OCR Text |
Show 1913 d' TIIF, LOFAN, UTAH, Has Progressive Education ft & Earned a Permanent Place in Our Schools? tigs. I Mr. Mem in K. Hart President, Xrw York Stale Economic Council. fn,.niKi'p,rivk ,ral,rim. Teachers t "'r'f"y Cdmhit The OPENS: lltrT,rK, , MSlriuSon"the con in eauc?l,.on tppy . tc characteristic feratic Jregard tor personality civilization: fof S ) : modem democracy honest open-mindn imposed indoc- to lSifMKoeptanceof mans must nature that at for the common octal morality), of the modern study 14) adds JJJS that each most to him. tSfiudiesby Wrightstone. by Experiment, by New itparhnent-corrobor- at- no otters and denied by rec- r.ful study show tl) New York City to r 5 rSess.ve education; (2) Progressive ' clcrnen-lutetantial- ly equal to measured respects, su- inferior in 1: similarly secondary schools equal fleets, superior in 22, inferior schools" (eight tbe Thirty 1,) graduates from college a a tl , somewhat better job and the a comparison group, the aperimental the school, col- me degree of success in tor tr ac-- ij Increasingly our schools ,j judgment! No- i bast CHALLENGES: orro I humane regard foro gen-aaMitt or the other vague But ns of Dr. Kilpatrick. too aave EducaUon attempts en-- d i spreads out too far, has itself too readily with collecpropaganda. In 30 doing it teaching the York City or four years ago it was found such poor were atany pupils n toey couldn't read textbooks In New read. to MR. HART OPENS: Like many philosophies. Progressive Euu .it, on has a kernel of truth namely, that it Is important for the student to be Interested in his work and to enjoy it. But this is no new discovery. And Progressive Education, as a system, has not earned a permanent place In our schools. Already some former friends have lost confidence In it. Thus, Dr. Nicholas Murray Butler, President of Columbia University, whose Teacheis College has long been the chief exponent of Progressive Education, recently described Progressive Education as the turning loose of youth in to form such habits the world and. tastes as they from time to time And he added that may choose. . . . . nothing could be more reacmore tionary or damaging to youth," than the "extreme forms" of Progressive Education Sound education shows youth how Jo live and how to make a living. We have little to go by except the experience of the past. That experience teaches that life Is not easy; that to meet it one must develop all one's mental moral, physical and spiritual powers: that such develop' ment comes only by Progressive Education, as a system, runs counter to these inescapable facts. That is why it has failed. ... DR. KILPATRICK CHALLENGES: President Butler was never friendly to progressive education (Mr. Hart made that up). He knows littie about it For forty years his gaze has been on politics and international affairs. Mr. Hart properly wishes sound education" and Progressive education best provides both. Wrightstone found, scientifically, that the progressive school teaches the subjects better and "provides more and better opportunities for develop- Furing desirable social qualities.ther the experimental school pupils were found to be significantly more honest, the conventional school puto be more deceitful." pils progressive education stresses; that is its chief aim. Here It Is Logan Couple Return From Coast Dll imp have Mr. and Mi's. F returned to their homo m L'K.im alter a stay of five weeks on tile coast planned to hasten the recovery of Mis Champ hum i.er recent illness. Both aie delighted to be lyaek home again and ale singing the praises of Log in and Cache Valley. They say it is a leal joy to be home again after the congestion and the activities in the coast area. While on the coast they spent considerable time on the beard and some time on the desert, at the same time as keeping in touch with essential business activities at home. At Los Angeles Mr. Champ also attended a meeting of the regional executive committee of the Boy Scouts of America, to which committee he had, been elected by the Utah people during his absence. He also had a conference with W. S. Rusecrans, president of the American Forestry association on the western application of the e association's forest resource study. It was a real thrill to retain to my home state when it was accomplishing the remarkable achievement