OCR Text |
Show j Hill Him the morning examinee: and restlessness groceries l. (Continued from Page Oue) and STAPLE New York. Feb. 1. The defen the Thaw case continued today with the introduction ( expert ieiiniouy na in the condition of the defendant' mind during ;he several month ful losing the tragedy of the Madiaot. Square roof garden. We do this, explained Mr. Del was, Thaw leading counsel, in or 4w that the Jury, by means of the wreckage on tl.e beach, may infer then has been a storm on the Water." The witness was Dr. B. D. Evans, superintendent of the New Jersey hospital for the insane. Pr. Evans declared that, when he first visited Thaw in the Tombs, on August 4U, there were indications u? the brain storm or explosive condition of mental unaoundneas through which be had recently come. . It now became evident for the first time that the defense Is endeavoring to show that while Thaw was insane prior to the killing id Stanford White and at the time and Immediately to the homicide, the alienists who visited him in the Tombs found that as their visits progressed hu manner storm and changed from stress- to calm and quiet. in ... fANCY ! Oran(Si Lemons, Bananas, Pineapples, Pates, Apples, tmY are the finest in market, the T.B.Evans&Co. GROCERS - 234. loth PkMN AVE. C3M WASHINGTON A Gerte Plana on Bros.' Organa. Newman New York. Feb. 12. Although today Lincoln's birthday, and consequenta legal holiday In this slate, the ly Thaw trial proceeded at the usual hour this morning. Justice Fitzgerald having ordered that, owing to the hardship on the Jury, which la to remain lacked up uutil the end of the trie., there would be no recess over the 1 C. . WARDLEIGH 0. flANOS . holiday. When Thaw walked to hi place at the counsel table, as he was removing hla ulster ooat and for some momenta after taking hla seat, he kept his eyta on District Attorney Jerome aud ignored hi own counsel for the time bring. Mr. Jerome wee busy with bis paper and did not notice Thaw's somewhat unusual action. s The first witness called by Mr. was Dr. Britton D. Evans, superintended of the State Insane hospital at Morris Plains, which he said contains an average of 1.8'Hi patients. Dr. Evans, said he had written and spoken n great deal upon the subject of Insanity and hsd appeared in a majority of the important rases in New Jersey where mental derangement or incapacity had to do with the matter under investigation. In several cases, the witness declared, he Had represented the prosecution amt the defense by consent of counsel anl under appointment by the court. The witness first saw Harry Thaw, August 4th, IDofi, in the Tombs, and In all visited him eight times. Dr. Evans said he waa alone upon the visits of August 14th and October 1st. At other times ha waa accompanied by Dr. Wagner, who testi-Beyesterday. What, during these visits, did you observe in the mental condition of Mr. Thaw?" On' the first visit nn August 14th, he exhibited a peculiar facial exnre alon, glaring of tbe eye, suspicious of hla surroundings and of me, nervous AND MUSICAL ORGANS MERCHANDISE Bare TtolisK Guitars, Aocordaona, joa, Strings. Utait Del-ma- Ihaat PubUeatkuis of Music, Sea tho Wonderful Pip Organ. Waahlngton Avenue. 2371 OGDEN, UATH. W. A. Malan. g. g. Malan. . WE CAN MOVE ANYTHING MALAN TRANSFER COMPANY t I , Vane, Drays and Baggage J uch agitation 1W0 ATT0RSEYS HAVE comes from a severs brain storm. con.-non :n timse woo bate rewnily p n, FIRST SERIOUS CLASH ihrjuph an explosive or fuimmanu; condition uf menial unoundnes. exhibited delusions of a personal character, an exaggerated ego. and along with them delusions of a persecutory character. 