Show THE SALT LAKE TRIBUNE SUNDAY MORNING MAY 4 1930 The coinmltt-- e enters fully into this aspect of the case But to a layman the committees legal arguments There seem In the main Is lure no case of public moneys being siient for religious Instruction Business Office: 2436 Washington Avenue Office Phone 117 Rome Phone 8892 There Is Tio sectarian religious teaching in the schools The semlnarv is c school seminaries would be entirely apart from and Independent GIVEN TO of the high school It Is a separate tarian For the third year In the and distinct Institution for the supsenior high school seminaries the of public avork would be frankly sectarian but port of which not a dollar PLAYGROUND WORK for this no high school credit would money Is used Hence most of the committee be asked legal cases as cited by the said that some minis appear to a layman as having no Stale Group Aorepls Offer tersDrof Jensen other denominations had sup bearing upon the case OGDEN— Mrs J E Cave one of in Effort to Solve Semiimrted the seminary Idea In com Gives Estimates of the founders of the playgrounds muntcatiuns to the board and Dr Credit Exchanges movement of Ogden and Miss Merrill told of negotiations going orr Wfbrr County Assessment nary Question now which might result In coopera "The public school may not legally Jeppson one of the playtlon to some extent with the Protest teach religion but to give a limited grounds supervisors of the city have Shows Falling Off From from Psm One ) (Continued returned from the conference of the ant Episcopal church authorities In amount of credit on transfer for BiLast Year member previous to the Saturday Utah ble study from a nonseotanan point Commercial Security BnnL western division of the Playgrounds and Recreation association of Amer"We want to begin this faM" said of view is an entirely different tiling meeting Dr Now Commerce Merge ica held at Beattie Wash April 24 Merrill "to remove the causes In that report Dr Merrill dismissed from teaching the Bible In the school OGDEN— County Assessor Bur25 and 26 of the statements of the In- of complaint such as Mr William various asby the public school teachers at public Smith den has completed Commercial Security At the closing luncheon session in- sessment of property In Weber counexpense True the schooUdoes not spector's report as "untrue” Satur- son had Justifiably made” vitations were presented for the con- ty and Saturday afternoon anDr George Thomas member of the have supervision of tilts Bible 'study day he used the word "unfounded In vention next year at which time the nounced that of the University nor could it legally have supervision the grand total for the preference asserting at the same board as president OGDEN —One of the largest fi- Invitation from the chamber of com- year was $46 29 9 224 showing a deNor does the public school have su- time In effect that there might by of Utah desired to have the record nancial deals that has taken place In merce of Ogden was read Vancouas to his "views made clear a of theoretical over pervLMon over the teaching In anv the process crease of valuation $504000 reasoning Ogden for several years was made ver presented Its pleat' for a convento be ample grounds for the Dr Thomas Denies school Yet It Is the practice About of the private apiiear year preceding anwas public Saturday when it tion at a future date withdrawing of the public schools of America to to this valuation will be added statements but that facts developed nounced that a merger of the Comthe Invitation for the 1931 conven- by the state boar dof equalzatlon Mr bv his own research proved that Mr Seminary Opposition give credit on transfer from private mercial Security bank 369 Twenty-fourt- h tion In favor of coming to Ogden T schools and further the public Williamson s fears were groundless “The statement" he said In subSmith said street and the National Bank s of 62 members Mr Williamson was desirous of stance "which has been made at schools accept credit on transfcf The decrease Is caused by the fact of Commerce 2453 Washington ave- adopted delegation the Blogan "On to Ogden for that the bunks which were assessed presenting his version that the facts times that I am opposed to religious from reputable private schools for nue had been effected The merged the Convention In 4931” and other last Nor is the on property to the value of ahow that what logically was to be education is not true subjects that they themselves do not year name of coast cities have Institutions will retain the This Is common practice in teach have to return a fifth year to gradupledged their sup- $647899 are not Included In this expected Is true The board how- statement that I am opposed to the the Commercial Security bank for the convention at Ogden In year assessment as the result of ever was more Interested In the It gal teaching of the New Testament ate? The inspector concludes they America To regard this practice as The Information was given out that port 1931 The conference do And