of leading the nation in the second victory loan drive," 1 "lt At debated by war-tim- Said Mr. Champ, who has served since early this year as general chairman of the Cache county war bond committee. "The result both in Cache county and throughout the state evidences not only the patriotic determination of (Utah citizens, but also he good sense which Utah citizens have al-- 1 ways manifested in times of stress, as well as the outstanding organization work carried through by those leaders in and out of the banking business who conducted NEW MEMBERS ' indued From Page One) Cadman, Nolan Sharp, Blaine Wilson, Verl iei Howard Hollingsworth, accompanied by DeWilt Swain;, ton; girls trio, "Teach Me To Pray", Jewitt, sung by Clarice Condie, Norma Harding, Jeanne Brown, accompanied by Franoinc Dunkley; cornet solo, "Ecstasy", by Smith, Robert Anderson, accompanied by Francine Dunkley; vocal solo. "A Flower For You, Mother Dear", by Wilson, Maxine Condie, .violin obligato by Anna Mae Palmer, accompanied by Colleen Geddcs: vocal solo, "Invietus, by Huhn, Blaine Wilson, Maxine Condie accompanist; vocal solo, King of Glory", by Parks, Coy Faye Packer, Kern- Packer, Nathan T. Packer, Junclin Wilcox Christensen, accompanied by Swainston. Perkins, Hal D. Peterson, GwenPresentation of graduates, Ern- dolyn Phippen, Alan Lee Pickett, est Eberhard: presentation of Ruth Pratt. It. June Rawlins. Am) Rasmussen, Pr2side.1t Paul diplomas, John M. Ri( hards, Jr., Gwen Wynn; benediction. Connie Cole. A list of graduates follows: Beatrice Scnmons, Nolan Barbara Larsen, Alene Alder, Porter Sharp, Alyeo Marie Smith, Zane G. Alder, Keith S. Alder, Barbara Connie Jcui Smith, Robert J. Anderson, Beulah Bell, Smith, Demine Smith. Glenda Eva M. Belnap, Fred Rich Bing- Smith, Leon D. Smith, B. Gnrnell hedukd for summer distribution is bus c War Ration Book No. 3. Each of the lour in ham. Margaret Binghm, Ned Jl Sorenson. Bonnie Lou Stocks, Cleo side pages has 48 "unit .tamps of the type now ustd for sugar, (orlop and shoes. Guns, Bodily, Phyllis Booker, Otlie Jean Talbot. Ellen Juanita Talbot, Ellen tanks, Bowden, Dale H. Brostrom, Zclina June Talbot, Donna Tanner, La (anirrs and warplanes are illusfR.ic on thi se stamps. The back four pages contain point stamps similar to those ;n Ration Buok No. 2, although ui slightly dilliu.nl design and punted in Chadwick, Albert B. Cherry, Beth Rue Tavlor, Verneal Taylor, Ida blown. ( O W photo.) , Choules, Ruth Choules, Coy E. Beth Ward, . Warrick, Virginia ivie Wells, Christensen, Colleen Coburn, Con- Arlalia Web-ter- , lielcfl nie Cluriie Cole, Kuthryn Cole, Wilcox., Wiser, Paul the drive. To Mr. Hurren, chair- during a tune when it has been responsibility of the county year Condie, Maxine Condie, Donna Ross Wynn. man of the victory fund commit- necessary for me to be away and bond organization embodied in its tee for Cache county, and to Mr. to leave this work entirely on his various committees to continue Russell S. Hanson, general vice hands. The people of Cache counchairman of the Cache county war ty have accomplished a remark-jabl- e (this job after the intensive effoit bond committee, who organized goal in purchasing, under the of the drivu, has been directed to the cooperation of the two com-- j leadership of thes' men and the'r completion by the victory fund or mittees so effectively in this great associates. $770,009 of war bonds financial transaction, the largest of the various types during the ganization." ever undertaken by the people of brief ieriiMl of (his dilie. We must DISBARRED Cache county, should go our sin- continue our regular purchases of cere congratulations. bonds of the E scries and extend SALT LJkKE CITY. April 29 (LD "X am particularly grateful to the effectiveness of our payroll - R. O. Pearce, Salt Lake City, toMr. Hanson, who has carried on so deduction and pledge purchases to day had been denied the right to effectively in the direction of the sustain the interim financing be- practice law in Utah by a Supreme war bond committee's program tween the victory (Lives. It is the Court ruling. - De-Wi- tt . Sca-mon- s, ge air-ci- 1 De-an- vhels 48 , Mr. Prjccts. Part-t,m- e in- - between graduated, and 1923, granted a masters cllege LS Little TROUBLES O , ' St' i iMHTSLEE- Pie 'n itv hPVrinv bed because ,w GAS 1 toss CON-R- E PRES-c- t you sleep. Be P take a dash of adler.uka pressure i; r"leve0n ,l,e ncrve and .ins of tk.' I" lirge 'i'Uve G tract. Ad- - ?t "a'tcs and through ormTs.?. lll t I'3''1' Free Brake and Front End Inspection! Motor Tune-u- p t bowel dy :of ' - , re(re.