers Sit Lake Cabinet; machn Frst Hatnl ... Bk; tire Co; equip 383 - Donald A McDonald, 2681 S. 360 E. SLC to BIC Lns; conasff gds Corp, to Zions 388 - boat Marion Willey A Son, Inc. S. Main Bntfl to Frd Mrktlng Corp; equip 256 1800 268 - Saveway Trlr Sales, 4125 S. State SLC to Zions 275 - Thomas M. price, 2609 W. 2100 H. SLC to Hatnvd Fin Corp Corp of Ut; couch - Gary C. Lund, 942 S. 8th to Duce Sprting Gds Inc; E. SLC equip 121 Utah 324, 241 P.2d 907; Fairclough v. Salt Lake County, 10 Utah 2d 10 Utah 2d 100, 349 417, 354 P. 2d 105; Springville Banking Company v. Burton, Investment Anderson 2d 368 13 P.2?d P.2d 585; Utah 65, State Parker, Turner. 21 Utah et aL, - Don K. Robinson, 433 Bradley Way Sndy to Duce Sprting Gds Inc; boat 4- - - J. Emer Gds - Gerald R. Barber, 3950 S. 4th E. SLC to intrlk Thrft; tv 177 Hen line, 4389 Lrkvd St. 098 - Harold A. Csss, 4460 W. 4865 S. Kras to Vly Bk & Trst Co; boat 110 - Deseret Leasing Co, 431 S. 3rd E. SLC to Frst Hatnl Bk of Denver; equip Bishop St. Grngr to Mry Frst Thrft & Ln Co; hh furn - Douglas L. Orr, 3838 W. Cntry Sqirs Dr. W. Jrdn to Ntn vide Finan Crp; hhg 111 - Jerry B. Carlson, 4914 Mandan Ave SLC to Vly Bk - George E. Pritchett, S. 4300 W. Grngr to Mry Frst Thrft A Ln co; hhg 099 Karen Ssley, 2450 S. SLC to Natnwd Fin Corp; E. cons or gds 100 9th - VastachElectric, 1574 S. V. Temple SLC to Rck Wrnr Frd; 101 equip - Wastch Electro, 1574 S. V. Temple SLC to ?rck Wrnr Frd; equip 103 - Karl 0. Wiberg, 865 E. 4125 S.SLC to BIC Lns; consmr 102 to Deseret leasin Co; gds & Trst 179 - Robert W. 127 - Serosystems Mfg. Corp, 955 W. Way - Joyca Rappleys, 5241 S. 5160 W. Krns to City Fin Co; - Allen David Taylor, 6508 Hickory La. SLC to Zions Frst 141 - Richard M. Taggart, 2155 E. 3715 S. SLC to Frst 3rd E. SLC to Sit Lake Empl Crdt bn; tv 106 - Ave. KUTV SLC Inc, 179 Social Hal to Frst Secur Bk of Ut equip - Harold Eire St. hhg SLC D. to Morrell, 444 Amrcn Fin Corp . 108 - Brent L. Hilton, 4446 V. 4835 S. Krns to Hatnvd Fin Corp; consmr gds of Ut; boat - Empire West, Inc., 5th E. 4800 S. Mry to - Douglas V. Ferguson, 1S51 E. 4500 S. Holliday to Hatnl Fin Co of Mry; furn The Lomas 189 - Harvey W. Eckman 100 S. 100 E. Sndy A Assoc, to Frst SecurBk; equip & E. 9800 S. Sndy to Commrcl Crdt - J. Johnson, 49 E. 4160 8. to Utah Marmon Trk Sales Inc; inven 194 Mettle ton Co; equip 175 - Lawrence M. Miller, 2557 Fin Inc; hhg 187 - Barry J. Shoda , 8755 S. 1540 E. Sndy to Plonr Dodge Centr Inc; empr Inc, 155 Reed Mgna 188 S. Youngdell, The Shervln E Bntfl to 100 Williams Co; equip 172 to Duce Sprting Gds Inc; - J. W. SLC Johnson, 49 E. 4160 S . SLC to Utah Marmon Trek Sales Inc inven 195 W. Trst; SLC to Centry Accept Cor 407 - Carma L. Smith, 368 SLC 1st to Centry Accept Corp1 consmr gds 408 M. Trst; - James Earl Thomas, 1866 Star Dr, SLC to Centry Accpt Corp; hhg 409 - Radix Corp, 1380 W. H. Temple SLC to Datapolnt Corp; empr equip Bk machn 411 - Sophia 175 Martinss, 548 W. Centrl Fin