thus these repeaters throw Illegal seems a draught on the Imagtheir winning a suit to prevent colphases of the Issue Involved and sat- am willing to challenge anyone here the respective boards of directors of to meet at the next then adjourned ination The schools of America hae heavy financial burdens on the taxcity lection of taxes and also because the isfied Itself with deciding that oppor- as to the amount of literature I have the two Institutions have approved whlih Is to be later convention and was another point on established their relations upon a the the be on automobiles has been tunity shall New read This decided valuation vote payers given to Mr Williamconcerning by plan for the merger to be ratified of the entire unit membership We basts of confidence The public school son at the next meeting to present Old Testaments I average one book which we sought information reduced by the state since the forby a meeting of stockholders of the went to the records of all the high has confidence In the honor and Inthe data on which his statements a month The statement Is not true high school graduates mer assessment The deciease In Ogtwo banks as soon as they can be Under date of February 25 1930 schools in Utah where we have semiare based that I am opposed to the seminary den ritv Is $406 809 and In the countegrity of the reputable private legally called "I believe I have read almost every Registrar Haves of the B Y U re- naries for the years 1928 and 1929 school so private school certificates ty $98 000 The drop In the county Is Leaden Presented Under the terms of the marger the subthat was one this the decision are commonly accepted by the pubcourt average scholarship We found In 1928 there only bearing- on ported attributed to a decrease In livestock A Meeting Opens capital stock of the Commercial Seand some of them I have reread grade of these 205 students was 75 6 student who fatted to complete in lic school at their face value and the decreased valuation on autject "The committee report quotes the curity bank will be Increased and Dr Merrill Mr Judd and Dr Guy in the last four months I hove Rohe and ttiat the average grade of the the regular four years the requireomobiles stockholders of the two banks will betwo of the L D S 180 high school but ments for high school graduation by Utah constitution: ’No public money The valuation In the county was C Wilson supervisor of church to four attorneys come stockholders In the merged was 713 There entered reason of taking seminary classes or property shall be appropriated for BChools were presented when the faith and one Protestant and one graduates OGDEN — Members of the city made rs follows: Real estate $19 bank The merged Institution it Is $18587000 meeting opened and tn accord with Catholic and I find' them divided the Utah State Agricultural college that Is this was the only case In or applied to any religious worship commission and Chief of Police A E 603 370 Improvements 373 these of announced will have assets of an effort to honest livestock $5682 20 personal property the decision of the meeting of March after making high school graduates which It could even be assumed the exercise or Instruction’ We believe and will maintain a thor- Wilfong have filed an answer In the other than livestock $9540634 the courts In the United States try to Dr Merrill was asked to present his reach a solution Some of them are of whom 213 were seminary gradu- seminary was the cause of failure Seeond district court to the appliates Under date of March 20 1930 In 1929 there were three students who give sane and liberal Interpretations oughly modem banking service w h cation of former Patrolman W A The levy on the assessed valuation views His talk was not long since not residents of Utah Bell of the college reported assigned this as the cause of thetr to all constitutional and statutory such departments as are commonly "My conclusion Is that It Is not Registrar comity will not be known until he referred to the statement already a writ of mandamus to Itof Isthefixed maintained in such Institutions In- Jones fur In the hands of the board members the economic nor the scholastic que- the average grades of these 213 stu- failure to graduate In the regular provisions The Utah legislature apby the county commissionto the him compel city pay as salary dents a trust Is real but the here stion being 8142 The average four years And this presents the propriates money for the salary of its that Issue cluding thoroughly equipped as explaining tils position He asfrom the time that he was dis- ers about July I and legal grade of the The state senate opens department serted that the church Is operating that it Is the statutory graduates case at its worst And for each of chaplains Chief of Police charged by was 7936 H E Hemingway president of the Harry these years only one of these failseminaries In response to a public problem the dally by praver— a religious exercise on Anderson 8 29 January bank and Commercial ‘The remainder