| Show r TIle Ellison Case Casei t i Defense Concludes s Its lIs Testimony iW and aid Court Adjourns Till Ti Monday c ll o Casts a il al at alTe alThe The Te Defense by hr h ig h lo le Out cAle Testimony Tc 10 Of Ille Ity and ald Other Oilier Witnesses The Tue defense In the Clyde murder case concluded Its B testimony t this morning with the exception of or Df Stewart an 11 export expert who woe was WB not nol present pre nt In la court when whon coiled called today tola The Tho he defendant Was under uner until about abut 11 and ho hoa howal witness stand by wal a followed on the Mrs Payne who vas i a few tew audi auditions lions tons by Attorney y Their tea tesS te was WOH nit all 11 that hat m was taken today A t bombshell Was as exploded by b the llio llo state Just after the defense rested ltd lie Io ene COIl Judge Julge Ju g Powers moved the Iho court cour to strike out all al the Iho testimony of ot Mm airs Ir Johnnie Mrs Murray and uld Mrs In relation to Watsons visit ISI to Bodka not lOot Springs with Mrs on the lie day la alter eec tion tUI Judge Powers lowers argued that the tic testimony of ot those la is not con CUI connected Mh the case at lt oil all oi because It I I wag WIS ns not shown that defendant prior to 10 the tile time hoe of ot the thc shooting knew anything about the Hot Springs affair and hence that could not have had anything to 10 todo todo do with his lila insanity or with stIth his Justi Justification Just for tor the net act The he defense lefens defens strongly resisted tho mo 10 molion lion ton to strike out the testimony Judge King and Mr Ir Truman both bOh ar tic argued Ir gued sued that the testimony sas tS material because It corroborated the testimony of ot several witnesses In regard leJan to Mr Watsons confession of illicit relations with Mm They niAo argued that any an testimony which proved roved that the deceased did defile the wIts wit of ot de defendant defendant tuis Wils certainly In this case Judge Morse announced that he would render lila hla hil decision on the Ito mo ma motion moton matlon tion ton Monday morning ut at 10 The rite usual crowd of ot sPectators was wn present at the trial this morning Mrs Mr Watson Mm Ir and Mr Mrs f Payne Jane were present and ond occupied their th lr seats acute The he defendant to be ll In better beter condition today toa than yesterday He lie appeared stronger and answered the questIons question put tut to tutu him In a clear and aud dis distinct distinct voice olce DEFENDANT ON THE ISlE TiE STAND When court was IS opened this lila morning Cl Clyde CIdo do Wits waa WOI called col d to the Iland stand and ane was wal further by Judge Powers loWer He lie I wild SOul lule that an ar or arrangement Ir was made nods between him and Mr Watson Vatson whereby the latter later was to board bOrd with wih defendant and his hla wife wie In exchange fur for the he rental of ot the house houle M l I lud and In Inthe the l olo at nt the time you OU went vent there did they the not notI 7 I know who lived up stairs thin ibis the tho gentleman Ben le man who lived Hurt there Indicating Mr Ir Dupont who arose at the request of ot Diet At Ally Atty Etch nor norI norI I 1 I dont Ilont know I dont think I ever ler IW the lie man Inan Ian who stayed there but about once the bedroom of at Mr and Mrs Mr Dupont Just above yours und and about aboul abc feet across the hall hail hal from ron Mr Watsons bed bC room 1 dont know kno where their bed bel room was 05 Were those people pe there during the two IWo there here weeks you and lt your our wife wore were lre Yes sir lr 11 Then Mr 11 Watson did dil not take your our wife witt Into d tt house where whee he would be I alone with her herNo herNo herNo No sir Now did you 01 look through the he win window window wIndow dow or the door that thai night when you saw Watson coming from trot your our les bedroom I looked through both hoth Dont you 01 know that lint from the door doors and from the Window you ou look hook lookup