Co; to H.Laytn hh furn 288 , 290 815 Mry 135 - William G. Bain, 2177 S Bonne w Dr. Bntfl to Bettllyn Mr t gage Ln Co; furn 171 - SLC 183 gds - Robert L. Curts, 3460 S. - Russell Beck, 2585 Hemstd - Joe B. Racheco, 2963 Banbury Rd. SLC to Tracy Clns Bk A Trst Co; equip Sndy to Frd Mtr Crdt Co; 184 - Copper Golf Club, to Leasing Inc; eulp 105 280 Boat, 2284 to (entry Accept M. 406 - David Coon, 1604 E. Ave. - Stephen L. Bray, 225 Carol Way Mdvl to Tracy. Clns - Launa Foots, 2118 Lorlta 129 - Romany Engineering & Mfg. Co, Box 15657 SLC to Cincinnati Mllacron Co; machn Secur Inc; equip 287 gds S. Temple fLC to Cine in Bk 7165 Gds A hhg Hatnl Bk; equip Jarvis, to Duce Sprting W. SLC 285 - Mor ley Sprague, 4933 S 1065 E. SLC to Tracy Cl ns - Paul L. Heuctt, 6995 S. Columbia Dr. S. Jrdn to Mry Frs Thrft ALn Co; hh furn 182 ! J96 - M. Douglas McGavin, 154 S. 2375 W. SLC to Homemakers FI Ser Inc; ensmr gds 17th S. equip 181 W 393 - Jerry C. Crofts, 9409 Streatham Rd. Sndy to Homemkrs Fin Serv; consmr gds consmr gds 180 112 - Stephen L. McKees, 1134 Diamond Way Sndy to Vly Bk A Trst Co; orgn - Donald 6. Vickery, 567 1600 N. V. Bntfl to Dial Fin Co of Bntfl; boat to Duce Sprting - Dennis V. S. 1700 Bk A 126 SLC Inc; boat 3676 McCardle, Mllacron Co; equip 104 279 3175 piano Co; 3500 S. W. 082 - Clark A. Leavitt, 1841 V. 2770 S. SLC to Gcnrl Crdt Co; hhg SLC 392 - Robert Darling, 1346 W Prkvay Ave. SLC to Gcnrl Elect Crdt Corp; equip 405 - Lawrence W. 3650 S. SLC Corp; hhg William L. Yonker, 5246 278 Financing Statements 109 tretr 277 ?.rSeeVEmeav!?&W,6Hit2k2fd8vk2Vi;,Sheffieldv. 2d 314, 445 P.2d 367. Virginia St - - Lorraine Purdy, 846 S. 276 Hawk, 239 to Frd Mtr Crdt Co; 391 - Charles A. Treadwell, 3620 Welllngtn SLC to Zales Jevlrs Corp; ring- 11th E. SLC to Hatnvd Fin Corp of Ut; stero WE CONCUR: - Hal 389 Inc; equip - Garth Dean, 116 J E. 1st 8, SLC to Ardell Brovan Auto Sales; empr 273 274 Continental Associates Industries, 660 Bllllnes, SLC to Quality Accept Corp; eulp 390 - Graphic Service A Supply Inc, 154 E. 7th S. P.0. Box 11253 SLC to Brandjen A Kluge Frst Matnl Bk; equip Costs to defendant (respondent). to Desert Leasin 381 - Jerrold R. Morgan, 555 E. 4th S. SLC to Desert Leasing - H. D. Landes, 5357 Ctnwd La. SLC to Frst Secur Bk of i Ut; boat 255 - Hu Trent Elec 45 W. 200 H. Bntfl W.Mgna Co; equip. 253 63-30- -3 Affirmed. S. 9150 Hatnl Bk; boat In considering the possible application of die foregoing statute to the proof the Act express-l- y blem presented here it is pertinent to note that Sec. provides for the continuance of sovereign immunity "except as may be otherthe wise provided in this act . . . for any injury which may result from " intention an indicate to seems This function. a of exercise governmental that the act be strictly applied to preserve sovereign immunity; and to waive it 6 only as clearly expressed therein. It is our opinion that reading Section in the light of that rule, the waiver of immunity from