-,lic- CJ". and dsy i wui k or fun. -- llljf Driii - or.,. Morq . . 4 Lubrication 1 ,00 Wash ....1.00 Simonizing 7.00 Our experienced meehan-ic- s can help you prolong car! the life of Motor 'ur Overhaul Jobs With Convenient GMAC Budget Plan for Repairs Exceeding $25.00! MILLER CHEV. CO. .. Ctf Y .id bordo ,aodYP0' coif A Quality to fill Every Roofing Need ncw JOy MICA SURFACED ROOFING . . . Complete With Nails. Covers 108 Square Feet MICA SURFACED ROOFING . . . Made on ary felt Covers 100 sq. ft with 2" overlap. Nails furnished. No. N326B. Per Roll $1.69 36-L- B. 34-l- 45-L- r MICA SURFACED ROOFING . . . 55-L- Made on 48-l- felt Galvanized nails furnished. Carries Underwriters proval, Class C Label. No. N326C Per Roll a MICA SURFACED ROOFING . . . 65-L- Ready-Paste- WASHABLE dry $1.98 Made on 58-!- Wallpaper d FADE PROOF GUARANTEED Ap- development Now, thanks to this greatest since wallpaper was invented, anyone can do expert home decoration without so much as changing into work clothes! labor-savin- g jlry felt. Thoroughly saturated and coated with pure asphalt Galvanized nails furnished. Carries Underwriters Approval, $2.-1Class C Label. No. 327A. Per Roll 9 So Easy To Hang! No more messy, smelly paste no All you more buckets, brushes, trimmers, seam-rollerdo is wet TRIMZ wallpaper apply to the wall and smooth over with a sponge! Its marked off in feet for SLATE SURFACED ASPHALT ROLLED ROOFING . . . Guaranteed 17 Years. Made with 100' L pure asphalt coating and finest quality saturated felt Covered with highest slate granules to give lasting beauty and priced Bears service far beyond the guarantee period. the Approval Label of Underwriters Laboratories. No. N328, Red. Per Roll $2.91 No. N329, Green. Per Roll .$2.91 90-L- s. Fade-proo- f Fire-resista- nt to insure straight easy measuring . . . and perfect pattern matching . ; ; and it dries in edges 20 minutes! , : So Easy To Select! Your choice of stunning style-teste- 90 LB. GUARANTEED 17 YEARS ready-paste- d ibeauty-by-tlie-bo- Split Roll ASPHALT BRICK SIDING Resembles regular bricks. Buff color brick effect with black mortar lines. Improves the appearance and Value of your home. Cuts down on upkeep for it never requires painting. Easily applied at a low cost Use over old wood siding. Roll covers 100 square feet 32 inches wide, 43 feet long. No. N332. No. N332A Base Starter. 47 lineal feet to a full roll. Per Roll ...$4.79 No. N332H Reinforced Corner Strips. 20 corners, per 2lj" x 2V,z", 331" long, covers 55 lineal ft Per box, Box $8.19 Three Tab Asphalt Standard Hex STRIP SHINGLES ASPHALT SHINGLES Guaranteed 17 Yean Guaranteed 17 Years Gambia's slata surfaced shingles stand up for years against the abuse of wind, snow, sleet, rain and hot rays of sun. They ere made of the same quality materials used in Tab shingles described at left. Two bundles weigh 168 pounds and cover 100 square feet allowing for head lap. Shingle size is lit i inches by 36 inches and are available in Jade Green and Tils Red colors. Each roll carries the Label of Approval of Underwriters' Laboratories. coat- ' Only 100 pure eiphalt ing and finest quality saturated felt are used in Gamble's shingles. Covered with highest a slate priced Fede-proto give lasting beauty and service far beyond the guarantee period. Size 12x36 inches. Three bundles weigh 220 pounds and cover 100 square h feet and allow lap. they bear the Underwritof Label Approval ers' Laboratories and will reduce insurance costs as much as 12 nt compared to wood thiagles. gran-ule- two-inc- Pr BuncJl Per Bundle No. XSSI, Green Blend msEvuseer; No. N331.V, Red Blend 2.(19 No. N830, Jade Green ... 3.19 No. N331B, Blue 2.