of the 962 graduing students returned for a fifth Does this violate the constitution? Security demand and disclaimed any Idea of It Is admitted In the answer that Speaker Says Court James H DcVlne of the National Chief ates who went to college— 204 in year oLhtgh school work 'Some- Literally yes a layman might say hi violating anv regulation of the board Action Is Unavoidable Anderson Jones and discharged seen times Commerce of when Bank there Is a very wide gap be- spirit no we believe every coiut number— entered the University of Dr Merrill presented data which that the city commission thereafter tween fact and fancy’ Can there be would Interpret It Does the support afternoon at Mr DeVlne's of- confirmed L D S church has spent a Utah Of these 92 were were "The based subon answers he said seminary Is his action it then set fice spoke optimistically with re- out of and praying of chaplains In conmitted to a questionnaire sent out to lot of money They say it depends graduates and 112 were nonseminary any Justification for a school offiof Jones’ disspect to the outlook for the new In- chargethatwasthehiscuuse "our people” From his research on a ministerial act of this board graduates A request for the aver- cial making grave charges against gress in the army and the navy of In action Four men age grade of the two groups was an Institution without having facts the United States violate the constistitution and said they were satis- that a detective In the rerirtlng work he found he said that the as- Some attorneys say not departinupt fied that a cltv of more than 40000 was under tution of our country? sumption of the state high school In- I have questioned said the giving of officially denied because of a long to substantiate hts charges? Influence of liquor the Its with established policy of the university Admits Benefit From large tributary In a soft drink population spector while based on on apparently credit Is unconstitutional on lower flperUI to Th Tribune Quote Law on parlor served would be better there to not make constitution reasonable theory was "entirely “If the by Twenty-fift- h territory public the grades of High School Transportation prohibits street and that he later LAYTON— Shook suffered when without foundation Tax state can students— of Exemption Is the merged bank than as heretofore called such the a In this people considered way a fact” being from his beat at Five Points she fell Into an Irrigation ditch In we ad“As to bus transportation Dr Merrill went on to say that correct It without asking this board confidential matter between the Inby the two smaller units "By law the property of rhurches said and that In the detective benIs mit quesher the home of that at seminary grandparents’ used for purposes of worship etc while he was at the Uni- to consent to something unconstit- stitution and the student— that it Is efitedfrankly It also Is announced that the A- tion had Rotten off a car and that he front proved by the transportation system Is fatal late Saturday versity of Utah professor ctual union of the two Institutions will If It docs not then It Is Impossible to give out the Informathe feeling had been utional exempted from taxation The propbelieved the detective had Syracuse (Jones) Is the corner of So school ton the afternoon toLeNa high two of weeks or decision for six for not take place common among his colleagues on the purely a matter tion asked" lay the erty of private schools used for school arrived to do him bodily harm stand refreshment the the old daughter of Mr and Mrs Delgrocery Is also exempted from taxwas months owing to the necessity for board Lake Salt this campus that City It Is further alleged in the answer bert E Lavton of Layton shop the business house and the '"rposes on Because of this would any "The American people respect the Argues Propriety complying with certain legal require that the detective making a mistake In curtailing its In question was town In which the as whole were a child's high The visiting school course by one year ments but upon the union of the two found not to be under the Influence parents decision of the courts Whatever we Of University Rule me person assert that public monIs located It could not be eys at the home of Mr and Mrs Robert Dr Merrill's report argues the pro- school banks all business will be conducted of liquor on lower Twenty-fift- h are being used to support the do here will be looked on a Something in the way otherwise the within But at of meaning Syracuse proBodily I think the matter at the Commercial Security bank street as alleged by Jones and himself caused Mr Eaton who is priety of such a ruling of the uni- of the law no sane person would as- churches and to support private that When Mr Layton walked across assistant superintendent of the Salt cedure should go back to the comwhile extensive alterations are being po trace of him could be schools? Is It not Just as versity authorities and points to infound at the road to visit a friend the baby Lake