suit "for the recovery of any property real or personal or for the possession thereof" cannot be construed to include an action of this character to recover damages for inconvenience of access' to property, nor as changing the law as set forth in the cases cited herein. Disposition of this case as set forth above renders it unnecessary to other contentions. Elden E. Krauss, 2812 380 - David Dodart, 1811 Laurelhurst SLC to The Frst involved. ... - Material Handling Equip SLC to Vly A Trst co; equip 248 pro-per- ty - Gerald Valdes, 516 S. 8th to Westside Catholic; SLC tv Co, 3450 S. 2nd V. Immunity from suit of all governmental entities is waived for the recovery of any property real or personal or for the possession thereof or to quiet title thereto, or to foreclose mortgages or other liens thereon or to determine any adverse claim thereon, or secure any adjudication touching any mortgage or otheclien said entity may have or claim on the 327 - Donald C. Bernson, 610 Medical Arts Bldg SLC to Zions Frst Hatnl Bk; equip E. 236 - Riggs Bout Hu Kars, Inc. 2634 S. State SLC to Vly Bk A Bk 312 - Robert D. Giles, 611 S. Main Bntfl to BIC Lns; hh furn 376 Co; hhg 6, Serv; consmr gds Hatnl Bk; equip - Richard gtraley, 1860 Sprlngvw Dr. SLC to Dial Fin 63-30- -1 63-30-- to Avco Flnan Way SLC Supernal 328 - Robert A. Barth, 2817 W. 7268 S. W. Jrdn to Zions Frst 219 237 Constrctn Co, to Amid Machn - Lawrence Jenkins, 8437 308 H. Morrison, 7767 Jo Ann Dr . Sndy to Dial Fin Co; hhg Justice; Indstrl Fin Tvn .306 - Janes L. Cutler, 7161 8. 2155 E. SLC to Drpr Bk A Trst; snvnbl 200 - Hockey Mtn. Refectory, 2436 W. 1540 8. Andrew SLC to L. M. Cummings, Clerk to SLC Co; hhg - Darwin A. Jones, 2220 E. 8. SLC to Llqd Air Inc; 216 CROCKETT. 8th S. - Rickey L.klca, 2220 E. 8. SLC to Hsehld yin Corp; equip Andrew Holt and Hilma E. Holt, hia wife; et al. , Plaintiffs and Appellants, july U,i7i flNANCING STATEMENTS Jn The Supreme Court Of The State Of Utah 107 'Wednesday, . T-- A 291 - Country Carpets, Inc. 1962 W. 3500 S. SLC to KFT 420 - Russell W. Simmons, 1240 H. 14th W. SLC to Mry Frst Thrf A Ln Co; items furn 293 - Utah Waste Paper Co, 738 W. s. Temple SLC to MR 427 - James E Walker, 4135 4715 S. Krns to Avco Flnan Serv; consmr gds W. Leasing; equip 295 - El Farol Dride 7223 S. State SLC to Inn, State St. - Mark Hedman, 1729 Rchrds to Tvn Indstrl Fin SLC Co; hhg 300 Elm - Bill Pappas, 4722 Aspen Avco Flnan Serv; La. 429 SLC to consmr gds - Albert E. Covdell,.325 St. Mdvl to Tun Indatrl Fin Co; hhg' 302 - Sharon S. Rosemsn, 4666 Mamba Way Mry to Avco Flnan Serv; consmr gds 428 Electronics Inc; equip 299 - Marvin Eldon Olsen, 199 Imperial St. SLC to Zions Frst Hatnl Bk; copr 418 Ln Co; consmr gi Mrtgage Corp; jr., Serv Inc; equip - 0. Herman Veblqngsnes, Silver Shadv Dr. SLC to Frst Thrft 412 - Steven D. Pedrosa 1298 H 50 E. Orem to Avco Flna - Steven R. Hall, 1467 I 430 - Dlno D lament 1, 93 Locst St . Helpr to Office Equip Co; 9 equip H. t- - |