OCR Text |
Show TUESDAY, APRIL 25, 1972 THE DAILY RECORD RAGE SEVEN Warranty Deeds Chester Lyman to Ches 178 Ruth Edda McDernott to Jack L. Tedesco etux. 754 ! Heber D.: Nelson Const, to Richard K. Allred etux. Arlene Bradshaw to 057 ' Joyce Cameron et al. 066 Sup- ply to Kenneth B. .Dowden etux. Luzie Loring to Saverio Barbiero etux. 066 764 Clarence E. Bowden etux to James D. Smith etux. James D. Smith etal to J. Scott Vhgner etux.. Magna Corp to National Mrge Co. 112 070 117 861 Craig LaMar Allen etux to R, B, Clark etux. 121 871 Max S. McDonald etux to David E, Crosby etux. Faris - W. Horner etux , C. Evelyn Elder to Gori V. Klungervik etux. 072 Jacob Brand to Jacob Brand etal. Conrad L. North etux to Jimmie B. Dorris etux. 789 2449- John H. VanWagoner etux to Utahna P. Belnap. L.A. Kolby etux to Michael F. McDonald etux. 078 W. Philip F. Mar Stella 897 etux to Jesse W, Hays etux. Mavor Gatehouse etal to Edward R. Grunander etux 795 Capital Enterprises to William Shirl Wenerstrom etux. ' Fritz Paul 934 Paul B. Neff Constr, Inc. to Russell J. Maynes etux. Neff Gbnst. Inc. to R.D. Winward etux. ' 081 Wol etux to Miller etux. Alberta Gallacher Clegg 935 Capital Entoprises Inc. to Larry A. Peterson etux. 799 W. to Edmund D, Cook etux. etux to William M. Riley etux James Dunn etux to Rodney D. McKell. 953 Henry A. Gregory etux to Cornells J. Versteeg etux. 806 Emerson R Hand etux to Security Title Tr. 955 2448- 531 963 Boise Cascade Corp. to Randy K. Larsen etux. 064 066 Wmdell B. Mendenhall etux to Ronald I. Holbrook ' . etux. 948 Fred LaMar Madsen Realty to Dee Fai-La- nd Chilinski etux. 079 Edna H. Broadhead to William T. Her odes etux. 915 797 - 075 877 Joan Erbst to William H. Schorr etux. 793 094 L.A. Campbell Const. to Darryl D. Rouska etux. to Leone H. Ashton et al. 069 860 788 Verl A. Haskell etux to Richard Gregory etux. ter 099 to Hilton M, McCulloch etux, 785 John Paul Fox etux to S. Neve Fox etux. 089 Harold C. Hogenson etux to Wm. M. Caroson etux. Myrtle Gates to Myrtla to Myrtle Gates et al. Lafe B. Brown etux to Burke W. Worthington etux. 852 765 804 Economy Builders 848 755 8(1 Empire Investment to American Tierra. 845 Halbert C. Nelson etux to Ida Rist. Ida Rist etux to Allied Develop. Emp, Prof. Sh. 087 Nancy Strong Jeavons tc Alcora Materials. 964 Alcora Materials to Iva Parkin. N k S Construction to Frank W. Meacham etux. 594 Vhlley Center Building to Theodore Mitchell etux. etux to H. G. Hathaway etux. Jackson Invest. Co. to Thos. L. Behunin etux. Deane H. Platt etux. Agnes May Mitchell to Ted. L. Anderson etux. 127 2449- 2449- 029 - Edith L. Vincent to Edith L. Vincent etal. Myrtle J. Brimhall to (13 to Douglas B. Wadsworth etux. Robt. G. Green etux. H. S. Muhlbach to H. Muhlbach. 032 Fairclough Brewer to Apollo Enterprises , 176 Zel-di- 036 Mtn. States Fence Inc. to Mtn. States Fence' Co. en etux. 039 240 McGhie Land Title t o Melbourne T. Yergensen etux Ernest Rich- 041 Adamson Rlty to R. G, Adamson Jr. etux. 2448- 807 Christopher U. Light Howelis . tiiy ftwHanald-S- same as 043, 045, 047, 049, 041 051 same as Judith S. Rieben to 052 Alan E. Hay nes. etux to 840 Flyco Land k Dev. to 053 F. J. Thacker etux to Kathern Grimm. 842 Sterling Homes Inc. to 054 R. V. BeckBtead etux to Ivan R. Hill etux. etux. Judith S. Rieben etal . 041, Farrell J. Thacker etux. Jerry J. PSrez etux. Stephen A. Gibson etux. Terral J. Hunsman 211 G.H. Chlarson etux to Rex A. Moosman etux. 155 Hal J. Withers etux to R, J. Taylor etux. Ruth B. Stevens to Vernon L, Anderson etux. 175 D.1 .Subscription Coupon NAME. ADDRESS. Mtge. Invest. Co. to Prud. Fed. Sav, k Loan. 218 R, Geo. Gregersen etux to Prud. Fed. Sav. k Loan. 222, 224. Mtge. Invest. Co. Inc. to Prud. Fed. Savings. In The Supreme Court Of The State Of Utah No. 12396 FILED April 10, 1972 L. M. Cummings, Clerk Defendant filed an affidavit in opposition to the motion wherein it was related that since 1959 when defendant purchased the Garfield Smelter from American Smelting and Refining Company, the records designated in the motion had been sent pursuant to request toi defense counsel in anticipation of litigation. Defendant characterized these records as privileged communications between a client and its attorney. There is no settled understanding of what "good cause" means; since the determination depends to a large extent upon the facts of each case, a wide latitude of discretion is necessarily vested in the trial judge. Although