schools to say that the and the attorney genera! and stances where standings have been sume that because these places are to sav that public moneys are being made In the banking rooms of the Five Points after Jones had mittee high of a shallthe benefited called followed She fell Into swift by the presence high used to support the seminaries? school course tn Salt Lake not they with others Interested should made public The report continues: National Bank of Commerce build- the police station In the community they are ow Irrigation ditch and was carried been curtailed in the least has work out a system by which the "It Is fortunate for us alt the high school "From a fair and reasonable point ing The permanent home of the The city asks that Jones’ applicaIn In therefore was recov500 before part feet any of view we believe our state constiher body supported question can be presented properly schools and the other two senior colmerged Institution will then be In tion be dismissed Dr Merrill Infers sense the whatsoever ered money legal by the to the Judiciary only leges in the state were willing to that structure That is tution does not prohibit the public Fears Are Unfounded of the taxpayers A physician worked over the Infant sensible thing to do The following men who are acschool from giving credit on trnns-fo- r give us scholarship data otherwise "While considering this point of two hours but failed to resusci"In any event” Dr Merrill contindocs not make much difference we would have been denied in part tive officers In the merging banks “It from a private school for Bible tate her ued "the facts seetn to show that how this question Is settled here It at least a constitutional right — the expense let us indicate how the tax- courses conducted In a nonsectarion will be retailed It Is announced: to of In the lungs the fears of the professors based on Is beneficiaries are of Utah Absence water payers defense against a Charles H Barton H E Hemingway manner And this Is the view that going to go to the courts some right of defens of extent thousands to of the hundreds declare not well were the caused founded" that ten theory physician Harmon B Barton A 8 Patterson time If hot thlsear perhaps publicly made charge by a public of dollars annually by the expendi- American educators are more and He drew the Inference that' Mr shock and not drowning caused officer more coming to take The colleges Samuel O Dye J II Riley H W years from now" Williamson’s fears death be might similarly 'Now the average grade of the 1928 tures of the L D S church for eduA A W Phil OGDEN— Kohn the country generally as do our Budge Hlhlcy Dry raiders spread their First let us mention Salt of unfounded Suggests Separation of 1929 graduates of all the Utah cation and J R Hinchcllff and Loins P Cook nets In Ogden again Saturday Utah colleges give entrance credit and of education Lake board The to He a referred the $500 From fact that School Seminaries city The present boards of directors of mad) an unusual catch The raidhigh schools where there were semi- has been receiving for Bible study completed in chirch state from the Chemoffered the American by prize who had Joined naries shows that the seminary from Mr Robertson the merging banks are as follows: ers comprised two prohibition enschools If It Is legal for the state ical society wont to a freshman stu- with Mr Eaton in $20000 to $25000 annually for Commercial Security bank: Prank forcement officers Deputy United upholding the po- graduate had a higher standing than the education colleges to accept for entrance this semwhom student it In was a of who Snow dent college also Mr FurWilliamson Is It not legal for the sition taken by graduate J Stevens chairmanA of the board States Marshal James M Smith does not educate for they attend the credit on transfer six desired to make It clear that he Is thermore the and of said that graduate inary records Y Sheriff Patterson JL E Hemingway to do the same thing? R (B D Plneock and Deputy schools college 8 high school L D Not a 8 one been had college private essay prizes awarded Is there In asking not opposed to teachingt the Bible U and U S A C) show the same Fred M Nve W H Shearman David Sheriff John Holden this but the city board has been But what logic taken by a Japanese and five by sem- In the The persons arrested on charges of light of the data presented thing Hence the charge that semi- only Utah state colleges to refuse what Hickey william C Hunter Joseph O nrciCHVM CITY— B o x f d e r inary graduates saved a dollars thousand hundred Mr Williamson he thought it nary work is a scholastic handicap Read Adam Patterson Jr Robert violating the prohibition law were’ comity's fourth annual Dairy and elsewhere mav or more because It has not state Institutions Dr Merrill left the legal phases by Joo Hull 320 Twentv-fiflclear that a considerable amount of to the high school is untrue The annually Constitutional provisions street Black and White clay laid ly Brig- of the question to Mr Judd