11a thought himself of exaggerated importance and believed himself persecuted by a number ui persons " By an exaggerated ego' Dr. Evans said be meant a dispropor ionite idea of importance of self, a belief that one is clothed with power, capacity and ability far above normal, or above those actually possessed." These symptom, he said, were characteristic of several mental One of the mental diseases in dicab'd by Thaw's actions. Dr. Evans declared, is adolescent insanity. It Is cbaramaristlc of the suprenn-perioof life from ten to forty years. The person thus aSUcted is known at: having a psychopathic taint, a predisposition to mental unsoundness. the result of heredity. Another form af insanity IndicatIs kuowu as ed. said the witness, paranosld. or fixed insanity on some subject. The third is maniacal, where the patient Jump from one Idea to another. These form and others are characterized by the exaggerated ego. t They are well defined forms which there can be no difference of opinion. I there any specific name. Doctor." asked Mr. Delmas, given to that form of insanity wherein one imhimself omnipresclent - the agines ruler of the wot id? That la included in the form of Insanity to which 1 have referred. Both adolescent insanity and paranoiad Insanity are characterized by delusions and exaggerated as to In adolescent lnsauity the paego. tient exhibits no marked symptoms, but when the stress cornea Dr. Evans took on a declamatory tone of voice the man dues nut break down as the ordinary or normal man would. There la a complete loss of mental balance, an explosive condition of tha brain, the reason becomes dethroned, the will power is lost and the brain ia operating as a ship does in the wind without a rudder the balance wheel is gone. The acts of such a man are not the acts of a normal man, but show him to be guided by disease aud stress. His mind has left lta moorings and yielded to diseased condl-tlies. ab-ju- e On my first visit 1 also nntirpd that Mr. Thaw suffered from a rapid flow of words not characteristic of the normal mind. He showed a condition of abnormal excitement a diseased condition of the brain. In the disease von describe, how do the conditions differ from the conditions In a normal man, who speaks rapidly? An ordinary normal man speaks more or leas deliberately. On nil mat ters of grave importance he talks slowly and his Ideas come logically and connectedly. In a man of unsound mind tbs Ideas come rapidly, tumbling over each other, jumbling from one subject to another, that at once leads a trained observer to suspect unaoundnesa of mind. To me it means that the mind baa either recently come through, or la Just going Wagon. mmomm OUR SPECIALTIES Plan FwrnL tuf Safa Maying and Storage J. M. FORRISTALL mmi ROBT. Q. AG E I 'ir OFFICE 40S Twanty-fift- I ltd MnK, h FHONEC 224, Bed, 220. . , f - Real Estate and Loans ' Surety Bonds I Tbe Fpringfiem F. and M. Inn Co. . Tbe Manchester Atumnince Co. The German Alliance Assn. of New York. The New Zealand Fire Inn. Co. v The New York Underwriters The Caledonian Insurance Company. . , troubles WITH OLD HARNESS a runaway may cause mot RonMa. Sarioua Injuria and a me death the awful results. Ag art harness ia oftaa responsibly but ASSETS OVER $80,000,000.00 . I The F lw ru kind w set hare NO WEAK SPOTS. . . "W Jrol,r worth If bay harneaa of na U 1X71 Washing A1W "F's l41' We Buy, Sell and Rent All Kinds of Real Estate Just let us know what you have to sell or wish to buy IC. Platt Saddlery Co. Second Hand Stores The JUMBLE buys,' aella ' or any aid thing (blues ceptad) and meat new' anas. Vach. Halle, 1144' . ' T NEVADA SECOND-HAN- . STORE. . Stars. . . . If yeti have anything to sell er buy call or phono 1170 to 1S7S Wash, Am . Sail 464-k- Will pay d Ind. STS. . x 5 First Natl Bank e d Beeond-Han- Bell 809 Office,-5- SJOO Wa boy and aell all Unds of now nd aaeond-hnngood a. Call or phono Wackar A HaynM, Prep. Ilf SSth St Phena, Ind. 122. PAUL ZIEGENHIRT, Phone, Ind. bo ; Ogdens Best Drug Store ,b Wm. Driver & Son Drug Co. CV B. A. DENKERS the Mg heat price for ascend-hanfurniture and aell to the publle lha cheapaaL MIS Grant Awn. Bail W-fInd. I20l d C. J. HERRICK A CO, Sticceaaere to H. L. Whltn. SUng your gooda hare If you want ta tail them. Call htna If you want by. IS42 Waah Arei BcM Phono Ind. 4d7. We are Headquarter for . If. ogdln, I into, a WurJs. u i dawn f a o- - UTAH, w ednekday, n;jti:iAiiV is, menial i.:hor or etthcr ihc ute of meu'j: .mil'll; B Tonu.? "I believe ir was September uu Mr Jerome objected i. the on the ground that the i.u'.r w:m no; fixed. I have fixed it no nmrl.. cun. 1 wa the Doctor's reply. Doctor Wagner aaiJ the Ur.h day," began Jerome. i have nothing to d. with Dr. Wagner's leslimou). interrupted Dr Evans. 