Show from the new york herald judge brocchus to ito governor young requesting to DC be carried to church MoR xiNG aug alst 1851 judge Bro brocchus cobus tenders his bis compliment a to gov j toung aud and begs leave to say that he be would be glad to accompany his excellency to church this morning judge B is still in feeble health and could not with pro propriety biety ven venture tare to walk to church Riemor memorandum andam when governor young arrived at church on an foot judge B was in the stand before win him T BULLOCK his clerk 13 YOUNG TO P IL G S L city sept 19 1651 DEAR sm SI REver ear wishing to promote the peace love and harmony of the people and to cultivate the spirit of charity and benevolence to all and especially towards strangers I 1 propose and respectfully invite your honor to meet our public assembly at the bowery on sunday morning next at 10 a m and address the same people from the stand that you addressed on the ath dinst at our general conference and if your honor shall then and there explain satisfy or apol apologize apologise ogise so to the satisfaction of the ladies who heard your address on the ath so that those feelings of kindness which you so dearly prized in your address can be reciprocated by them I 1 shall esteem it a duty and a plea I 1 sure sare to make every apology and satisfaction from my observation which you as a gentleman can claim or desire at my hands should your honor please to accept of this kind and benevolent invitation please answer by the bearer that public notice may be given and widely extended that the house may be full and believe me sir most sitio sincerely and respectfully your friend and servant BRIGHAM YOUNG zoli ho PERRY FY E BRoc cutis amsl justice P S be assured that no gentleman will be permitted to make any reply to your address on that occasion P PE E BROCCHUS TO YOUNG G S L city sept 19 1851 DEAR SIR your note of this date is before me while I 1 fully concur in ia and cordially reciprocate the sentiments expressed in the preface of your letter I 1 must be excused from the acceptance of your respectful invitation to address a public marri marrible bly at the bowery tomorrow to morrow morning aning ift if at the proper time the privilege lega of explaining had been allowed me I 1 should promptly and gedly have relieved myself from any an erroneous r imp p es lessious that my auditors might have derived from the tha substance or tone of my remarks but as that privilege was denied me at the peril of having my hair pulled or my throat cut I 1 must bo be permitted to decline appearing agid again i n in pu public alic upon the subject I 1 will take tak e occasion here to say that my speech in allias parts was the result of deliberation and care not proceeding from a heated imagination or a mad as seems to have been a general impression in I 1 intended to say what I 1 did say but in so doing I 1 did not design to offer indignity and insult to my audience my sole design in the branch of my remarks which seems to be the source of of fence was to vindicate the government n of the united states from those feelings of prejudice end and that spirit of defection which seemed to pervade the public sentiment that duty daty I 1 attempted to perform in a manner faithful to the government of which I 1 am a citizen and to which I 1 owe a patriotic allegiance alleg ianca without unjustly causing a chord to vibrate painfully in the bosom of my hearers such a duty I 1 trust I 1 shall ever be ready to discharge with the fidelity that belongs to a true american citizen with firmness with boldness with dignity always abs observing s a dus due respect toward other parties par lies whether assailants sai lants or neutrals it was not my intention to insult ar offer disrespect to my audience diance au and farthest possible was it from my design to excite a painful or unpleasant emotion in the hearts of the ladies who honored me with their presence and their respectful attention on the occasion in conclusion I 1 will remark that at the time of the delivery of my speech I 1 did not conceive that it contained anything deserving the cei censure sure of a just mind edderson ed person my subsequent reflections have fully fally confirmed me in that impression I 1 am am sir very respects U your obedient servant PEARY PERRY E BROC BROCCHUS CHUg to his excellency YOUNG BRIGHAM YOUNG TO r P E 0 S ir ci cay y sept 20 1851 drap SIR SIP the perusal of your note of the dinst has been the source of some sober reflections in my mind which I 1 beg leave to communicate in the same freedom with which roy my soul has been inspired in the contemplation with a war of words on party politics factions religious schisms sms current controversy of creeds policy of duns darls or state clipper clique I 1 have nothing to do but bat when the eternal principles of truth are falsified and light is turned into darkness by lo 10 mystification of language lai guage or a false delineation of facts so that the just indignation of the true virtuous upright peaceful citizens of ef the commonwealth is aroused into vigilance for the dear bought liberties of themselves and fathers fathera and that spirit of intolerance and persecution which has driven this people time and times limes again from their peace peaceful fal homes manifests itself in