| Show fM EMINENT l t T O DOMAIN M I BILLS BOTH r PASSI s Interest Ing Debate Precipitated In Semite In 1 Ii importune Water 0 Measures ARGUMENTS FOR AND Arm AGAINST A t That Snit Salt Lake and Many lul Oilier Utah Cities Chico Will tI 11 II Have lac to t Solve Some Semite Day loy IO or not hot Salt Malt Si Lakes long lone fight for Cor or a better water staler supply Is 18 to 10 result In its II now ilott nul on what the tho house of ot representatives will wil do to 10 time thu eminent domain bills of ot Senator Law Lawrence Lw rence Unit that yesterday afternoon through the tho senate and ammO were up to the line lower house for tor consideration Tho XII debate on tho the bill bi was wa extensive and fd kept kOHt the In lii II for tor two hours hour over Its Is long meet inset meeting lag ing The fht Html vote ot stood Iol 11 1 to G 6 tho the six voting cUng nay nl having announced their Intention so BO to tn vote ote wh u 1 th time the monsura was 18 first read rOd and refusing to bo ho con eon sorted orto by the tha long iong arguments with which friend of ot tIme tho bill bi them theism It finally won perhaps because county will soon poon face tace the tho l I I problem that Salt Sul Lake does docs now and will wi have need for 01 the tins law 11 It I watt wart WI the tho Ihl combination of ot Salt SnIt Lake and Wo We bor Lor that won 01 together with a 1 few tew re ro 10 from rain tho limo south who sho stated silted that hf ht casting an nn aye vote ote they stood AlOu on oil 01 the ground of ot favoring a larger civic lt over oer a personal The rime HII senators voting nay oro Bar Barber ber bel Clegg Gardner John Johnson son soil Ol and Walton The ho two lulls bills i Nos NOl 20 and auth 21 extend tIme the II right of at eminent domain which at itt prudent Present Includes realty realy only to Include water untO und property The he sec see second secand oslO and bill bi defines time the kinds of ot property and condemned Ind the thE purposes for tor which It may IRY be tie Both bills hil are ar frankly for tor a mm 1 purpose e that lint Is II local In itt II KB Its Il application What It IH In WitS was II mada IndO evident when Sentor Sentor said that a I man who stun of or offered fared ferl Ms his farm for COl 00 before beCore ho lie knew the tho city needed it Immediately latelY Jumped time the price to 1000 or 01 on nit finding ni out who wanted It I The rime Je problem problem lem It I Wad II pointed out In the senate Is ono ommo which IIAn of ot the time cities cites mid and midtowns towns town In Iii Utah will 1 have ha 8 to meet t et some In II the near future when Its Is growth limo tho capacity of ot Its vater sup supply ply ind ron for or that reason op 01 opposition position to 10 It Is t not hot considered fat far night Hi td or compatible with wih good goo public policy by many legislators ArONIO J How sacred shall water be ho to Its Ii owner Under tinder Ulder time the right of ot eminent i domain In the railroad oan osum lay hay IlY ltd Ito Is track through time thu house a mm man mun wa waborn I born Lorn lor In run over the tho grave IIVO of at Ma his hl ones one and amid pass IJAS through the Iho church In lit which he Iol Yet It I cannot touch the water wlter on which he lie has Imas squat squatters rights for tor which reason a Q lone lono rancher machen can ran tit sit li In state In lit 11 thu tho mouth 1 of a I canyon and laugh at nt a it I hundred thousand people In the oty aty below no n matter how hal great grent their steed need leed for Cor a it 1 itter wa water WI ter ler supply He le comm can pile pie his price pice on onto onto to 10 the skiM skies and ho he cannot be compelled to accept l a n ligure 1118 UTAH LAW rAW Ill In 11 other states It I Is 19 not nt so Senator Lawrence pointed out In defending hits his measured that In every ever eer state wa water 11 ter tr Is IR Included In the Iho rights eminent domain arid and has hUI frequently been taken from the Individual to servo serve the time par pur purpose pose ro e of ot the time many nt at a I fair Calr ton An Aim Idea Idel advanced by Senator Larson of ot Mantl was stas novel and was brought up tip Sen Kon In iii II opposition to tho the contentIons contention by hy Clogg Gardner Callner and Walton Wallon that hint tho thin new leI extended eminent do domain main maIms 1111 farther than was Wil proper r Ha lie le that tha on the tine autos sume principle the nation exercised the tIme right of ot eminent domain by attaching the time crop or er time tho