1 am not addressing my remarks to you. air," suappod Mr. Jerome. Latter ia the session Dr. Evaus explained he meant August l:h. I On this visit. said Dr. Evans. found Thaw still nervous, agitated and had the peculiar expression oi the eye familiar with mental disease. I also obserredbls suspicion of uie and all arouud him. Ale still exhibited decondition of lusion of persecution. revolt against these fancied persecution s because they were unfair." Dr. Evans next described his third visit to Thaw, September lftih. Mr. Thaw exhibited delusion of suspicion, lack of eoniidenrs in bis advisers, aud an explosiveness of nieuul make-uchaiucleritrtlc uf a person of uusouud mind." How lung did the thiid visit last?" "Only five minutes." What else did you observe?" There were no hallucinations. Mr. Thaw dismissed tbe physician and had an argument with his counsel which I shall not narrate." Mr. Delia a here Interrupted the examination to read from a number of authorities In support of the contention advanced by him yesterday that tbs statements of Thaw t the phyiiciana, tending to shed light m his vtate of mind, were admissible. Justice Fitxgerald said as no question was pending he could nut rule. Mr. Delius asked Dr Evans to state hla conversation with tbe defendant on September 19th. Mr. Jerome objected. Mr. Dcluas continued tu read from he court decisions as a foundation, said, for introducing statement a mads by Tbaw, at the time id tbe homicide end prior thereto. He wanted to allow that the staiemsuts of the defendant might he taken into consideration by an expert In determining the mental condition of his subject at the time of an examination. He said that yesterday a witness had not been allowed to give such an opinion. Mr. Jerome said he did not object to any such opinion, Mr. Delmas asserted that Mr. Jerome "has reasoned In a circle on this subject." Justice Fitxgerald said It waa a case of reasoning in n circle" as explained by Mr. lieliuas, hut he did not understand the facts that way. Mr. Jerome again declared be would not object to an opinion as to whether the defendant waa insane or sane subsequent to the shooting, but wished the question to be distinctly confined to a given period. The statement made by a man in Mr. Jeprison in his own rome, are not admissible under any circumstances. But If they claim that the man was insane at the time of the examination, as well aa whan the net wee committed, tbep I am willing that these conversations tUiall go in. Justice Fitzgerald sustained Mr. Jerome's objection and Mr. proceeded to quest Ira Dr. Evans. Were the oral statements made by Mr. Thaw material In the formation of your opinion as to hla mental cont dition?" p M. ' i j j ati 'In oue alluuid 1'v'inisa. v'viurae yuu can - sak the haw to ahuta 77 - in. ' waw Mila - in couNTNica. im aim, NarMarl m -dijffrwrtfpafcwt HhglcMhMHimiU fneth bdadady. scimwiWMiwiant waeMiwoTow. o. e. Ogdens Best Drug Store 1 Is assured you when you buy one of Dr. Pierces Family Medicine qurs-Uui-.ii- ." for all the ingredients entering into them are printed on the bottle-wrapp- er and their formula are attested under oath as being complete and correct. You know' just what yon are paying fur and that the ingredients are gathered from Nature's laboratory, being selected from the most valuable native, medicinal roots found growing in our American forests. While potent to cure they are perfectly harmless even to the most delicate women and children. Not a drop of alcohol enters into their composition. ' A much better agent ia used both for extracting and preserving the medicinal principles used in them, viz. pure triple-refine- d glycerine of proper strength. remarked the judge. a v our opiuiou after the hr-three iUIi as to the lueutal cou-vtun uf tLe Jefeudaut I w.i ;hen. aud I am now. firmly of the iipiuion ihai during the first three viai; Harrv K Thaw wa uusouud iu mind because ul a diseased ht i: ivrain." "Ak roult of your during the last five vUits did you term an opinion as to Mr. Thaw's uieutsl condition?" I .11.1 This agent possesses intrinsic medicinal properties of its own, being ' Please Mate it." "The stability of hi nnud was still belter than upimpaired, but