Byram and 8 G Dye grant? to educate those students had It the under was that it the work sectarianism "Doc” handicaps charge National Bank of Commerce: taught Thompson 2319 Washington ham City Saturday maiked a vast has provided no teachers it has pro- respecting separation of church and to look had Mr said he Judd tried Is unof student in also the avenue college H Barton W Abbott Fzra Charles John Sandman 2319 Wash- Improvement In the standard of the at this Issue from a legal J regulation vided and maintained no classrooms state sectarian religious teaching in point of Mr Robertson suggested as a so- true so far as is shown by availRichardson J H Riley P A Dlx ington avenue Tom Bernett the public schools etc are essen142 dairy steak of the county the In which to instruct them he He with had said conferred view grade be sepable records C J Humphrls O A Dickson Harry Twenty-fift- h street "Curley” y of animals being better than those Dr C N Jensen chairman of the lution that the seminaries tially the same in other states as the does not In any Cite Reason for 'Seminary work 8 Anderson L F WhlUock C H are In Utah" arrested In front of Cliff hotel displayed at previous dairy days The hoard Mr Robertson Mr Eaton Mr arated from the schools that they that the diminish number withdrawn of be the and way days Maintaining Dixie street Amell display consisted of Holstein Jersey Greenwood Mr Williamson and credit Thorstcnsen Fred E Williams at 214 Twenty-fift- h Authorities Other "reto the or sturecitations the devoted board about nothing 1L say A Mlebos basement of the Marlon ho- mid Guernsey Mock the black and others Thomas Leslie E R Alton "One reason for the maintenance Named in leased time" or the time during dent of English mathematics chemtel Lincoln avenue and Twenty-fift- h white Report More than 100 Bennlng and F M Drlggs Is no question In mv mind” is of Dixie church "There the that predominating college by to be per- istry or other prescribed subjects of street Roy Allen 2424 Lincoln purebred and Dr Merrill spends several pages in The directors of the merging banks rows and heifers said Mr Judd "that Mr Williamson school hours pupils were Itself district able the thinks grade hardly be absent from the school the high school curriculum Then Is will be organized and announced avenue Ben DcCorso 132 Twenty- - were displaced forth extracts from Weather conditions in hts inspections found violations mitted to public high his reply setting classes not pure fancy responsible for the to maintain a to attend K M LlghUtn 172 were Ideal during the dav when the legal steps carrying out fifth street publications and other utterances of We have agreed that classes Greenwood seminary law school Here again the school disof the mhis inference in that Mr Twenty-fift- h poor scholarship presented street Gus Dortls 226 the merger have been completed The cattle were assembled at tying there should be complete separation from educators In support of the contenthese fundamental subjects is trict has had Its apportionment Twenty-fift- h report to the board as a memstreet above tion in the last paragraph racks on North Main street at B a m of the was not edRom the high inority ber of the committee of which the chargeable to the seminary? The the state for students It or Bonds were fixed at $1000 In each and Judging began at 10 o'clock with school seminary more the quoted ucating For ten years rase The bonds were quit klv forth- Oeorge B Caine nnd George Bateauthorities Presare majority had reported at the March records do not support the Infer- public the Among school In Blanding has had ence He found: meeting coming and all the accused men were nina of the Utah State Agricultural Did Not Agree the free use of two or three class- ident F J Kelly of the University of released to await fui tlier action by college officiating as Judges On Blamed ailures Dean Milton Bennion of the Idaho On Bible Credits HunPresents rooms Greenwood and a big gymnasium all the authorities dreds of people viewed the dairy catLack of Study University of Utah J J Tigert Unitowned by the church "On the matter of giving credit Minority Report tle and Interested themselves In the lor Bllile study we did not agree "Other examples might be given ed States commissioner of education 'But from the standpoint of "1 That the operations of the L and others In connection with the “As to abuses of a rule the courts Judging Window to scholarship the Inspector's reported but we pass them and call attention have proven seminaries S D not Defacing The reply continues: club TRFMONTON— Herschel Arbon main exhibit the boys and have frequently held that the fact or a hindrance to the data on the time spent by students to the fact that the church Is giving be prejudicial “The sqminary system In Utah has of the p to students to about auffered a broken hip and a Dismissed agrieulUnal education on an high of the abuse could not be used studies indicate unfavortheir annually college Charge schools the of slate