hookup up II the stairs Ita Irs nt at all 11 and c see soe a aman aman man up UI there thereA ther A Take Toke the tle Jury up there and let them look through the he door Will Wil you OU answer my lY question queston we wenO may nO accommodate you ou later on that matter maler Yes sir you ou can wits was the reply DI nt you OU about two months before the lie shooting have hae a n conversation with withE E B C Pen Penrose rose a 1 Deseret De News reporter and Ind tell tIl him that you ou were vere going to get geta a divorce from your our wife I 1 dont remember that I did Ild I be positive though whether I 1 Idid Idid did or not Do Vo you ou remember one ono night of ot your or wife coming home about 9 and finding the door dour locked locke and she he could nt nl get ge In and then knocking for about abut 15 1 minutes before you ou let lot her In Vt Yes sir ste ANOTHER WOMAN WOMA your our wife accuse you ou of ot hay hav having ha haIng hayIng ing a woman In the rm room Ye YI es sir And you ou tell tel her lice that If It she sho wanted you U to you ou could give her the nanie of ot the woman No III sir lr I did dil not no you ou give 1 her the name Imo of ot a ayoung ayoung 1 young lady laly friend of ot hers here her In Butte Yes Yet sir sirI Do Th I you OU remember one on time while your ur wife won was Wi away awa representing to toa toI toa a I young oung lady that thA you were un an un unmarried married 11 r man mann mn manite n 1 n o air ite f I never leI I 11 the tha th pm em reply n h un Im o y m borrow JK from her yes Yen 11 sir air she request ruet the payment of ot the money lon and my M that hat you ou represent et 0 eti yourself to be I an n unmarried titan mn No sir r She ho hC did not not Where did dil you and ald your our wife 14 live when you IU separated the first tune time I think It was waa iS West Welt Third ThIr unit How low lOne lont on were you ou U In II Colorado Colordo a a year arH Did you u tend send nd her Iter Iler any money while you 01 were wor there theN I r a nt married marle to her then th n 1 Well WI oil you were there thur alter aler you U were wert married wet you 01 Yes Ye sir fir Ir about abut two months Did you U F nd her he any any ny money moe at all al during that tl time No Xo sir Ir When jo ot 01 went ent up to see tec fee Mr Hemp ton pon and hi h bib that talk with lh Win Hut d dt tIM l you 0 jay an aw anat al about abut Mr r Watson atson at a atal aim 4 Y Tr r I r IA 11 ltd J v vA A CLAN WEDDING You ou morn marr d tO your ur wife without her patents con ent nt and ane naJ without t their knowledge d nt Int your you Ve ye sir sIt I dont Wiley they knew knewL L anything about It It you were wore In the Jail did you send Ind tiny uny un message menage to 10 your our wife No Xo lr sir I dont tont think I Did DI you jou ou authorize dd to tell hr I r tint that II t It If the would wold sw aln ir as at a to 10 tl your jour our tur you would v IV save h he hat r cheese charac turro No ro sIr I Md Il not act you OU authorize Mr Truman U It tt make uch a 0 1 statement lt to 1 hur IO THE TUE TRUTH No tl alt lt It she ho e wants to tell the truth die can vun do BO so tel What do 10 tb you ou mean meun by that do you ou mean non taut list she ehi could go on 01 the stand und and Ind testify t You Iou wIll nin 11 have hao to se see my m attorney about ab ut that At I the time you would ob oh J i to her going on stand aloud j If U I knew she l ho would vou tell 11 the exact tide facts I 1 wouldn t TUB 11 WATSON INCIDENT Referring to the utson incident you jou ou claim jour hOur our wife 10 has hos not been Incident virtu otis Oll 4 Yes Ye s sir Have you always been I l dont cont know that I have Ille not Does an any Incident come to you mind on that tho t subject nt ft this timer time YOI f No o mr ir I 1 think not dry dr i y you U ever W r rk nt Ut lt n a I stun t 0 1 laun latin Nn Jn 1 i ii 1 know anyone v v who IAd at nt u I a slon laundry laundr rk Yes rel sir iota lota of ot loll people A