on the three former liMts. most valualde and nutritive and nothing' demulcent. "Was the improvements gradual?" Glycerine plays an Important part in Dr. Pierces Golden MedYes." in the cure of indigestion, dyspepsia and weak stomach, ical Discovery What, in your opiuiou. waa the attended by sour risings, 'heartburn," foul breath, coated tongue, poor CuUditloa of miud the sequel of?" am of the opiuiou that be was sufappetite, gnawing feeling in stomach, biliousness and kindred derangefering from a punitive disorder or ments of the stomach, liver and bowels. of mind as a result of Besides curing all the shove distressing ailments, the "Golden Medam of the hereditary predisposition. opinion that there were additional exia a specific for all diseases of tha mucous membranes, ical Discovery" isting causes in the order of at re, aa catarrh, whether of the nasal passages or of the stomach, bowels or strain aud ordeals of the mind which formed a brain storm, or mental explopelvic organs. Kven in its ulcerative stages it will yield to this soversion. which left Us trace behind." Dr. Evans was mantled the letters eign remedy if its use be persevered in. In Chronic Catarrh of tha written by Thaw and intruded la Nasal passages, it ia well, while taking tbe "Golden Medical Discovery " evidence. The doctor agsiu began the perusal uf the letters m hich were for the necessary comditutkmal treatment, to cleanse the passages freely later to form one of tbe bases of a two or three times a day with Dr. Sages Catarrh Remedy, This hypothetical question. Meanwhile a thorough course of treatment generally cares even in the worst cssak forty minute recesa waa taken. In coughs and hoarseness caused by bronchial, throat and lung After D. Evans had been twading for about forty minutes, District Attorney affections, except consumption in its advanced stages, the "Golden Jerome suggested a recess fur half fca hour while the doctor finished. This Medical Discovery " is a most efficient remedy, especially in those oboti-nstWas grautt-by the court at 2:10. but caused by irritation and congestion of the bronwhen court reconvened, lr. Kvaus chial mucous membranes. The "Discovery " ia not so good for acute still had two lettera to read. Mr. Jerome proposed another recess for leu coughs arising from sudden colds, nor must it be expected to cure conniliitiles, but Justice Fitzgerald refused it. Dr. Evans thereuimu return- sumption in its advanced stages- no medicine will do that bat for all , ed to the aund aud coutluued bts resilhang-onobstinate chronic or the coughs, which, if nrglected, or badly ing of tbs lettera. lead up to consumption, it is the best medicine that can be Dr. Evans finished reading of the treated, If the sweet taste of the "Discovery," canned by tbe glycerine, is lettera at. 4:14 p. m., having been an hour and at the task. disliked, s few drops of lemon juice, orange or lime juice, to each After reading these letters, have you been able inforra an opinion as dose will make it agreeable and pleasant and will not in the slightest to the mental condition of the author interfere with its bcnefical effects. at the time they were written?" asked Its an Insult to your Intelligence for a dealer to endeavor to Mr. Delmas. I have." palm off upon you some nostrum of unknown composition in plaae of Dr. Then, doctor, listen closely to what Pierces medicines which are of knoww comforitiow. I am about to ask you. Mr. Delmaa recommend Dr. Pierce's medicines because they know Most dealers rethen read from the stenographic port of yesterday's proceedings the what they are made of and that the ingredients employed are amot hypothetical question involving the the most valuable that a medicine for like purposes can be ami of. entire story as It appears In the evidence and which The same is true of leading physicians who do not hesitate to recomwas asked of Dr. Charles O. Wagner. mend them, since they know exactly wbat they contain and that their Dr. Wagner, It will be recaUed, waa Thaw aa that it his ingredients are the very best known to medical science far the cars of opinion gave In such a mental condition at tbe time the several diseases for which these medicines are recommended. of the tragedy that he did not know With tricky dealers it la different. hla acf wm wrong. f, Whan the hypothetical question was else that pays them a little greater profit will be nrg.