Show BY i jun S 1 WI 1111 HAD ka 0 TO LAM f in guesdon qiu atlon should ravert 1 q to tut ivl 1141 fi say says cje cue mill 1 al A beaded to maher Hl tier court SALT LAKE rob eb 17 through Th rouel a decision given 1 yesterday erday by judge john A marshall in the I 1 V U states dist district riot court COO j acrea acree of land located oa an the south fork ot of miller creek ta in cariton carbon coun ty and said to con conta talt lr coat coal which was cold sold by tho state land in 1904 to tao george r badger od ad later lator transferred to arthur A j sw sweat must revert to the th halted states judge mar ff shall hold bald that the state laud board bad had no right to 41 spose of the U am a it waa known to contain miner f als tho the case la Is similar to m y other others which have been the of coush lerable litigation tho the land in question iw atlon was A chool school section deeded to tho the state when utah waa admitted to the union tho to government ruling has been that where school sec sections tIona in the th laud land grant A were known to contain mineral tho the amton in hould should revert to the govern government mont and other made la n abol tead stead the e tate tte t te S 0 contended cou tended that this ruling appi oab ta in cases where the land wae was known to be mineral prior to the statehood brant grant the suit against mr air sweet was filed in ia tho the united state states court hero here h ere on an january Ja fluary 22 1807 1907 by fiod fred A A maynard special to 0 o the ith united states ut attorney torney gen aj iral eral arnd nd bolted strIct at torney II 11 E dor boh dorm M the A contending contend lne that ae as the land wa j known to contain ani noral the state had no title and wul therefore could ant 1 loniak into an agreement ent to in dispute of it the land iq 10 question tion la is all of section 32 township 15 1 south a 8 east fae located oear near lie mines of the 1111 fuel company at Il lU awatha lawatha boon soon attar tho the flur of tho the eielt a general denial waa was ad by the sweet interests ft pl though tin an wae vua nude that vol about forta fort a cres acree tt ot the track of u acrea wilah waa purchased from fc the state wae was known to contain cain coal tao tie suit has dragged gli the federal court tor for seven years and waa was finally clofed when judge mrshall marshall gave ate yesterday in which lie he b bom 44 that tha th a had no S right io to dispose of ot the section ot of land in que question and ordered that acres of the acre tract ro vert vart to the subtle the SS remaining rema laing forty acre acres may romala romain to the purchasers 7 ho he au autt it at aleo so asked for the aarm saana of the oon i art rat 1 ato br the tate state for or the t f the land but judge marshall refused to eater enter euch such an a order cm on the ground that the gov soy bad nothing whatever to do with the between the tho awa state ird ir nd d an individual but il waa was a dandeo which tb aby f mut mi settle bot tto te tet t tween f the decision givah erday WM wan against fred A kneet ae as admonia S tor for the estate of arthur A sweet aramast whom the original action was the land tion vas was trans to the tha united states smelting smelling Sm elting mining corn pany when thai that company look over ever other jarge large coal internet inter tats held hold by mr sac et and haa in i 1912 rho transfer waa mad out 4 deot ic 0 the decision of th 1 court on 1 the badger jand pending the do eul 11 no tw development work ban t A been done on the land p fred A sweet a vold id yesterday that in all probability an would bo be taken idge mar afar 01 ball shall a decision clelon dc as it as not shown during tl p rial that any of the land with the exception ot of the doity acres contained coat alood rain eral 1 |