OCR Text |
Show LIGHT PRINTJ1 PAGE TUESDAY, AUGUST 29, 1972 THE DAILY RECORD FOUR Suits In The Supreme Court Of Hie State Of Utah The Rogue, a nonprofit corporation. Plaintiff and Appellant, - industrial Conmisslon 46217 VS -- FILED August 9, 1972 The Utah Liquor Control Commission of the State of Utah and Sharp M. Larsen, F. Gerald Irvine, and Norma Giles Thomas, constituting the members of said Commis'sion, Defendants and Respondents. L. M. Cummings, Clerk vs CLARENCE MARSHALL CLARENCE MARSHALL; - Supreme Health Stud. Natl Health Stud, . the relevant facta in question are nor u, . dn-'puti- H. MORGAN AND MRS. BILL KELLER 5tai'-niT.t- r 46225 Robert Melvin Acocka. etux to Ziona, $5000. 230 Wentworth. 777 David L. Gregory etux ie to Miller b Viele; $350-0Land Title, Mc-Gh- 0. 1391 E. 8685 S. - Capitol Loan Co. vs E. CLARENCE BOYCE AND MARGARET 780 note Pltf$261.32; BOYCE; - Western Surety Co. vs JOHN F. NIELSEN; Plt $123.50; $57.75; note - Karen D. Bone 11 RALPH MOFFAT AND JEFF M. 46227 781 vs AND - Peoples Finance SL PAUL vs FILIP DAVID S. DYKMAN; & 784 Dermont L. Porterfield etux to 1st Sec. St. Bk; McGhie, $3 5800. 8418 Supernal. 794 Bartley K. Curtis etux to Utah Mtge Loan; Mc- Thr LUNDEEN Pltf - Calvin Johnson dba Johnson Collection Agency vs JERRALD SEVY; urge that by thus amending the statute the Legislature manifested a clear intention that the matter of zoning should be left entirely to the local authorise ., that the Liquor Commission should have no concern therewith, and that it in authority in giving concern to that matter in connection with it.- deml ol the pi i '.mill's application. It seems to us that the plaintiff has attempted to invert the meaning of that statute. Ihe fact that re in violation of it prohibits the Liquor Commission from locating a liquor l .u iucal zoning ordinance does not m-.the !.urai!ii?.'.',i innot take into consideration the matter ol zoning and the reaEons thereto i sn determining ifl appears where liquor stores should lc I'.ii'.ud. Nor does it !n?;,ri, to contend, that whenever proposed tore is nut n; with zoning ordinances the Liquor Oommi: - ion mu-- ; nti c - rily ,ppl :.alion. By parallel reasoning, the law dues r.nt require that whenever the county commis-- t ion has given its approval n3cfai a the county is lonccu jm d it becomes mandatory upon the Liquor Commission to grniit the application, it seems obvious that it tins wen- iht law, the Liquor Commission would be deprived of the authority confer led upon by Sec. 32-. . the number 6(b) to Deri and location of the islu-an': puvi igi at, ia !u be in the state." Plt$164.94 Ghie, $17800. 2373 Cava- $71.64; agreement - Calvin Johnson dba Johnson Collection Agency vs JAY C. LITTLE; Pltf$149.61 $66.53; unpaid bal lier. 46230 ex.-eede- 806 James E. McConkey etux to Murray 1st Thrift; Kay Lewis, $3204. 4461 Renardo. 808 Joe A. Martinez etux to Murray 1st Thrift; Kay Lewis, $3888. 4162 W. 4570 S. t - '.lu pr;.;. Liquor Counii.- In submitting '- - to the opinion that it asserts is solely a qu. ;.o., i,i - ;i- -- -- "will not ,! rely upon a tr.i.n-iiof the proceedings before tie: 'ru : xt the raordm justify try 'onifi, tiff to ill!V.' thlt the .II I' o; : nr urns and nrli.'r.u. o i.ipm , w-i- eedingi, we i s:h Hiding ihi- - i- -l ! ri'Vi-hr i it- i ;t r r, - opni.