--d Something asked lr. Mr. completed, as "just as good," or even better. Yon can hardly afford ?o you upon Evans: accept a aulwtitute of unknown competition and without any particub x "1 ask you to alaia cm (lies facta and tha light of tbe letters you have record of cures in place of Dr. Tierce's medicines which are of know j of cure t behind the: (. read, what wm the mental condition composition aud have a record of . of the defendant, assuming that the You know what you want and it ia alcrs business to supply tl whom I have described ?" ntt'tf utom it. want, anti-sept- ic anti-ferme- 1 1 e, d bang-on-coug- three-quarter- s world-fame- d Kcsbit-Tbaw-Whl- s Mr. Jerome hsd slowly arisen. The question is objected to, be declared, because of the statement that a maternal uncle of the defendant waa Insane. The testimony is that tha uncle wua not of unsound mind. I will amend tbe question to have it read unround mind, Mid Mr. Di-I-- "No. but she was tbre sad knew the character of II." Thr matter finally waa adjusted at the Miggcatliin of the court by Mr. DrlmM airtkiDK out uf the hyputhnU-ca- l question the description of the operation as. serious, if not capital. Mr. Jerome further objected to the I further object, said Mr. Jerome, on the ground that there ta no evi- quest Ion on tbe around that.lt ala ten dence here that Tbaw paid honorable that Mrs. Tbaw hid told her husband that Htsnford White had apuken to court to Mias Nesblt." said Mr. her after the marriage. Tha district I will . split hairs Delmas, aud tusks It acquainted with attorney aald the evidence wa that the girl paased While and beard hill her." 1 am not splitting hairs," said Mr. say. Evelyn." Mr. Delmaa accepted an amendJerome, with some irritation. I asld I ment to the question. 1 did nut MV you were. would not," as id Mr. Delmas. Mr Jennie further objected totho question on the ground that it referred to the fact that a serious, if as performed not espltal operation, nl Were the conversations necessary to enable an expert to form a correct Judgment as to the defendant's mental condition?" "They were not entirely necessary, but they were highly Important. Now what was it Mr. Thaw said? Dtstrlet Attorney Jerome objected and was austnlned. on Miss Neshli. I will now ask you, continued Mr. It Is called a severe if not a capiDelmaa, 'If, aa a result of your eight tal operation, it was an ordinary op examinations, you formed an opinion erailon for appendicitis' " began aa to this man's mental state at the Mr. Jerome. time of your visits?" I object, broke in Mr. Delmaa His mental eoudltion varied." The record does nut show any such Answer, yes or no, as to whether evidence. you formed an opinion. Every question has lieen put to Yea." tbla wit new," continued Mr. Jerome, Dr. Evans then went on to the next raising hla voice, to instill In tr.s visit, on September 22. mind and Into the mindu of the jure We examined his general attitude, that tbla operation was what la known his manner of entering the room, mana a criminal operation, aa that la unner of thought and general deport- derstood. ment. He was still highly nervous Yoor . Honor." criej Mr. Delma; and Mill suspicious of every one. He I take exception to these remarks exhibited the exaggerated ego. the air and the exception noted on the and the disposition record, and I wish it noted on gniunda of to direct me rather than be directed of mlscouduct of the district attor. by me. ney. When did rou next see him? continued mind." normal To any On September !7tb, when we made Mr. Jerome, the Impression thut examination. a complete phvsfcsl would be cnnled by these atatementi Dr. Evans said tbe next visit waa on is that tbe operation waa of a crimiof 29ih. prethe Many September nal nature. If they will exclude such were Thaw tests protested. vious as this I am willing to an asked various questions and the pris- let operation the question go. The very unuwn answers to them oner gave his willingness - to do thla ia In Itself and made a diagram