o l L you Into get trouble with a girl who worked at a I laundry 1 No sir 1 I did chit not r i herr n you ou wont down clown to lo see Mr do you ou remember seeing Mr Ir Murphy there I dont remember member whether I did or nt not Ht lie was aa asked It if r he tell lug Ing tel M w 11 Murphy that lie lle IJ w wanted n to 10 see eee c Mr about moving out of ot his hIl house b tilt the work aula was wn too hard for tor Ida his hl IS wife He did not any aUY lt at of ot al all the llie tIl conversation with sith Mr Murphy 1 think 01 all answered Judge I Th The was vas Concluded 1 at t 1 11 T HI was al thou thon naked few Okell fl Ii b T ulli on rn o e Il lie c he e was in f Colorado alor do v he Wa 0 sick und anti un on aide t to W ana had md to TO coIl akun nt ala a a phy pity How long were you ou sIck nick weeks I should suppose It was abol about three How hIo Ion long a you OU Work you OU were there thereAbout About three weeks OUI vito understand why went to Colordo Colorado wl ou Yes Yel sir Did you ou go there because of oC any you OU and your our wife work No sir 11 she he kleI I 1 lent there to W get gt He lie Ie said old that while he worked at the Oregon Short r m Une he e nil l hi his a lime chieck Ji 1 and J gave ene theun ther to ida hi wl wife hl wh who ho cashed them Ind and ant ol the moner ney n the tho ho Incident when a young lady ld caine Cle to 10 the Imn hou ni ni i ii i Jl Judge JUdIe Powers w UI I IELATI S AN A One evening when Mrs Ir was ia a gone to 10 her tier mothers this young lady who W was as a particular frIend Wend SI of Mr miln ca called sail and said ald she ehe he wanted i MI Mrs t to go co to n a ball wh with her I r told toll her that Mrs Mr 1 sins wih not nt very wen well anti had tied P gone to tat her hie mothers hut but that she sits might 11 ht be b back soon I invite her In and she came mme Into the room oni sat ft there the with Wih her wraps on rom About 9 sue she he left lef I then thee retired and about nut a n half later Mrs cam rn and I got I jo a up and anil 11 let lei her hN In She accused me of ot having a ti woman In the th room rom anti anil ani I told her who ho had rolled coiled She wild saul site she hoard horl that the airi mill was woi wn thre for tor Immoral purposes purpose and ane said she he wai IU going to s ee see her he r I told lol her I would ou Id go 0 eliOt lh her We went ven nt and Ind when whon ehe he r re turned ture she phe sh apologized o and said old she ahe wa was rl Ia wrong rong Witness then thea testified to the hours he went to work and the hours hout he quit work while he lie h stayed at Mr Watsons His 1 examination was nai a concluded at nt about 13 il la PAYNE Mrs I r Payne hayne was recalled to the witness Site She testified that tha when hen Clyde Clytie was Wasp a so 10 sick at It Mr Me r Jet ferys rooming house hou on that Sunday then when she ahe WM seas to attend to him aM sh heard Mr Mrs IN ralpd Ellison say n Clyde CIde If you jou OU Mil 11 forgive me for tor this wrong I will trill 1 never nl r do so o again Slit She was rai 1 not by the th ly state atae John Shea Shea WM 1 the next witness called Ho He t not noi present however so I Mr Truman stated tale that thai with th the exception of ot one ono export f ort witness who w Wi vas s not flEnt at nt this time the Ile de tIe d tense feme would w uM ret rest Its I osse ise lle MOTION TO STRIKE OUT Now IW W It If your honor please said Id I Judge J Powers Power the defense delen having hn In ret rest rested ed e Its It I caie cace carl with wih the exception of t the tl n Qt ot Dr Stewart Siewart their expert pet eJ the th state stute now moves loes to strike out at ott tin testimony of ot Mrs Mr McNamara ni Johnnie Mrs Ir Murray Murry sLid and Mrs n Proctor and al to Instruct th the Jur Jury that list they cannot consider any al of or their evidence at 1 nil all RI lm bU ue their testimony Is I ii In III no way WA with Uh Ih de tIe or this hit MM c n It I does doe do not ap sp lp pear that