the ability of the movant to obtain the desired information by other means is relevant, the real question is whether the movant can , STATE.. CITY ...... Chock inclosed 1 year $60.00 lf. Bill mo Q 6 mo. 35.00 3 mo. $2000 Mail to: Tho Ddfy I Eicon, Shell. Norman O. Jensen etux Y. Hahn etux. -- j 1397 South, AW", Soft Lot City, Utah 4115, Rhone 4V-065- 1 etux to Bernard 214-2- 17 . to James C. Robbins Sr. On appeal, defendant urges that plaintiffs had failed to indicate by means of a verified motion or supporting affidavit a factual basis to support the requisite claim of "good cause" as jreguired in Rule 34, U. R. C. P. for an order for production of documents. Turther contendsthat plain- tiffs' motion contained mere opinions and conclusions which were not sufficient as a matter of law to constitute good cause. Dscisioa makers isly on - Utah Dkiry Comm. etux to Larry to Donald R, Fox etux. 174 on The trial court granted plaintiffs' motion, and defendant filed a petition for interlocutory appeal, which this court granted. Are You A Decision Maker? r Johnson-Anders- Defendant responded that the record of emissions is maintained in the legal counsel files as privileged information collected at the request of legal counsel. Defendant explained that several times daily, the personnel of the smoke test section of the smelter process control and improvement department take samples of flue gas, which they test and analyze to determine the amount of sulfur dioxide, sulfuric acid, and dust (arsenic, copper, lead, and molybdenum). These daily calculations are tabulated on a monthly report, which is forwarded to legal counsel. Plaintiffs filed a motion for production of these documents under Rule 34, U. R. C. P. In their motion plaintiffs asserted that it was based on good cause in that the documents sought contain information regarding the emission of acid and other materials and that plaintiffs' causes of action were based on the damages caused by such emissions. D. Schettler etux to Western Industries Pension Tr. ard Prows Inc. 831 Utah Dairy Comm, to Plaintiffs propounded certain interrogatories to defendant, included therein was an inquiry as to the existence and the location of any records concerning the amount of acid or smelting materials which escape duriiig a designated period of time. ne n Harold L. Peterson et al. Plaintiffs initiated this action claiming they had sustained damage to their motor vehicles, while they were parked in a parking lot maintained by defendant. Plaintiffs alleged that from December 15, 1966, through January 6, 1969, defendant negligently allowed acid or other harmful substances to flow into the air about its smelter facilities in Salt Lake County; these substances, when associated with certain atmospheric conditions, caused damage to the vehicles of the various plaintiffs. GCE. Trends Inv. to Levi Carrilo etux. Prud. Service to C. Taylor Burton etux 991 to Muriel C. Crus. to Exquisite Home Builders. 271 199 207 152 CALLISTER. Chief Justice: McGhie Land Title, Tr , Mark K. Carroll etux to Marvin Perea etux. James F, Selander etux to R. W. Wilpon etux. 982 Flyco Land k Develop, to Douglas P. Wyatt etux. 676 Yer-gens- Susannah P. L. Koovm-ato Kay F . Curtis etux. to Geo. P. Ruff etux. McGhie Land Title, to Rural k Recreational Dev. to Carl R. Ghran Inc. R.L. 184 Research Homes Inc. 974 Leona H. Ashton etal to Archibald V. Arnold etux. McGhie to Ro- 203 144 McGhie Land Title, Tr 238 Dial Bldrs. Inc. to bt. O. Anderson etux. 183 210 Robertson B. DeHaan etux to Stanley G. Ivie etux. 129 Kennecott Copper Corporation, a foreign corporation, Defendant and Appellant. s Marvin C. Zitting et al 192 Elizabeth D. Link to v. GordonA. Leonard etux Russell C. Westwood etux. Equity Realty k Const, to Evan M. Hansen etux. American Saving 182 Geo. C. Cundiff etux to Glen J. East etux. 973 641 143 Ralph A. Barnes etux to Dial Bldrs. Inc. Orren J. Greenwood Paul R. Jackson, et al. , Plaintiffs and Respondents, 965 602 Flyco Land k Dev. to Calvin B. Brown etux. 836 180 Finco Inc. to Duane A. Fluckiger etux. Fairclough Brewer to Gam G. Christensen Const. 664 . S. Lyman etux. obtain the facts without production of the documents. "Good cause" is shown where the full, accurate disclosure of facts, which it is the purpose of the process to secure, could not be accomplished through other discovery means. 1 The moving party must make a showing not only that the documents , |