the flippancy of rhetoric for female insult and desecration it is time that I 1 forbear to hold hola iny my peace lest the thundering anathemas ana themas of nations born and unborn should rest upon my head when the marrow of my bones shall be ill illy prepared to sustain the threatened blow it kas has been said that advise man fora fore seeth evil od and aideth himself the evil ag of your course coarse I 1 foresee and shall bide myself not by attempt attempting ilig to screen my aay act or the conduct of this people from the gaze of an assembled universe tin iverie but bat by exposing some of of your movements designs plans and purposes so that the injury which you have designed for foi this people may fall upon your own head unless yon shall choose t till is accept the proffered boon the friendship which I 1 extended to you yesterday by irviing you to make satisfaction to the ladies of this valley who felt themselves insulted and abused by your address of the ath dinst and which you have declined to do in your noto note to chieh this is a reply in your note you romark remark if at the proper tune time the privilege of explaining had bad ben b en allowed me I 1 should promptly and gladly have relieved myself from any erroneous imp es my auditors might have derived de n 1 v e d from the substance and tone of my remarks b but a tas as that privilege was denied meat me at the peril aff having my hair pulled or my throat cut I 1 must be permitted to decline appearing again in public on the subject 1 sir when was the proper time to which you refer was vas it when you had exhausted the patience of yom audience on oil the eth after having given a personal bhulla challenge to any one oae who would accept was it a proper lime dine to challenge for single combat before a general assembly of the people convened especially lor for religious worship how could you thena have promptly and gladly relieved yourself from any erroneous impression your auditors might have derived from the substance and tone of bf your remarks when you knew not from what source your auditors derived those impressions and was it your boasted privilege your proper time to fire and fight your battles oer again as quick as you had given a challenge without waiting wailing to see if any one accepted it ita if so BO who would yoa have been likely to hit ladies or gentlemen genO emen it was true sir air what I 1 said at the close of your speech and I 1 repeat it here that my expressions may not be mistaken I 1 said in reference to your speech judge brocchus is either profoundly ignorant or wilfully wicked bopf one ef the two there are several gentlemen tle an who would be very glad t to 0 prove rove the statements that have been made abo about ut it judge adge brooch brocchus Broc chue is and ana which he hp has attempted to repel but bat I 1 will hear nothing more on either side at this conference and why did I 1 say ii h to quell the excitement which your your remarks hd bd caused in that audience not to kive give bir or accept accent a challenge but to prevent any one of which there them were many present wishing the opportunity tuula tun ity and every one from accepting your challen challenge 9 I 1 and thereby bringing down d 0 nan upon con your head he ad toe indignation bf an outraged outrage d p people eol in the I 1 midst of a conference J convened for religious oas instruction and business and which your remarks continued must have 1 continued continue aAe the excitement until there would have been danger er diff of pulling of hair and cutting of throats perhaps pe rEaps haps on both sides if parties had proved equal for there are points in human actions and events beyond oud I 1 which men and women cannot be controlled starvation MI I 1 A will revolutionize any people and lead them to act of atrocity that human power cannot control and wall ill not a bothers pothers po bothel mothel s feelings liveli 1 in in view of her bar murderer wring I 1 her bleeding anfu husband baiad and her dying ami sire by wands of violence be equally strong and uncontrollable and especially when tantalized to the highest pitch by those who stand or ought to sa stand or sit with dignity on the judgment seat and L kincart mp rt justice alike to all sir what confidence can this persecuted murdered outcast people have in your decisions from the bench after you have tantalized their feelings from the stand by informing them there th ereis is yet hope in their case if they will apply to missouri and illinois I 1 ask you yon biz 64 it if you youdia edid idid not know when you was thus making your plea that this people have plead with the authorities of those states which are doomed to irretrievable ruin by their own acts from their lowest magistrate to their highest judge and from their halls of legislature to their governors times and times and tunes times again until they with force of arms have driven us from their midst and utterly refused the possibility of the cries of murdered innocence from teaching reaching their polluted ears I 1 ask sir air did you know this if not you were profoundly ignorant you were possessed of ignorance not to be tolerated in children of ten years in these united slates but bat on the other hand if you were in pos possession bession of the facts you yon were wilfully