operations school displayed their purebred argue against the constitutionality bone and Ray Glenn 17 sufable condition From the standpoint two thousand Utah students How grown up under the sanction of the "2 That the expenses of the OGDEN— Charles It was rather of scholarship the data docs not in- much Is this saving the taxpayers of state board of education The fh't fered severe gashes about the Hlckenlooper calves and the cnlves provided the of such a regulation of and running 1912 a problem of correction of the abuse such seminariesoperation head Friday when an old car In 33 after remaining In the city Jml bovs by the 11local Kntnrv club students spend too much Utah? Several hundred thousand seminary began In September have not In any dicate tothat school with the at Granite Between the Mr Judd raised the question as to high and 12 o'clock the know as dollars all educators earn In in credits Bible time hich the boys were riding ove- nil night was arraigned In the cltv thetr state manner been borne bv tiie too little time to earn view of the above facts does it not unanimous permission of the local high school band composed of whether the constitution which gives rturned In front of the Bear River court Saturday morning on the "3 That there has not been any history but in credits pieces umi duerted by "genet at control'' of such rnnttets to Intention other studies Herein seem like a mockery for the Inspector school authorities These authorities their Joe Murray 17 es- chatge of defacing a plate glass win- seventv-tw- o the opof high school with Interfering C C Watkins gave an opcn-acondow In the Eccles building ttie state board and "control” to the erations of the the colleges will find an explanation to charge that the L D S seminaries permitted from the beginning reThat Reboots caped with minor bruises stale was placed under a $75 bond ceit at the coui1house giounds IochI boards did not take the issue for the unsatisfactory preparation of are a financial burden to the tax- leased time and creditwas for Bible They were removed to the Valley butHelater the relationship of ttie L D S semalso made tiie prosecuting wirings in from the Jurisdiction of the state inaries But another phase of this study This beginning payers? state sc hools has been their freshmen in English matheto hospital the ra-the knowledge of the office of board of education He waived that nnd will remain appeared and said that he The boys had obtained a dilap- the and matics etc 'There is no excellence question will be considered further with Independent of the of the for the purpose superintendent public Instrucno royal road to on present arguhliout labor idated automobile from a local pa- could not identity Hlckenlooper ns connections which Later January 5 1916 ment and assumed that ttie board free from any the "The inspector builds his case upon tion the case was houis of study Longer learning' with to the tend rage and were drlvmg It at top the culprit and Interfere might w hldi the charge was lias Jurisdiction to preset ibe the curseem to be a crying need in high the assumptions that the seminary state board of education formally austate of schools the woik speed when the car suddenly ove- dismissedupon thorized the giving of credit for Bible riculum 111 the schools At toast the credit in Bible handicaps the high school scholastioil the ground of insuffirturned making two complete some"4 That attendance at the sem- schoolsseems Mr Judd cited various state suto be earned something cally and burdens It financially study The records do not sho wthat ciency of the evidence study rsaults inal les is not tn any manner compucoutt He decisions admitted preme whs arrested across for which we are thankful Too lit- Since these assumptions are base- anyone objected on request of the parMurray was thrown clear but theHlckenlooper that there is good ground for doubt lsory but onlv "It may be that the teaching of sheet from ttie Eccles building of such students tle sturiv and not the seminary is to less In fact his whole case falls He the oilier two boys were pinned be- and ns to the legality of ttie regulation ents or guardians iy!ud that lie knew inching about blame tor failures in college fContlruiM on Followlnc Psr speaks cautiously of the legal phase with schools at the suite neath the car together of the windows and BRIGHAM the CITY —The annual of 1916 but held that there is no notice to the teacher and of fleers ot Oeorge and Vernon Glenn took ketnichlng no pan m It Mav scout cirrus of the Boxelder judicial decision which gives much state schools cousins of Rav Glen also are paslake was held at the high School help That under the law and cotients at the Valley hospital as a Under such circumstances he campus In this city Satmdav afterThree Hurt as Autos slate the statesi hool result of inturies suffered last Sunthat a mere attack on the con- nstitution of our noon at 3 o'clock under the direction 1W rights “Give day when their sedan toppled from of the regulation which board