| Show V Suspicion Rests ests Upon Judge in ii Handing Down His Findings Says Sas if riI l Fads Would in My M i Opinion Constitute A el Just Ground of Suspicion on ozi Oi a C Could Be Ja Issued Ha Bc Il i March Murphy hand ald eJ it I down dowl lili III Id findings finding In III th the thu BurIck In lUIs tOday loday and declared delar that thu the Identity of time the 4 murderer re had hiatt ha not been blon proved proe The tal nehl li ii an exhaustive review or ot o the lie evidence brought out during tho mho Inquest Special attention Is l given to II the letter leUr hanged between Arthur K R Penned and Ind Mr M Burdick Durek tb thi 0 One c containing a threat against life lre Concerning these them the this the Judge sats nays a these hs facts would III In my 1 iii constitute a just ground of f mw ml lUl l Photon Mon on which a warrant be It Is Isue I ue w were ru he lie alive al Inferring tu to Mrs Ir Hull ul Judge Murphy i 1 says This The action alot of ot Mm Ir Hull lul on that morn mor In lug th UI after f the murder and MiU Id muret h he her r testimony on the stand tand hag lioa tU rallied rna mile 18 much thought and worry To my they Iley are arl Incontinent with wih a perfect want of or knowledge an as I to what whit had hail actual atul ly h occurred r So ao little lithe apparent feeling for or this dead man such tuch an III evident 1 t desire to 0 cover rOI up the he crime and MO no disposition whatever r to aid the tue authorities In lii bending th the hi murderer may I b b be explainable hUt but lies hai h not III explained Peaking of rallon rl relations with Mrs Mra 1111 Murphy sas 1 lilt 11 Ill of or all alt others other was a the Ilia motive moth ol strong enough to 10 Incite a H desperate mind steeped In wrung doing doln to 10 ao so 0 foul toul fouland and cruel a it 1 murder He 11 can never I be placed on vial trial tria nor can Cn hla hi case Ot ever eer be Judicially determined l Let t iw us I lie be ht M as fair thin to tu tho hat dead teR na as 11 the law presume ua us to 10 l Is 10 e to the living He lie I must mint b be p pm turned sawed Innocent until proven guilty Continuing Judge J Murphy said Hd The Tue he theory that list had a I wo woman 0 neil man lal guest In II hla hi dm den that night lies hat not been Len sustained by 1 the evidence It I I hue hat hatnot ha hanot not a a tingle Immoral act un on lilt hI Mrs Ir Paine and amid all Mist Ills lut are ara completely exonerated In Judg Murphys findings finding which In conclusion My M MI It I It Is our duty to Mr Itts Ir Hut ut great at as a her he wrong linn treat greet greetis la is I her bier At A t the beginning h of oC Ms hits report r JOrl Judge Judg Murphy Murph certified that tho lie cause otc of ot nur dicks death deth was sas compound comminuted ed oil multiple fracture of oC the skull kul That said alil ll fracture wan stas WA lie result of several IOK by with n dul tUI edged ollon delivered principally on the tb bad back of ot th this Tho Thu ld Wows were We delvaro with homicidal intent and anil the tim Identity of oC said salil ll person lisa ling not mint been I II proved Ho lie I e reviews briefly the events of ot the this evening preceding the tho as al brought out In the this testimony which he lie heRI pays saya RI does llo not show Mho that anything un unusual usual occurred at lt the tIm In the lie fore forepart tor part hart of this the Ih night The story glory of the find finding Ins ing of ot body ody next morning and of oC the this events cents preceding It its I discovery an as a I related by Imy the lie tle different ul h of ot tho it Is told unil thI ti Un tl Ohi itt p elM elMIn In lIt Il II the testimony of oC Tho Thu tul Mr lire Irl Hull ull are pointed out out Continuing to rew the tite no Judy Judge Jude Murphy the lie Dr of Marcy In iii which h hi he iI he be sent for tor or Jr Dr 1 1 How Und laud the hip examiner The Thu two a It t n in II which Lr Vr Marcy said If I the death proved to Iw he It would Pave ve lila ii and Ind family email a great relt third dial teul of DC scan cnn scandal dal a I Ur VI said ald saidI aldI I dont domit tnt think It I It is I suicide and Dr Dc Mater armid d with him bere in Is I the motive for Cor thIs crime Judge Judg Murphy and then than lie lu alien tip till the lii of Mr Mrs t amid Pennell and toys says ay it I at IMI seems m live rears rs n no o on the lie occasion of ot a n visit bl to New I VIt by ly the and amid I Mrs I gave avo the tie lovo be tie belonged longed to II her hem to another She loved hll l and amid Ito lio l Infatuated with wih her learned the truth ruth AI d a s fol mI followed lowed lowet but bUI l because ec u o for Cor love loe of or her ler chili Uren he lie hl took his hil wife Ito back and forgave the lie author of hIs Ills wrong upon his hla hil prom l li las e to II leave This and the he which Mrs 1 to her bier husband ways says NY Judge Judie Murphy Murph wore wura ly I broken Mr told li her r iho she mutt must leave leAe his house hOIt and ho applied for forthe time the divorce divor which action acton she he not care elre to as ns she he wished to i marry mrry who hall had aI to support her hOI her to 10 d defend f nd the lie suit had been l nn ll and ROl Mrs i and anti Pennal hail lie ile shadowing So far Car n a as appears from the Ii evl avI y dene lence nays soya ss the judge 1111 had hadnot not hot In III flue Ulf tuck dick In any an way however hower hind Imd a n lot of ot evidence consisting of ot lit let litters tees written by Mr to Mrs Mn Implicit of or such Much Im tin Importuning nature that their publication hu llon anti And ant social ruin to lh lr author rl rIi u ug all 11 11 mitt Mr te jus justic J jim OOt tie tic lc wet w the ti motive lugI to 16 Incite a mu I desperate mind already steeped tt In to 10 do llo so 10 foul and cruel crela a murder Did h hi do tie It It Was Wg he lie re me roo tar for It He lie Ie h returned from the tle dead inane manti wife ICe time the tl d diU dl y li Jor for this lie Ih runnier He lie was WH very ery much excited tilt the Ih next morning and anti went lt mid and pur purchased chased rhaNI n u revolver The This clerks at Nt the sale gale If state that butt he hi did not appear all like hue hImself at lt Ille |