I tarot farm of ot an nun Individual of ot attaching liU hil water staten supply or II even een demanding his hit hi hilIfe life Itself Ise In itt n it time Into of ot peril herIl WALTON Time The debate wan Wil opened by Senator Walton who ho made lud a IL motion to 10 amend time the billis hils by hy striking out null the tIme paragraph referring to 10 water wlter In n support of ot tilts hi motion loton he claimed this bill bi was WIS taking InkIng time tho tight right of ot eminent domain Into Inlo an tin new Meld holding tho time position that It I Invaded personal rights He lie le questioned whether time the courts would sustain time the law lass If It passed and and emceed clamed It I as a 1 measure men lr In iii 11 that bitt It I gave onus one body of ot citizens a I right to 10 take n it commodity 1011 I from another body of ot dUan and amid ties uie UI It for far time the same lame pur purpose Purpose pose but for tor their exclusive benefIt bel l Concluding he his sold said ho hue favored tle time dinner who could old not It tight In the court time the powerful city ely corporations lights would sock leek ek to 0 C destroy hi his water wlter O Lawrence admitted the charge that the measure Invaded private rights but hut buthe buthe he run tended that such ludl Invasion wan ants 1 cud and for the time good food of the I many U it I teem atm mOIl moat selfish he lie h wild said Il ld I for or Individuals to II oppose a broad I lute like 11 this Ihle mid I 11 Individuals should hould not mint lot be bt allowed to 11 hold holl tip tin 1 for tor or outrageous Prices price for tO property ment i necessary Itry lo tim public Improve impress Improvement WALTON J I Walton Walon that there Ih r sav no et sit for to 8 fal l I to condemn water right In Iii 11 the time neigh but bul that the city could CIl on RO farther up lp Into the and nd build buil 10 ir 1 In to II states flute lat wh whir r similar laws law ho li h claimed chili med that thit the tor le not IMd for tor tr mr pur pun 5 Ills His H reference to 10 building brought Il retort from mm who van UK In lo know If It the Ihl actually tl In advising this city elty to build reservoIr to stale water te unlit to tl drink thit would Imperil Imperl time the whole city In lii ra rue ease of DC a R or break He mOe then Ihen went on 00 pointing out olt that lint the iho Ihl church chuich IH tM not sacred or the grave gave ir i ir nr or r the home hOne when hl It Is II I situated In a n ai i lac lace needed for mIme Ihl public good Ar Arguments i 1 i against the bill hi ho lie concluded I have been prompted by b neM le this ThU view Io was wat A heartily by who wh claimed that If It the objecting should them J of or towns tie the allot anno problem that Salt Lake if is I they would bo be tho the first to spelt In Its Ie favor THE OLD oD HOMESTEAD Senator Gardner of ot Fork lork wa M In II hits hla loss Ioe for fot time the old homa hOla Moad Ho Ito le Bi ok of the Ihl hard work of lt the this settlers of ot Utah uh In Iii building their home lom l that would be devastated should time tha law mw In j fi w Ho Ito 10 the hits city ely of lt Halt hait Helt L Ike Lake ke could coull anti and should get et water devastating these home and Ind Invited him hIm to sub molt any amy to Suit Salt l lithe t that would bo be bt Ild directed Ills his hi at attention lt lention tenton to the time long tight to 10 solve JIe time tho water problem MICAY HILL 11 Senator McKay spoke at lt length go going goIng ing Into Inlo tho tIme history of ot early starting with smiths wih time the Ih Who drove Iroll up imp to a II spring of ot water I til or orto orto to tn the time headwater n of ot a 1 creek crek and a 11 set settled let Lieu tlell lime to build hl hi IsIs home Then hEI below Leloss other settlers come ome and a nO a I oily grows row up UD It I hums ban no 10 water and coma to th the settler above asking him to 10 soil audI 1 that Its may mi bo be 10 prospered Will viii Wil ho hue soil null el arid and go 10 with wih hi imPs full tul of or money or will wili wi he Ins hI have haveR hl 1 R a right light to cling on and refuse water to his hil brothers bloth l below 7 MulCay McKay thought not 1101 and amid announced lila his Intention of or voting for tor or time measure When placed upon un tine the both holh went by one onto tote iota l s than man a majority U 11 1 to 10 H 1 Today rohey odlY the th senators havo hi 0 either elthel gone to then their lien homes hom or are Ire busy hUB bus on oil com coin committees |