acted In keeping wit h people the facts scout W of D commisCollide stitutionality on Street Cummings Ogden credit tor Bible students I grade on the Blue Creek road has been In existence fourteen yeais In allowing sioner of tills district and the Instbv students Of church country is OGDEN -- Mr and Mrs J L Tin-ge- y The winners in the events were is sufficient tfo Justify the board 'in pursued tills present boaid of itutions That un—Abraham Lincoln the was that d saving regulation son Dahl as follows: and their education notwithstanding the rewere ui lured Satmdiy evening In an Bugling — Paul Welling Troop constitutional of ttie the of special majority port automobho collision at Twenty-fourt- h 1(12 lirst Bvron Jensen Troop 102 Advocates "Peaceful committee may assume that such s’reet and Jeffeison avenue second Oleen Anrfetson Troop 101 act wes and Is regular and should Actions” when a car belonging to I red Conway third: Rigby Roskellcy Troop 104 Legal "The question arises" continued stand until sueh time by proper proformer ns 'slant enmity attorney fourth it cedure it Is Jiidinausly determined Scout rare — Don Call Troop 103 Mr Judd "whether wewshould test OGDEN— Bovs' dav meet and Mav Mini k the 'l tpgev nnu lime to be wrong and unconstitutional Merout Dr ith After conferring sec604 Russell Police Dean vet who not event was luue determined week Bovs' Troop of flrt fiesta final rill and others they have authorized Claims No Misuse held at Lorin Farr park Saturday was (Irnmg th Conway car The loud: Leon Packer Troop 106 third me to sav that If the boaid follows diner of the car is alleged to have Ralph Holmes Troop 167 fourth the afternoon Numerous contests outline made here and H there of Irivllrges Granted under the direction of S sdipptd following the smash to ask Eat! Pierce Troop 107 fifth "6 That under the showing of Utah’s Eminent Geologist those who feel that the action are — bv Shuman Oi Hansen friction 1’ire If of tnev the Hi 3T ar DUworth Young Boy Scout cupauts is unconstitutional rather than open oi'cratuuis of the state schools and Carlvle Bowden were badly hu:: Jle then drove Troop 1(16 llist: schools for fourteen church ot the all for the liieworks jears up ON question Troop 192 second Talks on citizenship will be Risen HWHV that might result and If the last there appears to be no misuse Mr Tmgrv suffered cuts on the Jeppson Archery— Claud Troop sorts Monday In the schools on account of order of under such to matter the have wishes privileges board the of the fact that they could no: be aims and legs Mrs Tmgcy sut fried 107 first Fmmuel Robinette Troop tested we will cooierate in working this board as to forfeit or set aside an m lured buk and a rut light hand 102 second Clyde Mulspii Troop ? Riven Friday Citizenship day and the out up nn such action of the state board making plan Hansen 664 a Shuman third: the child closed fool were suflored schools and biuiscd cause the Troop "7 It docs not appear from the ' sttpula'ion of facts that we ran agree ICO fourth T on and m having a peaceful decision latent information we lias e that there Paul rivee— Welling Dressing Stake Contests Feature on the question without stirring up u nn inclination and desire to exgij Ogden Census Taking Troop loj and Hov Shaw Troop 103 tend and encourage the oppoitunlti feehtiss m the state M A tied I first for llox Cider Is About Finished Day Axle throwing — Thomas Yates public "At the same time we would like for religious and moral training and - time !' for have assurance to state oRIrestocooperntewlthprl-tlia- t since the Stone Spencer rRIGII M CITY -l- b F'rfer stake Troop D7 first OGDFN— Census enumerators of contracts should aheniv have vat" organizations (or such purposes Haile Tu’gev and distribution Mu! mh hr t u :r ar’oal M I V Tmop 1H2 second 11 the manufacturing under proper and lfga1 regulH'iqns been signed for nest year that the-Chile Madsen I'll third in ('tv Fatnrdac Tnvvp t survey is orswi g n a close snd it Mav dav be no Added to that I thuik t he rights of Troon 6nl fourth Ben Call Troop mav go out amt that there w illundtr:s said by W J Crltchtow who Is Conn os were held s’ 'he hleh si ho individuals should hi these matters need for disturbing them I M i hericing In that the si inrarv an i Fust waul chaiw! 