the tho at t th ft any time 11 prior to ID th the of or the th ter te l to by be Ih they witnesses The Th testimony In is tl 1 because l e It ran cJ hn hise no rue n lifting 1 upon th the ques u Ions ton of ot er or D be b oUM tuI tin hi i at the Iho the tIme tint I he f commItted 1 th ti t art act r did not 11 know of ot the alleged visit to D s Hot springs JURY JUnr Before nto any Rl was wis presented on the mot kin ta tl the court elf th th he Jury Jut to retire tram the th lb court room ruoni They Tha Were are taken In n tha charge by cur two to 11 unit baIt bJ Iffs and until Ita Id tal ual morn moon ing lug at 10 Judge Juige Powers th n the theme mo Continued on page two THE rUE ELLISON MURDER CASE CASH Continued from page one lion without Any tny argument Mr Tru Truman titan man the tho motion IU lie II sold said that tha thalie lIte lie evidence nce shows shown that Watson tul toll told defendant of or the shooting on the lie day cl that lie hi did take julie hut his wife wie to 10 North Noth Salt Like talt In a I buggy notwithstanding 81 his promise premise to lo defendant never again to iia see pee ee his hI wife Wire Mr Ellison so 10 on 01 the tha stand land ned we Wi have havo Ino the right t to have this testimony tut lony to corroborate Mr tony about the trip to North Bait Lake Jake Joke anti to show that Mr suspicion about what oo 00 during that lint trip trill was WIS correct corret corret Judge Judg J King argued that anything t to r prove that Mr lr Watson did dil defile dem th the tho If of or 11 this I hi defendant Is II perfectly proper pr er In connection with this Ihla ease cue cueno nn no matter how remote the act Hence len co coAn any An testimony to the effect erect that lint the tho deceased did Mrs Ellison Is tIer per ft He lit argued that tha thattie the tie testimony would be to ta borato this th testimony of Mrs Payne and nd others In III regard to tile tie eon con tendon tet lon cf of Hr Watson WAt on anti that It Is therefore very sery nr material to the case At the tile conclusion of the tho arguments argument on en the th motion mollon Judge Mor stated that tha h ht be would render his hla decision deel lon on the tho matter upon the he opening of ot court Mon Monday Mondo Monday day do morning The court then ad nil until that time After Arter the News report clo closed d yes yesterday yesterday yesterday afternoon the defendant defend nt was naked lI by llY Judge Powers It If Mrs hail not first mot tact Mr Watson by being Vent rent to him by her hu husband band to 0 borrow barrow us IS on i II chattel mortgage S I 1 new liefer sent ent her tier she went Without my mt It II was waa the reply She wits van ft II good to you she stood by 1 you she Rhe Yes Yea up to hid time of ot this She mIght bare done dono better The Tho defendant d admitted that his Ills wife Iwo by her Intercession procured his hI reinstatement In the employ of or the Oregon Short LIne Lino He lie said ho had hod treat Ineat and love for ter his hll wife up UI to the tho time of ot the th shooting Allison confessed that some lImo domestic Ull had hail been blen caused roused by the lie Visits lIlts of or Mrs If Ellison lIl on to her parents wilen he lie thought she he shoud have re remained teamed at home with him He Ito admitted that they tiny had moved moud 14 U times How many times time urn b J before fore forc the Watson teon did dill you ou talk all with your wife VICe about separatIng Only once that I remember of or you OU threaten that It she left loft you Ou you would ruin her character It If Hou you ou had to hire every and keeper In III the ho city No sir air Ir IrAnd And you oU advertise this wife wire you ou love lor 10 M so dearly Yes Yell sir lr Ellison Billion admitted tint that he had bad lift an unpaid tonal board bill In Florence Colo Cob He lie said lie he hi had been a IL little jealous of ot his tta at t times He lie not think It U right for tor her to 10 go III und have Ice lee orm Grem with a II man and |