-i- i ; , . rim : i. i 823 and $19000 3443 S 830 693 1 . rn-i- i -h .s ir, d i vs i n. t rrltic 'ari'-t- 1 1 oi-- i t h u1. or i 1 v of ir i'i . Di'l'T'c 1, I he d i A- t r - .I . - . i i ir. or. i s i f Mi'ii-r- ; iti'i - ,imI , i". : t? 5 H. irv niainus in the state as rn I, dl i'i dd a control actions of :,! Is . - ind rlni'u1!, uth" ar-i- - 700 l ci'SFary to carry into a general control them give 'vruv I u within their respective jurisdictions"; and we held lliat the lib J.dd 30k, wln-rcinot curtnil or limit th c onstitutional authu (.alJistor, Jr,, Chief .Iu' L. Tuckett. Justice K. R. it Jack C. Pferdener et ux to Fimer C. Pferd ner; Pioneer Title Ins. $30,000. 8130 Viscoun-t- i. . H. 703 A . f. Id-- ' M. Imct t f McGhie, $48000. 1389 Canterbury. Felix Fratto etux to Prud. Fed. Sav. $21, 100, 2786 844 Downs. Glenn E, Jessop etux to Prud. Fed. Sav. $23,200. 5482 Avalon. i. 853 Chad E, Ball etux to Home Benefit Sav. $16600. 3998 Kecuane. Thoma s Richard Garri ga etux to Prud. Fed. Sav. $23850. 72 Ami. Whentomcone needt legal help, he tee a lawyer, right 1 When YOU need COLLECTION help... tee a PROFESSIONAL F. Hi'nri IJenriud, .lustir.i J Bernard L. Huelskamp etux to 1st Sec. St. Blq 842 W. m a prup- r ri .".o, w.d 836 Merrill D. Kolan etux to The Lomas b Nettle ton; Utah Title and Abs $21300. 4505 S. 4920 1. 1 - 1 697 ' f nut SS Ut ih 4 ' d", I 'Jo. . Sterling Sagers etux to Walker Bank b Trust, $12500, 767 Fremont. ( v. Jd-- i 1 jil.irf-- r ca3e, irrespective b sec Sec. 7 of id. U.C.A. Stc. 1953). ..it . . .The District ( our ts . . . shall have power t"i",v - rt - I,1 o i ii Lout: iri.-il- , I Limi'ii 'loi.in.! v. Audi Andi-rsr-I 1 uili-nu- r .. ! ' . . . , 11 to '.s.t'jr i - ion " i ' sni .'A n r l - v. S i n i r c! : ! r.c (nurt Watkin5. to b. ;s powrof nroviriion? ;'iiii(! V i ot l" ic-'i-t ATI's 'ill ci oi ' stun:.- - to bn known as state . - 4. Shih Chih Shen etux to st Fed. Sav. $25500. 9055 S. 3500 E. 834 1 1 - Rodney J. Hutchings Spartan. . Affirmed. Mu .''ckJ. r." Tutdh Vr! fV 57 pVrMiUL i. Lhrip. M. 5. . J.L 1. f vi'huh pruvidr Sf: nl.su Sue. ' i;iv by tin liquir stores ii.- Mis'idercd advisable for b - ip- of lirpiur State etux to Prud. Fed. Sav. $21150. 8718 S. do not warrant thcref-ir- Exquisite Home Bldrs to Ut. Mtge Loan; McGhie, I have been considered but are not , ) Carl M, Newell etux to Walker Bank & Trust, $20,000. 1062 E. 21st S. U 1.- , dm o q t i .p'J.I the pj il .lai its authority, ' uscript of the pro- 5 ie iy the court. r" : - 'lu puiie-- b; ' i: ! ( : e ' hi! Other point: thjt thev would u .. o- s . j 821 no ti an .vcnpl in order to i; :,r , "( ' , ; ir1 : ! lapb ot ini's the plaint 'll ,( j - ir . :L John E. Runyan etux to Ut. Bank b Trust, $5000. 190 E. 3200 S. bi .j1 i.,-,- 810 - - a'ii: W, Owen to Murray 1st Thrift; Kay Lewis, $2484. 3854 S. 807 pl-nr- u-- Barbara 6620 W. -- 1 Ent. to Ut. Mtge 46229 now gr-.r.- K Melvin B. Peterson etux to Valley Bank, $6, 970.80. 3 3 21 Melbourne. $220.99; $85.00; note - -- Jb Ent. to Ut. Mtge 782 auto damages 46228 Co. o K McGhie, $18400. 