Show Thv Salt OPINION akv Tribune I AA) 200-- Sunday Sepionl i i vote is correctly recorded and provides a way to perform a full recount should problems arise Paper less voting proponents cite the added expense of printers and caution that mechanical printers may frequently break Inexpensive reliable printers are used everywhere in our daily lives We all insist on a receipt at the grocery store or the bank So why shouldn't we expect the same from our voting systems? Some people believe that ply:tecording the vote on two different devices in the voting machine creates an audit trail but: computer scientists know thal is not true It's too easy for the:computer program no matter how thoroughly tested to record the same mistake in two places ! I Another objection to VVI)13s potential confusion about whether the electronic or paper version is the official ballot Most of us believe that each machine's electronic tallies should provide only preliminary results with official counts from the paper ballots In any case the "problem" is solved with election rules and procedures The consensus of computer and security experts is overwhelming: In a poll of tnembers of the ACM the premier organization for computing professionals over 95 percent of the is E: e 101 t:g :do? 4 TOP QUALITY BEST PRICES 11 Oro Tontorrowl irmwmagromp000mmimmmpowrommowinwimmommempgamwormm 1499 West 3500 South SLC UT 84119 801-972-88- SEEKING RESEARCH STUDY VOLUNTEERS & Weed Control J----- GEVITY ” New 4' ' ' ' -- 1' i''' -I '4"- 1 4 - -- -- - - " uni ' ' '444' 4VLtZ':' ' "' 1 : '1 ' : 11 14 ! : '' '2 ' ‘''' '''''''' '''' Pht r'1 r --- t :'t 4115 cxtpc:21Eao )uth'4075West 491 —- ' 11 UTI84118 est:Valley tritritICi!ll ' 7 i I to ' 1 - - - kcienh Rescarth Options' tSfth 352922S isil our ipriewti 10611 v IIPM4UA0111 'A 1440 f fq1 - - -- I 4 Trill's - I "4 &lir L ) - 46 16 i I 1 c15 1144A I- rTil 112-- k -- I 1 ‘IA10 111:t711:0 vtattilt!riltP(tAalti wadmisaikutafiogi e'(80))?62:8Q064801)967 81'44 e I- - S 4 352-922- 8 pRO itel$ a ' 7 0 ki's1!:??4014'44!:tit!"!":""( 1 t11' ' I ' '" N-- as Phsicians Our Personal Guarantee ‘i41 N to You ii know the exad price before we begin the job You do we IRLE until the stains are permanently gone You SC) II "- 1 i Ii - i be completely satisfied before we leave 3 Room Speciall $790c stains mum It MIMI IIME MOM House Special Carpet and Upholstery Cleaning Fr i Independently I R Save le RI MONAL so PET IREATMIAT Owned and Operated and Kell' Ostler rpiret 101604 by Rark(A " t 7I VII 4 '' - ' mai - - 1ZsZ ge' — S 0 pi SKS 8G0 i N sq ft I ltpores 101614 - 1 0 6 tr- I I 8 A ' II cit f 11 t t 4 k t - Yu s- i - - 5 04 MEM i$ t (IS' flown 1016 1111 199 ke 1 sq fl 111)10 SOO MIMI Whole -- 23 Pre-Finish- ed volt (S01 00 4' 1)i!lconlfortPkcpcpsia I St Itt IAING MORE t‘l ORM IiON1()NtIDEVil relined medical cornsilab pro‘ided at no t'oci a allabk tiii tioalitaqi partn ipants me and n a el compoNn 1 801-972-49- Complete Kitchens on Display 01 ner Builder Specialist & Assembled Cabinets in Stock Countertop Specialist Bathroom Cabinets & Vanities Entertainment Centers Professional Installation Project Specialist from Floor to Ceiling Free Design Consultation n !him-tensio- Si uJ '''' 1st Application MB Customers Only 'til "N i 25(11-Only $ '5' s t' 1 M0111401 )' Reg $35 00 AWN Endoinctrinsis kl:74 Fax 15 YOUR KITCHEN CABINET & COUNTERTOP SPECIALIST FUNERAL HOMES Serving on of Salt taLe City Based on 4000 your price may vary Orem Chris 11 Dick's qatt Ailit Ztibun Fertilizer 5q Ft 1 AIPougal a skeptical eye on Utah government Ba - 41A1111 10 968-380- 0 SAL - Factory Direct Sales To the Public BE PREPARED TODAY So Four Family Won't A'eed to Phillip J Windhy is an associate professor ((computer science at itrighatn Young University and the farmer state chief inArmation officer under Gov Mike Leavitt Jay Lepreau is a research professor of computer science at the University of Utah THE WOOD FLOOR WAREHOUSE SLC TI I E WATCI I DOGS lIarrie Rebecca Walsh and Rirsten Stewart ifl! We applaud the stales goal of improving our voting systems lowever the result must really be an improvement Voting costs standards equipment laws judicial rulings and public opinion are all changing fast respondents felt that voting systems should provide