(19No. 3:10V, Ith-m- l Mode by lh maker of TRIMZ Ready-Fatte- d Border for painted Tile Red 3.19 . wall. x, ' s d, washable patterns. Packed in indi-vidua! boxes. Simple chart tells correct color schemes, shows exactly how many boxes needed (3 boxes enough for average room). Priced $1.98 and $2.19 per box, borders included. $1.39 for ceilings. Transform your home with this and amaze your friends. fade-proo- f, return ysvvj.,.' lnd 'hi discomforts req re P Before you know I: keimg cfe!n' Birning finds bY Spring Special (6cyl.) i ?T )UST BIG SAVINGS In Essay Contest ,e M C' , I) e alt 1 - LUon n, From Page One) AT greatest cheer la Corbridge, DeKoy Crot kett, barn Cummings. B. Reed Beverly Ciimaiings, Cutler, Inn Egbert, Maxine Fors-greVermin L. Forsgren, Cleo Marie Fryer, Neva M. Gamble, Colleen Geildes. Virginia Geddes, H. Gilbert, Dallas Dorothy Greaves, Barbara Hansen, Robert Hansen, Joyce Harris, Bret Hart, Ruhiird W. Hendricks, Dorothy HollingsHollingsworth, Phyllis Aebeeca Utuna worth, Inglet, Phyllis C. Johnson, Vents Johnson. Dr Mar R. Kern, Margaret Jane Kerr, Carol Kofoed. La Vera Larson, I.ynu J. Larson. Willurd Helen Lemmon, Lewis, Glemla Lloyd, Don Martin, Mary Lou Maughan, Mamie Jean Earl R. McEntire, McCombs, Erma Merrill,. Merrill, Douglas Geruld Men d, Ida Moekli, Nona Mortcnson. Dorothy Nelson, Fay Nelson. Ethel Ann Oliverson, Anna Mao Palmer, Palmer, Mildred HERE'S MORE ABOUT CARLOAD JUST ARRIVED . ORDER NOW leaders is State winner of the annual essay I G. Fister, graduate of the contest sponsored by the Veterans C m 1938 and now personnel of Foreign Wars Auxiliary is Shirley Miles, 18, of Price, student ht In the industrial acof Columbia at Carbon senior high school, cording to Mrs. Ruby Welch of company. Mr. Fister has had contest gsduate work at Stanford Logan, chairman of the "sty. He is married and has in Utah. Written on the subject, United cloldren. Formerly employed We Win, the essay was entered Personal Finance Company Lt Lake and Provo as assis-ba-n in the contest along with other from various manager, he has also outstanding articles Miss 4 on the board of directors high schools of the state. unani chosen was Miles' M tbe Provo essay and Salt Lake (clambers of commerce. Mr. mously by the three Utah State A. N. r 'cond generation Ag- - Agricultural college judges associate ' Drprofessor of M. Fister, Sorensen, George f Ogden. English; Dr. Ira N. Hayward, Rice, W. Hillnm la vocational dean of men, and Moyle Q. Wore instructor professor of English. at Granite assistant Second place winner was Clair ' Salt Lake City. He " h im the college in 1918 Huffaker Jr., 18, of Magna, stuwhile received a master's degree dent at Cyprus high sehool, stu17, of Providence, USAC i,i 1941. He i Lowe, Ray the at South Cacho high, cHinc 0 Aggie grads, Duane dent nl Bruce . Htllam, 41, third. Mrs. Welch, in commenting upon are now in the Rrm "Wur has ird member of the the essays, observed, ,7 y Shirll'y. is a student had an effect upon young people. i now. They write with vigor, sincerity 5?0, k1800 is construction and conviction. Their ideals are Provo river proj-bee- n patriotic and wholesome distinct. . on in the employ of ly American." eau of Reclamation for years, during which time Charge of the in "itoTJ" planning of numerous i'i 3 Gcdilos, Cunnic Jean Smith. Muhic.il numbers during panel: boys quartet, "The Builder", by Winners Anounced ABOUT War Ration Book No. (Continued gressive Education just doesn't work. HERE'S MORE TAGE FIVE. L SEMINARY WPA workin, taught to made to reading, and then ne this in the hese pupils to read m! school system in America.' EEPLIES: Mr. L HLf ATRICK show his educa-- j I statements MR. HART REPLIES: Laymen are ignorance. The New York City not alone In thinking progressive tl progressive education began education spreads out too far. toe first grade in 1935. "Three In 1933 the Principal of Haaren nr rears ago" these pupils were High School, New York, complained K third or fourth grade. Mr. of having to offer 100 subjects under poor high school readers then a highly complex elective system. As according to his own a result, he said, We have a After tut years trial of prone education in' seventy city bewildered student body and a conlk 50,000 pupils, the State De-a- nt fused and harassed teaching force. who of Education evaluated it; We have graduating groups (abetter; recommended its per-ts- t are masters of nothing and not even adoption throughout the sys-ni- u jacks of all they have attempted to the city has approved. study. We have a letdown In student is elsewhere V show like superi-- L morale and stamina The trend toward progressive Space prevents further Comment tat is both widespread and As a system and a philosophy Pro- -' year High School. ed to be brought Tt HERALD-JOURNA- !f |