7573 S. State. Pltf$180.31; $25.00 MOFFAT; Jb McGhie, $17650. 7573 S. State. 46226 6, Harvey L. Chrptens en etux to Valley Bank, $22,000. 2833 Tiills-de- n. 767 due $196.95; $85.00; note or-m- Plaintill 761 46224 - Metropolitan Finance Co. vs RANDY L. FISHER; Plt 1 ..r- $143.72; bal Plt$384.00; Richleigh H. Gilliat etux to Western Sav. $30,000. 9777 Alta-mou- BILL JERALD C. HERBERT AND MRS. HERALD C. HERBERT 1 . AND MRS. Walter G. Vande Vee gaeta etux to 1st Sec. Bk; Sec. Title, $23, nt. vs as lu defendant's The argument made by the plaintiff is that denial of plaintiffs upplu it ion it made reference to matters pertaining to the nature of the neighborhood, and the effects to be anticipated from so locating a liquor store, the (..ormnimion transgressed its authority in considering questions relating to zoning and that therefore its denial of the application was of Salt Lake derives fic-- the capricious and arbitrary. This argument 1 tV.1 and the action of State Legislature County v. Liquor Control Commission, e ci-a over the involved That thereto. subsequent dispute luihority of the of a to violation a locale Commission in store Liquor liquor cuunty zoning ordIJ.C.A. 1953, having inance. It was held that the state statute. Sec. .'inti location of the to the decide number Commission given p'eniry power oidin-in. nee took over Subsequent to county zoning liquor stores, precedi ' that decision the Legi cture saw fit to eliminate the toilin' by amending that section, 32-6(b), by .idding the provision: "that a state store or package not shall be located in violation ot any valid oi (finance of any agency . 754 47223 - Supreme Health Stud. Inc. dba Natl Health Stud, to-w- it or county H. bal due Pltf$92.50;bal due KELLER; ' liree 850 . 4688 S. 2080 W. ROBERT - Dermatology Assoc vs 46222 quired to issue petitioner plaintiff club a liquor locker permit and to establish a State liquor store in its the Salt premises because the local authorities, Lake County Commission, approved of the granting to petitioner such a license and the establishment of a store on its premises. town 751 ROBERT Plts$72.25; MORGAN; v 32-1-- - Winder Dairy vs 46221 and the matter should be resolved aa a mat.ti r o J.r-- as to whether respondents Liquor Commission are re- city, . Pltf$186.00; bal The case is presented to this court on llie b..sis ol th: Blair R. Morris to Prud. Fed. Sav. Fountains Drive. LINDA VELASQUEZ AND MR. VELASQUEZ AKA DONALD iv-o- Arland K. Pope etux to Prud. Fed. Sav. $14000. 5125 E. dba Inc. The Rogue, a private nonprofit club located at about 3400 South and 4300 West in Salt Lake County, asks this court to order the district court l to issue a writ of mandamus to compel the Utah Liuaur f Commission to grant the club a liquor license. , $33750. 790 i Justice r . 744 Plt$155. bal due 46220 ie, 4620 W. AND MRS. vs C ROCKETT, 722 - Comnerclal Collection 46219 Mc-Gh- Western Mtge; $13,500. 2491 Mockingbird. wage claims 46218 - Commercial Collection Co. vs WILFORD HERMANS EN; Ptf $516.65; bal due :o. 12721 American Tierra to 719 CONSTRUCTION SOV-RAN-- Pltf$22.20; v. Trust Deeds City Court INTERSTATE 60 East Clay bourn i COLLECTIONS Salt Laka City, Utah Call 486-84- 5 |