Show OPI OPINION IO O ON THE B BAD DEBT C CASEI SL Justice McCarty Files Ills His Legal View Icv of Booth versus SAYS PLAINTIFF CAN OAH RECOVER to Opinion In lii Supreme Court An 1 lct I ml Authorities a z A dissenting opinion hs hi hap Iwen nl dl McCarty of ot the 1 court courtIn In im the time CM cast of A Booth Li I Co Ca vs y 1 Ct CI M j 1 appellant The rim fh majority of the time court cOUll In km an In opInion tendered rendered on Dec 31 It l hold that plaintiff not nol recover from frail d tar for certain moor mer merchandise chandise void bold It hall hail not nol com compiled piled with the tho law In In regard legard to 10 Ha its It articles nf or Incorporation In this state lund find hence was smite tint lint legally final I to transact tn lit the Iho stale slide In support of hU his dissenting opinion I Justice Tu lIco McCurlY cites section R article 12 IZ of ot tho tile Constitution of ot Utah which that Alt All 11 corporation Khali havo hitro time thu right to 10 mo tue and be he subject to tim tobe I I be Mind clued In oil nil courts courle In iii like as n I natural persons persona r on It U ii contended that thin Ihla section Is IB mandatory and In Is l not nut qualified by section 9 D of ot tIme the name arti article ole cle which r ilie n to 10 tile Ills tilea a MIl copy o m Its Ito In the th i ci of stolen states sin toa orne before betI It Lt tan un transact any business lit to It th the lime state mutate Tho Iho jim opinion status mutateS that there thoro Is hi an irreconcilable In Ili tho the authorities ties In regard rez 0 tin time lh two sections of af the time Constitution i m ted I d hut but that cht from ruin matte made by hy McCarty ho iii hoU U is of or the opinion article 8 B eMul control In such uch mutters |