with matches desire to make that proof that tbi-Mr. Jerome objected. on the witness." Impression Mr. Thaw took matches and tooth "Yon did not object to this quespicks and placed them so as to show tion, yesterday?" said Mr. Delmas. positions which may have been clca" No, yet I did not realise what It to him. but were confusing to me. I meant. did not think his explanations were me the word of yu will give dear or logical. He waa calm, lees tbe"If defendant's continue4 counsel ttmre and confiding." auspicious the district attorney, that they d The next visit Dr. Evans made not know the character of this cra was on October let tlon. I am willing to let It go." Thla time Mr. Tbaw was extreme"I give my word I don't know, reto talked me a like ly cordial and Mr. Delmas. plied friend. brother or I didn't nay you; I said defend-snt'b. Octobe-fitwas on visit Tbe eighth I will give yon time to roun-e- l. We had a protracted Interview consult with associates. yur which a subject with Mr. Thaw la do that." replied care to don't "I was discussed. It near to his heart Delmaa. Mr. lasted two hours." said Dr. Evans. do want to make this In"Then Under the ruling of the court, can sinuation?you Mr. Jerome. snapped further regarding you say knything Again Mr. Delmaa noted an excepibis visit?" 1 tion to Mr. Jerome's remarks. Under the court's eliminations there moat earnestly protest sgainsl this." can Is nothing more I say. The district attorney he exclaimed. At this point the court took a rehla character and forgets strangely cess for luncheon. me with an when he charges position Dr. Evans resumed the stand after attempt to deceive. He must n dereress. the mid-daliberation sec the Injustice of bis im"Doctor." asked Mr. Delmas, as a plied discourtesy. result of eight of your visits to Mr. "I see plainly said Mr. Thaw did you form an opinion as to Jerome, Injustice but not in my remark, of Thaw? condition Mr, a the mental will ask this witness wbat be Yea. in the hypotbe operation by Waa It based I" Prt upon the thetical question." oral statemeus of Mr. Thaw during May I Mk the learned district atthe visits?" torney where he got his Information " Ia wa in part aa to the operation V suavely suggestWill you nuw state what that opln-io-n ed Mr. Delmas. was?" Yea," said Mr. Jerome, sharply. Mr. Jerome objected. Did yon get it without violating Tbe witness said that aa a result a confidence? Yea." of hla first three visit he formed an Did you get It from Mrs. Thaw?" opinion; aa to the result of the last NO." live visits he formed another. From her physician? Were they based in part on oral Then where did you get II?" statements by tbe defendant?" From her mother. "Yes." Oh, did her mother perform the State those two reasons. That la objected to, Interrupted operation?" ct - evidence, (Continued on Pago Seven) AND Commercial Electric Co 2279 Wash. Ave. - Ind. Phone 362 Garden Seeds It is not time to plant yot, but soon WILL BE and wt want yon to know where to get your FEEDS. I was in the big tin, us you all remember, and all my old stock was burnttl. Our new stock is arriving aud will be the best ever brought to Ogtleu. Seeds That Are Sure to Grow t HAY OR GRAIN FLOUR, In Large or Small Qudntities Remember, we carry a full line of that famous PrattB Poultry Food fur animals aud poultry. r. Both Phones T. ASTILL v . - Here Mr, Jerome consulted, hi notes. "I can't carry sorb a question a tbla tn my head, explained the d'a-trlattorney. Probably not, commented Mr. Del maa In a tone of toleration. rejoined Mr.- JeTertainly not, rome, that would be an Illusion. There waa considerable laughter. Mr. Jerome further objected to thy question on the ground that It was said White wae not visible to the yoiiBK husband at tbs t'afa Martin. Mr, Jerome said there was no such i undet-atanJ- OUR 0001)8 ARE THE PRICES ARE BE8T. GALL REASONABLE. A SQUARE DEAL ivu, will 1 lit sak the seeum!?" iuquiieJ ques- t't ' W J "The two m ; ir.iu-d.- "It I menu false iiles out itf wl:;nt a man can uoi Ik- - argued by lugh.,1 sud usri arguments. Mr. Thaw which whit believe were talsc idr in v argument could nor shake." ' When was your next visit to rti Yes." .!:. Mi' be 1007. 2264 Washington Ave. |