wicked in presuming to tantalize and rouse in an ger dire those feelings of frail humanity on one hand and offended justice on the other which it is our object to bury in forgetful forgetfulness nes and leave the issue to the decision of a just god your motive action or design you wholly concealed or yu you could never have gained a hearing on such an occasion As presiding officer in said conference did I 1 permit any man to 10 accept your challenge no sir air you know I 1 did not and could you as a gentleman ask the privilege to defend your chal challenge lengo before it was waa accepted don otte should not be named in such a fare farce no sir air out of mercy to you I 1 prohibited any man from accepting your challenge and until the challenge was accepted you had nothing to reply to when then was the he proper time you refer to when dien you would have replied and the privilege was denied you no such time as you had supposed existed and now sir air as it appears from the whole face of the subject that tomorrow to morrow might have been the first proper time that might have given you the die privilege of explaining and as this courtesy you have ut berly refused and thereby manifest a choice to leave arx an incense incensed d public in incense sti still ill against your year as they now view it dishonorable course I 1 shall ake the liberty of doing my duty by adverting still further lo 10 you reply of yesterday charity wo id have ind iced me to hope at least leas that speech in par part was prompted by the impulse jim pulsa 0 of the moment but I 1 am fo forbid abid this pleasing re flecion ion by your note who ein you s diate ate that my speech in all its parts was the result of deliberation and cars care not proceeding from a heated imagination or a maddened impulse 1 I intended to say su y what I 1 did say now if you did actually aey acy cl intend clintena to say what you did say it is a that were not no ignorant birong sl rong presumptive testimony you for if you had been ignorant from whence arose your intentions in ent ions and if you were wera not ignorant T i no r you must mist have lave been wilt wilf I 1 uly lly wicked and lean can not conceive of a more charitable construction to put p ut upon your conduct on that occasion than ihan to beli believe 11 you designedly and deliberately planned a speech to excite the in indignation dig nation of your hearers to an exten I 1 I 1 that hat would cause them to break the bonds of propriety by pulling your hair or cutting your throat willing no bulling doubt in the utmost of your benevolence to die a martyrs death if you could only get occasion t to 0 raise the hue and cry and re murder a virtuous people as missouri and illinois has so often done before you glorious philanthropy this and corresponds most fully with the declaration which it is reported on pretty that judge brocchus made while on his journey to the valley substantially as follows if the citizens of utah do not send me as their delegate to washington by god ill use all my influence against them and and will crush them I 1 have the influence and the power to do it and I 1 will accomplish it if they do not make me their delegate now sir I 1 will not stop to aggue the point nt whether your honor made those observations that at rumor says you did but I 1 will leave it to an intelligent world or so much of that I 1 world as are acquainted with the facts in the case to decide whether your conduct has not fully fally proved that you harbored those malicious beelin feelings s in your heart when you beliber abely planned a speech calculated in its nature to rouse this community to violence and that too on a day consecrated to religious duties your declaration to the contrary notwithstanding that yon von did not design desi fiti to offer indignity in n i V and insult when a mans words are set in direct f opposition to his bis acts which will men believe his acts all the time where then is the force of your denial one item more from your note reads thus my V sole design in the branch of my remarks ks which seems to be the source of of fence was to vindicate the government of the united states from those feelings of prejudice and that spirit of detection defection which seemed to pervade the public sentiment ac aei me sentiment referred to 9 qubie lie what public you vlas was it the sentiments of the states at laige if so your honor missed his him dm most widely when he left the city of washington to become the author of such remarks arks you left home when w bed you left washington if I 1 such prejudice and defection as you i le ep present resent there existed there you should h have ave blundered you anathemas ana themas and made e the people feel your patriotic allegiance ahlegian all egian hut but if ever you believed for a moment soul that the citizens of if ever an idea entered your utah the people generally whom you addressed on the ath were possessed of a spirit of defection towards the general government or that they harbored prejudices against it unjustly so far you proved i yourself youself profoundly agnora ignorant nil I 1 of the subject in which you was engaged and of the views and feelings in s of the people whom you addressed and this awn ignorance orance alone might have been been sufficient to lead you into all |