103 Pf’li that a dh'pn Maud that new textbooks wil be not be overlooked ” -- Bob Andeison me I now fh a be a ild Big p short Aeropl made wplim sic He recommended that a committee Frank Htcken-Troo- p written and that we have found maGirls' noutile trio Four'll ward Troop lu6 Inst while He snd that there were nmy d be sclee'ed "to formulate sueh rules terial that shou’d not be 102 second cto aers about twenty-fiv- e yit to luai f'rsl pare Bei hive reto d s’orv Ru'h to these as will be proper and neco-Mi'- y Tent pi Thing — Troop in first: as ec‘arian We willforsubmit Hatisi n Si ci i d ward first double Irnm vour critiand regulation cl the control the you 1 minute to unofficially Time h)(( second Robc-tM ward Second rem is supervisor mixed quarte' first Troop D II ma'ters herein set forth ” cism and suggestion for the nornem (Barret 5mii Sat- Men) sneaklrg contest Harding 15 seconds Dr Merrill's reply to Inspector "VYilh the understanding that you 103 first Wall ! sealing— refirst Troop In 1’1'v and Seeond ward Girl: open Horsley Brigham urday e Williamson's rypoit after setting out the issue tested we will for the purpose of rpudug up ‘the told story Fsher Ormc Bear liner Troop 3111)7 second Troop 106 third want in taking it to the coutt COURTESY UTAH STOKER CO SUGARHOUSE the issues by quotations fyem tl f seconds Cenfust: ancuard re'old si my Time enumeration In those p!'ty Mr Williamson and of the of 102 ftr-- t Troon lelav— d 1n:-ribr Merrill first Dru Troop ward Plug sus taking frr geperai vJua:on Peg Skidmore Dr (Paid Advertisement) Hurd Troop inaioritv of the committee sas in speaking Zella 108 second Troop 103 figures outude of the lancer rices Gleaner Girls' public Church ObJeitne part should have been comoped tv the Skidmore Third w ard first M Met s 107 fourth Tune 22 — secondsli”2 "The language of both ronortscon-vrv- s Dr Merrill sup bmen'ed these rc-Tmop I last of April and It ! evope'ri hs male chorus won bv Ihhd ward Pyramid building bv tnl'‘re Dr Jensen tha' the urpresshn that the inew- iroep 107 second Tr vp 106 t marks rrrumnarv lgpres whi be cpcra fcjiilnatce ' won by Tlnrd fits' belli vi the Bibc CuU be tau': ur had made a ciueiul and even- 5 he seconds 11 Tunc thud W ai d witlun a lew oai OGDENYICINITY IMPETUS OGDEN BANKS Tn answer to without sectarianism another question he Raid the church Is considering proposals to have Junior high school seminaries which the are really religion classes the church has conducted for forty years and the work In these and In the first two years of the senior high L D S CHURCH SCHOOL TEST non-se- VALUES DROP PLAN FAVORED HALF MILLION JOIN BOARDS APPROVE PLAN la 00 - Ogden Answers slve investigation and was reporting But they exist only the facts as was not the case unfortunately this T iie facts are that the scholarship of seminary graduates is superior to ttiat of graduates both in high school and In college and ttiat the seminary is a financial help rather than a financial burden to tiie high school We secured data from every high 6chool in Utah where we have a in number — and seminary— fifty-tw- o found that in 1928 there were 2017 graduates from these high schools Of these 1109 or 55 per cent were also seminary graduates These students according to the high school records bad an average scholarship Rrade of 833 The 908 high school but graduates had an average grade of 81 In 1929 there were 2292 high school graduates from these schools where there were seminaries of whom 1197 or 58 per cent were also seminary graduates These had an average scholarship grade of 83 6 The 1095 high school but graduates had an average grade of 81 6 Claims Higher Grades For Seminary Graduates Further we followed these graduates into college We obtained from twenty of the largest high schools in the state where ttiere are L D S seminaries ttie names of the graduates of 1928 and of 1929 who had gone to college and the names of the Institutions entered There were 962 who entered college Of these 385 entered ttie Brigham Young univer slty 205 were bemtnary as well as "And the charge that the seminaries are costing the taxpayers of Utah thousands of dollars os also untrue The fact Is that they are annually saving these taxpavers How many thousands of dollars could it be otherwise? There are o seminaries In Utah serving an equal number of high schools They give a unit of credit for semiThis Is nary work of the work required for high school This sixteenth of the graduation work is costing many thousands of dollars not one penny of which the public schools are paying" Quotes School Leaden As Authorities Arguments in support of this contention are quoted by Dr Merrill from Francis W Kirkham formerly of Granite high superintendent school district from Superintendent R V Larson of Cache county Superintendent H A Pace of North Summit and others The argument continues: "These indicate the character of the answers received from the sixteen superintendents who wrote us What foundation in fact is there for the charge that the seminaries are costing the taxpayers of Utah many thousands of dollars? Why did the inspector charge that they do? "By reason of thetr seminary work do students fall in high school and fifty-tw- - Suit for Salary ry BABY FALLS INTO DITCH Sat-urd- SHOCK KILLS -- Ogden Haiders Gather In Ten IIoKlcin Club Displays Stock 1 h La-lie- Two Injured as Car Overturns 4-- ptl-vi- ’’ Box-eld- er lr Box Elder Slake Holds Annual e ' Scout Circus the safe" Joys’ Day Meet Held at Ogden 2- r ear-ol- HEAR DR FRED J PACK e — Weak Spots in Bowman’s - be-"- it Three Million Dollar Dam Scheme u- ( TONIGHT! At 9:45 Over KSL ' rr-p- re-u- "’ ron-true- TUNE IN AND GET TIIE FACTS s toop-erat- 5 1 ava-em- ' e 1 5-- THE ELECTION IS NEXT TUESDAY |