a recount-ablphysical record eg paper On the other side of the issue by contrast the sane few national "experts" testify over and over again tzxoAA Dan a single Fully electronic systems provide no means to independently audit their results so there is no tcyty to be sure that they correctly recorded your vote It'e must simply accept that "the computa is always right" no matter how unlikely the nported result or how crucial Thu fault a recount? Sony! their reckless Delaying the acquisition by Just year would definitely reduce the state's risks and likely its costs the state Most important must convince its citizens that any new voting system is at least as secure and trustworthy as the financial systems we use daily Ally other course is simply Continued from previous page alga Rive - S15995 :s1999 :11 r tft y'fjej")Nayeipinfgunscony Ind o6r R a rik're tint rit a ILL-rttitiLLI- 0 r I ' t " - 1- AND WINDOWS DOORS r174' :: i 4 '''''l 41413" - - 'f -- :: :ii:' : '' 1 :: ' st6i ::: ' ' ': - I ' "11011010taioL44144114 t-- i'''7 : P"1----7:1-- 1 f 'i' A04 ''b I : I ''' 0 !- I I 4 The Sprint PCS Fair & Flexible Plan m Every month Sprint automatically adjusts your plan to the minutes you use YCHI can save up to S3G3 a year — a great value 5trttembot nrtnNr r kont 'lex' a five r- 1 7 $35 " f WV For t4Anbr 11 1 comtA!ts:or) in-h- feli IMk Lome r 41 Mitt p Int $3'5 $40 as little as $35 a month ()the! monthly charge Iw Se1 atm Includes: Adjustable Anytime Minutes BY ANDERSEN '4'414 Win Au and door replaetrent firm a company you can trust t "- r7! F t A t Unlimited Night &Weekend Minutes 4s' aeN t!tt7't I Nationwide Long Distance included Every minute Every day Otte!' reateres b two year Sprint PCS Aniarnage Agreement Th3 phcrto evcrycn3 rants :' 1 I ii'l i! I l'171" 1 t li 31:11 'al 4 :' I I 11 i multi-shot- s --- ‘ 'k t c c'''''' ': phone book and dialing e v 1 - :- A — cameras Eu'y one for ‘ Ect rf': - 1 Lco 4 ere IEEE fetr'rt1044-'43a- 7i Personalize with voice clips 1 - " ( II'S t picturer with 22 customizable fun frames I ri: nt 4 flash Built-i- ssor:1 PCS V1310fi POOR! PhOIVE VG11OOL by Samsunc r Save $399 99 after instant savings with pontoon LA activotion of two new litifIS nf service on a Sprint PCS Service Plan with Vision oral s two-sliSprint PCS Advantaue Agreemem on each Ws of service tormi in Hurry Offers end October 10 2004 We r v" I 4 monitilvd '‘ 1 ots70me) okm 0 I 1 It S I t 'A t - ' " ' 1 '"- i : ow CPrtilitql Sprint PCS limine Sreciallsts enstiploo detttonstrwions! op f (!--- Store' 30t South um" Stem e tAlotn PCS NOW The PCS Center Mewl !Ilh4 I r -I -- $otiot PCS phoi p orr hra 14011 wwwsprintpcscom AmFRIrom FORK LAYTON -I 715 SAIT IAKr if touti Olif Pa (Tr( 13C3 ' 144 1 F Oto 1 PV I i MURRAY Spool 401 South ! Fp' frt 1 Mort r) 1 S 10 4' S IP S S "Taxes Stircharge! (including a USF charr of 2 OVA and cost recovery fee nl $fl are not taxes or government-require- BO or other surcharu( burcharge I I q'0 I 'NPF1 i'VOY iw— r! ID 0 frist!Wte ITT Co PVC MUITAY that vary by market) it Included charges ii I Nationwde thatlinfiv rearthes nye 740 million pitmtle Coverantt not avttile evevwbere Otteo ITOv not ht CfP11! 'term and condition! Fenity nvntwnoo: !Uh!f: Sec stnrc tnt detail! Otter end! Itt11tift4 Sprint PCS Fair Plan: Include minimum 3fiti MGIillr Anvlmt- k'inut!! 2! or 51) rmolim inctementt tot Lt 5(j A nnmetundaric witt 'ill ()I ow mmete tor UcIO(3 ablVt? 12ttit minute $3b phone activation fee deo $1Y: tnttnaalnn lee anti) A rtentr:! rdthiltid Night 8 Wftokend and tn 9orn - MOn JIrn DOMPIIIC roateenp can! are C3r1°C Si (S)r oer fliiiili- and It Mnutqs an Mon -- 111 nr gl:rn a attomund $f ?f dei minute for torip distance ajl:3IIf X1 WhOIP Call! ate rounded up to trlf rnintlte S300 Savings: Savings may not he typi e a and wh vmy based on ctownt fran anc antuai see sptintpcs cum turandliexitde fel detaii instant Savings: Immor savinm only available at pammating Swint Sturm Hequirer in stritc purohotAtt and attivanon ne two new itnet nt sittvice with Swim PCS Vision Savings may not exceed total purchase puce of phones (ft21J04 Sprint Ali oglds tecetved Soon! 810 the motrinf0 tutu am trademark of t)ptint fommunications Company L P en Ul I it' p i 1 JE 7ary v t morkFlk 1 1r A 4 ILA 'W 1 |